Expert witnesses

New Jersey affidavit of merit in medical malpractice: who may sign it, and what happens when the 120 days run out?

In New Jersey a malpractice plaintiff has 60 days after each defendant's answer to serve an affidavit of an appropriate licensed person, and the court may add one period of up to 60 days. For a physician defendant the affiant must match the defendant's specialty under N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-41. A missing affidavit is treated as a failure to state a cause of action.

Hands rest a one-page affidavit on a thick chart as a soft clock hangs on the wall

What is the New Jersey affidavit of merit?

A sworn statement of an appropriate licensed person that there is a reasonable probability that the care, skill or knowledge shown in the treatment at issue fell outside acceptable professional standards. The plaintiff serves it on each defendant.

The requirement is in N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27, enacted in 1995 and amended in 2004. It applies in "any action for damages for personal injuries, wrongful death or property damage" resulting "from an alleged act of malpractice or negligence by a licensed person in his profession or occupation."

The affiant states that "there exists a reasonable probability that the care, skill or knowledge exercised or exhibited in the treatment, practice or work that is the subject of the complaint, fell outside acceptable professional or occupational standards or treatment practices."

The New Jersey Supreme Court described the purpose in Wiggins v. Hackensack Meridian Health, decided January 22, 2025: the statute has two aims, to weed out frivolous suits early and to let meritorious claims be heard.

The affidavit is a threshold document. It does not replace the expert report and the trial testimony that prove the standard of care, the deviation and causation later in the case.

When is the affidavit due?

Within 60 days following the filing of the defendant's answer. On a finding of good cause the court may grant one additional period of no more than 60 days, so the outer limit is 120 days per defendant.

Section 2A:53A-27 states that the plaintiff shall provide the affidavit "within 60 days following the date of filing of the answer to the complaint by the defendant." The same sentence says the plaintiff provides it to "each defendant," so in a case with several defendants the period is counted separately for each one, starting with that defendant's own answer.

The extension is limited by the text: "The court may grant no more than one additional period, not to exceed 60 days, to file the affidavit pursuant to this section, upon a finding of good cause."

The clock starts with the answer, not with the complaint. That differs from the Delaware statute discussed below, which required the affidavit to accompany the complaint. Sixty days from the answer is the whole period for locating a physician of the right specialty, sending the records and obtaining a signed affidavit, unless the court adds the second 60 days.

Who may sign the affidavit against a physician?

A physician or other health care professional licensed in the United States who meets N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-41. If the defendant is a specialist and the care involved that specialty, the affiant must have specialized in it when the events occurred.

For medical malpractice, section 2A:53A-27 refers to the expert qualification statute: the person executing the affidavit "shall meet the requirements of a person who provides expert testimony or executes an affidavit" under section 2A:53A-41. The same person may later testify, since 2A:53A-41 sets one standard for the affidavit and for trial.

Section 2A:53A-41 opens with a licensing rule. A person shall not give expert testimony or execute an affidavit "unless the person is licensed as a physician or other health care professional in the United States." A New Jersey license is not required. Assembly Bill No. 906, pre-filed for the 2026 session of the New Jersey Legislature, proposes to replace the words "United States" in that sentence with "State of New Jersey." The text on the Legislature's site is the bill as introduced, with the status "Introduced Pending Technical Review by Legislative Counsel," and its history line for section 2A:53A-41 cites only the 2004 act that created the section.

Subsection a. applies when the defendant is "a specialist or subspecialist recognized by the American Board of Medical Specialties or the American Osteopathic Association" and the care at issue involves that specialty. The expert then "shall have specialized at the time of the occurrence" in the same specialty or subspecialty. In Wiggins the Supreme Court called this the kind-for-kind rule: the challenging expert must be equivalently qualified to the defendant.

Section 2A:53A-27 adds a condition of independence: the affiant "shall have no financial interest in the outcome of the case under review, but this prohibition shall not exclude the person from being an expert witness in the case."

What more is required when the defendant is board certified?

The affiant must be either a physician credentialed by a hospital to treat the condition or perform the procedure, or board certified in the same specialty with most professional time in practice or teaching during the preceding year.

