Examinations

Prior user rights: what must an accused infringer prove under 35 U.S.C. 273, and what does the technical expert compare?

A company that has run a process in its plant for years can be sued when someone else later patents the same process. Section 273 of the Patent Act gives that company a defense if its commercial use in the United States began at least one year before the patent's effective filing date. The defense is personal and is proved by clear and convincing evidence. Dated production records and a technical comparison with the claims carry it.

An engineer from behind watches an older factory machine, a closed binder under one arm

What is the prior user rights defense?

A defense to infringement for a person who, acting in good faith, commercially used the patented subject matter in the United States at least one year before the patent's effective filing date or the inventor's earlier public disclosure.

The defense is codified at 35 U.S.C. 273 as a defense based on prior commercial use. It is raised under section 282(b) against a claim that a process, or a machine, manufacture or composition of matter used in a commercial process, infringes a claimed invention.

The use may be an internal commercial use, or an actual arm's length sale or other arm's length commercial transfer of a useful end result of that use. A process that never leaves the plant can qualify.

A successful defense leaves the patent in force against everyone else. Subsection (g) provides that a patent shall not be deemed invalid under section 102 or 103 solely because a defense is raised or established under section 273.

Congress rewrote the section in section 5 of Pub. L. 112-29, the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act, signed into law on September 16, 2011. The earlier section, added on November 29, 1999, related to a defense based on an earlier inventor. Under section 5(c) of the Act the amended text applies to any patent issued on or after the date of enactment. The Patent and Trademark Office sent Congress a Report on the Prior User Rights Defense in January 2012.

How early must the commercial use have started?

At least one year before the earlier of two dates: the effective filing date of the claimed invention, or the date the invention was publicly disclosed in a way that qualified for the grace period exception of section 102(b).

The second date exists because of the inventor's grace period. Under section 102(b)(1) a disclosure made one year or less before the effective filing date is not prior art if it was made by the inventor or a joint inventor, or if the subject matter had already been publicly disclosed by the inventor. Where the inventor published inside that year, the prior user's year is counted back starting at the publication.

The arithmetic is simple. With an effective filing date of March 1, 2020 and no earlier disclosure by the inventor, the commercial use must have begun on or before March 1, 2019. If the inventor published on June 1, 2019, the use must have begun on or before June 1, 2018.

Which date is the effective filing date of a claim is a legal question. The technical expert works on the other end of the interval: the first date on which the records show the complete process or product in commercial operation.

Who carries the burden of proof, and how heavy is it?

The person asserting the defense, by clear and convincing evidence under section 273(b). A defendant found to infringe who pleaded the defense without a reasonable basis faces a mandatory finding that the case is exceptional for attorney fees.

Section 273(b) reads in one line: a person asserting the defense has the burden of establishing it by clear and convincing evidence. The patent itself is presumed valid under section 282(a), and the burden of establishing invalidity rests on the party asserting it. A defendant who pleads both invalidity and prior commercial use carries the burden on each.

Subsection (f) adds a sanction. If the defense is pleaded by a person who is found to infringe the patent and who then fails to show a reasonable basis for asserting it, "the court shall find the case exceptional" for the purpose of awarding attorney fees under section 285. A defendant who pleads the defense before its records have been compared with the claims takes that risk.

What counts as commercial use?

Internal commercial use, or an actual arm's length sale or other commercial transfer of a useful end result. The statute adds two special cases: premarketing regulatory review and noncommercial use by a nonprofit laboratory.

The first special case is in section 273(c)(1). Subject matter whose commercial marketing or use is subject to a premarketing regulatory review period, during which its safety or efficacy is established, is deemed to be commercially used during that period. The provision names the period specified in section 156(g).

The second is in section 273(c)(2). Use by a nonprofit research laboratory or another nonprofit entity, such as a university or hospital, for which the public is the intended beneficiary, is deemed a commercial use. The defense then covers only continued and noncommercial use by and in that laboratory or entity.

The use must be in the United States. A process run abroad before the cutoff date and moved to a US plant afterwards does not fit the text of subsection (a).

What does the technical expert compare?

The process or product as it was run before the cutoff date, element by element against each asserted claim, using dated records. The expert also compares that earlier version with what the company does today.

