Expert report review
Easement location dispute: how does a reviewer check the opposing survey of an easement?
Where an easement runs is decided first by the words of the grant and only then by the ground. A right of way described by metes and bounds stays where the deed puts it; one granted with location and width undefined still exists, and in Serth v. Segrue (January 2026) a New York court set a procedure for fixing its location. A review checks the opposing map against the deeds, the evidence of use and the filing record.

What decides where an easement runs?
The grant. A metes-and-bounds description fixes the location. A grant that leaves location and width undefined still creates the easement, and a reasonable location is then fixed on the parties' proposals or by the court.
Serth v. Segrue, decided by the Supreme Court of New York, Schenectady County, on January 26, 2026 (Index No. 2021-1998, 2026 NY Slip Op 30069(U)), involved three easements with three kinds of description. The first, 50 by 80 feet, came from a 1993 right-of-way agreement with a metes-and-bounds description, and a 2019 agreement between the parties acknowledged it, so its location was treated as fixed. The second, a 20-foot right of way, was defined in the 2019 agreement as the 8-foot paved driveway plus 12 feet on its westerly side.
The third crossed the former Morgan lot to reach the former Martin lot. Deeds of 1973 and 1974, 1997, 2012 and 2021 referred to a right of way; the 1973 deed called it undefined in any type of location or width, and the 1997 deed described its location and width as undefined. The court found that the grantor intended access across the Morgan lot and, citing Wilcox v. Reals, held that an imprecise location does not defeat the existence of an easement.
The three easements show the order of a review. The reviewer first sorts each easement by its description: fixed by metes and bounds, defined by reference to a physical feature, or undefined. Each kind is tested differently, and a survey that treats an undefined right of way as if it had fixed bearings and distances has mapped something the deeds do not contain.
What can a surveyor say when the deed does not locate the easement?
That the easement exists in a general area but cannot be plotted from the record. In Serth v. Segrue the surveyor marked the right of way as not protractible, and the court declared a permanent but non-protractible easement.
The plaintiff's surveyor in Serth, Kevin H. Weed, marked the right of way across the former Morgan lot as not protractible on his survey of July 1, 2021. On his site visit he found no remaining evidence of a right of way; brush had overgrown the area. A 1968 aerial photograph showed a path in the general area, the plaintiff testified that he rode snowmobiles and four-wheelers over the route in 1986, and the defendant had seen the previous owners reach the Martin lot by four-wheel drive around 2007 and 2008.
The court accepted that analysis. It found the easement undefined in location and width and gave the defendant 30 days to propose a reasonable location and width. If he did not, the plaintiff could submit a proposal, and if that proposal was unreasonable the court would fashion the easement itself on the parties' proof and convenience.
For a reviewer this is the honest limit of a survey. When the record does not locate the easement, a surveyor who draws a precise centerline is giving an opinion the deeds do not support. The review asks what the line is drawn from: a deed call, an old aerial photograph, a fence, testimony. Each source carries different weight, and the court in Serth treated the evidence of use as proof of existence, not of exact location.
Why was one of the surveys in Serth v. Segrue not considered?
The court did not admit the Blackstone survey because it had not been filed with the County Clerk, and it disregarded the defendant's testimony about that survey as hearsay. The court relied on the plaintiff's surveyor, Kevin Weed.
Two surveys were offered. The court relied on the survey prepared by the plaintiff's surveyor and did not admit the Blackstone survey, which had not been filed with the County Clerk. The defendant's testimony about what the Blackstone survey showed was hearsay, and the court disregarded it.
A review therefore checks the status of the opposing survey before its content. Was it filed or recorded where the jurisdiction requires? Is its author available to testify? Does the party offer it through a surveyor, or only through a lay witness describing it? A map that never becomes evidence cannot locate an easement, however careful the fieldwork.
How wide is the easement, and what does it allow the holder to build?
As wide as the grant says; an access easement gives a right of passage, not a right in the roadway itself. In Serth the court refused to let the holder clear the full width or build a two-lane road.
The plaintiff in Serth asked to clear the full width of the easements, to build a two-lane road and to clear ten feet on each side for snow. The court denied the request as going beyond the language of the grants. It wrote that the holder has "the right of passage, and not any right in a physical passageway itself."
Width and use are separate questions on a survey. The plat can show the width the grant describes, here a minimum of 50 feet along the easterly boundary of two former lots and the paved driveway plus 12 feet for another, while the right to clear, pave or widen depends on the grant and on the use the parties made of it. A survey that labels the whole strip as a road gives the holder more than the court in Serth allowed.
Can the owner of the land move an easement fixed by the deed?
In Massachusetts yes, under M.P.M. Builders v. Dwyer (2004), if the move does not significantly lessen the easement's utility, increase the holder's burdens or frustrate its purpose. The owner must first obtain a court declaration.
