Expert report review
Defense review of a police crash reconstruction: what does the reviewer check in a vehicular homicide case?
In a vehicular homicide case the speed, the timing and the avoidability of the crash usually come from a police reconstructionist. A defense review sorts the officer's report into observations and inferences, then rebuilds each inference: the training behind it, the formula, every input and its source, and the check against recorder data. An Ohio appellate court in 2026 and a federal court in Michigan in 2019 show where such reports hold and where they fail.

Who reconstructs the crash in a vehicular homicide case?
Usually a police officer from a traffic or crash unit, trained through a series of reconstruction courses. A prosecutors' monograph says some reconstructionists take the ACTAR test to achieve certification and many others do not.
In State v. Logsdon, 2026-Ohio-1789, decided by the Ohio Court of Appeals for the Second District on May 15, 2026, the defendant was convicted of vehicular homicide and vehicular manslaughter in a case from Montgomery County. The speed estimate came from Detective Christopher Jordan of the Dayton Police Department's Traffic Services Unit. He had completed four levels of crash reconstruction training, including speed calculation based on damage. He was fairly new to the unit at the time of the crash; by trial he had worked on 62 serious-injury crash investigations, 19 of them fatal, and had been lead investigator on about 50.
Training paths of this kind are common. Crash Reconstruction Basics for Prosecutors, a 2003 monograph by John Kwasnoski published by the American Prosecutors Research Institute, an affiliate of the National District Attorneys Association, describes the Accrediting Commission for Traffic Accident Reconstructionists (ACTAR) and says: "Some reconstructionists take the ACTAR test to achieve certification, but many others do not." It lists "Is not ACTAR certified" and "Lacks formal training in physics" among the points a defense may raise against an officer reconstructionist.
The same monograph notes that "due to lack of training, some law enforcement reconstructionists do not use crush analysis." For the defense the training record is the first document to request: which courses, how many hours, which methods each course covered, and which of those methods the officer used in this case.
A review starts by matching each opinion in the report with the training behind it. An officer trained in speed from skid marks who also offers an opinion on speed from crush, on event data recorder downloads or on occupant kinematics has to show training for each of those methods.
Is the officer testifying as an expert or as a lay witness?
It depends on what the officer says. In Logsdon an Ohio court wrote that collecting scene data needs no expert, but reconstruction uses scientific methodology to draw inferences from that data.
In Logsdon the defendant argued on appeal that Detective Jordan's speed calculation was improper expert testimony because he was not certified as an expert in crash reconstruction. The court framed the question under the line between lay and expert opinion in the Ohio Rules of Evidence. It wrote that "a police officer does not need to be an expert" to testify about collecting data at a scene, while accident reconstruction "involves the use of scientific methodology to draw inferences from investigative data."
The distinction matters for the review. Measurements of tire marks, the rest positions of the vehicles and photographs of the scene are facts the officer observed. A speed figure derived from those facts through an equation is an inference, and the method behind it must meet the expert standard of the court.
In federal court that standard is Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence. Since the 2023 amendment the proponent must show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the facts of the case. The committee note says the amendment "clarifies that the preponderance standard applies to the three reliability-based requirements added in 2000." State courts apply their own rules of evidence, and the review cites the rule of the court where the case is pending.
The review therefore sorts the officer's report into two columns: observations and inferences. Each inference is traced to a formula, its inputs and the source of each input.
What should the defense obtain from the police reconstruction file?
Field notes and measurements, the scale diagram, scene and vehicle photographs, the calculations with inputs, the recorder download and the training record. In federal court Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure is the route.
The prosecutors' monograph lists questions a prosecutor should ask of a reconstruction: "Does the report include a scale drawing?", whether all aspects of the scene have been photographed, such as the vehicles, the debris distribution and the road evidence, and whether road evidence "has been completely documented, including measurements and photographs." Each question names a record the defense can request.
The monograph also tells prosecutors to request from a defense reconstructionist "working notes and calculations (these will show your expert exactly where the defense expert plans to go)" and "copies of any research papers or references that expert relied upon." The same categories exist in the police file, and a defense request names them in the same words.
In federal prosecutions Rule 16(a)(1)(F) requires the government, on request, to permit inspection of results or reports of scientific tests or experiments that are material to the defense or that the government intends to use in its case-in-chief. Rule 16(a)(1)(E) covers items material to preparing the defense, items the government will use at trial and items that belong to the defendant or were obtained from the defendant, such as the defendant's vehicle and its recorder. Rule 16(a)(1)(G) requires a written expert disclosure with a complete statement of all opinions, their bases and reasons, the witness's qualifications and prior testimony, signed by the witness.
