Profile audit
The EB-1A high salary criterion: what pay counts as high, and which comparison data does USCIS accept?
The EB-1A high salary criterion is met when the applicant's pay is high compared with others in the same occupation, at the same level and in the same place. Chapter 2 of Part F of the USCIS Policy Manual accepts tax returns, pay statements, contracts and job offers and compares them with position-appropriate wage surveys. In 2023 the AAO accepted a physician's $300,000 contract and rejected an executive chef's $85,000 salary.

What does the EB-1A high salary criterion require?
Evidence that the applicant has commanded a high salary or other significantly high remuneration for services compared with others in the field. It is one of ten criteria, and the petition needs at least three.
The criterion is 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(ix). It asks for evidence that the applicant "has commanded a high salary or other significantly high remuneration for services, in relation to others in the field." Paragraph (h)(3) lists it among ten criteria and requires either a one-time achievement, which the regulation describes as "a major, international recognized award," or evidence under at least three of the ten.
The standard behind all ten criteria sits in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(2). Extraordinary ability means "a level of expertise indicating that the individual is one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor." The regulation names no dollar amount, no percentile and no multiple of the average wage. The officer decides whether the pay is high by comparing it with data about the same field.
Neither an offer of employment nor a labor certification is required for EB-1A under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(5), so an applicant may file without an employer. The salary criterion still rests on money that someone has paid or agreed to pay for the applicant's work: an employer, a client or the applicant's own company.
Does the high salary have to be paid already?
No. The Policy Manual reads "has commanded" to cover pay agreed but not yet received. A credible contract or job offer with the future salary can meet the criterion, and the AAO accepted one in 2023.
Chapter 2 of Part F of the Policy Manual states: "USCIS does not interpret the phrase 'has commanded' to mean that the person must have already earned such salary." It adds that "a credible contract or job offer showing prospective salary or remuneration may establish" that the person has been able to command such pay.
On September 29, 2023 the AAO decided the appeal of a nuclear medicine physician (In Re: 28423489). His employment agreement with a Florida professional corporation set an annual salary of $300,000 starting in March 2021 and guaranteed raises reaching $320,000 in the third year. The employer confirmed that he started work in March 2021.
The Director had looked only at his 2022 Form W-2, which appeared to show his pay as a department director, disregarded the agreement and noted that the comparison data covered physicians rather than department directors. The AAO held that the Director erred. The agreement showed the salary he "has commanded" as a nuclear medicine physician, the occupation he intended to pursue, and the AAO compared that salary with the physician salary data in the record.
The AAO concluded that "he established by a preponderance of the evidence that he has commanded a high salary in relation to others in the field." With this criterion the petition reached three, and the case went back to the Director for the final merits determination.
For founders the Policy Manual adds a test of credibility. When the future pay comes from a startup, officers consider evidence that the business has received significant funding from "government entities, venture capital funds, angel investors, or other such funders." The Policy Manual uses that evidence to judge whether the contract, the job offer or other evidence of future pay is credible.
Which documents prove the applicant's own pay?
Tax returns, pay statements and other records of past pay, and contracts or job offers for future pay. The figures must agree across documents: in 2023 the AAO rejected a claim whose monthly salary changed between filings.
The Policy Manual lists three kinds of evidence for the criterion: "Tax returns, pay statements, or other evidence of past salary or remuneration for services"; a "Contract, job offer letter, or other evidence of prospective salary or remuneration for services"; and comparative wage or remuneration data for the person's field. The first two prove what the applicant earns. The third proves that the amount is high.
On October 25, 2023 the AAO dismissed the appeal of a chief executive in small business development (In Re: 28355068) and adopted the Director's decision. The initial filing stated a monthly salary of 230,000 rubles. The response to the request for evidence appeared to state 207,000 rubles, and the Director pointed to the discrepancy.
On appeal the petitioner relied on a contract dated September 21, 2021, an additional agreement and bonus certificates, which, he said, raised his average monthly salary. He did not address the discrepancy or the Director's concern about the lack of objective evidence. The AAO found that he "has not met his burden under the plain language of the regulation."
Before filing, the figures in the CV, the petition letter, the employer letter and the pay records are checked against one another. Each figure names its period and currency and says whether it is gross or net pay.
Who are the others in the field that the salary is compared with?
People in the same occupation, at a comparable level and, where data exist, in the same place. The Policy Manual warns that broad categories mixing several occupations or industries may not give an accurate comparison.
