For attorneys
Expert opinion letters for immigration attorneys: what must the letter contain, who may pay for it, and when should it be ordered?
USCIS may use an expert opinion letter as an advisory opinion. In Matter of Caron International (1988) the Commissioner wrote that an opinion not in accord with other information, or in any way questionable, may be rejected or given less weight. For H-1B petitions, 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(ii) lists four statements a recognized authority's opinion must contain, and the Department of Labor bars charging petition expenses to an H-1B worker below the required wage.

What is an expert opinion letter in an immigration petition?
A signed opinion of a specialist on a question that USCIS decides, such as whether a position requires a degree in a specific field. USCIS may use it as an advisory opinion and is not bound by it.
The rule comes from Matter of Caron International, Inc., Interim Decision 3085, decided by the Commissioner on October 28, 1988. The Commissioner wrote that the Service "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities, professional organizations, or other sources" submitted "as expert testimony." The next point limits that use: "where an opinion is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable," the Service "is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence."
The petitioner in Caron manufactured and dyed hand knitting and industrial yarns. It sought H-1 classification for its vice-president of manufacturing as a person of distinguished merit and ability and on appeal filed three university letters and a letter from the American Yarn Spinners Association as proof that the job required a degree. The Commissioner found that the letters did not establish a specific degree requirement and that the position was not within the professions.
The appeal was still sustained. The Commissioner found the beneficiary to be a preeminent business executive and approved the petition on that ground. The letters lost the degree question, and the record on the beneficiary's career decided the case.
From Caron the attorney takes two checks for any letter in the file. The opinion has to agree with the exhibits, and nothing in it should give the officer a reason to call it questionable: a wrong date, a title the beneficiary never held, or a conclusion the author does not explain.
How is an expert opinion different from a credential evaluation?
A credential evaluation compares foreign education with a U.S. degree. An expert opinion answers other questions, such as what a position requires or what the beneficiary's experience is worth. USCIS treats both as advisory.
Thirteen days after Caron, on November 10, 1988, the Commissioner decided Matter of Sea, Inc., Interim Decision 3089. The decision states that the Service "uses an evaluation by a credentials evaluation organization of a person's foreign education as an advisory opinion only." An evaluation that is not in accord with previous equivalencies, or is otherwise questionable, may be discounted or given less weight.
The petitioner in Sea manufactured marine radio equipment and sought classification for a Danish electrical design engineer. The director found that he lacked a bachelor's-level education. On appeal the Commissioner held that his education, long experience in the field and professional recognition together equaled a U.S. bachelor's degree in electrical engineering, and approved the petition.
For H-1B petitions, 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(iii)(D) lists five ways to show that a beneficiary's training and experience equal a degree. The first is an evaluation by an official "who has authority to grant college-level credit for training and/or experience" at an accredited college or university with a program that awards such credit. The third is an evaluation of education by "a reliable credentials evaluation service" that specializes in foreign educational credentials. The others are recognized college-level equivalency examinations, certification or registration from a nationally-recognized professional association, and a determination by USCIS.
Under (D)(5), the USCIS determination counts three years of specialized training or work experience for each year of college-level training the beneficiary lacks. Two of the types of documentation listed there turn on outside opinions: "Recognition of expertise in the specialty occupation by at least two recognized authorities" in the same specialty occupation, and "Achievements which a recognized authority has determined to be significant contributions" to the specialty. A firm that relies on (D)(5) plans for two separate authors.
What does a letter about the position have to address in an H-1B case?
The link between the degree and the duties. Under the current definition a specialty occupation requires a bachelor's degree or higher in a directly related specific specialty, and each accepted degree field must relate directly to the duties.
The same paragraph defines a specialty occupation as one that requires "theoretical and practical application of a body of highly specialized knowledge" and "the attainment of a bachelor's degree or higher in a directly related specific specialty, or its equivalent, as a minimum for entry into the occupation in the United States."
The definition then adds two rules. "A position is not a specialty occupation if attainment of a general degree, without further specialization, is sufficient to qualify for the position." At the same time, "A position may allow for a range of qualifying degree fields, provided that each of those fields is directly related to the duties of the position." The regulation defines the term: "Directly related means there is a logical connection between the required degree, or its equivalent, and the duties of the position."
