RFE responses
An EB-1A RFE on the leading or critical role criterion: what evidence answers it?
The leading or critical role criterion for EB-1A has two parts, and an RFE can question either: what the applicant did in the organization, and whether the organization has a distinguished reputation. In three decisions from 2024 and 2025, the AAO accepted a detailed letter from a research section chief, rejected letters that gave no details, and found a role sufficient while the petition still failed on the final merits.

What does the leading or critical role criterion require?
Evidence that the applicant has performed in a leading or critical role for organizations or establishments with a distinguished reputation. It is one of ten criteria in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3); a petition needs three or a one-time achievement.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), an EB-1A petition rests on evidence of a one-time achievement or on at least three of ten listed kinds of evidence. Item (viii) reads: "Evidence that the alien has performed in a leading or critical role for organizations or establishments" that have a distinguished reputation.
The criterion has two parts, and the petition proves both. The first is the role: what the applicant did and where it sat in the organization. The second is the organization: its reputation. A role without proof of the organization's reputation does not meet the criterion, and neither does proof of reputation without a leading or critical role.
The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 explains each criterion. Policy Alert PA-2024-24 of October 2, 2024 revised the explanations for prizes, memberships, published material and exhibitions; it does not mention the leading or critical role criterion.
What is the difference between a leading role and a critical role?
The Policy Manual calls a role leading when the applicant is or was a leader in the organization or one of its divisions or departments, and critical when the contribution was of significant importance to the outcome of its activities.
The Policy Manual asks whether the person "is (or was) a leader within the organization or establishment or a division or department thereof." It adds: "A title, with appropriate matching duties, can help to establish that a role is (or was), in fact, leading."
For a critical role, the Policy Manual asks whether the person "has contributed in a way that is of significant importance to the outcome of the organization or establishment's activities." The title does not decide this test: "It is not the title of the person's role, but rather the person's performance in the role that determines whether the role is (or was) critical."
AAO decisions restate these tests in shorter words. In a decision of February 5, 2024, the AAO wrote that a critical role means the noncitizen "contributed in a significantly important way to the activities of the organization." In a decision of November 21, 2024, it cited a Policy Manual example of a qualifying role: a "[s]enior research position for a distinguished non-academic institution."
The letter accepted in that November 2024 decision covered both tests: the research projects the petitioner led and the fellows he supervised, and his contribution to specific studies.
Why did an RFE response on this criterion fail in 2024?
The letters described activities without details showing a leading or critical role, and the record did not establish the organizations' reputation. A company letter added in the RFE response said nothing about the company's size, longevity, customers or media coverage.
In the February 5, 2024 decision (Matter ID 28282807), a veterinary science researcher claimed several roles. Letters stated that in 2015-2016 he had served as a university ambassador to an organization whose name is redacted, had helped edit and draft the Nepali national vocational training curriculum in 2021 and 2022, had reviewed undergraduate research proposals and projects at a Nepali university, and had trained farmers and served as a key speaker for a Nepali nonprofit veterinary and agriculture service.
The Director issued an RFE. In response, the petitioner submitted a letter from a science and commercialization manager at a company that held a patent on a compound he had studied. On appeal he argued that the letter showed the company's international operations and multiple patents.
The AAO dismissed the appeal. It found that the letters lacked sufficient details to establish that the petitioner's roles were leading or critical, and that the record lacked evidence of the organizations' distinguished reputations. The company letter did not explain how the petitioner served in a leading or critical role for the company, and it gave none of the reputation facts USCIS looks at.
What evidence met the criterion in another 2024 AAO decision?
A detailed letter from the chief of the research section where the applicant worked, describing the projects he led, the fellows he supervised and the studies he shaped, plus articles on the institute's place in its field.
In the November 21, 2024 decision (Matter ID 34800541), a neuroscience researcher had held a Senior Research Fellow position for several years at a U.S. government research institute, whose name is redacted in the published text. The Director found that he had not held a leading or critical role. The AAO, reviewing de novo, disagreed.
