For attorneys
Suing USCIS after a denial: what does a federal court review under the APA, and why must the evidence already be in the record?
A final USCIS denial can be challenged in federal district court under the Administrative Procedure Act. The court sets aside a decision that is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion or not in accordance with law, and it decides on the whole record or the parts a party cites. Evidence never filed with USCIS is not in that record, and some discretionary decisions, such as an NIW waiver in the Ninth Circuit, are beyond review.

Can a petitioner sue USCIS in federal court after a denial?
Yes, when the denial is final agency action with no other adequate remedy in a court. The APA, 5 U.S.C. 704 and 706, provides for review, and Kazarian v. USCIS (9th Cir. 2010) reviewed an EB-1A denial this way.
Section 704 of title 5 makes two kinds of agency action reviewable: action made reviewable by statute, and final agency action for which there is no other adequate remedy in a court. Preliminary, procedural or intermediate steps are reviewed together with the final action.
Section 706 tells the court what to do. "To the extent necessary to decision and when presented, the reviewing court shall decide all relevant questions of law, interpret constitutional and statutory provisions, and determine the meaning or applicability of the terms of an agency action." The court then may compel action unlawfully withheld or unreasonably delayed, or hold unlawful and set aside action that fails one of six tests.
Employment-based petitions have reached the courts this way. Poghos Kazarian filed an EB-1A petition in December 2003 as a theoretical physicist. USCIS denied it in August 2005, the AAO dismissed his appeal, and the Central District of California granted summary judgment to USCIS; the Ninth Circuit reviewed the case under the APA standard in its amended opinion of March 4, 2010.
The sections below go through the conditions of such a suit, the standard the court applies, the record it reads and the decisions it cannot review, then turn to what this means for expert letters filed before the decision.
When is a USCIS denial final agency action?
Under 5 U.S.C. 704 an otherwise final action stays final while the party seeks reconsideration or appeals inside the agency, unless a statute expressly requires otherwise, or an agency rule requires the appeal and makes the action inoperative meanwhile.
Section 704 contains a rule on finality. Agency action that is otherwise final is final for the purposes of the section whether or not the party has applied for a declaratory order, for reconsideration or for an appeal to a superior agency authority. The exceptions are a statute that expressly requires otherwise and an agency rule that requires the appeal and provides that the action is inoperative meanwhile.
A USCIS denial that the petitioner could appeal to the AAO is therefore not automatically non-final because the appeal exists. The question is whether a statute expressly requires the appeal, or an agency rule requires it and makes the denial inoperative meanwhile.
The same section explains how intermediate steps are treated. A request for evidence or a notice of intent to deny is not itself the final action; the court reviews it as part of the final denial, if the denial rests on it.
Must the petitioner appeal to the AAO before going to court?
Under Darby v. Cisneros (1993), courts may not require exhaustion of an optional administrative appeal under the APA. Exhaustion is required only where a statute requires it, or an agency rule requires the appeal and makes the action inoperative meanwhile.
The Supreme Court decided Darby v. Cisneros, 509 U.S. 137, on June 21, 1993, in an opinion by Justice Blackmun. The Court held that where the APA applies, exhaustion of administrative remedies is a prerequisite to judicial review only where a statute expressly requires it, or where an agency rule requires an appeal before review and makes the action inoperative pending that review. Because neither the statute nor the agency's rules required the further appeal in Darby, the lower courts could not require it.
The Court reversed the Fourth Circuit, which had required the plaintiffs to exhaust an optional administrative appeal before suing.
For an attorney the choice between an AAO appeal and a lawsuit turns on the record: a court under section 706 reads the record as it stood at the decision. Kazarian went through the AAO before suing, and the AAO's decision was the decision the court reviewed. The attorney checks the rules that govern the particular form against the Darby conditions before advising the client to skip the appeal.
What standard does the court apply to a USCIS denial?
Section 706(2)(A) has the court set aside action that is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion or otherwise not in accordance with law. The court also takes due account of prejudicial error, so harmless mistakes do not reverse.
Section 706(2) lists six grounds on which the court holds agency action unlawful and sets it aside: "(A) arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law; (B) contrary to constitutional right, power, privilege, or immunity; (C) in excess of statutory jurisdiction, authority, or limitations, or short of statutory right; (D) without observance of procedure required by law;" (E) unsupported by substantial evidence in cases subject to formal hearing rules; and (F) unwarranted by the facts where the facts are subject to trial de novo.
For a USCIS benefit decision the main ground is (A). In Kazarian the Ninth Circuit reviewed the summary judgment de novo and applied that standard: agency action may be set aside only if "arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law."
The last sentence of section 706 adds that "due account shall be taken of the rule of prejudicial error." Kazarian applied it: the court "will not usually overturn agency action unless there is a showing of prejudice to the petitioner." An error that did not change the outcome does not lead to reversal.
What does the court read, and why must the evidence already be in the record?
Section 706 directs the court to review the whole record or the parts a party cites. Evidence the petitioner never gave USCIS is not in that record, so the case is argued on the file as it stood.
