Expert witnesses
Florida presuit investigation in medical malpractice: what must the corroborating expert opinion contain?
In Florida a medical malpractice claim starts with an expert before any complaint is filed. Section 766.203(2) of the Florida Statutes requires the claimant to investigate first and to mail a verified written opinion of a medical expert with the notice of intent to initiate litigation. Suit then waits 90 days. A claim sent without a qualifying opinion is dismissed under section 766.206(2), and the expert can be reported to the state.

What has to happen before a Florida malpractice suit can be filed?
Counsel investigates, a medical expert corroborates the claim in a verified written opinion, the notice of intent goes to each prospective defendant with that opinion, and 90 days pass. Only then may the complaint be filed.
Chapter 766 of the Florida Statutes sets the order. Section 766.104(1) bars any action for personal injury or wrongful death arising out of medical negligence unless the attorney filing it has first made a reasonable investigation. Section 766.203(2) then describes what that investigation must find: reasonable grounds to believe that a named defendant was negligent in the care or treatment of the claimant, and that this negligence resulted in injury to the claimant.
The investigation ends with a document. When the claimant mails the notice of intent under section 766.106, the notice must carry a verified written medical expert opinion that corroborates those reasonable grounds. No suit may be filed for 90 days after the notice is delivered to a prospective defendant (section 766.106(3)(a)).
The rules reach almost every claim against a health care provider. Section 766.203(1) applies presuit investigation to all medical negligence claims and defenses, including wrongful death actions under section 768.19 and claims against the state and its agencies under section 768.28. Section 766.202(7) defines medical negligence as medical malpractice, whether grounded in tort or in contract.
The Second District Court of Appeal called these procedures "meticulous in their chronology" in Brundage v. Evans (2020). The order matters because each later step, including informal discovery and the waiver rules, depends on a valid notice with an expert opinion.
What must the verified written expert opinion say?
It must corroborate reasonable grounds to believe that a named defendant was negligent and that the negligence injured the claimant. It must also state whether any earlier opinion of the same expert was disqualified.
The opinion answers the two questions of section 766.203(2): was a named defendant negligent in the care or treatment of the claimant, and did that negligence result in injury. The expert does not have to prove the case at this stage. In Apostolico v. Orlando Regional Health Care System (2004), the Fifth District Court of Appeal wrote that presuit notice and screening requirements are "not intended to deny access to the courts on basis of technicalities."
The defense side has the same burden. Under section 766.203(3), the prospective defendant or its insurer investigates within the response period. A response that rejects the claim must include a verified written medical expert opinion, mailed with the rejection, that supports the denial of negligent injury.
Section 766.203(4) makes these presuit opinions subject to discovery. Each opinion must also state whether any previous opinion by the same expert has been disqualified and, if so, name the court and the case number. A physician with a disqualification on record therefore discloses it in every later presuit opinion.
Other presuit materials are protected. Statements, discussions, written documents, reports and other work product generated by the presuit screening process are not discoverable or admissible in any civil action for any purpose by the opposing party (section 766.106(5); section 766.205(4)). Under the same subsection of 766.106, a Florida physician who submits a verified written expert opinion remains subject to license discipline under section 458.331(1)(oo).
Who can sign the presuit opinion?
A medical expert as defined in section 766.202(6): a person who regularly and actively practices the profession, holds a health care professional degree and meets the expert witness requirements of section 766.102.
Under section 766.102(5), testimony on the prevailing professional standard of care may come only from a licensed health care provider who has completely reviewed the pertinent medical records. If the defendant is a specialist, the expert must specialize in the same specialty and must have devoted professional time, during the 3 years before the occurrence, to active clinical practice or consulting in that specialty, to teaching it in an accredited health professional school or residency program, or to clinical research in it. For a general practitioner the look-back period is 5 years; for other health care providers it is 3 years in the same or a similar profession.
Against a Florida physician the expert also needs a Florida license under chapter 458 or 459, or an expert witness certificate under section 458.3175 or 459.0066 (section 766.102(12)). A physician licensed only in another state therefore needs the certificate before signing a presuit opinion against a Florida physician.
Specialty disputes come up at the presuit stage. In Dontineni v. Sanderson (2022), the defendant was board certified in internal medicine and said he worked as a hospitalist. The claimant's presuit expert was board certified in internal medicine and gastroenterology and treated outpatients. The trial court denied the defendant's motion to determine the reasonableness of the presuit investigation without findings. The Fifth District quashed that order because it contained no express findings on compliance with the presuit requirements, remanded for further proceedings and left open whether a hospitalist is a specialty under section 766.102(5)(a)1.
Apostolico (2004) allowed a registered nurse with critical care and cardiovascular experience to corroborate both the standard of care and causation in a claim about a misplaced PICC line. The court applied the 2002 statutes, because the 2003 revisions did not govern that notice. The current definition in section 766.202(6) requires the medical expert to meet the requirements of section 766.102, so the specialty and practice tests above apply to the presuit signer as well.
