Examinations
Design patent infringement: how the ordinary observer test works and what the expert compares
A design patent is infringed when, in the eye of an ordinary observer who gives the attention a purchaser usually gives, the accused design is substantially the same as the patented one. The Supreme Court set this test in Gorham v. White in 1871. Since Egyptian Goddess v. Swisa (2008) it is the only test, and the two designs are compared against the background of earlier designs.

What does a design patent protect?
A new, original and ornamental design for an article of manufacture (35 U.S.C. 171). The patent covers the appearance shown in its drawings, for the article the claim names, for 15 years from the date of grant.
Under 35 U.S.C. 171(a), "Whoever invents any new, original and ornamental design for an article of manufacture may obtain a patent therefor," subject to the conditions of the patent title. Section 171(b) applies the provisions on patents for inventions to designs unless the title provides otherwise. Under 35 U.S.C. 173, "Patents for designs shall be granted for the term of 15 years from the date of grant." The term was fourteen years until a 2012 amendment, which took effect on May 13, 2015.
The words of the claim matter as much as the drawings. In Curver Luxembourg, SARL v. Home Expressions Inc., No. 2018-2214, decided September 12, 2019, the design patent D677,946 claimed an "ornamental design for a pattern for a chair." The figures showed an overlapping Y pattern and no chair. During prosecution the title "Pattern for a Chair" replaced the earlier "Furniture (Part of-)."
Curver sued over baskets with a similar pattern. Judge Chen wrote for the panel: "we hold that claim language can limit the scope of a design patent" where it names an article of manufacture that does not appear in the figures. Since the claim was limited to chairs, "no 'ordinary observer' could be deceived into purchasing Home Expressions's baskets," and the dismissal of the complaint was affirmed.
For an expert this sets the first check of any infringement analysis: what article the claim names, and whether the accused product is that article.
Where does the ordinary observer test come from?
From Gorham Co. v. White (1871). The Supreme Court held that a design is infringed if, to an ordinary observer giving the attention a purchaser usually gives, the two designs are substantially the same.
Gorham held a design patent for the handles of tablespoons and forks, which, the opinion says, became popular "under the name of the 'cottage pattern.'" The defendant sold spoons and forks made to two designs patented to White in 1867 and 1868.
Justice Strong wrote for the Court in Gorham Co. v. White, 81 U.S. 511: "We hold, therefore, that if, in the eye of an ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser usually gives, two designs are substantially the same, if the resemblance is such as to deceive such an observer, inducing him to purchase one supposing it to be the other, the first one patented is infringed by the other."
The Court explained that "human ingenuity has never yet produced a design, in all its details, exactly like another," so a comparison through the eyes of specialists would find a difference in every case. "Experts, therefore, are not the persons to be deceived." The decree was reversed and the case sent back with instructions to enter a decree in line with the opinion. Justices Miller, Field and Bradley dissented.
The Federal Circuit repeated this point in Ethicon in 2015, as described below. The expert in a design case explains the designs and the earlier art to the court or jury, but the question is how the designs look to a purchaser, not to the expert.
What changed with Egyptian Goddess v. Swisa?
In 2008 the en banc Federal Circuit dropped the point of novelty test and held that the ordinary observer test is the sole test for design patent infringement, applied with the prior art in view.
Until 2008 the Federal Circuit applied a second test, the point of novelty test, alongside the ordinary observer test. On September 22, 2008, the en banc court, in an opinion by Judge Bryson, held "that the 'point of novelty' test should no longer be used in the analysis of a claim of design patent infringement," and that "the 'ordinary observer' test should be the sole test for determining whether a design patent has been infringed." The text of Egyptian Goddess, Inc. v. Swisa, Inc., 543 F.3d 665 describes two kinds of cases.
In the first, "the claimed design and the accused design will be sufficiently distinct that it will be clear without more that the patentee has not met its burden" of proof. In the second, "when the claimed and accused designs are not plainly dissimilar," the prior art enters the comparison: "differences between the claimed and accused designs that might not be noticeable in the abstract can become significant to the hypothetical ordinary observer who is conversant with the prior art."
The court also explained what such an observer notices. "When the differences between the claimed and accused design are viewed in light of the prior art, the attention of the hypothetical ordinary observer will be drawn to those aspects of the claimed design that differ from the prior art."
Who must prove what?
The patentee proves infringement by a preponderance of the evidence. If the accused infringer relies on comparison prior art, Egyptian Goddess put the burden of producing that art on the accused infringer.
The en banc court wrote: "Thus, as is always the case, the burden of proof as to infringement remains on the patentee." The standard is a preponderance: the patentee bears "the ultimate burden of proof" of infringement by a preponderance of the evidence.
The defense brings the prior art. In the court's words, "if the accused infringer elects to rely on the comparison prior art as part of its defense against the claim of infringement, the burden of production of that prior art is on the accused infringer."
Invalidity is proved to a higher standard. In Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. v. Covidien, Inc., 796 F.3d 1312 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 7, 2015), the court wrote that "Covidien has the burden to prove invalidity of the Design Patents by clear and convincing evidence." For the expert this means two separate tasks with two sets of materials: a comparison of the patent with the accused product for infringement, and a search and analysis of earlier designs for validity.
