EB-1A
The Kazarian two-step review: why three EB-1A criteria are not enough
In Kazarian v. USCIS, decided on March 4, 2010, the Ninth Circuit separated two questions in an EB-1A case: whether the evidence meets at least three of the ten criteria in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), and whether the whole record places the person at the very top of the field. The USCIS Policy Manual tells officers to answer them in that order. In 2022 the Fifth Circuit upheld a denial after USCIS had found three criteria met.

What did the Ninth Circuit decide in Kazarian v. USCIS?
It held that the AAO had added requirements to two EB-1A criteria that the regulation does not contain. With those errors corrected, Kazarian had two criteria instead of the three required, so the denial stood.
Poghos Kazarian, a native and citizen of Armenia, received a Ph.D. in theoretical physics from Yerevan State University in 1997. On December 31, 2003, at age 34, he filed Form I-140 as a theoretical physicist of extraordinary ability. USCIS denied the petition in August 2005. The Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) dismissed his appeal and found that he met none of the regulatory criteria. The U.S. District Court for the Central District of California granted summary judgment to USCIS, and Kazarian appealed.
The Ninth Circuit filed its opinion on March 4, 2010 (Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010)). The same order withdrew the earlier opinion of September 4, 2009, published at 580 F.3d 1030. Four of the ten criteria were at issue on appeal.
His resume listed six publications in Astrophysics that he had authored or co-authored and one e-print in the public archives of the Los Alamos National Laboratory. The AAO wrote that "publication of scholarly articles is not automatically evidence of sustained acclaim" and that "we must consider the research community's reaction to these articles." The court found nothing of the kind in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi) and added: "neither USCIS nor an AAO may unilaterally impose novel substantive or evidentiary requirements beyond those set forth at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5." Citations by other authors "might be relevant to the final merits determination," but not to "the antecedent procedural question of whether the petitioner has provided at least three types of evidence."
The court reached the same result on judging. Kazarian was a research associate at Yerevan State University in 1997-2000 and reviewed the diploma works of the department's graduates. The AAO wanted proof that he had been an external dissertation reviewer "for a university with which he is not otherwise affiliated." Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(iv), the court held, the answer does not turn on the judge's university, and "the AAO may not unilaterally impose a novel evidentiary requirement."
On the other two criteria the AAO prevailed. Kazarian had submitted letters in which physics professors attested to his contributions, and the AAO found that "his contributions were not major." The court called that analysis "consistent with the relevant regulatory language." The AAO also found that a self-published textbook, lectures at a community college and conference presentations were not displays of work at artistic exhibitions under criterion (vii), and the court upheld that finding.
"The AAO should have held that Kazarian presented two types of evidence," the court wrote, and the regulation requires three. The AAO's conclusion that he presented none "was in error, but the error was harmless." The court affirmed the judgment.
How does the USCIS Policy Manual set out the two steps?
Step one asks which criteria the evidence objectively meets, by a preponderance of the evidence. Step two weighs all the evidence together and asks whether the person has sustained acclaim and stands at the very top of the field.
The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 says that officers "should use a two-step analysis to evaluate the evidence submitted with the petition" and cites Kazarian in a footnote.
- At step one the officer determines, by a preponderance of the evidence, which evidence "objectively meets the parameters of the regulatory description that applies to that type of evidence."
- At step two, the final merits determination, the officer evaluates "all the evidence together when considering the petition in its entirety," in the context of the high level of expertise the classification requires.
Which standard applies at step two?
The standard comes from the regulation. Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(2), extraordinary ability means "a level of expertise indicating that the individual is one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor." Paragraph (h)(3) requires evidence that the person "has sustained national or international acclaim and that his or her achievements have been recognized in the field of expertise."
At step one, according to the Policy Manual, officers "should not yet make a determination" on either question. Both belong to the final merits determination.
What does the officer check at step one?
Whether each piece of evidence fits the description in the regulation. Quality counts at this step only where the criterion itself sets a qualitative requirement, as the criterion of original contributions of major significance does.
Step one "is limited to determining whether the evidence submitted with the petition meets the regulatory criteria." The evidence must be a one-time achievement, that is, a major, internationally recognized award, or meet at least three of the ten criteria, or be comparable to at least three of them. Comparable evidence is permitted by 8 CFR 204.5(h)(4) when the criteria "do not readily apply to the beneficiary's occupation." Officers weigh "the quality and caliber of the evidence" at this step only "to the extent the criterion has qualitative requirements."
The Policy Manual gives two examples. Judging the work of others in the same or an allied field should satisfy the criterion at step one "regardless of the circumstances," and scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media should satisfy it "regardless of the caliber." At step two the officer looks at the same judging and the same articles again and asks whether they place the person among the small percentage at the very top of the field. In Kazarian the AAO had asked the step-two questions at step one, for articles and for judging.