A 2022 training handout titled Anticipating Defenses in a DWI Crash Case, prepared by John B. Kwasnoski for law enforcement and prosecutors and posted by the Warren County, New York, District Attorney, lists among expected defense points that the "EDR was not secured and made available to defense." A request that names the module, the download report and the software version leaves no doubt about what was asked.
How does the reviewer check the speed calculation?
By rebuilding it: formula, inputs and their sources, then comparing the result with independent evidence. In Logsdon a crush-based estimate of about 41 mph was compared with recorder readings of 53 and 42 mph.
In Logsdon Detective Jordan measured the towed Envoy and used NHTSA measurements for that model. He applied the Vomhof standard crush narrow object formula. The crush data gave an estimated speed of 40.66 mph from the bumper and 41.30 mph from the hood, and he put the speed at impact at approximately 41 mph. The two estimates differ by 0.64 mph, and the review records such spreads with the rounding used in the final figure.
Another officer testified about the crash data recorder. It showed 53 mph three seconds before the airbag deployed and 42 mph one second before. The appellate court noted that "Jordan's estimates of the Envoy's speed at impact were consistent with Officer Rizer's prior testimony" about the recorder data.
A review of such a calculation asks four things. Which formula was used, and for what kind of impact was it developed? Which inputs were measured on this vehicle and which were taken from published data for the model? How sensitive is the result to each input? Does the result agree with independent evidence, and at what moment does that evidence measure speed? A recorder value one second before deployment and a crush estimate at impact describe different moments, and the review says so.
The prosecutors' monograph adds a caution that runs both ways: a prosecutor should check whether "the reconstructionist did not use the full drag factor if there is no evidence that all the wheels were locked up after collision." A defense review asks the same question of a skid-based speed estimate.
Why is the drag factor a frequent target?
Because a skid-mark speed depends on it directly, and it is measured or assumed for one surface on one day. A prosecutors' guide says this single piece of evidence is often the focus of the defense attack.
The monograph states that the drag factor is a "single piece of evidence" that "is often the focus of the entire defense attack." It also warns prosecutors that "some defense attorneys may misstate that this is the only possible range of values" for drag factors. Both statements tell a reviewer where the dispute usually sits.
The Kwasnoski handout lists cases in which defense experts rejected the police drag sled value after running their own tests weeks later. In cases 5 and 21 of the handout the defense tests were run about four and three weeks later, and the rejected sled values were 0.84 and 0.85. The review records which device the officer used, when the test was run, under what surface and weather conditions, and whether the test vehicle and tires match the vehicle in the crash.
The monograph's caution turns on the same point: the full drag factor fits only a vehicle whose wheels were all locked. If the vehicle had anti-lock brakes or if the marks show that only some wheels were braking, the calculation needs an adjusted value. The review checks the marks in the photographs and the measurement notes against the value used.
A drag factor taken from a table rather than measured at the scene is an assumption. The review states that, gives the range listed in the table, and recalculates speed at both ends of the range.
What does the reviewer check in the event data recorder evidence?
Who downloaded the module with which software version, whether the event belongs to this crash, what the recorded speed measures, and whether the module was preserved for the defense. A prosecutors' handout lists these points.
The Kwasnoski handout lists the recorder issues a prosecutor should expect: the difference between a witness certified as a technician and one certified as an analyst; that the examiner "did not use most recent version of the CDR software"; that the vehicle computer was not checked for re-calibration; that "wheel sensor speeds may not be the same as actual vehicle speeds"; that "the EDR data is from a different crash"; and that "the EDR has a limited amount of recording time for impact data."
The handout also lists a defense expert's assertion that the cumulative change in velocity is the same as the impact speed, and notes that this "may not be true." A defense review uses the recorder data in the same terms: delta-V is a change in velocity, not a speed.
The prosecutors' monograph advises that "the EDR should be secured in anticipation of being able to read the computer memory at a later time" and that "prosecutors should always ask if the vehicle had an EDR and whether the data can be downloaded." It adds that recorder information "may have limited use" on its own but is useful in conjunction with a reconstruction analysis.