The Policy Manual says that "broad descriptions that include multiple occupations or multiple industries" may not provide an accurate comparison to others in the field. Its example is a film director whose pay is compared with a category that also covers a "radio show producer."
The AAO applied this reasoning twice in the autumn of 2023. In the October case the comparison data came from Rosstat, the Russian statistics service, and described the salaries of development directors. The petitioner had not shown that his position was comparable to a development director's. The AAO wrote: "Here, the comparative salary data is insufficient objective evidence for comparison to his salary and position."
In the November case (In Re: 28881711, decided November 15, 2023) an upscale restaurant in southern California had petitioned for its executive chef. Much of its data described head chefs. The AAO called the head chef figures an inappropriate comparison and found no position-appropriate, geographically specific data for executive chefs in the area. The petitioner also did not show that such data was unavailable.
In both cases the occupation in the survey differed from the job the applicant held, and the survey lost its value as evidence. The comparison group is therefore fixed first, from the applicant's duties, level of responsibility and type of employer, and only then is a survey chosen for it.
Which salary surveys does USCIS accept?
Geographical or position-appropriate compensation surveys. The Policy Manual names the BLS wage data by area and occupation and the Department of Labor's CareerOneStop site and warns about user-reported data with too few entries.
The Policy Manual describes comparative data as "geographical or position-appropriate compensation surveys" and names two government sources: "The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Overview of BLS Wage Data by Area and Occupation webpage" and "the Department of Labor's Career One Stop website." An employer's explanation of why it pays above the survey data can be filed with them.
Private salary sites get a warning: "Some websites provide user-reported salary data, which may not be a valid comparison if" too few users reported their salaries or the data is otherwise not credible or reliable.
The record in the executive chef's case held six sources. The BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook gave chefs and head cooks a median of $53,380 for May 2020 and more than $90,790 for the top 10 percent. BLS metropolitan data gave a mean of $59,190. Glassdoor gave head chefs a national average of $52,752 and top earners up to $78,000, and executive chefs, a related career, an average of $65,491. Indeed gave head chefs a national average of $58,778, a high of $83,048 and an average of $76,159 in the highest-paying cities. ZipRecruiter had national figures only. O*NET put the top 10 percent of chefs and head cooks in the metropolitan area at $103,930 or more.
The chef's $85,000 exceeded several of these averages. The AAO agreed with the Director "as the submitted data included only an average salary for the city where the Beneficiary works" and found that "there is insufficient data to support a determination that he earns a high salary in relation to others." The decision separates pay that is above average from pay that is high, and a survey that gives only a mean answers the first question.
How does USCIS compare a salary earned outside the United States?
Against wage data for the place where the person works. The Policy Manual rejects converting a foreign salary into dollars and asking whether that amount would be high in the United States.
The Policy Manual states: "Officers evaluate persons working outside of the United States based on the wage statistics or comparable evidence relevant to the applicable work location, rather than by simply converting the salary to U.S. dollars and then viewing whether that salary would be considered high in the United States."
A salary of 230,000 rubles a month is therefore compared with Russian data for the same occupation and region, and the October 2023 petitioner filed such data from Rosstat. His evidence failed on the occupation: the table described development directors, and the petitioner had not shown that his job was one.
A foreign survey goes into the file as the original table with the occupation, the region and the year, its English translation and a description of how the publisher collected the figures. An applicant who worked in several countries compares each period with its own market, using data for the place and the years of that job.
Do bonuses, equity and daily rates count as remuneration?
They can, if they are documented and compared with the same kind of pay for others. Hourly data needs the hours worked, and startup equity can go in as comparable evidence when salary does not readily apply.
The regulation covers "a high salary or other significantly high remuneration for services," so pay beyond the base salary falls within the criterion when it is paid for services. The October 2023 decision set the evidence bar for bonuses: to count year-end and quarterly bonuses, the petitioner needed objective evidence of the bonuses offered to others in his field, and he filed none.
The Policy Manual also checks the unit of pay. "Officers consider whether the comparison data measures an hourly rate or an annual salary." It adds: "Many artists are not paid an hourly rate but instead are paid a daily rate," and a day may not equal 8 hours. Hourly wage data "may still be probative if the petitioner submits documentation regarding the number of hours worked," such as "pay statements, personnel records, or testimonial evidence from the relevant employer."
Equity enters through comparable evidence. Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(4), when the listed standards "do not readily apply to the beneficiary's occupation," the petitioner "may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility." The Policy Manual's example concerns an entrepreneur for whom a high salary does not readily apply: "highly valued equity holdings in the startup are of comparable significance to the high salary criterion."
