Examinations

Patent inventorship dispute: who is an inventor, and how does the technical expert map each contribution to the claims?

An inventorship dispute asks who conceived what the claims cover. A former employee, a university collaborator or a supplier's engineer says he or she contributed to a patent that names someone else. The answer decides who owns the patent, who can license it and whether an infringement suit can go forward. The technical expert's part is to set each person's documented contribution against each claim and against what was already known.

Two pairs of hands pause over a small unmarked prototype, notebooks closed, in a workshop

Who counts as an inventor of a patent?

A person who contributed to the conception of the claimed invention. Under 35 U.S.C. 116(a) joint inventors need not work together, make the same type or amount of contribution, or contribute to every claim.

In Ethicon, Inc. v. United States Surgical Corp., 135 F.3d 1456, decided on February 3, 1998, the Federal Circuit wrote that conception is the touchstone of inventorship, so each joint inventor generally must contribute to conception. It defined conception as the formation in the mind of the inventor of a definite and permanent idea of the complete and operative invention.

35 U.S.C. 116(a) provides that inventors may apply for a patent jointly even though they did not physically work together or at the same time, each did not make the same type or amount of contribution, or each did not make a contribution to the subject matter of every claim of the patent. The Ethicon court applied that rule directly: a contribution to one claim is enough.

The test set out in Pannu, below, excludes explaining well-known concepts or the state of the art. Work that adds nothing to the idea a claim covers, such as building a prototype to someone else's design or running tests that someone else planned, is measured against the same test. The question is always whether the person formed part of the definite idea that a claim now covers.

What must an alleged co-inventor prove?

Under Pannu v. Iolab, a significant contribution to conception or reduction to practice, not insignificant in quality measured against the full invention, and more than explaining well-known concepts or the state of the art, all by clear and convincing evidence.

In Pannu v. Iolab Corp., 155 F.3d 1344, decided on August 6, 1998, the Federal Circuit set out what a joint inventor must do: contribute in some significant manner to the conception or reduction to practice of the invention, make a contribution to the claimed invention that is not insignificant in quality when measured against the dimension of the full invention, and do more than merely explain to the real inventors well-known concepts and/or the current state of the art.

The burden is high. Pannu relied on the rule that misjoinder or nonjoinder must be proved by clear and convincing evidence, and directed the district court on remand to determine first whether there was clear and convincing proof that the alleged unnamed inventor was in fact a co-inventor. The court vacated the infringement judgment and remanded for that determination, because a reasonable jury could have found that another person was an inventor.

Testimony alone does not carry that burden. In Ethicon, the court quoted the rule that an inventor's testimony cannot, standing alone, rise to the level of clear and convincing proof. Corroboration is judged under a rule of reason, weighing all pertinent evidence, including contemporaneous documents and circumstantial evidence, to assess the credibility of the claimed contribution.

How does the technical expert map a contribution to the claims?

Claim by claim: the claims are construed, the person's documented contribution is identified, and the expert shows whether that contribution appears in a claim element and whether it was already known in the field at the time.

The Ethicon court worked in two steps. It first determined what the alleged co-inventor had contributed, then construed the claim language to see whether that contribution found its way into the defined invention. For claim 33 it held that the claim, properly construed, included the elements the co-inventor had contributed. The same order of work applies to an expert report.

The expert starts with the claims as construed by the court, or with the parties' proposed constructions if the court has not ruled. Each claim is broken into elements, in a table like an infringement claim chart. Next to each element the expert places the documents that show who first described it and when: notebook pages, emails, drawings, presentation slides, draft applications and test plans.

The third column holds the state of the art. Under the third Pannu prong, explaining well-known concepts does not make a person an inventor. For each element that the alleged co-inventor claims to have contributed, the expert identifies whether that element appeared in publications, products or patents before the date of the contribution. An element that was already standard in the field is a weak basis for a claim of co-inventorship, even if the person was the one who suggested it to the team.

The result is a table that a judge can read in an afternoon: which claims contain an element traceable to the alleged co-inventor, which documents support it, and which of those elements were new at the time.

How is the inventorship of an issued patent corrected?

Under 35 U.S.C. 256, by the USPTO Director on application of all parties and assignees, or by a court after notice and hearing. The error does not invalidate the patent if it can be corrected.