In Fields v. Ashford, a civil case in the Eastern District of Michigan, the reconstructionist's report stated that the module it called the ACM "black box" "was damaged to the extent that it could not be downloaded with the CDR tool." When no download exists, the review asks what replaced it and how the speed was reached without it. Where a download exists, the review relates changes in recorded speed to the scene: in Logsdon the readings three seconds and one second before deployment differed by 11 mph, a change the reviewer compares with the braking evidence on the road.
How does the reviewer tie the recorder data to the defendant's vehicle?
Through the download report, the custody record of the module and the match between the recorded event and the crash. The prosecutors' handout lists a different crash and an unproven link to the defendant's vehicle among expected defense points.
The Kwasnoski handout warns prosecutors that the defense may argue "the EDR data is from a different crash" and that the "State has not proven that the EDR data was from the defendant's vehicle." It also lists the claims that an "EDR report can be altered before it is printed" and that if one piece of recorder data is invalid or missing, all of it is invalid. The handout presents these as arguments to anticipate, not as findings.
For a reviewer each claim becomes a check. Does the download report identify the vehicle? Is the time of the download recorded, and by whom? Was the module removed from the vehicle, and if so, who held it between the scene and the download? Is the printed report the one the software produced, and is the original download file in the production?
The question of event matching is separate. A recorder may hold more than one event, and the reviewer compares the recorded event with the crash: the direction of impact, the change in velocity, airbag deployment and the timing against witness accounts and scene evidence. A recorded event that does not fit the crash is set aside in the review with the reasons stated.
Where the defense never had access to the module, the review says what could not be checked and why. That statement goes to counsel before trial, when a request under Rule 16(a)(1)(E) or the state equivalent can still be made.
How are perception-reaction time and avoidability tested?
By asking which reaction time the officer used, where it came from and whether it fits this driver and this hazard. A federal court in Michigan excluded a former state police officer's report that never factored in perception-reaction time.
In Fields v. Ashford, Judge Matthew F. Leitman of the Eastern District of Michigan ruled on November 5, 2019, on a defense motion to exclude the plaintiff's accident reconstructionist, Gary McDonald, who "is a former officer with the Michigan State Police." The court wrote that "his expert report is one page and lists conclusions without any causation analysis" and that he "never factored in 'perception-reaction time' when determining whether Fields had an opportunity to stop."
The court also found that "many of McDonald's calculations were completed nearly a year after McDonald drafted his expert report." It held that the plaintiff had not shown that his causation opinions rested on a reliable foundation under Rule 702 and excluded that testimony in its entirety.
Fields was a civil case, but the same questions arise when a police reconstructionist says a defendant could have avoided the crash. The Kwasnoski handout lists defense arguments in which long perception-reaction times are used to argue unavoidability, one of them that "a PRT of as much as 6 seconds could occur." The review states the value the officer used, its source, and the result at other values the literature supports.
Avoidability also depends on when the hazard became visible. The review checks sight distance, lighting and the position of the other road user at the moment the officer treats as the start of the hazard, and whether that moment comes from measurements or from a witness account.
What happens if the defense does not object at trial?
The appellate court reviews only for plain error. In Logsdon the Ohio court assumed an expert was required, found no plain error, and said the officer was qualified had there been an objection.
Logsdon did not object to Detective Jordan's speed calculation at trial, so the court of appeals reviewed only for plain error. It declined to decide whether an expert was required. It assumed, "for the sake of argument, that an expert was required to testify about the calculated speed estimates," and found "no plain error in this case."
Two reasons carried the ruling. The court said "he had the qualifications to be an expert in crash reconstruction had Logsdon raised an objection," and it found that his estimates matched the recorder testimony. It concluded that the outcome would not clearly have been different and overruled the assignment of error.
A review delivered before trial gives counsel what an objection needs: the specific opinions that are inferences, the method behind each, and the inputs that were assumed. An objection made at trial on those grounds is reviewed under the ordinary standard instead of plain error.
The review also identifies agreement between methods. Where the crush estimate and the recorder data agree, as in Logsdon, the defense may decide not to contest speed and to focus on another element; that decision belongs to counsel.
When must the government disclose its reconstructionist in federal court?
At the time the court sets, sufficiently before trial for a fair opportunity to meet the evidence. Rule 16(c) requires updates, and Rule 16(d)(2) lets the court order discovery, grant a continuance or exclude evidence.