Criterion (v) is different, because the regulation itself asks for contributions "of major significance in the field." The officer makes two determinations: whether the contributions are original, and whether they "are of major significance to the field." Evidence that the work "was funded, patented, or published" will not necessarily establish major significance on its own. Published research that "has provoked widespread commentary on its importance from others working in the field" and is highly cited relative to others' work in the field may be probative of significance. A patented technology that has attracted significant attention or commercialization may establish it.
Kazarian lost criterion (v) at this step: the AAO found that his contributions "were not major." So did Bhaveshkumar Amin, whose case the Fifth Circuit decided in 2022. The USCIS officer found that he "failed to show a significant impact on the field of chemical engineering as a whole."
What does the final merits determination weigh?
The whole record. The officer considers any relevant evidence, including evidence that fits no criterion, and decides by a preponderance of the evidence whether the person has sustained acclaim and is among the small percentage at the top.
At step two the officer "should consider the petition in its entirety to determine eligibility according to the standard." Officers "consider any potentially relevant evidence in the record, even if such evidence does not fit one of the above regulatory criteria or was not presented as comparable evidence." The Policy Manual adds: "Some evidence may weigh more favorably on its own, while other evidence is more persuasive when viewed with other evidence."
The chapter gives examples of evidence that officers may use to judge the quality of the initial or comparable evidence and to decide, in a totality analysis, whether the person is among the small percentage at the top of the field. All five examples concern research.
- The person published articles in particularly highly ranked journals relative to other journals in the field, for example by impact factor, with more weight when the person is the main contributor, a senior author or the sole author.
- The total rate of citations to the person's published work is high relative to others in the field, for example a high h-index for the field.
- The person worked or did research at leading institutions, such as U.S. universities with high or very high research activity in the Carnegie Classification, foreign universities with comparably high research activity, or a university ranked high by a widely recognized metric such as the QS World University Rankings.
- The person received unsolicited invitations to speak or present research at nationally or internationally recognized conferences in the field.
- The person is named as an investigator, scientist or researcher on a peer-reviewed, competitively funded U.S. government grant or stipend for STEM research.
What may the officer not do at step two?
The officer may not decide in advance which type of evidence an extraordinary person should have and deny the petition when that type is missing. The Policy Manual's example is published articles about the person: an officer "cannot deny the petition because no published articles were submitted" if the petitioner submitted other evidence that meets three criteria and establishes extraordinary ability. "Approval or denial of a petition is based on the type and quality of evidence submitted rather than assumptions about the failure to address different criteria."
A denial must give reasons. The officer "should not merely make general assertions" about the failure and "must articulate the specific reasons" for concluding that extraordinary ability is not proven by a preponderance of the evidence. A request for evidence should explain the deficiencies in the evidence already submitted and, if possible, give examples of persuasive evidence. How to answer such a request with an expert letter is covered in the guide Answering an RFE with an expert letter, point by point.
Can USCIS deny a petition after finding three criteria met?
Yes. In Amin v. Mayorkas, decided on January 24, 2022, the Fifth Circuit upheld such a denial. USCIS found three criteria met and then concluded that the record did not establish sustained acclaim.
Amin, a project manager in the field of chemical engineering, claimed four criteria: judging the work of peers, original contributions of major significance, leadership in distinguished industry organizations and a high salary relative to his peers. A USCIS officer first found only the judging criterion met. Amin sued in federal district court. USCIS then agreed to reconsider the petition, and on second review the officer found three criteria met: judging the work of others, leadership roles and a relatively high salary.
The officer then "considered whether the record established his sustained acclaim and status at the top of his field" and concluded that it did not. USCIS "credited Amin's contribution to his employers but found evidence of his impact on the field lacking." The district court granted summary judgment to the government.
On appeal Amin argued that his leadership in industry organizations, his $342,000 salary and his peer review experience were in themselves evidence of his recognition as a leader in his field. The Fifth Circuit answered: "This argument cannot be correct. If meeting the regulatory criteria was enough to establish one's acclaim, there would be no step two of the analysis."
The opinion in No. 21-20212 (Amin v. Mayorkas (5th Cir. 2022)) traces the two steps to a 2010 USCIS policy memorandum, PM-602-0005.1, which amended the Adjudicator's Field Manual: "In the memo, the agency adopted the two-step approach to adjudication outlined in Kazarian v. USCIS." The court held that "The agency's reading is consistent with the governing statute and regulation" and affirmed the judgment.
What does a criterion need before you count it?
Every condition written into its text in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3). An item that matches a criterion only by name, such as a lecture counted as an exhibition, does not count at step one.
Each criterion in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) carries its own conditions. The conditions of seven criteria, with what the Policy Manual and Kazarian add to them:
- Under (h)(3)(ii), membership counts only in associations "which require outstanding achievements of their members, as judged by recognized national or international experts in their disciplines or fields."