The petitioner explains why salary is not the measure in that case. The Policy Manual gives no probative value to "A general unsupported assertion that the listed evidentiary criterion does not readily apply," while a detailed, specific and credible statement from the petitioner can be enough.
On which date must the salary be high?
On the filing date. In November 2023 the AAO judged an executive chef by his $85,000 salary at filing and set aside evidence of a later salary of $95,000.
The restaurant filed its petition in September 2021, when the chef earned $85,000 a year. Evidence of $95,000 in early 2023 was excluded. The AAO wrote that "the Petitioner's evidence must establish the Beneficiary met this criterion at the time it filed this petition."
A raise received after filing does not repair the criterion in a pending petition. It can go into a new petition, filed with the new pay records and a new filing date.
The same date applies to the comparison. The chef's 2021 salary was set against BLS figures for May 2020. A survey for the year of the pay, or the closest year published, keeps both numbers on the same footing.
Is meeting the salary criterion enough for EB-1A approval?
No. It counts as one of the three criteria. The officer then weighs the whole record to decide whether the applicant has sustained acclaim and stands in the small percentage at the very top of the field.
In the physician's case the AAO found that the salary criterion completed the three required criteria. It did not decide whether he had sustained national or international acclaim and left that question to the Director on remand.
The second step is the final merits determination described in the IAE guide to the Kazarian two-step review. At that step the officer reads the pay records again, together with the evidence under the other criteria, against the definition in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(2).
The Policy Manual describes that step as a weighing of the totality of the evidence, in which the officer may consider any relevant evidence in the record.
How does an IAE audit check the high salary criterion?
An IAE registry expert marks each of the ten EB-1A criteria, high salary included, as met, partly met or not met, names the documents behind each mark and sends a written report within 5 business days.
On the profile audit page one report covers one category: EB-1A, EB-2 NIW, O-1A or O-1B. The assessment follows the criteria of 8 CFR 204.5(h), the Dhanasar test and 8 CFR 214.2(o). For EB-1A the report shows which of the ten criteria the documents prove, which rest on a single piece of evidence and how to strengthen them.
The report has four parts. The criteria map marks each criterion as met, partly met or not met and names the documents behind each mark. The gaps part lists missing or weak evidence, such as a single source, no independent confirmation or the wrong form of document. The collection plan says what to obtain before filing, in what order and from whom. The last part names the category closest to the profile now and what changes in six to twelve months if the plan is followed.
The request form takes a CV and up to 10 files or one archive in .pdf, .docx, .jpg, .png or .zip, up to 25 MB each, so pay statements, contracts and the surveys can go in with the other documents. A request for evidence, a NOID or a denial can be attached, and the report then addresses the weak criteria it names. If the CV and documents are not enough for the criteria map, the expert requests what is missing in one email within 1-2 business days.
The report names the expert and the registry record number. Questions about the report are answered by email for 14 days after delivery. IAE membership is not required and does not affect the assessment or the timing. The audit is an expert assessment against published criteria, not legal advice and not a forecast of the USCIS decision; the petition is filed by the applicant or the applicant's attorney. To start, order an audit.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants, paragraph (h) (LII, Cornell Law School)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability (copy of the chapter as of August 8, 2025, Immigration Policy Tracking Project)
- AAO, In Re: 28423489, September 29, 2023 (nuclear medicine physician, criterion met, remanded)
- AAO, In Re: 28355068, October 25, 2023 (chief executive, salary data from Rosstat, dismissed)
- AAO, In Re: 28881711, November 15, 2023 (executive chef, dismissed)
Read also
All articles
EB-2 NIW or EB-1A as a PhD student: can you file before you graduate, and what happens to F-1 status?
No rule makes a PhD student wait for the diploma. EB-2 NIW and EB-1A are self-petitions, and neither regulation asks for a particular immigration
O-1 visa salary requirement: is there a minimum, and how do you prove high remuneration?
An O-1 petition does not have to meet a salary threshold. The O-1A regulation lists high pay as one of eight criteria, and a petition needs three
O-1 or H-1B: which visa fits a specialist with a U.S. job offer?
H-1B is limited to 65,000 new workers a year plus 20,000 with U.S. master's degrees, chosen in a selection that now gives more chances to higher wageProfile audit
Is your profile ready for the petition?
A report on the EB‑1A, EB‑2 NIW, O‑1A or O‑1B criteria within 5 business days of receiving the materials and payment: what is proven, what is missing and what to collect before filing.

