Expert report review
USDA inspection certificate in a produce dispute: what does it prove, and how is it checked?
A certificate issued by a USDA inspector is prima facie evidence of the facts it states in every federal court proceeding under the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act, and New York gives it the same effect in state court. Prima facie evidence can be rebutted. A review of the certificate checks what lot was inspected, when, on what sample, which defects were found and whether the sale terms make those defects relevant.

What is a USDA inspection certificate in a produce sale?
A document issued by a federal or federal-state inspector after examining a lot of fresh fruits or vegetables at the request of a financially interested party. It records the grade, the condition and the defects found in the sample examined.
Section 499n of the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA), codified in title 7 of the U.S. Code, deals with the inspection of perishable agricultural commodities and with the certificates that inspectors issue. The AMS Certification Manual for fruit and vegetable inspection, dated November 2017, states that "Applicants may obtain inspections of any fresh and/or processed fruit and vegetable and related products for which they have a financial interest," and defines the applicant as "the financially interested party, company, or agency who requests the inspection; or any authorized agent acting on their behalf."
The contract decides who orders the inspection and where. Under the PACA trade definitions in 7 CFR 46.43, "shipping-point inspection" means that "the seller is required to obtain Federal or Federal-State inspection." In an f.o.b. sale, "The buyer shall have the right of inspection at destination before the goods are paid for." A buyer who believes the produce arrived in bad condition orders a destination inspection.
The certificate is not a report written for litigation. The inspector records the lot, the sample, the temperatures noted and the defects by type and percentage. The dispute starts when one side relies on those numbers and the other side says they do not mean what the first side claims.
What weight does the certificate carry in court?
Under 7 U.S.C. 499n(a), all courts of the United States receive the certificates in PACA proceedings as prima facie evidence of the truth of their statements. New York CPLR 4529 gives them the same effect in state court.
The statute reads that the certificates "shall be received by all officers and all courts of the United States, in all proceedings under this chapter, and in all transactions upon contract markets" as "prima-facie evidence of the truth of the statements therein contained."
New York has a parallel rule for its own courts. The Guide to New York Evidence, rule 3.29, restates CPLR 4529 verbatim: "An inspection certificate issued by the authorized agents of the United States department of agriculture on file with the United States secretary of agriculture is prima facie evidence of the facts stated." The certificate must come from an authorized agent and be on file with the Secretary.
Prima facie means the certificate proves its facts until something else is shown. The note to the New York rule says that "evidence may be introduced to rebut the accuracy of the facts stated or otherwise affect the weight of the evidence." The other side therefore does not have to accept the certificate. It has to produce evidence, and an expert review of the certificate and its circumstances is one form of that evidence.
What does good delivery mean in an f.o.b. sale?
That the produce met the contract at loading and was in suitable shipping condition to arrive without abnormal deterioration. USDA good delivery guidelines set the defect percentages allowed at destination for f.o.b. sales.
Under 7 CFR 46.43(i), "F.o.b." means that the produce "is to be placed free on board the boat, car, or other agency," with the buyer bearing the risk of damage and delay in transit not caused by the seller. "Suitable shipping condition" in 46.43(j) means that the commodity, at time of billing, is in a condition which, if the shipment is handled normally, "will assure delivery without abnormal deterioration at the contract destination agreed upon between the parties."
Section 46.44 defines good delivery: "Unless otherwise agreed to between the contracting parties," good delivery in connection with f.o.b. contracts "means that the commodity meets the requirements of the contract at time of loading or sale" and "will meet the following additional requirements on delivery at the contract destination."
The USDA AMS page on good delivery guidelines states: "In an F.O.B. sale, the seller warrants that the produce meets the contract terms at shipping point," and that it is "also in suitable shipping condition to arrive at the contract destination without abnormal deterioration." The guidelines interpret maximum allowances for produce inspected at a destination between 1 and 5 days away from the shipping point. A three-number entry such as "15-8-3 means 15% total damage, including not more than 8% serious damage (including decay) and not more than 3% decay." For commodities without a U.S. grade standard the allowance is "10% for average defects, including 5% for defects causing serious damage and 1% for decay."
The same page cautions that the table "does not have the force of law and is subject to judicial review at any given time," and that "The F.O.B. Good Delivery Guidelines Table applies only to produce sold F.O.B."
How do the regulatory tolerances work for a specific commodity?
Section 46.44(a) gives lettuce as the regulatory example: the percentage allowed at destination depends on whether the contract specified a U.S. grade, specified a percentage or said nothing, and the parties may agree otherwise.
