For attorneys

Notice of intent to revoke an approved I-140: what triggers it, how do you respond, and can a court review the revocation?

An approved I-140 is not final. Under 8 U.S.C. 1155 the Secretary of Homeland Security may revoke the approval at any time for good and sufficient cause, and the revocation reaches back to the approval date. Before that, 8 CFR 205.2 requires a notice of intent to revoke and a chance to answer it. Since Bouarfa v. Mayorkas federal courts do not review the revocation itself, which leaves the response and the administrative appeal.

An attorney from behind opens a courier envelope onto a thick file and a thin notice, pages turned away

What is a notice of intent to revoke?

It is the written notice that 8 CFR 205.2 requires before USCIS revokes an approved petition on a ground that is not automatic. It names the grounds and opens the petitioner's opportunity to offer evidence.

The statute is two sentences long. The Secretary "may, at any time, for what he deems to be good and sufficient cause, revoke the approval of any petition approved by him under section 1154 of this title." The section ends: "Such revocation shall be effective as of the date of approval of any such petition."

The procedure is in the regulation. Under 8 CFR 205.2(a) any officer authorized to approve a petition may revoke the approval, on notice to the petitioner, on any ground other than those listed in section 205.1. Under paragraph (b) the petitioner or self-petitioner must be given the opportunity to offer evidence in support of the petition and in opposition to the grounds alleged for revocation. Under paragraph (c) a revocation is issued as a written notification "that explains the specific reasons for the revocation."

Which revocations happen without a notice?

Those listed in 8 CFR 205.1. For employment-based petitions they include a withdrawal by the petitioner and the end of the employer's business, and only when either comes less than 180 days after the approval.

Paragraph (a)(3)(iii)(C) revokes the approval automatically on a written notice of withdrawal filed by the petitioner less than 180 days after the approval, unless an associated adjustment application has been pending for 180 days or more. A petition withdrawn 180 days or more after the approval "remains approved unless its approval is revoked on other grounds." Paragraph (D) applies the same 180-day rule to the termination of the employer's business for EB-1B, EB-1C, EB-2 and EB-3 petitions.

The statute points the same way. Under 8 U.S.C. 1154(j) a petition for a person whose adjustment application has been pending for 180 days or more stays valid for a new job in the same or a similar occupational classification.

A self-petition in EB-1A or NIW has no employer to withdraw it or close down. For those petitions a revocation over the merits goes through the notice under section 205.2.

What counts as good and sufficient cause?

A record that would support a denial. Under Matter of Estime and Matter of Ho the notice is proper when the evidence, if unexplained and unrebutted, would warrant a denial, and an error in the original approval is enough.

The Board of Immigration Appeals decided Matter of Estime on August 12, 1987 and Matter of Ho on March 17, 1988. Together they set a two-step test. The notice is properly issued when the record at the time of issuance, "if unexplained and unrebutted, would warrant a denial" for failure to meet the burden of proof. The revocation is sustained when the record at the time of the decision, including the petitioner's rebuttal, would still warrant a denial.

Matter of Ho adds three holdings. The director's realization that he erred in approving the petition "may be good and sufficient cause for revoking his approval," provided the revised opinion is supported by the record. The evidence behind the notice need not have been unavailable or undiscoverable earlier. And the approval of a petition vests no rights in the beneficiary.

Three AAO decisions give examples of what leads to a notice. The U.S. Embassy in Seoul telephoned the author of a reference letter in an NIW case decided on December 1, 2021. A consular post returned an EB-1A petition, and the notice cited a memorandum of the National Visa Center Fraud Prevention Unit, in a case decided on December 13, 2023. And in an EB-1C case decided on September 27, 2024 an interview held three months after the approval raised doubts about the beneficiary's duties and place of work.

What must the notice state?

The specific facts and the evidence behind them. Under Matter of Estime a revocation cannot stand on an unsupported statement, an unstated presumption or derogatory evidence the petitioner was never told about.

