Expert witnesses

New York medical malpractice expert: what do the certificate of merit and CPLR 3101(d) require?

A New York medical malpractice complaint is filed with a certificate in which the plaintiff's attorney declares that he or she consulted at least one physician and found a reasonable basis for the action. That is CPLR 3012-a. Later, under CPLR 3101(d)(1)(i), each side discloses what its experts will say, but in malpractice cases it may withhold their names. Expert depositions happen only by mutual offer or by court order on special circumstances.

A physician from behind slides a short certificate into a court folder beside a stethoscope

What does the New York certificate of merit require?

Under CPLR 3012-a(a)(1), the plaintiff's attorney certifies that he or she reviewed the facts, consulted at least one physician licensed in New York or any other state and concluded there is a reasonable basis for the action.

Section 3012-a of the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules applies to actions for medical, dental and podiatric malpractice. The complaint must be accompanied by a certificate executed by the attorney for the plaintiff. Under paragraph (a)(1), the attorney declares that he or she has reviewed the facts of the case, has consulted with at least one physician, dentist or podiatrist licensed in New York or any other state whom the attorney reasonably believes to be knowledgeable in the relevant issues, and has concluded on the basis of that review and consultation that there is a reasonable basis for the action.

The certificate is signed by the attorney, not by the physician. The consulted physician does not have to be licensed in New York, and the statute asks only that the attorney reasonably believe the physician knowledgeable in the issues involved.

Under subdivision (b), a single certificate is filed for each action, even if more than one defendant is named or defendants are added later. Subdivision (f) excludes plaintiffs who are not represented by an attorney.

What if the attorney could not consult a physician before filing?

Two alternatives exist. If the statute of limitations would run first, the certificate is filed within 90 days after service of the complaint. If three physicians in good faith declined to consult, the attorney certifies those three attempts.

Paragraph (a)(2) of CPLR 3012-a covers the deadline problem. If the attorney was unable to obtain the consultation because a limitation of time would bar the action, the certificate must be filed within ninety days after service of the complaint.

Paragraph (a)(3) covers refusals. The attorney certifies that he or she made three separate good faith attempts with three separate physicians, dentists or podiatrists to obtain a consultation, and that none of them would agree. Under subdivision (e), on a defendant's request made before the plaintiff complies with section 3101, the court may require the attorney to divulge to the court the names of those who refused.

Subdivision (d) addresses records. If the plaintiff has requested the relevant treatment records from a defendant and they have not been produced, the certificate is not required until ninety days after the records have been produced. An attorney who has asked for the chart and is waiting for it therefore has a statutory path to file without the consultation.

Is a certificate needed in a res ipsa loquitur case?

No certificate of consultation. Under CPLR 3012-a(c), if the attorney intends to rely solely on res ipsa loquitur, the attorney files a certificate stating that reliance instead.

Subdivision (c) of CPLR 3012-a provides that where the attorney intends to rely solely on the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, the certificate of consultation is not required. The attorney files a certificate stating that he or she is relying solely on that doctrine and, for that reason, is not filing a certificate under the section.

The word solely matters. A complaint that alleges a retained instrument and also a departure in the postoperative care relies on more than res ipsa loquitur for the second theory, and the second theory needs the consultation.

The doctrine also affects the limitations period. Under CPLR 214-a, a claim based on a foreign object left in the body may be brought within one year of its discovery, and the statute excludes a chemical compound, a fixation device and a prosthetic aid or device from the term foreign object.

Does the consulted physician's name have to be disclosed?

Generally not. Under CPLR 3012-a(e), the attorney and the consulted physician are not required to disclose the physician's identity or the substance of the consultation, subject to CPLR 3101.

Subdivision (e) of CPLR 3012-a states that, except as provided in section 3101, the attorney and the consulted physician, dentist or podiatrist are not required to disclose the identity of the physician consulted or the facts or opinions of that physician. The certificate itself says that the consultation took place and what the attorney concluded.

The exception for refusals under paragraph (a)(3) is the one described above: on a timely request by a defendant, the court may require the attorney to divulge to the court the names of the providers who declined.

Subdivision (g) gives the plaintiff another option. In lieu of serving the certificate, the plaintiff may provide the defendant with the information required by CPLR 3101(d)(1)(i) within the same period. That information is the expert disclosure itself, so a plaintiff who already has a retained expert can serve the disclosure instead of the certificate.

What must be disclosed about a medical expert under CPLR 3101(d)?

On request, each party identifies its trial experts and discloses in reasonable detail the subject matter, the substance of the facts and opinions, the qualifications and a summary of the grounds. In malpractice actions the names may be omitted.

