Expert report review
Left-turn collision: how does a reviewer check the opposing reconstruction of the oncoming vehicle's speed and the turning driver's gap?
In a left-turn crash each side blames the other: the turning driver failed to yield, or the oncoming driver was speeding. State statutes require the turning driver to yield to a vehicle close enough to be an immediate hazard, and Minnesota's statute adds that a driver at an unlawful speed forfeits the right-of-way. A reviewer of the opposing reconstruction checks the speed estimate, the time and distance figures and every opinion phrased as a legal conclusion.

What does the law require of a driver turning left?
To yield to a vehicle approaching in the opposite direction that is within the intersection or so close as to be an immediate hazard. Florida, Minnesota and California state the duty in nearly the same words.
Florida Statutes section 316.122 reads: "The driver of a vehicle intending to turn to the left within an intersection or into an alley, private road, or driveway shall yield the right-of-way to any vehicle approaching from the opposite direction," or vehicles lawfully passing on the left of the turning vehicle, "which is within the intersection or so close thereto as to constitute an immediate hazard." Minnesota Statutes section 169.20, subdivision 2, uses the same test for a vehicle approaching in the opposite direction.
California Vehicle Code section 21801(a) extends the duty over the whole maneuver. The turning driver yields to all vehicles approaching in the opposite direction "which are close enough to constitute a hazard at any time during the turning movement" and continues to yield "until the left turn or U-turn can be made with reasonable safety." Subdivision (b) then reverses the duty: a driver who has yielded as required may turn, and drivers approaching in the opposite direction "shall yield the right-of-way to the turning vehicle."
None of these statutes gives a distance in feet. "Immediate hazard" and "close enough to constitute a hazard" are filled in by evidence: where the oncoming vehicle was when the turn began, how fast it was going, and how long the turning vehicle needed to clear the lane. That is the reconstruction a reviewer is asked to check.
What changes if the oncoming driver was speeding?
In Minnesota the statute answers directly: a driver travelling at an unlawful speed forfeits any right-of-way the driver might otherwise have. In any state the oncoming speed decides how far away the vehicle was when the turn began.
Minnesota Statutes section 169.20, subdivision 1(d), states: "The driver of any vehicle traveling at an unlawful speed shall forfeit any right-of-way which the driver might otherwise have hereunder." Under that text the question of who had to yield cannot be answered until the speed is found.
Lemieux v. Bishop, 209 N.W.2d 379 (Minn. June 22, 1973), is a left-turn case in which the jury heard a disputed estimate of the oncoming car's speed. The opinion does not cite section 169.20; the dispute on appeal was the expert's speed estimate. Shortly after midnight on a rural county road with a 50 mph limit, an eastbound car began a left turn into a driveway and was struck by a westbound 1965 Chevrolet driven by a 16-year-old. The turning driver and one of his passengers were killed. The oncoming driver testified that he was going about 50 mph. The jury found him 72 percent negligent and the turning driver 28 percent negligent, and the Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed.
The court wrote: "Determination of speed is for the triers of fact." The reconstruction does not decide the case, but it supplies the number on which the allocation of fault turns. A reviewer therefore spends the largest share of the work on the speed estimate.
How is the oncoming vehicle's speed estimated, and where do errors enter?
Usually by adding the speed lost in braking to the speed at impact. In Lemieux v. Bishop the plaintiff's engineer added 52 mph and 29 mph to reach 81 mph, while the defense's formula gave about 59.5 mph.
In Lemieux the oncoming car left 107 feet of skid marks. The plaintiff's expert, a registered mechanical engineer, measured a friction coefficient of 0.89 with a test vehicle at the scene under substantially similar conditions. He estimated a minimum speed at impact of 29 mph and a speed of 52 mph accounted for by the skid, and added the two for a minimum speed before braking of 81 mph.
The defendants argued that the two speeds must be combined as the square root of the sum of their squares. On the same inputs that gives about 59.5 mph. The difference between the two answers is more than 20 mph, and it comes from one line of arithmetic. The court called 81 mph a figure that "seems exceedingly high" but held that an error in calculation or assumptions "goes to the weight of the testimony, not to its admissibility."
A reviewer repeats the calculation in the opposing report with the report's own inputs. Four items are checked. Was the skid length measured at the scene or scaled off a photograph? Was the friction value measured, as in Lemieux, or taken out of a table, and for which surface and weather? What is the basis of the speed at impact: crush measurements, a recorder download, or an assumption? And how were the component speeds combined?
Each answer is written with the page of the report where it is found. If the report gives a single speed with no range, the reviewer recalculates with the lowest and highest inputs the evidence supports and reports both results.
What do event data recorders add in a left-turn case?
A record of indicated speed, accelerator position and brake status before the crash. Under 49 CFR 563.7 the required record is 5 seconds at 2 samples per second until a phase-in to 20 seconds begins in 2028.
Table I of 49 CFR 563.7 lists the data elements every event data recorder must capture. Indicated vehicle speed, engine throttle or accelerator pedal position, and service brake status are recorded before time zero. A footnote to the table sets the current interval at "-5.0 to 0 sec" at 2 samples per second. For vehicles manufactured on or after September 1, 2028, a phase-in begins toward an interval of 20 seconds at 10 samples per second, starting with 25 percent of each manufacturer's production in the first year. Longitudinal delta-V is recorded during the crash pulse at 100 samples per second.