Estime requires the notice to state specifically both the facts underlying the proposed action and the supporting evidence. Where the notice rests on "an unsupported statement or an unstated presumption," or where the petitioner was unaware of the derogatory evidence, the revocation "cannot be sustained," even if the petitioner did not respond. 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(i) gives the same protection in general terms: a petitioner must be advised of derogatory information of which he is unaware and offered an opportunity to rebut it.

The AAO applied the rule in the 2023 EB-1A case. The petition of a research geophysicist had been approved in January 2016. The notice of March 30, 2023 said that he had submitted "fraudulent documents" and had not met three criteria. It did not identify the documents or explain the criteria, and the revocation did not address the rebuttal. The AAO wrote: "The Director did not properly revoke the approved petition." It withdrew the decision and remanded for a new notice.

The 2024 EB-1C case ended the same way. The Director had found a willful misrepresentation of the beneficiary's experience as chief financial officer. The AAO held the notice and the revocation too vague to support that finding: the beneficiary's earlier career as a dentist had been disclosed, and her residence in Florida raised questions without disproving the employment. The decision was withdrawn and the matter remanded.

Who receives the notice: the petitioner or the beneficiary?

The petitioner. The regulations exclude the beneficiary of a visa petition from the affected parties, with one exception adopted by USCIS in 2017: a beneficiary who has properly asked to port to a new job under section 204(j).

Section 205.2 addresses the notice, the decision and the appeal to the petitioner or self-petitioner, and 8 CFR 103.3(a)(1)(iii)(B) says of the term affected party: "It does not include the beneficiary of a visa petition."

The exception comes from Matter of V-S-G- Inc., Adopted Decision 2017-06 (AAO Nov. 11, 2017). The AAO described the holding in a decision of February 2, 2018: beneficiaries of valid employment-based petitions who are eligible to change jobs or employers and have properly requested to do so under section 204(j) "are 'affected parties' under DHS regulations for purposes of revocation proceedings." In that 2018 case the beneficiary appealed the revocation of a petition filed by a provider of medical services. The AAO remanded with an instruction: if the beneficiary had properly ported, the Director was to issue a new notice of intent to revoke to the petitioner and the beneficiary, and otherwise to the petitioner only. For a proper request the decision cites 8 CFR 245.25(a)(2): an adjustment application pending for at least 180 days at the time of the request, sufficient notice to USCIS of the new job, and a new job in the same or a similar occupational classification.

In EB-1A and NIW self-petitions the question does not arise. The beneficiary is the petitioner and receives the notice directly.

How long do you have to respond?

Section 205.2 names no number of days. The deadline is the date printed in the notice. In Matter of Estime the notice gave 15 days, and the Board treats a missed deadline as a ground to sustain the revocation.

Paragraph (b) gives the opportunity to offer evidence and stops there. For comparison, 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv) caps the response time for a notice of intent to deny at thirty days.

Estime states both sides of the rule. A revocation is sustained when the notice was proper and the petitioner did not make a timely explanation or submission after a reasonable opportunity. In Estime itself the petitioner submitted on appeal a copy of a letter answering the notice. The Board found by the date of its notarization that the response had been prepared in time and remanded the record for further proceedings and a new decision.

What goes into the response?

Evidence on each ground named in the notice. The revocation is tested against the record at the time of the decision, rebuttal included, and inconsistencies are resolved with independent objective evidence.

Under Matter of Ho the burden stays with the petitioner in revocation proceedings. Two sentences of the decision set the method: "Doubt cast on any aspect of the petitioner's proof may, of course, lead to a reevaluation" of the remaining evidence, and "it is incumbent upon the petitioner to resolve the inconsistencies by independent objective evidence."

The 2023 EB-1A response worked on two levels. Counsel argued, citing Estime, that the notice did not say which documents were fraudulent. The petitioner also rebuilt the merits: documents explaining the work experience recorded on his Form I-20, W-2 forms, service as a book editor, a Google Scholar profile with 453 citations, two granted and three pending patents, and claims under the leading or critical role and high salary criteria. The AAO faulted the Director for ignoring that material.

The 2021 NIW response failed. A professor had told the embassy that he never wrote the reference letter. The petitioner answered with a second statement by the same professor saying that he had written it and had been caught off guard. The AAO presumed that the consular officer had recorded the call accurately, found that the new statement did not explain the contradictions, and upheld a finding that she "knowingly submitted a false document."