How was the test applied to the nail buffer in Egyptian Goddess?
The patented buffer had pads on three of its four sides; the accused buffer had pads on all four. Viewed against two earlier buffers, the court held that no reasonable fact-finder could find infringement, and it affirmed summary judgment.
The patent claimed "a design for a nail buffer, consisting of a rectangular, hollow tube having a generally square cross-section" with "buffer surfaces on three of its four sides." Swisa's product was also "a rectangular, hollow tube having a square cross-section," but with buffer surfaces "on all four of its sides."
Two earlier designs framed the comparison. The Nailco patent showed a buffer with "a triangular shape and a hollow cross section, and in which raised buffing pads are located on all three sides." The Falley buffer had "a solid, rectangular cross section with slightly raised buffers on all sides." The court noted that the Nailco design differed from the accused buffer in having three sides rather than four.
The conclusion: "no reasonable fact-finder could find that EGI met its burden of showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, that an ordinary observer, taking into account the prior art, would believe the accused design to be the same as the patented design." The summary judgment of no infringement was affirmed.
What did the court expect from the expert's declaration?
A comparison that deals with each difference and with the prior art. In Egyptian Goddess the court faulted the patentee's expert for not acknowledging that the patented design has three pads and the accused design four.
The patentee's expert, Kathleen Eaton, declared that the two designs would "confuse an ordinary observer into purchasing the accused buffer thinking it to be the patented buffer design." She based this on both designs "having a hollow tube, square in cross section and rectangular in length, with multiple raised rectangular pads mounted on the sides, and that do not cover the corners of the tube."
On the extra pad she wrote: "I do not believe that, to an ordinary observer and purchaser of nail buffers, the presence of one more buffer pad[s] greatly alters the ornamental effect and appearance of the whole design as compared to the whole patented design."
The court found that she had characterized the designs as similar "without directly acknowledging that the patented design has three pads while the accused design has four, one on each side." Her reference to the prior art was limited to "the single, and conclusory, comment that an ordinary observer and purchaser of nail buffers would consider the patented design and the accused buffer to be substantially similar."
The two points the court raised can be checked in any declaration: whether it names each visible difference between the patent drawings and the accused product, and whether it compares the prior art feature by feature with both designs, so that the court can see which features of the patented design are new.
How are functional features treated?
Only ornamental aspects are protected. Egyptian Goddess lists separating ornamental from purely functional features as guidance, and in Ethicon (2015) the Federal Circuit limited the claim scope to the ornamental aspects of the design.
Egyptian Goddess left claim construction to the trial court's discretion: "the court is not obligated to issue a detailed verbal description of the design." Among the matters that can guide the finder of fact, the opinion lists "distinguishing between those features of the claimed design that are ornamental and those that are purely functional."
Ethicon concerned design patents on ultrasonic surgical shears. Judge Chen wrote that "an inquiry into whether a claimed design is primarily functional should begin with an inquiry into the existence of alternative designs." Where a design is not primarily functional but has functional elements, "the scope of that claim, however, must be limited to the ornamental aspects of the design."
The court reversed the district court's ruling that the design patents were invalid for functionality and vacated its construction that left the claims with no scope. It affirmed summary judgment of no infringement because the designs were plainly dissimilar: the district court had contrasted the contoured shape of the claimed design with the linear shape of the accused one, and the trigger handles curved in the patent but ran parallel in the accused device.
An expert who sorts features into functional and ornamental needs evidence for each: alternative designs that perform the same function, or the absence of them.
Who is the ordinary observer?
Not an expert in the designs. In Ethicon (2015) the Federal Circuit read Gorham as describing a person of ordinary acuteness who is a principal purchaser of the articles bearing the claimed designs.
The Ethicon opinion: "The Supreme Court explained in Gorham that the ordinary observer is not an expert in the claimed designs, but one of 'ordinary acuteness' who is a 'principal purchaser[]' of the underlying articles with the claimed designs."
The parties disagreed about who that was. The district court found the ordinary observer to be a sophisticated entity that managed the purchasing of complex medical devices. Ethicon argued that it was the surgeon who would use the shears. The Federal Circuit did not decide, because "the claimed and accused designs are plainly dissimilar even to one less discerning than the ordinary observer."
Who the purchaser is decides how much attention the observer gives under Gorham. An expert report that describes the market for the product, who buys it and how, gives the court the facts it needs to fix that observer.
What can a design patent owner recover?
Under 35 U.S.C. 289, the infringer's total profit on the article of manufacture, not less than $250, on top of other remedies but without recovering the profit twice. Samsung v. Apple (2016) held that the article can be a component.
35 U.S.C. 289 makes liable whoever, during the term of a design patent and without license, "applies the patented design, or any colorable imitation thereof, to any article of manufacture for the purpose of sale," or sells or exposes for sale such an article. That person "shall be liable to the owner to the extent of his total profit, but not less than $250." The owner keeps the other remedies of the patent title "but he shall not twice recover the profit made from the infringement."