The record held a detailed letter from the Chief of the Neurocircuitry of Motivation Section. It stated that the petitioner had conducted and led research projects, had supervised and mentored post-baccalaureate and postdoctoral fellows, and had played a critical role in several research studies, whose titles are redacted in the published text. On that basis the AAO wrote: "it is clear the Petitioner has played a critical role at the organization."
For the reputation, the petitioner submitted articles stating that the institute is the largest supporter of the world's research in its subject area. The AAO called it "a highly distinguished organization." It found three criteria met, including this one, and remanded the case for the final merits determination.
Can the role be in one department or section of the organization?
Yes. The Policy Manual covers a leader within a division or department, and it applies the reputation test to the organization or establishment, or to the department or division where the role was held.
The words "a division or department thereof" in the Policy Manual mean that the applicant does not have to run the whole organization. Under that wording, the head of a laboratory or a section can hold a leading role within that unit.
The reputation can also be the unit's. The Policy Manual applies the distinguished reputation test to "the organization or establishment, or the department or division for which the person holds or held a leading or critical role." In the November 2024 decision the role was in one section, and the reputation evidence concerned the institute as a whole. An RFE response can rest on either, and its evidence names the unit or the organization whose reputation it shows.
How do you prove that the organization has a distinguished reputation?
With facts about the organization or the unit, such as the scale of its customer base and relevant media coverage. The Policy Manual says that relative size or longevity is not in and of itself a determining factor.
The Policy Manual states: "The relative size or longevity of an organization or establishment is not in and of itself a determining factor." Other factors can include the scale of its customer base and relevant media coverage. For academic units it names relevant national rankings and government research grants, and for a startup significant funding from government entities, venture capital or angel investors that matches its stage and industry.
In the February 2024 decision, the AAO listed "an organization's relative size or longevity; the scale of its customer base, or relevant media coverage of it" as factors USCIS considers. The company's statements about international operations and patents were not enough without those facts.
In the November 2024 decision, articles about the institute's role in funding research in its area carried the reputation part. For a company, the matching documents state the size, age, customers and press coverage in numbers and names, such as annual reports and articles in trade or general media.
What should the letters in the RFE response say?
Facts the officer can check: the applicant's position and its place in the structure, the projects led, the people supervised, the results with dates, and the organization's size, age, customers and press coverage.
The three decisions point to the same content. The letter that passed in November 2024 named the section, the position, the projects, the fellows supervised and the studies. The letters that failed in February 2024 listed activities, such as a curriculum or a training program, without saying what the applicant led or what depended on his work.
In the January 2025 decision, the AAO noted that each letter "explains the nature and importance of his contributions dating back to 2017." On motion the petitioner added increment and promotion letters from 2018 and 2019 and an offer letter dated February 2021, which dated stages of his career at the company.
The same decision drew a line between the two kinds of proof. The AAO found the evidence of his roles before 2021 persuasive, but the record did not show that he "garnered external recognition" for those roles.
Can a petition meet this criterion and still be denied?
Yes. Meeting three criteria is the first step; the second is a final merits determination of sustained national or international acclaim. In January 2025 the AAO dismissed motions in a case where the role criterion was met.
In the January 29, 2025 decision (Matter ID 35578420), the petitioner had worked since 2017 at a consumer technology company, becoming Associate Vice President, Head of Analytics and Data Science, in August 2021. In its prior decision, the AAO had agreed with the Director that he met the leading or critical role criterion and the judging criterion, and it found the scholarly articles criterion met as well. In January 2025 it dismissed both his motion to reopen and his motion to reconsider.
At the final merits stage, the AAO found that the petitioner "has not explained or documented how his contributions to his employer's success were acknowledged or recognized outside the organization." The record did not show that the company hired him in 2017 based on an existing reputation, or that his career progression within the company was evidence of sustained acclaim.