The defense is not a general license. Under section 273(e)(3) it does not extend to all claims of the patent. It covers the specific subject matter for which the commercial use has been established, plus variations in the quantity or volume of use and improvements that do not infringe additional specifically claimed subject matter. Each asserted claim therefore gets its own chart.

For this defense the chart needs three columns: the claim element, the corresponding step or component in records dated before the cutoff, and the same step or component in the accused process today. A change made after the cutoff is then tested against the remaining claims. If the changed step falls within a claim that the earlier process did not practice, the defense does not reach it.

The records are production documents: batch records, standard operating procedures, equipment purchase and qualification files, drawings, versions of control software, quality records and invoices for the end result. They have to show the complete process, the date, the site and the continuity of use.

In federal court the opinion is tested under Rule 702. The proponent must show that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data and is the product of reliable principles and methods reliably applied to the facts of the case. The written report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) must contain a complete statement of all opinions with the basis and reasons for them and the facts or data considered by the witness.

Can the defense be licensed, sold or moved to another site?

Only within narrow limits. It belongs to the person who performed or directed the commercial use and to affiliated entities, passes only with the whole enterprise or line of business, and then covers only sites already in use.

Section 273(e)(1)(A) lets the defense be asserted only by the person who performed or directed the performance of the commercial use, or by an entity that controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with that person. Under subparagraph (B) the right to assert it may not be licensed, assigned or transferred, except to the patent owner or as "an ancillary and subordinate part of a good-faith assignment" or transfer, for other reasons, of the entire enterprise or line of business to which the defense relates.

Subparagraph (C) restricts the acquirer. A defense acquired as part of such a transfer may be asserted only for uses at sites where the subject matter was in use before the later of the effective filing date of the claimed invention or the date of the assignment or transfer. After an acquisition the question becomes site-specific, and production records for each plant answer it.

Customers are protected through exhaustion. Under subsection (d) the sale or other disposition of a useful end result by a person entitled to assert the defense "shall exhaust the patent owner's rights" to the same extent as if the patent owner had made the sale.

When is the defense unavailable or lost?

When the subject matter was derived from the patentee, when the qualifying use was abandoned, and when the invention was owned by or subject to assignment to a university or its technology transfer organization at the time it was made.

Derivation is the first bar. Under section 273(e)(2) a person may not assert the defense if the subject matter on which it is based was derived from the patentee or persons in privity with the patentee. Subsection (a) also requires that the user acted in good faith.

Abandonment is the second. Under section 273(e)(4) a person who has abandoned commercial use of the subject matter "may not rely on activities performed before the date of such abandonment" in establishing a defense for actions taken on or after that date. Gaps in production therefore matter, and the expert reads campaign records and shutdown periods as closely as the first batch.

The third is the university exception in section 273(e)(5). The defense is not available if the claimed invention, at the time it was made, was owned by or subject to an obligation of assignment to an institution of higher education or a technology transfer organization of such institutions. The exception does not apply if the activities required to reduce the invention to practice could not have been undertaken using funds provided by the Federal Government.

Why not invalidate the patent with the earlier use instead?

Because prior art under section 102(a)(1) must have been patented, published, in public use, on sale or otherwise available to the public. An in-house process may meet none of those terms, and section 273 does not require publicity.

Section 102(a)(1) bars a patent if the claimed invention "was patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale, or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date of the claimed invention." Section 273(a) asks for something different: good-faith commercial use in the United States, internal use included, at least one year before the cutoff.

Both defenses can rest on the same records. The expert answers two separate questions on them: whether the earlier process contained every element of the claim, and what about that process was accessible outside the company. The first answer serves both defenses. The second decides which of the two is available.

What does IAE do when prior commercial use is at issue?

An IAE expert prepares a report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing technical expert's report, in up to 5 business days. The patent, the asserted claims and the questions are confirmed before work starts.

The patent expertise page describes claim charts that map each claim element to the accused product and a prior art search before the effective filing date, for district court cases and PTAB proceedings. A prior commercial use question is put to the expert in the same form: which elements of the asserted claims the client's dated production records show.

IAE chooses the expert by the technical field of the patent and confirms the patent, the asserted claims and the questions before work starts. The client sends the patent, the claim construction if there is one, and the production records it may share under the protective order. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the expert from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Every expert is a member of the public IAE registry, verifiable by Member ID or QR code, and states in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member