The final sentence of section 706 reads: "In making the foregoing determinations, the court shall review the whole record or those parts of it cited by a party." In a petition case the documents before the agency are the petition and its evidence, any RFE or NOID and the response, the denial and, after an appeal, the AAO decision.
Chief Judge McConnell of the District of Rhode Island quoted the same words in Dorcas International Institute of Rhode Island v. USCIS, No. 26-cv-132, decided on June 5, 2026, in a challenge to four USCIS policies. In the Ninth Circuit's March 5, 2026 decision in Chairez v. Mayorkas, the court noted in a footnote that the district court "was under no obligation to require Defendants to file the administrative record" in a case it dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
For an employment-based petition the record rule has a direct consequence. An expert letter that was not filed with the petition or the RFE response is not part of that record, and a letter written after the denial is not among the documents the court reviews under section 706. The time to build the evidence is before USCIS decides: in the initial filing, in the response to an RFE or NOID and, where an appeal is taken, in the materials the AAO receives.
The court reads the record against the regulation. In Kazarian the question was whether the AAO had applied 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) as written, judged on the documents Kazarian had filed.
What did Kazarian v. USCIS decide about an EB-1A denial?
The Ninth Circuit held that the AAO could not impose novel evidentiary requirements beyond 8 CFR 204.5 for the scholarly articles and judging criteria, but affirmed because Kazarian still met only two of the three required criteria.
The amended opinion, written by Judge D.W. Nelson for a panel with Judges Pregerson and Thompson, replaced the earlier opinion at 580 F.3d 1030. The AAO had found that Kazarian satisfied none of the evidentiary criteria.
On scholarly articles, criterion (h)(3)(vi), the AAO had required proof that other scholars cited Kazarian's articles. The court held that citations go to the final merits question and not to whether the criterion is met. On judging, criterion (h)(3)(iv), the AAO had discounted his judging of diploma works because they were at his own university. The court wrote that "the AAO may not unilaterally impose a novel evidentiary requirement," relying on Love Korean Church v. Chertoff, 549 F.3d 749 (9th Cir. 2008).
The court found no error in the AAO's analysis of the contributions and display criteria. Kazarian therefore had two criteria, and "the 'extraordinary ability' visa regulations require three." The AAO's error was harmless, and the judgment for USCIS was affirmed.
The case is an example of a lawsuit that corrected the agency's reading of the regulation without changing the outcome, because the record lacked a third criterion.
What can the court order if the petitioner wins?
Under section 706(2) the court holds the decision unlawful and sets it aside; under 706(1) it can compel action unlawfully withheld or unreasonably delayed. In Dorcas (D.R.I. 2026) the court vacated four USCIS policies.
The remedy in section 706(2) is to "hold unlawful and set aside agency action, findings, and conclusions" that fail one of the six tests. The text of the statute speaks of setting aside; it does not direct the court to grant the benefit itself.
Section 706(1) covers inaction: the reviewing court shall "compel agency action unlawfully withheld or unreasonably delayed." Its words cover a petition that has waited without a decision, if the court finds the delay unreasonable.
In Dorcas, the challenged USCIS policies included a hold on adjudication of benefit requests from nationals of countries named in a travel ban and a re-review of approved benefits. The court rejected the argument that national security considerations made the policies unreviewable, held that 8 U.S.C. 1252(a)(2)(B) did not strip jurisdiction over categorical challenges to agency policies, found the policies contrary to law and arbitrary and capricious, and ordered that each of them is "declared unlawful and are vacated and set aside." The court granted declaratory relief and denied a permanent injunction.
Which USCIS decisions can a court not review?
Under 8 U.S.C. 1252(a)(2)(B) no court may review listed judgments on relief or any other decision the statute places in the discretion of the Attorney General or the Secretary, apart from asylum.
Section 1252(a)(2)(B) begins: "Notwithstanding any other provision of law (statutory or nonstatutory)" and "regardless of whether the judgment, decision, or action is made in removal proceedings, no court shall have jurisdiction to review." Clause (i) covers judgments regarding relief under sections 1182(h), 1182(i), 1229b, 1229c and 1255. Clause (ii) covers "any other decision or action of the Attorney General or the Secretary of Homeland Security the authority for which is specified under this subchapter to be in the discretion of" either official, other than the granting of asylum under section 1158(a).
Section 1252(a)(2)(D) preserves review of "constitutional claims or questions of law raised upon a petition for review filed with an appropriate court of appeals." In Chairez v. Mayorkas the Ninth Circuit held that this savings clause works only in a petition for review from a final removal order and gives no district court jurisdiction.
In Chairez, decided on March 5, 2026, the court applied clause (ii) to a U-visa waiver of inadmissibility and held that "ANA International is no longer good law": whether statutory guidance, stripped of its context, is a judicially manageable standard "is no longer relevant." Because the INA precluded review, the APA did not apply under 5 U.S.C. 701(a)(1).
Can a federal court review the denial of a national interest waiver?
Not in the Ninth Circuit. In Poursina v. USCIS (2019) the court held that the authority to grant or deny a national interest waiver is in the Attorney General's discretion, so 8 U.S.C. 1252(a)(2)(B)(ii) bars review.