If the defendant "is board certified" and the care involves that board specialty, subsection a. of 2A:53A-41 gives two routes. Under paragraph (1) the expert is "a physician credentialed by a hospital to treat patients for the medical condition, or to perform the procedure" that is the basis for the claim.

Under paragraph (2) the expert is a specialist "who is board certified in the same specialty or subspecialty" and who, "during the year immediately preceding the date of the occurrence that is the basis for the claim or action," devoted "a majority of his professional time" to one of two activities or to both. The first is "the active clinical practice of the same health care profession in which the defendant is licensed." The second is "the instruction of students in an accredited medical school" or other accredited health professional school.

The year is counted back from the date of the occurrence, not from the date of the affidavit. As paragraph (2) is written, a physician who left clinical practice and teaching two years before the treatment in question does not meet it, whatever the length of the earlier career.

What if the defendant physician practices in two specialties?

One matching affidavit is enough. In Wiggins (2025) the Supreme Court held that when the treatment falls within either of the defendant's specialties, an affidavit of a physician specializing in one of them satisfies the statutes.

The plaintiffs in Wiggins were the administrators of the estate of April Carden. They alleged that in 2016 she had a severe allergic reaction, later diagnosed as Stevens-Johnson syndrome, and that Dr. Alok Goyal had prescribed allopurinol, which was contraindicated and caused her death. Dr. Goyal was board certified in internal medicine and in the subspecialty of gastroenterology. His answer stated that the treatment involved both.

The plaintiffs served an affidavit of Dr. Stella Jones Fitzgibbons, who is board certified by the American Board of Internal Medicine and not in gastroenterology. The trial court denied the motions to dismiss. The Appellate Division reversed and required an affidavit of a physician board certified in each of the defendant's specialties.

The Supreme Court reversed in a unanimous opinion by Justice Fasciale (A-43-23). It held: "an AOM from a physician specializing in one of those specialties is sufficient under the statutes." The Court relied on its earlier statement in Buck v. Henry, 207 N.J. 377 (2011), that an affidavit of a physician specializing in either area will suffice, and held that this statement was binding guidance and not dicta. It also read the singular words "specialty or subspecialty" in 2A:53A-41. The Court added that the plaintiffs still have to prove professional negligence at trial.

How does the plaintiff learn which specialty to match?

The defendant must say so. Under Rule 4:5-3 a physician's answer states the field of medicine in which he or she specialized and whether the treatment involved it. A case management conference follows within 90 days of the answer.

As Wiggins describes it, Rule 4:5-3 requires that a physician defending a malpractice claim "must include in his or her answer the field of medicine in which he or she specialized at that time," and state whether the treatment involved that specialty. Buck v. Henry had directed defendants to state their specialty in the answer; the defendant in that case was board certified in emergency medicine but practiced family medicine.

The second safeguard is the conference named after Ferreira v. Rancocas Orthopedic Associates, 178 N.J. 144 (2003). The trial court holds a case management conference "within ninety days of the service of an answer" to address compliance with the affidavit statute. Wiggins describes the conference as addressing discovery issues and compliance with the affidavit statute and case law. Ninety days from the answer falls before the 120-day outer limit.

For plaintiff's counsel the statutes and the rule give a sequence: read the specialty statement in each answer when it arrives, compare it with the affiant's certification and practice in the year before the treatment, and replace the affiant within the period if they do not match.

Can the court waive the same-specialty requirement?

Yes, on motion. Under 2A:53A-41(c) the moving party shows a good faith effort to identify an expert in the same specialty, and the court decides whether the proposed expert has sufficient training, experience and knowledge.

Subsection c. provides that a court "may waive the same specialty or subspecialty" requirement "upon motion by the party seeking a waiver." The moving party must first show the court "that a good faith effort has been made to identify an expert in the same specialty," and the court then determines that the expert "possesses sufficient training, experience and knowledge" to testify.

A record of the search can serve as the evidence of good faith for that motion: whom counsel contacted, in which specialty, when, and why each declined.