CPLR 3101(d)(1)(i) requires each party, upon request, to identify each person it expects to call as an expert witness at trial and to disclose in reasonable detail the subject matter on which the expert is expected to testify, the substance of the facts and opinions on which the expert is expected to testify, the qualifications of each expert and a summary of the grounds for each expert's opinion.

For medical, dental and podiatric malpractice the same paragraph contains a proviso: a party may omit the names of medical, dental or podiatric experts, but is required to disclose all other information concerning them. The opposing side therefore learns the expert's specialty, training and the substance of the opinions, but not who the expert is.

The paragraph also addresses late retention. If, for good cause shown, a party retains an expert an insufficient period of time before trial to give appropriate notice, the party is not for that reason alone precluded from introducing the testimony, and the court may make whatever order is just. This is a different rule from the federal one, where Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a written report signed by the expert.

Can the opposing medical expert be deposed in New York?

Only by agreement under CPLR 3101(d)(1)(ii) or by court order on special circumstances under (d)(1)(iii). If all parties accept the offer, each must produce its experts.

CPLR 3101(d)(1)(ii) lets a party in a medical, dental or podiatric malpractice action serve and file a written offer to disclose the names of, and make available for oral deposition, the experts it expects to call. The other parties have twenty days to accept or reject in writing, and failure to respond is deemed a rejection.

If all parties accept, each must produce its experts for deposition when noticed. A party that made or accepted the offer and then fails to produce an expert is precluded from offering expert testimony at the trial.

Without such an agreement, further disclosure about an expert's expected testimony may be obtained only by court order upon a showing of special circumstances, under CPLR 3101(d)(1)(iii), with limits the court may set on scope, fees and expenses. Under the same paragraph, a party may take the testimony of its own treating or retained expert without a court order, and the other parties are then entitled to full disclosure about that expert.

Does New York require the expert to share the defendant's specialty?

Not in the current text of CPLR 3101(d). Bills that would have added same-profession and same-board-certification requirements, S7159 of the 2009-2010 session and A5465 of 2011, were referred to committee and not enacted.

The current text of CPLR 3101(d)(1)(i) asks for the qualifications of each expert but sets no specialty test. Florida, by contrast, writes such rules into section 766.102(5) of its statutes: an expert against a specialist must practice the same specialty and have devoted professional time to it in the 3 years before the occurrence.

Senate bill S7159 of the 2009-2010 session, introduced on March 17, 2010, would have required a malpractice expert to be licensed in the same profession as the defendant, to be actively engaged in clinical practice or teaching and, if the defendant is board certified, to be certified in the same specialty. It would also have removed the rule allowing names to be withheld and required expert reports and depositions. It was referred to the Codes Committee the same day, and its record shows no further action. Assembly bill A5465 of 2011 proposed the same qualification rule as an amendment to CPLR 3101(d)(1)(i) and was referred to the Committee on Codes on February 22, 2011.

Under the current text, the court decides the qualification question case by case. The disclosure under 3101(d)(1)(i) states the expert's specialty and training, and the other side tests whether that background supports each opinion.

How long does a patient have to sue for malpractice in New York?

Two years and six months from the act or omission, or from the last continuous treatment, under CPLR 214-a. Foreign object claims run one year from discovery; missed cancer has a discovery rule capped at seven years.

CPLR 214-a sets a period of two years and six months of the act, omission or failure complained of, or of the last treatment where there is continuous treatment for the same illness, injury or condition. Continuous treatment does not include examinations undertaken at the patient's request for the sole purpose of ascertaining the state of the patient's condition.

For a foreign object left in the body, the action may be commenced within one year of the date of discovery or of the date of discovery of facts that would reasonably lead to discovery, whichever is earlier.

For a failure to diagnose cancer or a malignant tumor, the period runs from the later of the date the person knew or reasonably should have known of the negligent act or omission and that it caused injury, or the last treatment in a continuous course; but the action must be commenced no later than seven years after the act or omission. The Senate site dates the latest revision of the section February 2, 2018.

These dates drive the certificate. An attorney who receives the case close to the deadline uses the 90-day alternative of CPLR 3012-a(a)(2) and files the certificate after the complaint is served.

How does IAE find a medical expert for a New York case?

Choose the case type Medical malpractice and write New York and the court in the State and court field. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

The IAE medical malpractice expert witness page names surgeons, obstetricians, anesthesiologists, emergency physicians, nurses and geriatricians among six medical malpractice specialties, and IAE matches the expert to the defendant's specialty and the state's requirements. The page notes that specialty rules and the deadline for the first expert opinion differ by state, so the request names the state and the court.

The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties with their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. For a New York certificate of merit the description can say that a consultation under CPLR 3012-a is needed before filing; for trial the deadline field can carry the date set for 3101(d) disclosure. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.

Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that specialty by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. Candidate names and CVs come after the $2,000 search fee is paid in advance. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee.

The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, and the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case