In a left-turn case both vehicles matter. The oncoming vehicle's record gives its speed and the moment the brake was applied. The turning vehicle's record gives its speed through the turn, which tells how long it had been moving across the lane. A reviewer checks whether the opposing expert downloaded both recorders, whether the report attaches the full download or only selected rows, and whether the speeds in the calculations match the recorded values.
Five seconds at two samples per second is a coarse record. Braking that begins between two samples appears half a second late or early, and at 60 mph a vehicle covers 44 feet in that half second. Where the report places the oncoming vehicle to the foot, the reviewer asks what resolution of data supports that precision.
What does a time-distance analysis have to show?
Where each vehicle was at each moment before impact: when the turn began, how far away the oncoming vehicle was then, and whether its driver could have avoided the crash at the actual and the lawful speed.
The analysis runs backward in time, starting at the point of impact. The turning vehicle's path across the lane, at its speed, gives the time since the turn began. The oncoming vehicle's speed over the same time gives its distance at that moment. Perception and reaction time is then set against that distance: could the oncoming driver have stopped or slowed enough, and would the turning vehicle have cleared the lane if the oncoming vehicle had been travelling at the limit?
Fields v. Ashford, No. 17-cv-11812 (E.D. Mich. Nov. 5, 2019), is a record of what happens when this analysis is missing. A truck pulled off the shoulder of I-96 into the right lane at 20 to 25 mph, and a car struck it in the rear. The plaintiff's reconstructionist, a former state police officer, wrote a report of less than one page concluding that the truck driver was the cause of the crash. At deposition he admitted that he had not factored in perception time, had calculated no speed for the plaintiff's car, had done no testing, modeling or simulation, and could not say that the plaintiff lacked time to avoid the collision.
Judge Leitman excluded his testimony in its entirety under Rule 702. The court found no discernible methodology. It noted that the handwritten calculations he prepared almost a year after the report, two days before his deposition, were hard to follow, and that many of them used a speed of 92 mph, which he said was not the speed in the actual crash. The collision in Fields was not a left turn, but the defect is the one a reviewer looks for in every right-of-way case: a conclusion about who cut off whom, with no positions, times or speeds behind it.
May the reconstructionist testify that a driver failed to yield?
In Fields v. Ashford all of the expert's opinions, including that the defendant failed to yield and took away the plaintiff's right-of-way, were excluded for lack of method. A footnote noted authority that such opinions are legal conclusions.
The expert in Fields testified that the truck driver "failed to yield," was driving below the minimum speed for commercial vehicles, "took away Ms. Fields' right-of-way" and was "a hundred percent" at fault. The court excluded this testimony with the rest of his causation opinion. In a footnote it noted authority that an expert should not testify that a party violated the motor vehicle code, because that is a legal conclusion, and it did not rest the ruling on that point. As an alternative ground for excluding the minimum-speed opinion the court held that it was not based on specialized knowledge and would not help the jury, because jurors could compare the admitted 20 to 25 mph with the statutory minimum themselves.
A reviewer goes through the opposing report sentence by sentence and sorts the opinions into two groups. Engineering findings state a speed, a distance, a time or a position and name the data behind it. Legal characterizations state that a driver had the right-of-way, violated a statute or caused the crash. The review lists the second group with page numbers. Whether to move to exclude them is counsel's decision.
The same sorting protects the client's own position. If the engineering findings in the opposing report are sound and only the labels are objectionable, the review says so, and counsel knows that a motion directed at the labels leaves the numbers in the case.
What does IAE do when a left-turn reconstruction is disputed?
An engineer in the IAE registry reviews the opposing reconstruction: inputs, reaction times, calculations, tests and opinions that go past engineering. The review takes up to 5 business days, with a 48-hour rush.
The IAE accident reconstruction review is for counsel facing the other side's reconstructionist in an injury or property damage case in a US court. The engineer checks the inputs, the reaction times, the calculations, the tests and the limits of engineering opinion. Each point is tied to a page of the report. Counsel also receives an inspection list.
The client sends the report with its exhibits, the police report, photographs, recorder downloads and deposition transcripts, and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist in its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix. The Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- Florida Statutes section 316.122, Vehicle turning left (2024) (Florida Senate)
- Minnesota Statutes section 169.20, Right-of-way (2025) (Justia)
- California Vehicle Code section 21801 (California Public Law)
- Lemieux v. Bishop, 209 N.W.2d 379 (Minn. June 22, 1973) (Justia)
- Fields v. Ashford, No. 17-cv-11812 (E.D. Mich. Nov. 5, 2019), ECF No. 88 (Justia)
- 49 CFR 563.7, Data elements (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
The police accident report is wrong: how is it checked, and what weight does it carry in court?
A police crash report is written by an officer who usually arrived after the vehicles stopped moving. It records what the officer saw, measured
Rear-end collision: how does a reviewer check the opposing reconstruction of a sudden stop or chain crash?
In a rear-end crash the law starts against the rear driver: New York treats the collision as a prima facie case of negligence, and Florida presumes
Seat belt defense: how does a reviewer check the opposing expert's opinion that a belt would have prevented the injuries?
When the defense says the plaintiff was not wearing a seat belt, the argument stands on two expert findings: that the plaintiff was unbeltedExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