A letter on the position therefore takes each degree field the employer accepts and connects it to named duties of the job. The Caron letters failed on this point in 1988: they said that the job needed a degree but did not establish a specific one. The four statements of a recognized authority in the previous section go into the same letter, so the officer sees who reached the conclusion, how, and on what research.
Who files the petition, and who orders the letters, in EB-1A, EB-1B and EB-2 NIW cases?
Under 8 CFR 204.5, the beneficiary or anyone on the beneficiary's behalf may file an EB-1A or an NIW petition, and a U.S. employer with a job offer files an EB-1B petition.
8 CFR 204.5(h)(1) reads: "An alien, or any person on behalf of the alien, may file an I-140 visa petition" for classification as an alien of extraordinary ability. Paragraph (h)(4) adds that if the listed standards do not readily apply to the beneficiary's occupation, "the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility."
For outstanding professors and researchers, paragraph (i)(1) names "Any United States employer desiring and intending to employ a professor or researcher" as the petitioner. Paragraph (i)(3)(iv) requires "An offer of employment from a prospective United States employer," and the section states: "A labor certification is not required for this classification."
In the second preference, paragraph (k)(1) provides that "the alien, or anyone in the alien's behalf, may be the petitioner" when the alien seeks an exemption from the job offer requirement. Under (k)(4)(ii) the director "may exempt the requirement of a job offer" if the "exemption would be in the national interest."
The regulation names the petitioner, and the engagement letter names the payer. In an EB-1A or NIW self-petition the beneficiary is both the petitioner and the firm's client. In an EB-1B case the university or company petitions, and its agreement with the firm says whether the employer or the researcher pays for the letters. For H-1B petitions, a Department of Labor rule limits that choice.
Can an H-1B employer pass the cost of an expert letter to the worker?
Not in a way that brings pay below the required wage. DOL Fact Sheet #62H lists expenses directly related to filing the Form I-129, including attorney fees, among business expenses the worker can never be required to pay.
The Wage and Hour Division's Fact Sheet #62H, revised in August 2009, opens one list with the sentence: "An H-1B worker, whether through payroll deduction or otherwise, can never be required to pay the following:" One item on it is "Any deduction for the employer's business expenses that would reduce an H-1B worker's pay below the required wage rate," with a citation to 20 CFR 655.731(c)(9).
Under that item the fact sheet lists "Any expenses, including attorney fees, directly related to the filing of the Labor Condition Application" and "Any expenses, including attorney fees and the premium processing fee" directly related to the filing of the Petition for Nonimmigrant Worker, Form I-129/129W. The same list covers any part of the statutory training and processing fee and the fraud protection and detection fee.
Other deductions, the fact sheet says, may be made "even if they reduce the H-1B worker's pay" only when they fall into one of three categories: deductions required by law, reasonable and customary deductions, and voluntarily authorized deductions. Attorney fees do not appear in that second list.
The fact sheet does not name expert opinion letters. Its wording reaches "any expenses" directly related to filing the I-129, and a letter ordered for an H-1B petition is filed with that form. Before an employer's agreement assigns the cost of such a letter to the worker, the firm checks the charge against this rule and the worker's required wage.
How does USCIS weigh an expert letter against the rest of the record?
By the quality of each item. The Policy Manual tells officers to examine each piece of evidence for relevance, probative value and credibility. Under Caron an opinion that conflicts with other information may get less weight.
The O-1 chapter of the USCIS Policy Manual (Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4) quotes Matter of Chawathe: "[T]ruth is to be determined not by the quantity of evidence alone but by its quality." The director "must examine each piece of evidence for relevance, probative value, and credibility."
The same chapter addresses comparable evidence. "A general unsupported assertion that the listed criterion does not readily apply" is not probative. On the other hand, "[A] statement alone can be sufficient if it is detailed, specific, and credible."
For the O-1B criterion on recognition from experts, the chapter describes testimonials in a form that "clearly indicates the author's authority, expertise, and knowledge of the beneficiary's achievements." With Caron, the officer has three questions about each letter: who the author is, what the author knows about the beneficiary's work, and whether the letter agrees with the exhibits.