Leslie Dwyer held a 1941 deeded right of way along a cartway across land in Raynham, Massachusetts; the cartway branched to reach his property at three points. The owner of the land, M.P.M. Builders, obtained approval to subdivide it into seven house lots, and the easement crossed three of them. M.P.M. offered to build two replacement access ways at its own expense. Dwyer refused and wanted to keep the route he had used for 62 years.
The Land Court applied the common-law rule that a fixed location can be changed only by agreement. The Supreme Judicial Court, deciding the case on June 15, 2004 (442 Mass. 87), adopted Restatement (Third) of Property (Servitudes) section 4.8(3). A servient owner may relocate an easement at its own expense, without the holder's consent, if the change does not significantly lessen the utility of the easement, does not increase the burdens on the holder's use and enjoyment, and does not frustrate the purpose for which it was created. The deed did not prohibit relocation, so the rule applied.
The court added that the servient owner may not resort to self-help and should obtain a declaratory judgment before altering anything. It vacated the judgment and remanded, because the record did not show whether the proposed relocation met the three criteria.
What does a relocation case need from the surveyor?
A plan that puts the old and the new route side by side, with length, width, grade, points of connection and every structure along both, so the court can test utility, burden and purpose.
The three tests of section 4.8(3) are factual, and most of the facts are on the ground. Utility depends on where the route connects to the dominant land, how long it is, how wide and steep, and what it crosses. Burden includes the holder's cost and inconvenience during and after the move. Purpose turns on what the easement was granted for, which the grant and the history of use show.
In M.P.M. Builders the original cartway reached the dominant land at three points, and the proposal replaced it with two access ways. A survey for either side would have to show whether the two new connections serve every part of the dominant land the three old ones served. A review of the opposing relocation plan checks exactly such points: missing connections, changed grades, new crossings and any gap between the plan and the deeds.
Can an unused easement be lost?
Not easily. In Serth the court found no evidence of abandonment, conveyance, condemnation or adverse possession and noted that forfeiture of easements created by grant is disfavored.
The defendant in Serth argued, in effect, that the right of way across the former Morgan lot had disappeared: the surveyor found no remnants of a path. The court held that the easement survived. The defendant offered no evidence of abandonment, conveyance, condemnation or adverse possession, and the court noted that forfeiture of an easement created by grant is disfavored.
For the survey this means that the absence of a visible path proves little by itself. A reviewer who sees an opposing plat omit a deeded right of way because nothing was found on the ground notes the omission and lists the deeds that create the easement. The review checks the opposite case as well: a worn path drawn as a deeded easement without any deed that grants it.
Which standard does the reviewing surveyor's testimony have to meet?
In federal court, Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence: the proponent must show that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data and reliable methods reliably applied.
Rule 702, as amended effective December 1, 2023, admits expert testimony if the proponent proves to the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion is a reliable application of those methods to the facts of the case. State courts apply their own rules of evidence.
For an easement survey the four conditions translate into a short list: which deeds were read, which prior surveys and photographs were used, which field evidence was looked for and found, and how each of these led to the line on the plat. Where the line rests on an assumption, the review names it.
What does IAE do when the other side's survey locates an easement?
IAE prepares a review of the opposing surveyor's report, deposition questions and a rebuttal survey report for boundary, quiet title and encroachment cases. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The reviewer reads the opposing survey with its field notes, plats and record documents and checks which records the survey used, which monuments it found and how its measurements compare with the record. For an easement this means the chain of deeds that create or mention the right of way, the description in each, and the evidence of use and possession shown on the plat. A rebuttal survey report is due within 30 days after the opposing disclosure unless the court sets other dates.
For an expert report on the client's questions, the surveyor collects the deeds, recorded plats and original field notes for the parcel and its neighbors, searches for the original monuments, measures with GNSS and a total station and compares measured bearings and distances with the calls in each deed. Send the deeds, plats and any prior surveys with your request.
The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush. Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code. The court weighs a review together with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the surveyor guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
Read also
All articles
The other side relies on a county GIS map: is it evidence of the boundary, and what does a reviewing surveyor check?
County GIS parcel lines are drawn for assessment, and the counties that publish them say so. Sedgwick County, Kansas, describes its boundaries as
Adverse possession survey: what does a reviewer check in the opposing surveyor's map of the claimed strip?
An adverse possession claim to a strip of a neighbor's land stands on two maps: the record line and the area actually possessed. The opposing
Building in a utility easement: how does the survey prove the encroachment, and when must the structure come down?
A structure built inside an easement stays or goes on two things: the words of the easement and the measurements on the ground. In a 2011 caseExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