- Under (h)(3)(iii), the published material is about the person and relates to the person's work in the field, and the evidence "shall include the title, date, and author of the material, and any necessary translation."
- Under (h)(3)(iv) and (vi), judging the work of others and authorship of scholarly articles satisfy step one regardless of the circumstances or the caliber, and Kazarian bars the officer from adding a citation or outside-university requirement at that step.
- Under (h)(3)(v), the contributions are original and of major significance to the field, and the Policy Manual says that funding, a patent or publication does not necessarily establish major significance on its own.
- Criterion (h)(3)(vii) covers the display of the person's work in the field at artistic exhibitions; in Kazarian a self-published textbook, lectures and conference presentations did not meet it.
- Under (h)(3)(viii), the role is leading or critical, and the organization or establishment has a distinguished reputation.
- Under (h)(3)(ix), the salary or other remuneration is high in relation to others in the field, and the officer compares it with "the compensation paid to others working in the field."
Where does an expert letter fit in the two steps?
At step one a detailed letter can explain why a contribution has major significance. At step two it adds context to the whole record. Under the Policy Manual, its statements should be corroborated by documents in the record.
For criterion (v), detailed letters from experts "may also provide valuable context for evaluating the claimed original contributions of major significance, particularly when the record includes documentation corroborating the claimed significance." Such letters "should specifically describe the person's contribution and its significance to the field and should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise."
The chapter's passage on letters of support reads: "Letters of support, while not without weight, should not form the cornerstone of a successful claim for this classification. Rather, the statements made by the witnesses should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record." Letters that "merely reiterate USCIS' definitions" or make general and expansive statements about the person are generally not persuasive. Under the chapter, a person with sustained acclaim is generally expected to be recognized "well beyond the circle of their personal and professional acquaintances."
Kazarian's first reference was a letter from Kip S. Thorne, the Feynman Professor of Theoretical Physics at the California Institute of Technology, who, the opinion notes, "worked in the same research group as Kazarian." Thorne wrote that the research was "of the caliber that one would expect from a young professor at a strong research-oriented university in the United States." How officers weigh expert letters in general is covered in the guide How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?
How does IAE prepare an expert letter for EB-1A?
For an IAE expert opinion letter, the secretariat prepares a draft from the applicant's documents, and a registry expert in the subject area checks it, makes changes and signs it. For EB-1A the expert assesses the contribution, originality and recognition against the level of the field. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with the analysis set out under the regulatory criteria. The expert's CV and a declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by QR code. The draft goes to the applicant and the attorney before signing, with one round of factual edits included. The standard term is 10 business days, or 5 in rush mode, counted from payment and receipt of all materials.
IAE is not a law firm. The letter does not guarantee approval: USCIS weighs it together with the rest of the record and decides the petition.
How can you test your record against both steps before filing?
Count the criteria against the text of 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), then build a separate list of evidence for step two. A criterion that rests on one document or on letters alone is a gap to close before filing.
The check takes six steps.
- Copy the text of each criterion you claim from 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) and write next to every condition in that text the document that meets it.
- Remove any item that matches a criterion only by name, such as conference lectures listed under artistic exhibitions or a membership in an association that admits members without an assessment of their achievements.
- For original contributions, list the evidence of major significance to the field, such as commentary by others in the field, citations relative to others' work or commercial use of a patented technology, in addition to the funding, patent or publication itself.
- Claim every criterion the record supports, even beyond three, because in Amin the USCIS officer at first accepted one of the four criteria claimed.
- Make a separate list for step two with journal rankings, citation data relative to the field, positions at leading institutions, unsolicited invitations to speak and competitively funded government grants, each with a date and a source.
- Check every letter against the exhibits, so that each statement about a contribution, a figure or a role points to a document in the record.
What if you are not sure the record covers the criteria?
The IAE profile audit answers that in writing. An IAE expert checks the record against the EB-1A criteria of 8 CFR 204.5(h). For each criterion the report says whether it is met, partly met or not met and names the documents behind the conclusion. It shows which criteria rest on a single piece of evidence and how to strengthen them, and it adds a list of gaps, a collection plan and a category recommendation. The audit costs $350 for one category, and the report comes within 5 business days of receiving the materials and payment. The audit is an expert assessment of the profile against published criteria. It gives no legal advice and no forecast of the USCIS decision.
Sources
Read also
All guides
How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?
USCIS treats an expert letter as one piece of evidence. Under Matter of Caron International, USCIS may use such a letter as an advisory opinion
Answering an RFE with an expert letter, point by point
An RFE tells the petitioner what evidence USCIS requires and sets a deadline of no more than twelve weeks under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv). The response
The DV-2027 lottery has not opened: which paths remain for professionals in the US?
The State Department postponed registration for the DV-2027 diversity visa lottery in a notice last updated on November 5, 2025, and has notGuides
Case assessment in 1 business day
Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.
Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