What goes out with the notice of intent?
The verified expert opinion and, if available, lists of providers who treated the claimant, copies of the records the expert relied on and the signed authorization for release of health information under section 766.1065.
Section 766.106(2)(a) lists four ways of service that can be verified: certified mail with return receipt requested, mail with a tracking number, an interstate commercial carrier or a person authorized by law to serve process. Proof of delivery to an address on file with the Department of Health, the Secretary of State or the Agency for Health Care Administration creates a rebuttable presumption of receipt (section 766.106(2)(b)).
Under section 766.106(2)(c) the notice must include, if available, a list of all known health care providers seen by the claimant for the injuries after the alleged negligence, a list of all known providers who treated or evaluated the claimant during the 2 years before it, copies of all medical records relied on by the expert in signing the affidavit, and the executed authorization form of section 766.1065.
The notice carries copies of the records the expert relied on, so the prospective defendant and its own expert review the claim on the same records during the 90 days. Under section 766.106(6)(b) either side may then request further documents, which are due within 20 days.
What happens during the 90-day screening period?
The prospective defendant and its insurer review the claim and, by the end of 90 days, reject it, offer a settlement or offer arbitration on damages with liability admitted. Silence for 90 days counts as a final rejection.
Section 766.106(3)(a) requires each insurer or self-insurer to have a procedure for prompt review of claims. The procedure must include at least one of the following: internal review by a qualified claims adjuster; a panel of an attorney experienced in medical negligence, a health care provider in the same or a similar specialty and a claims adjuster; a contract with a professional society that maintains a medical review committee; or another procedure that evaluates the claim fairly and promptly. If the insurer requires it, the claimant must appear before a screening panel or committee and submit to a physical examination.
By the end of the period the defendant or its insurer responds in one of three ways under section 766.106(3)(b): rejection of the claim, a settlement offer, or an offer to arbitrate in which liability is deemed admitted and arbitration determines only damages. A rejection needs its own corroborating expert opinion under section 766.203(3).
The response goes by certified mail with return receipt requested. If the defendant does not reply within 90 days after receiving the notice, the claim is deemed finally rejected (section 766.106(3)(c)). A represented claimant then hears from counsel within 30 days in writing: the exact response, the terms of any offer, the consequences of accepting or rejecting it, an evaluation of the chances at trial and an estimate of costs and fees through trial (section 766.106(3)(d)).
What informal discovery is available during presuit?
Unsworn statements, production of documents within 20 days, an examination of the claimant, up to 30 written questions, interviews of treating providers and unsworn statements of treating providers, all without formal discovery.
Once a notice of claim is received, section 766.106(6)(a) requires the parties to make discoverable information available without formal discovery, and failure to do so is grounds for dismissal of claims or defenses later asserted. Section 766.106(6)(b) lists the methods. Each request must be in writing, with a copy and a certificate of service to all parties (section 766.106(6)(c)).
- Any party may require other parties to appear for an unsworn statement, which may be recorded and can be used only for presuit screening.
- Any party may request documents or things, which are produced at the requesting party's expense within 20 days after the request is received; medical records follow section 766.204.
- A prospective defendant may require the claimant to be examined by an appropriate health care provider, with one examination for all potential defendants unless that is impractical.
- A party may serve up to 30 written questions, including subparts, answered within 20 days.
- A prospective defendant may interview the claimant's treating providers within the scope of the authorization, and the claimant's side arranges the first interview within 15 days after the request.
- Unsworn statements of treating providers may be taken on areas potentially relevant to the claim, with notice to the claimant, who may attend.
How does presuit affect the statute of limitations?
The notice must be served within the period of section 95.11, and the limitations period is tolled during the 90 days. Counsel can also obtain an automatic 90-day extension under section 766.104(2) to complete the investigation.
Under section 766.106(4), mailing the notice by one of the first three methods tolls the statute of limitations as to all prospective defendants for the 90-day period. If a process server is used, tolling starts at the first attempt to serve. The parties may stipulate to extend the 90 days, and tolling continues during the extension. If negotiations end during an extension, the claimant has 60 days or the rest of the limitations period, whichever is longer, to file suit.
Section 766.104(2) gives one more period. On petition to the clerk of court and payment of a filing fee, the claimant receives an automatic 90-day extension of the statute of limitations to complete the reasonable investigation.
In Brundage the timing decided the case. Etta Evans died in June 2014 after a colostomy reversal at a St. Petersburg hospital. The personal representative requested the hospital records in November 2014 and received the full set in April 2016. On September 23, 2016, counsel sent the notice of intent without an expert opinion, asked that the corroboration requirement be waived, and filed the complaint the same day. An opinion obtained on September 28, 2016 reached the defendants only at a hearing on August 23, 2017, after the limitations period had run.