When a U.S. grade is specified, "the lettuce may contain an average of not more than 3 percent condition defects" at destination, in addition to the grade tolerances. The regulation gives the grade example: "the U.S. No. 1 grade provides a 12 percent tolerance for damage at destination."
When no grade or percentage is specified, "the lettuce at destination may contain a maximum of 15 percent, by count, of the heads in any lot," "including therein not more than 9 percent serious damage of which not more than 5 percent may be decay." When a percentage is specified, the lettuce at destination may contain either "One and one-half times the specified percentage of damage or serious damage by condition defects" or the 15 percent standard, "whichever is greater." Paragraph (a)(5) lets the buyer and seller agree to destination percentages higher or lower than these.
For a review, the first question is therefore what the contract said. The same certificate showing, for example, a given percentage of decay can mean good delivery under one set of terms and a breach under another. The reviewer reads the certificate against the contract terms, the grade stated and the commodity's own tolerances.
Why does the difference between condition and quality defects matter?
Condition defects change over time, such as decay and bruising; quality defects do not, such as scars and misshapen produce. Destination tolerances for suitable shipping condition concern condition defects, while quality defects point back to the grade at loading.
A USDA AMS webinar of December 5, 2013, "Interpreting USDA Fruit & Vegetable Inspections: Does the Shipment Make Good Delivery?", defines condition defects as "Defects that will change over time (decay, bruising, discoloration, etc.)" and quality defects as "Defects that will not change over time (scars, misshapen, etc.)."
The distinction tells the reviewer which party the defect points to. A quality defect found at destination existed at shipping point, so it bears on whether the produce met the contract grade when loaded. A condition defect may have developed in transit, so it bears on suitable shipping condition and on handling, temperatures and time on the road.
In Classic Fruit Company, Inc. v. Ayco Farms, Inc., 72 Agric. Dec. 867 (U.S.D.A. 2013), a dispute over cantaloupes, the decision states: "There are essentially two (2) defects disclosed by the inspection, internal damage and fermentation," and finds that the fermentation reported "exceeds the decay tolerance by eleven percent (11%)." A review that does not separate the defects by type cannot say which warranty they affect.
Does the same analysis apply to a delivered sale?
No. In a delivered sale the seller delivers at destination free of transportation charges, and the warranty of suitable shipping condition does not apply. A USDA decision in 2013 said it has no relevance in a delivered sale contract.
Under 7 CFR 46.43(p), "Delivered" means that the produce "is to be delivered by the seller on board car, or truck or on dock if delivered by boat" at the destination, "free of any and all charges for transportation or protective service." The risk in transit stays with the seller.
Classic Fruit v. Ayco Farms states the consequence: "The warranty of suitable shipping condition has no relevance in a delivered sale contract." In a delivered sale the question is whether the produce met the contract on arrival, so the f.o.b. destination tolerances in the good delivery guidelines do not decide it.
Other PACA trade terms shift the risk again. Under 46.43(y), in a sale on "shipping-point inspection final" terms the buyer "assumes the risk incident to incorrect certification." Under 46.43(l), in an f.o.b. acceptance or shipping point acceptance, the buyer "accepts the produce at shipping point" and "has no right of rejection." A review that starts from the certificate without the sale terms can reach the wrong answer.
Does it matter when the inspection was made?
Yes. The certificate reports the produce as found on the inspection date, and USDA notes that it cannot guarantee the product will not change after inspection. Timing is one of the factors USDA lists for applying the good delivery guidelines.
The AMS Certification Manual states that the inspection "cannot guarantee the product will not undergo adverse changes after inspection and certification," and that where no additional sample units are examined "the certificate must show the last date on which the grade or product condition was determined." A certificate dated several days after arrival describes the produce on that date, not on arrival.
The good delivery page lists the timing of the inspection among the considerations: "Some other considerations may be the timing of the inspection." The webinar's advice to receivers is direct: "Call for an inspection immediately" when a shipment may not make good delivery.
For a review, the timeline is a separate exhibit: bill of lading date, arrival time, the time the buyer notified the seller, the time the inspection was requested and the time it was performed. Under 46.43(dd), "The buyer may not reject without reasonable cause," so delays and the reasons for them are part of the analysis of any rejection.
Temperatures belong to the same timeline. The webinar lists "Temperature" among the fields of the certificate, with examples of "Bill of lading temperature" and "Transit temperatures." Where condition defects are in dispute, the recorded temperatures are compared with those required for the commodity and with the carrier's data.
What sample does the certificate rest on, and does it cover the whole lot?