Where do expert letters fit in a response?

They answer grounds that turn on judgment: whether a contribution is significant or a criterion is met. They do not answer a factual allegation about a document, which calls for records.

A notice like the one in the 2023 case, which says that fewer than three EB-1A criteria were met, puts the merits back in issue. Matter of Caron International, decided by the Commissioner on October 28, 1988, describes what an expert's statement is in a petition: the Service "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities, professional organizations, or other sources submitted in evidence as expert testimony," and "where an opinion is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable, the Service is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence."

A notice that alleges a false document is a different task. In the Seoul case a further statement by the letter's own author did not overcome the embassy's report, and the AAO then found the remaining documents insufficient. Section 205.2(b) lets the petitioner submit evidence both in support of the petition and against the grounds of the notice, so one response can carry records on the facts and an independent expert's analysis of the merits.

What follows a revocation: appeal, motion or court?

An administrative appeal within 15 days after service of the revocation notice, on Form I-290B with an $800 fee. Federal courts do not review the revocation, and a new petition remains possible.

Under 8 CFR 205.2(d) the petitioner or self-petitioner may appeal the decision to revoke "within 15 days after the service of notice of the revocation." The general appeal period in 8 CFR 103.3(a)(2)(i) is 30 days, so the revocation deadline is half the usual one. The appeal is filed on Form I-290B, whose fee in 8 CFR 106.2(a)(16) is $800. An appeal filed late is rejected, unless it meets the requirements of a motion to reopen or reconsider and is treated as one.

The appeals in the three cases above ended in two remands and one dismissal.

The Supreme Court closed the judicial route on December 10, 2024. In Bouarfa v. Mayorkas it held unanimously that a revocation under section 1155, there based on a sham-marriage finding, is a discretionary decision within 8 U.S.C. 1252(a)(2)(B)(ii), which federal courts cannot review. The Court read the statute's words closely: "the word 'may' clearly connotes discretion." It noted that the petitioner could file a new petition and, if it were denied on the same finding, "can seek judicial review of that determination."

What does a revocation do to the priority date?

It depends on the ground. Under 8 CFR 204.5(e)(2) the date is lost when the approval is revoked for fraud or willful misrepresentation, for a revoked or invalidated labor certification, or for material error.

Paragraph (e)(1) lets an approved EB-1, EB-2 or EB-3 petition pass its priority date to later petitions in those categories. Paragraph (e)(2) removes that benefit in four cases: "Fraud, or a willful misrepresentation of a material fact," revocation of the labor certification by the Department of Labor, invalidation of the labor certification by USCIS or the Department of State, and "A determination by USCIS that petition approval was based on a material error."

The ground written into the revocation notice therefore matters for the next petition. A finding of willful misrepresentation also reaches beyond the petition: under 8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(6)(C)(i) a person who sought an immigration benefit by fraud or by willfully misrepresenting a material fact is inadmissible.

How does IAE prepare expert letters for a response to a USCIS notice?

A member of the public IAE registry in the beneficiary's field answers each point of the notice in a signed letter with a declaration of independence. A response to an RFE or NOID takes 5 business days, 3 on rush.

The page for attorneys names responses to an RFE and a NOID; a notice of intent to revoke is not listed, so send the notice itself with its deadline, the beneficiary's CV and the petition category. Within one business day the Secretariat replies, free of charge, which letters make sense for the case, who the expert is, the cost and the deadline.

You receive the expert's CV, degree, memberships and publications and a link to the registry record before the invoice, and you may decline the candidate. In every letter the expert confirms that there is no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition.

Before delivery the letter passes the IAE checklist: facts and dates are checked against the beneficiary's documents, and no template text is used. IAE provides an independent expert opinion. The attorney decides the strategy of the response, and the letter does not guarantee the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Request

Send your first case

The beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline. The expert, the CV, the cost and the deadline within one business day.

Case for assessment

Received

Expert, cost and deadline within one business day

CategoryEB‑2 NIW
Beneficiary's fieldGeotechnics
RFE response duein 30 days