The November 2024 decision ended the same way at this point: the AAO found the role criterion met and sent the case back for the final merits determination. An RFE response on the role is therefore written with the second step in view, with evidence of how the work was recognized outside the employer. The guide to the Kazarian two-step review covers that stage.
Can comparable evidence replace this criterion?
Only if the regulation's standards do not readily apply to the applicant's occupation. In that case 8 CFR 204.5(h)(4) permits the petitioner to submit comparable evidence of eligibility.
Section 204.5(h)(4) reads: "If the above standards do not readily apply to the beneficiary's occupation, the petitioner may submit comparable evidence" to establish eligibility.
The text ties this option to the occupation: it applies when the listed standards do not fit the kind of work the beneficiary does.
How long is the response period, and how is the response filed?
At most 12 weeks for an RFE and 30 days for a NOID, with no extension. All requested materials go in together, and a partial response counts as a request for a decision on the record.
The rule of April 17, 2007, in force since June 18, 2007, sets the limits in 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv): "in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks," and the maximum for a notice of intent to deny is thirty days. "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted."
Under 103.2(b)(11), all requested materials are submitted together at one time. "Submission of only some of the requested evidence will be considered a request for a decision on the record." The guide on RFE and NOID differences covers the response rules in more detail.
How does IAE prepare an expert letter for an RFE on the leading or critical role criterion?
IAE prepares an expert opinion letter built on the text of the RFE, with a separate section for each finding within the expert's field. The standard turnaround is 5 business days, and the rush option takes 3.
On the RFE and NOID response page, the EB-1A and O-1 finding is listed as "Criteria and the significance of achievements," with an assessment of publications, awards, memberships and original contributions. The text of the request is split into separate findings. The expert takes the points within their field, and legal points stay with the attorney. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with point-by-point answers and references to the case file.
The request includes the text of the RFE or NOID, the petition and the supporting file. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and checks the turnaround against the response deadline. Within one business day IAE confirms the fee, the turnaround and the expert in writing; the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. The secretariat prepares the draft from the client's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs it. Revisions before signing are included, and the draft goes to the attorney. RFE and NOID orders go into a priority queue, and the 3-day rush counts from payment and receipt of all materials.
The client receives a signed PDF with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence. The expert's record can be checked by Member ID or QR code on the status check page. When the findings call for different specializations, a second expert joins at the assessment stage. IAE is not a law firm: the attorney prepares the response, the letter is one piece of evidence in it, and USCIS makes the decision.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (LII, Cornell Law School)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- AAO, In Re: 28282807, Form I-140, extraordinary ability, dismissed (February 5, 2024)
- AAO, In Re: 34800541, Form I-140, extraordinary ability, remanded (November 21, 2024)
- AAO, In Re: 35578420, Form I-140, extraordinary ability, motions dismissed (January 29, 2025)
- USCIS Policy Alert PA-2024-24, Extraordinary Ability Criteria Clarification (October 2, 2024)
- Federal Register, vol. 72, no. 73 (April 17, 2007), Removal of the Standardized Request for Evidence Processing Timeframe, final rule (govinfo)
Read also
All articles
A second RFE after you responded: why does USCIS ask again, and how do you answer?
USCIS can send a second request for evidence on the same petition. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8) it may deny, request more evidence or give notice of its
An H-1B RFE on a Level I wage: why does the wage level put the specialty occupation in question, and what evidence answers it?
A Level I wage on the labor condition application tells USCIS that the employer is paying an entry-level worker who performs routine tasks under
An EB-1A RFE on commercial success in the performing arts: what evidence answers it?
The tenth EB-1A criterion counts commercial successes in the performing arts, shown by box office receipts or record, cassette, compact disk or videoRFE and NOID responses
Received an RFE? We count the days with you.
The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. We confirm the fee, the turnaround and the expert within one business day and check the turnaround against the response deadline.