The certificate reports defects in the sample examined and identifies the lot. The reviewer checks lot identity, lot size and sample size, and whether the certificate covers the whole shipment the claim concerns.
The AMS Certification Manual directs inspectors to "Include the usual information regarding lot identity, lot size, location, etc." and to "Ordinarily report only the number of defective containers in the sample examined." The certificate is a statement about a sample from an identified lot, not about every container.
In Classic Fruit v. Ayco Farms, a Nevada State inspector sampled nine of the sixteen pallets available, at a rate the decision gives as approximately one percent, and the decision found: "We find that the sample size used by the surveyor is sufficient." The certificate there was a state one, but the question the decision asks applies to any certificate: was the sample adequate for the lot.
The coverage problem decided part of Genecco Produce, Inc. v. Sandia Depot, Inc., 386 F. Supp. 2d 165 (W.D.N.Y. Aug. 19, 2005). For one invoice, the Secretary had found that "the inspection certificate produced by Genecco did not indicate that the entire shipment was inspected." Genecco contended that the certificate did cover the entire shipment and recorded it as defective. For another, the court noted that "the inspection report is a fax or a photocopy that is difficult to read." Judge Siragusa found issues of fact and denied summary judgment.
What are appeal inspections and restricted inspections?
An appeal inspection re-examines a lot already inspected, and its certificate refers to the original and reports the grade as sustained or reversed. A restricted certificate for frozen product covers only the requested factors and states no grade.
Under the AMS Certification Manual, appeal certificates show "APPEAL INSPECTION" in the upper right corner, and the remarks state that the certificate "covers an appeal inspection of the above-mentioned lot which was previously inspected and reported on USDA Certificate No." followed by the original number. The result is reported as sustained or reversed as to grade.
The manual sets the rule for restricted certificates in its section on certification of temperature and condition on frozen product: such a certificate "should clearly state the fact that it is restricted to certain factors or condition at the request of the applicant," and "There will be no statement of grade." One example reads: "Inspection and certification restricted to product temperature only."
Both matter to a review. Where an appeal inspection exists, the reviewer compares the two certificates and asks why the first was challenged. Where a restricted certificate is offered to prove grade, the reviewer points out that the certificate, by its own terms, contains no statement of grade.
What if the produce was dumped before or after inspection?
PACA rules require an official certificate or other adequate evidence if five percent or more of a shipment is dumped. In Genecco the Secretary's reparation decision had found that the necessity of dumping the entire load was not shown.
Genecco quotes 7 CFR 46.22: "if five percent or more of a shipment is dumped, an official certificate, or other adequate evidence, shall be obtained." The rule ties the disposal of produce to proof of its condition.
For one invoice in Genecco, the seller said the entire shipment was worthless and had to be dumped. The Secretary had found that Genecco failed to establish the necessity of dumping the entire load under that rule, and the court listed the invoice among those with issues of fact about the value of the produce as accepted. A claim for the value of dumped produce therefore rests on a certificate or other adequate evidence of the condition at the time of disposal, and on proof that disposal was necessary.
The reviewer checks the dates of inspection and dumping, the share of the shipment covered by the certificate and the documents of disposal. Produce dumped before any inspection leaves the party relying on other evidence, which the review weighs against the rule.
What happens if a certificate was altered?
Falsely making, altering or forging a certificate for a fraudulent purpose is a misdemeanor under 7 U.S.C. 499n(b). In Heimos (2003) the USDA Judicial Officer imposed a 48-day license suspension or a $98,400 civil penalty for altered certificates.
Section 499n(b) provides that "Whoever shall falsely make, issue, alter, forge, or counterfeit" a certificate "for a fraudulent purpose" "shall be guilty of a misdemeanor" and "upon conviction shall be punished by a fine of not more than $500 or by imprisonment for a period of not more than one year, or both, at the discretion of the court."
In In re Geo. A. Heimos Produce Company, Inc., PACA Docket No. D-99-0016, decided by Judicial Officer William G. Jenson on October 29, 2003, the agency had investigated 200 files of transactions in which the company applied for inspection. The Judicial Officer wrote that "The alteration of a United States Department of Agriculture inspection certificate is particularly egregious" and that "inspection certificates play a critical role in the produce industry."
He concluded that "a 48-day suspension of Respondent's PACA license is an appropriate sanction," allowed a $98,400 civil penalty in lieu of suspension, and did not adopt the $8,000 penalty set by the Chief Administrative Law Judge. For a review, the practical step is to compare the copy offered in the case with the certificate on file, especially where the copy is a fax or a photocopy, as in Genecco.
How does a PACA reparation decision reach a court, and what happens to the certificate there?