Before filing, the attorney can run the same check. Each factual statement in a draft is matched with an exhibit, each conclusion with the reasoning behind it, and the author's CV with the field of the petition.
When should a firm order expert letters: with the filing or after an RFE?
With the filing, where the schedule permits. An RFE gives at most twelve weeks and a NOID at most thirty days, no extension is granted, and USCIS treats a partial response as a request for a final decision.
The limits are set in 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv): "in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks, nor shall the maximum response time provided in a notice of intent to deny exceed thirty days." The next sentence reads: "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted."
Chapter 6 of Part E in Volume 1 of the Policy Manual states that "USCIS treats any submission partially responding to an RFE or NOID as a request for a final decision on the record." USCIS "does not wait for a second response or issue a second RFE simply because a response from the benefit requestor is a partial response." USCIS does not wait for a letter that comes after a partial response.
When the letter is ordered after the RFE arrives, its preparation, the author's signature and the firm's review of the draft fit inside the response period together with the rest of the response. A letter ordered for the initial filing is checked against the exhibits before USCIS sees the case.
How does IAE work with immigration firms on expert letters?
Within one business day IAE names the expert, the cost and the deadline. A letter takes 10 business days, 5 in rush mode, and an RFE or NOID response 5, 3 in rush mode.
On the page for attorneys the firm sends the petition category, the beneficiary's field and the filing or RFE deadline, with the beneficiary's CV and the draft petition or the RFE. The secretariat replies which letters make sense for the case, who the expert from the IAE registry is, the cost and the deadline. Letters cover EB-1A, EB-1B, EB-2 NIW, O-1, H-1B and L-1B petitions and RFE and NOID responses, where the expert answers each point of the request.
The firm receives the expert's CV and a link to the registry record before the invoice and may decline the candidate. The deadline runs from payment and receipt of the full file and is fixed in the invoice. The secretariat prepares the draft from the beneficiary's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. The draft goes to the attorney and the beneficiary with one round of factual edits, and the conclusions remain the expert's own.
Before delivery, facts, dates and quotations are checked against the beneficiary's documents, and text from earlier letters is not reused except section headings. In every letter the expert signs a declaration of no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary under the IAE Impartiality Policy IAE-GOV-002, and declines the order if there is one. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition, so a package of three letters has three different signers.
Each case has its own number in the email subject, the letter and the invoice. A firm can send several cases in one table, and the secretariat answers on each one separately. The invoice for each case goes to the firm or to the client. The firm cabinet holds orders, a monthly statement and payment from the balance. IAE gives an independent expert opinion and does not provide legal services: case strategy stays with the attorney, and USCIS weighs the letter together with the other evidence.
Sources
- Matter of Caron International, Inc., Interim Decision 3085 (Comm'r, October 28, 1988)
- Matter of Sea, Inc., Interim Decision 3089 (Comm'r, November 10, 1988)
- 8 CFR 214.2, Special requirements for admission, extension, and maintenance of status (LII)
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (LII)
- U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, Fact Sheet #62H: What are the rules concerning deductions from an H-1B worker's pay? (revised August 2009)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4, O-1 Beneficiaries
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 1, Part E, Chapter 6, Evidence
- 8 CFR 103.2, Submission and adjudication of benefit requests (govinfo, 2023 edition)
Read also
All articles
Notice of intent to revoke an approved I-140: what triggers it, how do you respond, and can a court review the revocation?
An approved I-140 is not final. Under 8 U.S.C. 1155 the Secretary of Homeland Security may revoke the approval at any time for good and sufficient
USCIS signature requirements after the July 10, 2026 rule: who signs a petition, can the attorney sign for the client, and what happens to an invalid signature?
The petitioner signs the petition, and the attorney signs the G-28. The Policy Manual states that an attorney generally may not sign a benefit
Suing USCIS after a denial: what does a federal court review under the APA, and why must the evidence already be in the record?
A final USCIS denial can be challenged in federal district court under the Administrative Procedure Act. The court sets aside a decision that isRequest
Send your first case
The beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline. The expert, the CV, the cost and the deadline within one business day.