35 U.S.C. 256(a) provides that whenever through error a person is named in an issued patent as the inventor, or through error an inventor is not named, the Director may, on application of all the parties and assignees, with proof of the facts and such other requirements as may be imposed, issue a certificate correcting the error.

Section 256(b) provides that the error of omitting inventors or naming persons who are not inventors shall not invalidate the patent in which it occurred if it can be corrected as provided in that section. The court before which the matter is called in question may order correction of the patent on notice and hearing of all parties concerned, and the Director then issues a certificate.

The administrative route needs everyone's agreement. When the named inventors or the owner refuse, the alleged inventor sues for correction in federal court, or the question comes up as a defense in an infringement case. In both settings the claim chart of contributions and the corroborating documents are the core of the proof.

Why does inventorship decide infringement cases?

Each co-inventor is presumptively a co-owner of the whole patent, and under 35 U.S.C. 262 each joint owner may use the invention without the others' consent. In Ethicon a co-inventor's license and refusal to join ended the suit.

35 U.S.C. 262 provides that, in the absence of any agreement to the contrary, each of the joint owners of a patent may make, use, offer to sell or sell the patented invention within the United States, or import it, without the consent of and without accounting to the other owners.

Ethicon shows what that means in litigation. The Federal Circuit affirmed that Dr. Choi was a co-inventor of claims 33 and 47 of the patent in suit. As a joint owner of the entire patent, he had the power to license it, and he had granted a license to the accused infringer, United States Surgical. He did not consent to the suit, and because not all co-owners had joined as plaintiffs, the court affirmed the dismissal of Ethicon's infringement action. Judge Newman dissented, arguing that a contribution to two of 55 claims should not make Dr. Choi a joint owner of the whole patent.

An accused infringer therefore has a reason to look for an unnamed inventor, and a patent owner has a reason to secure assignments from everyone who worked on the invention. Both sides need an expert who can say, claim by claim, whose idea each element was.

What records prove a contribution to conception?

Dated records made at the time: laboratory notebooks, emails, invention disclosure forms, drawings, slides and draft applications. Later testimony needs this corroboration under the rule of reason applied in Ethicon.

The records that carry weight are those made before the dispute: a dated and witnessed notebook page with a sketch of the claimed structure, an email that describes the idea to a colleague, an invention disclosure form filed with the employer, a slide shown at a project meeting, a comment in a draft application. Each is tied to a date and to an author.

Records made after the dispute began carry less weight, and the rule of reason lets the court weigh all of them. Circumstantial evidence also counts: who had the skills to devise the element, who was present at the meeting where it first appeared, who worked on the component it belongs to.

The expert reads the records for their technical content. A sketch that shows a rod-shaped part does not necessarily disclose the rod detaining means of a claim; the expert explains what the sketch discloses and what it lacks, element by element. The weight and credibility of the documents and witnesses remain for the court or the jury.

What can the technical expert testify about in an inventorship case?

About the technology, the state of the art at the time, the technical content of each document and how it compares with each claim element. Whether a person is an inventor is the court's decision.

Federal Rule of Evidence 702 lets a qualified expert give an opinion if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion will help the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, comes from reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the facts of the case.

In an inventorship case that means the expert explains what the claims cover as construed, what the field knew before the contribution date, what each document discloses and how it maps to each element. The expert does not decide whether a witness is telling the truth about a conversation, and does not state the legal conclusion that a person is or is not a joint inventor.

The other side's expert is reviewed against the same structure: whether every element of every asserted claim was analyzed, whether the dates of the documents were checked, whether the state of the art was searched and whether the report treats an element as contributed when the document shows only a related idea.

What does IAE do in an inventorship dispute?

An IAE expert prepares a report that maps each person's documented contribution to each claim element and to the prior art, or a review of the opposing technical report, in up to 5 business days.

The patent expertise page describes claim charts that map each claim element to the accused product and a prior art search before the effective filing date. For an inventorship question the chart maps each element to the dated documents of each person and to the publications and products that came before.

IAE chooses the expert by the technical field of the patent and confirms the patent, the claims and the questions before work starts. The client sends the patent, the claim construction if there is one, and the notebooks, emails and other records it may share under the protective order. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the expert from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Every expert is a member of the public IAE registry, verifiable by Member ID or QR code, and states in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member