What if the provider does not produce the medical records?
Records must be produced within 10 business days of a request under section 766.204. Failure to produce, or an unreasonable charge, is evidence of bad faith and waives the corroboration requirement for the party that asked.
Section 766.204(1) requires copies of relevant medical records within 10 business days of a request, at a reasonable charge. An independent special hospital district with taxing authority that owns two or more hospitals has 20 days. Records may not be withheld because they are incomplete or because a bill is unpaid.
Under section 766.204(2), failure to provide the records, or a demand for an unreasonable fee, is evidence of failure to comply with good faith discovery requirements and waives the requirement of written medical corroboration by the requesting party. Section 766.205(3) applies the same consequence to a party that does not give reasonable access to information during presuit discovery.
The waiver is narrow. In Brundage the trial court found that the defense waived the expert opinion requirement by answering an informal discovery request late. The Second District quashed that order on certiorari in March 2020. Informal discovery under section 766.106(6) begins only after a valid notice of intent, and the waiver of section 766.204(2) applies to presuit requests for medical records, which the claimant had not made to that physician. A late response "cannot cure the omission of a prerequisite to maintaining the cause of action in the first place."
What happens if the court finds the presuit investigation unreasonable?
The court dismisses the claim or strikes the defense, the side at fault pays the other side's fees and costs, the attorney is referred to The Florida Bar, and an unqualified expert is reported to the state.
Section 766.206(1) lets any party move the court to determine whether the opposing party's claim or denial rests on a reasonable basis. If the notice of intent does not comply with the reasonable investigation requirements, including review of the claim and a verified written expert opinion, the court shall dismiss the claim, and the claimant or the attorney who mailed the notice is personally liable for the defendant's attorney's fees and costs of investigating and evaluating the claim (section 766.206(2)). A noncomplying rejection by the defense leads the court to strike the defendant's pleading, with the same liability for the claimant's fees and costs (section 766.206(3)).
Section 766.206(4) requires the court to refer an attorney who sent a notice or a rejection without a reasonable investigation to The Florida Bar. An attorney reported three or more times within 5 years goes to a circuit grievance committee.
The expert's exposure is in section 766.206(5). If the court finds that a corroborating opinion was not based on a reasonable investigation, or that the expert did not meet the qualifications of section 766.102(5), the court must report the expert to the Division of Medical Quality Assurance or its designee; for a nonresident expert, the report is forwarded to the expert's home licensing authority. The court must refuse to consider the testimony or opinion of an expert disqualified three times under section 766.206.
Section 766.106(7) adds a separate sanction: if any party fails to cooperate in the presuit investigation, the court may strike that party's claim or defense in the later suit.
How does IAE find a presuit expert for a Florida claim?
Choose the case type Medical malpractice and write Florida and the court in the State and court field. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.
The IAE medical malpractice expert witness page names surgeons, obstetricians, anesthesiologists, emergency physicians, nurses and geriatricians among six medical malpractice specialties, and IAE matches the expert to the defendant's specialty and the state's requirements. Its answer on the first expert opinion reads: in Florida, before suit, a verified written medical expert opinion goes out with the notice of intent to initiate litigation (s. 766.203(2)). The same page notes that an expert against a Florida physician needs a Florida license or an expert witness certificate under section 458.3175.
The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties with their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. For a presuit opinion the deadline field can carry the date by which the notice of intent must go out, and the description can name the defendant's specialty and board certification, since section 766.102(5) ties the expert to them. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.
Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that specialty by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. Candidate names and CVs come after the $2,000 search fee is paid in advance. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee.
The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, and the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- Florida Statutes 2025, chapter 766, Medical Malpractice and Related Matters: sections 766.102, 766.104, 766.106, 766.202, 766.203, 766.204, 766.205, 766.206 (The Florida Senate)
- Brundage v. Evans, No. 2D19-1441 (Fla. 2d DCA Mar. 18, 2020)
- Apostolico v. Orlando Regional Health Care System, Inc., No. 5D03-1505 (Fla. 5th DCA Mar. 26, 2004)
- Dontineni v. Sanderson, No. 5D21-2956 (Fla. 5th DCA July 1, 2022)
Read also
All articles
New Jersey affidavit of merit in medical malpractice: who may sign it, and what happens when the 120 days run out?
In New Jersey a malpractice plaintiff has 60 days after each defendant's answer to serve an affidavit of an appropriate licensed person
Pennsylvania certificate of merit in medical malpractice: what must the expert's written statement say?
In Pennsylvania a malpractice claim against a physician needs a certificate of merit within 60 days after the complaint is filed. The certificate
New York medical malpractice expert: what do the certificate of merit and CPLR 3101(d) require?
A New York medical malpractice complaint is filed with a certificate in which the plaintiff's attorney declares that he or she consulted at least oneExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