Rule 16(a)(1)(G)(ii) leaves the timing to the court, by order or local rule, but requires it to be sufficiently before trial "to provide a fair opportunity for the defendant to meet the government's evidence." The disclosure must be approved and signed by the witness unless the government explains why it could not obtain the signature or relies on an earlier signed report.
Rule 16(c) imposes a continuing duty: "A party who discovers additional evidence or material before or during trial must promptly disclose its existence." A supplementary reconstruction or a second recorder download made after the first disclosure falls under it.
Rule 16(d)(2) sets the remedies for failure to comply: the court may order the discovery, grant a continuance, prohibit the party from introducing the undisclosed evidence or enter another just order. Fields shows a civil court's view of calculations made long after the report; in a criminal case the same timing question is raised under Rule 16.
Most vehicular homicide prosecutions are brought in state courts, which have their own discovery rules. The review lists the documents by category so that counsel can match them to the state rule.
When does the defense call its own reconstructionist?
When the review finds an alternative account of speed, timing or avoidability that the jury needs explained. In federal court the defense then discloses its expert's signed opinions if it received the government's expert disclosure.
Rule 16(b)(1)(C) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure requires the defense, at the government's request, to disclose in writing the opinions of an expert it will call, with bases, qualifications and prior testimony, when the defense requested and the government provided its own expert disclosure. The defense witness must approve and sign the disclosure.
A defense reconstructionist can rely on published data and present it to the jury in the way Rule 803(18) of the Federal Rules of Evidence permits: a statement in a treatise or periodical established as a reliable authority may be read into evidence, but not received as an exhibit. Rule 705 lets an expert give an opinion without first testifying to the underlying data, but the expert may be required to disclose that data on cross-examination.
A reviewer who only prepares counsel for cross-examination does not testify and produces no report the defense intends to use at trial. Whether to call a defense expert is a decision for counsel.
A 2003 abstract presented to the American Academy of Forensic Sciences, titled Is This a Case of Prosecutorial Misconduct?, by Peter Alexander and John Smith, describes a felony reckless vehicular assault case in which a defense reconstruction analysis argued that the State's speed estimate was unsupported. Such analyses reach the jury only through a disclosed defense witness.
What does IAE do when a party needs a review of an accident reconstruction report?
IAE reviews the opposing reconstructionist's report: inputs, reaction times, calculations, tests and the limits of engineering opinion. Delivery takes up to 5 business days, with a 48-hour rush, and counsel receives an inspection list.
IAE's page for accident reconstruction reviews describes the work for counsel facing the other side's reconstructionist in injury and property damage cases in US courts. The engineer asks whether the opposing reconstructionist applied the intellectual rigor that practice in the field requires. For the vehicles the engineer lists for counsel what needs to be measured and downloaded, including the event data recorder.
IAE confirms the questions, the format and the deadline with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt of the materials the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work begins.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are sent through the contact form or by email and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs a review with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; legal questions are for the client's attorney.
Sources
- State v. Logsdon, 2026-Ohio-1789 (Ohio Ct. App. 2d Dist. May 15, 2026), Supreme Court of Ohio
- Fields v. Ashford, No. 17-cv-11812 (E.D. Mich. Nov. 5, 2019), ECF No. 88 (Justia)
- Kwasnoski J., Crash Reconstruction Basics for Prosecutors: Targeting Hardcore Impaired Drivers, American Prosecutors Research Institute, March 2003 (TDCAA)
- Kwasnoski J. B., Anticipating Defenses in a DWI Crash Case, training handout (Warren County, N.Y., District Attorney)
- Alexander P., Smith J., Is This a Case of Prosecutorial Misconduct?, American Academy of Forensic Sciences, 2003, abstract E10
- Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 16 (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, with committee note to the 2023 amendment (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 705 (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 803(18) (LII)
Read also
All articles
Left-turn collision: how does a reviewer check the opposing reconstruction of the oncoming vehicle's speed and the turning driver's gap?
In a left-turn crash each side blames the other: the turning driver failed to yield, or the oncoming driver was speeding. State statutes require
The police accident report is wrong: how is it checked, and what weight does it carry in court?
A police crash report is written by an officer who usually arrived after the vehicles stopped moving. It records what the officer saw, measured
Rear-end collision: how does a reviewer check the opposing reconstruction of a sudden stop or chain crash?
In a rear-end crash the law starts against the rear driver: New York treats the collision as a prima facie case of negligence, and Florida presumesExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