Mohammad Poursina, an Iranian citizen with mechanical engineering degrees, sought an employment-based visa in 2012 and, because he "could not show that an employer sought his services," asked for a national interest waiver. USCIS denied the request, the AAO dismissed his appeal, and the District of Arizona dismissed his suit for lack of jurisdiction.
Judge O'Scannlain wrote for a panel with Judges Schroeder and Rawlinson. The statute says the Attorney General "may, when the Attorney General deems it to be in the national interest" waive the job offer requirement; the court read "may" with "the usual presumption of discretion" and held that "the authority to grant (or to deny) a national-interest waiver is in the discretion of the Attorney General." It added that under the Dhanasar framework approval is still granted only "as a matter of discretion."
The court dismissed the non-constitutional claims because they "simply repackage that core grievance." The due process claim was reviewable in principle but failed, because notice mailed to the address on file was reasonably calculated to reach him. The judgment was affirmed.
In Chairez the Ninth Circuit kept jurisdiction over colorable procedural due process claims under Poursina. Judge Bea, concurring in part, wrote that Poursina and another Ninth Circuit decision, Nakka, conflict and that the court should resolve the question en banc. For an NIW petitioner in the Ninth Circuit the routes left after a denial are an AAO appeal or a new petition, and a due process claim where one is colorable.
What should be in the file before USCIS decides, if a lawsuit is possible?
Everything the petitioner would want a judge to read: evidence for each criterion, expert letters that explain it, a complete RFE response and, for an appeal, the brief. The court reviews the record as it stood at the decision.
Because section 706 limits the court to the record, the litigation file is built during the administrative case. Each criterion relied on has its documents in the petition. Each expert letter states the author's qualifications, the documents the author reviewed and the facts behind each conclusion, so that a judge reading the record can follow the reasoning without outside material.
The response to an RFE or NOID answers every point raised, in one package, within the deadline. A point left unanswered becomes part of the record as a gap. Where the AAO is used, the appeal brief identifies the errors of law, such as a requirement the regulation does not contain, which is the kind of error Kazarian found.
Where the denial is of a kind that 1252(a)(2)(B)(ii) places beyond review, as an NIW waiver is in the Ninth Circuit, the file matters for a different reason: the AAO or a new petition is where the evidence will be weighed again.
How does IAE prepare expert letters for a record that may go to court?
A member of the public IAE registry in the beneficiary's field signs each letter, with a declaration of independence, after the IAE checklist compares facts, dates and quotations with the documents. An RFE response takes 5 business days.
You receive the expert's CV, degree, memberships and publications and a link to the registry record before the invoice and may decline the candidate. In every letter the expert confirms no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary; if there is one, the expert declines the order. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition.
The Secretariat prepares the draft from the beneficiary's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. Before delivery the letter passes the IAE checklist: facts, dates and quotations are checked against the beneficiary's documents, and text from earlier letters is not reused except section headings. One round of factual edits is included; the conclusions remain the expert's own.
An expert letter takes 10 business days, 5 on rush; an answer to an RFE or NOID takes 5 business days, 3 on rush, and the expert answers each point of the request. Send the beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline through the page for attorneys, with the RFE or NOID if there is one. Within one business day the Secretariat replies, free of charge, which letters make sense for the case, who the expert is, the cost and the deadline.
IAE provides an independent expert opinion, and the attorney is responsible for the case strategy, including an appeal or a lawsuit. The letter does not guarantee approval or a result in court.
Sources
- 5 U.S.C. 706, Scope of review (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 5 U.S.C. 704, Actions reviewable (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 8 U.S.C. 1252(a)(2), Matters not subject to judicial review (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Darby v. Cisneros, 509 U.S. 137 (1993), syllabus (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Kazarian v. USCIS, No. 07-56774 (9th Cir. Mar. 4, 2010), amended opinion (Justia, PDF)
- Poursina v. USCIS, No. 17-16579 (9th Cir. Aug. 28, 2019) (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit)
- Chairez v. Mayorkas, No. 24-4137 (9th Cir. Mar. 5, 2026) (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit)
- Dorcas International Institute of Rhode Island v. USCIS, No. 26-cv-132-JJM-PAS (D.R.I. June 5, 2026), order (PDF)
Read also
All articles
Notice of intent to revoke an approved I-140: what triggers it, how do you respond, and can a court review the revocation?
An approved I-140 is not final. Under 8 U.S.C. 1155 the Secretary of Homeland Security may revoke the approval at any time for good and sufficient
USCIS signature requirements after the July 10, 2026 rule: who signs a petition, can the attorney sign for the client, and what happens to an invalid signature?
The petitioner signs the petition, and the attorney signs the G-28. The Policy Manual states that an attorney generally may not sign a benefit
Withdrawing a petition before USCIS decides: what happens to the fee and the priority date, and when is refiling the better route?
A petitioner may withdraw a benefit request at any time until USCIS issues a decision, and a withdrawal cannot be taken back. That is 8 CFRRequest
Send your first case
The beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline. The expert, the CV, the cost and the deadline within one business day.