A party may appeal a reparation order to the district court, where the case is tried de novo and the Secretary's findings and order are prima facie evidence of the facts stated. The certificate keeps its own prima facie effect.
Genecco quotes 7 U.S.C. 499g(c): "Such suit in the district court shall be a trial de novo," and "the findings of fact and order or orders of the Secretary shall be prima-facie evidence of the facts therein stated." The case concerned "twelve separate shipments of produce," among them watermelons, pumpkins and pineapples.
Two layers of prima facie evidence can therefore meet in court: the certificate under 499n(a) and the Secretary's findings under 499g(c). The party challenging them produces evidence on each disputed point. In Genecco, issues of fact about breach and about the value of the produce as accepted, including the invoice where the coverage of the certificate was disputed, were enough to deny summary judgment.
Expert evidence on the certificate enters under the usual federal rules. An expert who interprets the certificate and testifies about condition, temperatures or sampling provides a report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and the testimony is admitted under Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence if the proponent shows it is more likely than not that it rests on sufficient facts or data and reliable methods reliably applied.
What does a review of the certificate and the opposing report check?
The sale terms, the lot and share of the shipment inspected, the date against arrival, the sample, each defect against its tolerance, appeal or restriction marks, and whether the copy matches the file.
The review starts with the contract: f.o.b., delivered, shipping-point inspection final or another term from 46.43, the grade specified and any agreed tolerance. It then reads the certificate line by line: lot identity and size, the number of containers sampled, the defects by type and percentage, the temperatures and the date the condition was determined.
Each finding is compared with the standard that applies to it. Condition defects at destination are compared with the good delivery tolerances for an f.o.b. sale; quality defects are compared with the grade at loading. The timeline of arrival, notice, request and inspection is set out with the source of each time. Restricted and appeal certificates are identified as such.
When the other side has an expert report built on the certificate, the review applies the same checks to the report: whether the expert used the certificate for something it does not state, such as a grade on a restricted certificate or the condition of a whole shipment from a partial inspection, and whether the expert accounted for transit time and temperatures before attributing a condition defect to the seller.
What does IAE do in a dispute over an inspection certificate?
IAE prepares a review of the opposing expert's report or an expert report on the client's questions for warranty and supply disputes in US courts, in up to 5 business days.
The review page for goods and product defect reports describes the work for warranty and supply disputes: the review reads the other side's report against Rule 26(a)(2)(B) and Rule 702, lists the tests the expert did not run and the conclusions the data do not support, and checks the valuation under UCC 2-714(2). The page notes that a manufacturer's inspection report binds the buyer only if the parties agreed to a third-party inspection with binding findings.
The client sends the certificate, the contract or confirmation with its trade terms, the bill of lading, temperature records, photographs and the other side's report, and describes what to check. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. The court weighs a review together with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- 7 U.S. Code 499n, Inspection of perishable agricultural commodities (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 7 CFR 46.43, Terms construed (2021, govinfo)
- 7 CFR 46.44, Good delivery standards (LII, Cornell Law School)
- PACA Good Delivery Guidelines (USDA Agricultural Marketing Service)
- Interpreting USDA Fruit and Vegetable Inspections: Does the Shipment Make Good Delivery? Webinar, December 5, 2013 (USDA AMS)
- AIM Inspection Series Certification Manual, November 2017 (USDA AMS)
- Guide to New York Evidence, rule 3.29, Inspection Certificate Issued by United States Department of Agriculture (New York State Unified Court System)
- Genecco Produce, Inc. v. Sandia Depot, Inc., 386 F. Supp. 2d 165 (W.D.N.Y. 2005)
- Agriculture Decisions, Vol. 72, Book Two, PACA, including Classic Fruit Company, Inc. v. Ayco Farms, Inc. (USDA, 2013)
- In re Geo. A. Heimos Produce Company, Inc., PACA Docket No. D-99-0016, Decision and Order (USDA Judicial Officer, Oct. 29, 2003)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Warranty denied for liquid damage: how does a reviewer check the finding that water caused the failure?
A red liquid indicator records one fact: water touched the indicator. A warranty denial needs a second fact, that the liquid caused the failure
The shipment was rejected on a sample: how does a reviewer check whether the opposing expert's sample speaks for the whole lot?
Nobody tests 10,000 sweatshirts or 1,709 microprocessors one by one. A buyer who rejects a shipment, and a seller who sues for the price, both rely
Defect after the warranty expired: is there still a claim, and what must the expert prove about when it arose?
A defect that first shows up after the warranty period has ended is usually outside the express warranty, even if the cause was there from the startExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