In Samsung Electronics Co. v. Apple Inc., No. 15-777, decided December 6, 2016, the patents were D618,677 (a black rectangular front face with rounded corners), D593,087 (a rectangular front face with rounded corners and a raised rim) and D604,305 ("a grid of 16 colorful icons on a black screen"). Apple had been awarded $399 million, Samsung's entire profit from the infringing smartphones.
Justice Sotomayor wrote for the Court that "the term 'article of manufacture' is broad enough to embrace both a product sold to a consumer and a component of that product, whether sold separately or not." The damages inquiry has two steps: "First, identify the 'article of manufacture' to which the infringed design has been applied. Second, calculate the infringer's total profit made on that article of manufacture." The Court declined to set out a test for the first step, reversed and remanded.
How is a design patent's validity tested after LKQ v. GM?
Through the Graham factors, from the viewpoint of an ordinary designer in the field of the claimed design. In May 2024 the en banc Federal Circuit overruled the Rosen-Durling requirements for design patent obviousness.
LKQ Corp. v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, No. 2021-2348, decided May 21, 2024, came from an inter partes review of GM's design patent D797,625 for a front fender of the 2018-2020 Chevrolet Equinox. Judge Stoll wrote for the court; Judge Lourie concurred in the judgment.
The court overruled "the Rosen-Durling test requirements that the primary reference must be 'basically the same' as the challenged design claim and that any secondary references must be 'so related' to the primary reference." Obviousness is assessed from "the viewpoint of an ordinary designer in the field to which the claimed design pertains," and "analogous art for a design patent includes art from the same field of endeavor as the article of manufacture." The inquiry "focuses on the visual impression of the claimed design as a whole and not on selected individual features."
The Board's nonobviousness determination was vacated and the case remanded. The two standards sit side by side in one case: infringement is judged through the ordinary observer of Gorham, validity through the ordinary designer of LKQ, and an expert report keeps the two analyses apart.
What does the expert compare in a design patent case?
The patent drawings, the accused product and the earlier designs, view by view: which features are ornamental and which functional, where the designs differ, and how those differences look against the prior art of the same article.
Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence lets a witness qualified "by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education" testify if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony "is based on sufficient facts or data," that it "is the product of reliable principles and methods," and that the opinion applies those principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case.
In a design patent case the facts or data are concrete. The expert starts with the claim and the drawings, including the article the claim names (Curver). The accused product is shown in the same views as the patent figures. Features dictated by function are identified with evidence of alternative designs (Ethicon). Earlier designs of the same article are gathered, because the accused infringer bears the burden of producing comparison prior art and the observer's attention goes to the features that differ from it (Egyptian Goddess). Each difference between the patent and the accused product is named, including the ones that favor the other side.
The ultimate question stays with the finder of fact. The expert's declaration in Egyptian Goddess was criticized for its conclusory treatment of the prior art, while Gorham itself said that experts "are not the persons to be deceived."
What does IAE prepare in a design patent dispute?
An IAE expert prepares a report on infringement or validity over the prior art on the client's questions, or a review of the opposing technical expert's report, for district court cases and PTAB proceedings, in up to 5 business days.
The IAE patent page describes expert reports on whether a product meets the patent claim and on validity over the prior art, for district court cases and PTAB proceedings, and reviews of the opposing technical expert's report. IAE chooses the expert by the technical field of the patent and confirms the patent, the asserted claims and the questions before work starts.
The secretariat confirms receipt of the materials the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the expert from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
Every expert is a member of the public IAE registry and can be checked by Member ID or QR code, and the expert confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. Materials are sent through the contact form and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent.
Sources
- 35 U.S.C. 171, Patents for designs (Cornell LII)
- 35 U.S.C. 173, Term of design patent (Cornell LII)
- 35 U.S.C. 289, Additional remedy for infringement of design patent (Cornell LII)
- Gorham Co. v. White, 81 U.S. 511 (1871) (Justia)
- Egyptian Goddess, Inc. v. Swisa, Inc., 543 F.3d 665 (Fed. Cir. 2008) (en banc), full text (BitLaw)
- Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. v. Covidien, Inc., 796 F.3d 1312 (Fed. Cir. 2015), full text (BitLaw)
- Curver Luxembourg, SARL v. Home Expressions Inc., No. 2018-2214 (Fed. Cir. Sept. 12, 2019) (PDF)
- Samsung Electronics Co. v. Apple Inc., No. 15-777 (U.S. Dec. 6, 2016) (Justia)
- LKQ Corp. v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, No. 2021-2348 (Fed. Cir. May 21, 2024) (en banc) (court PDF)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (Cornell LII)
Read also
All articles
Prior user rights: what must an accused infringer prove under 35 U.S.C. 273, and what does the technical expert compare?
A company that has run a process in its plant for years can be sued when someone else later patents the same process. Section 273 of the Patent Act
Patent inventorship dispute: who is an inventor, and how does the technical expert map each contribution to the claims?
An inventorship dispute asks who conceived what the claims cover. A former employee, a university collaborator or a supplier's engineer says he
Process patent infringement: how is it proved that a product was made by the patented method?
A process patent is infringed when someone performs the claimed method in the United States, or imports, sells or uses a product made by itExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