A separate rule covers a defendant who is a general practitioner. Under subsection b. the expert, in the year before the occurrence, must have devoted a majority of professional time to "active clinical practice as a general practitioner," to "active clinical practice that encompasses the medical condition, or that includes performance of the procedure" at issue, to teaching, or to a combination.

What if the defendant has not produced the medical records?

The plaintiff may serve a sworn statement in lieu of the affidavit under N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-28, stating that records with a substantial bearing on the affidavit were requested in writing and at least 45 days have passed.

Section 2A:53A-28 provides that an affidavit "shall not be required" if the plaintiff provides a sworn statement setting out three facts. The defendant has failed to provide "medical records or other records or information having a substantial bearing on preparation of the affidavit." A written request, with a signed authorization for release if necessary, "has been made by certified mail or personal service." And "at least 45 days have elapsed since the defendant received the request."

The 45 days inside a 60-day period leave little margin. A request sent with the complaint, or before it, keeps this route open.

What happens if the affidavit is missing or defective?

Under N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-29 the failure is deemed a failure to state a cause of action. The Supreme Court in Wiggins described the result as dismissal with prejudice once the 120 days pass.

Section 2A:53A-29 is one sentence: if the plaintiff fails to provide an affidavit or a statement in lieu of it, "it shall be deemed a failure to state a cause of action." Wiggins restates the effect: a failure to serve within 120 days is "tantamount to the failure to state a cause of action" and subjects the complaint to dismissal with prejudice.

Three other provisions of 2A:53A-41 affect the choice of expert. Subsection e. states: "In an action alleging medical malpractice, an expert witness shall not testify on a contingency fee basis." Subsection f. makes a person who retaliates against someone for providing or agreeing to provide expert testimony "liable to a civil penalty not to exceed $10,000" and other damages. Subsection d. preserves the trial court's power to disqualify an expert on grounds other than the statutory qualifications.

Does the statute cover nurses, hospitals and other professionals?

Yes. N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-26 lists licensed persons, 17 kinds in the text checked, among them physicians, dentists, registered professional nurses, health care facilities, pharmacists and physical therapists. Outside medical malpractice the affiant needs board certification or five years of practice.

In the text of 2A:53A-26 published by Justia (2023 edition) and by FindLaw (current as of January 1, 2024) the list runs through the letter q.: accountants, architects, attorneys, dentists, engineers, physicians, podiatrists, chiropractors, registered professional nurses, health care facilities, physical therapists, land surveyors, registered pharmacists, veterinarians, insurance producers, certified midwives and licensed site remediation professionals. The history line of the section records amendments in 2001, 2010 and 2019.

For actions other than medical malpractice, 2A:53A-27 sets a different standard for the affiant. The person must "be licensed in this or any other state" and "have particular expertise in the general area or specialty involved in the action, as evidenced by board certification or by devotion of the person's practice substantially to the general area or specialty involved in the action for a period of at least five years."

Because 2A:53A-27 requires the plaintiff to provide the affidavit to each defendant, in a complaint against two physicians and a hospital each of the three defendants has to be provided with an affidavit.

Does the requirement apply in federal court after Berk v. Choy?

The Supreme Court held on January 20, 2026 that Delaware's affidavit of merit law does not apply in federal court. The opinion does not mention New Jersey's statute, so counsel filing in federal court must check current decisions there.

In Berk v. Choy, No. 24-440, Justice Barrett wrote the opinion of the Court, joined by seven other Justices: "We consider whether Delaware's affidavit requirement applies in federal court and hold that it does not." Justice Jackson concurred in the judgment. The Court reasoned that Rule 8 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure governs what a plaintiff must provide at the outset: "Rule 8 sets a ceiling on the information that plaintiffs can be required to provide." Under Rule 8 factual allegations suffice, while the Delaware law required evidence as well.

The Delaware statute, 18 Del. C. 6853, differs in mechanics. It required the affidavit to accompany the complaint and directed the clerk to refuse the filing without it. New Jersey's affidavit is due after the answer, and its absence is "deemed a failure to state a cause of action." Berk reversed a Third Circuit decision that had applied the Delaware statute in a diversity case, and the opinion does not discuss New Jersey law.

The deadlines described above are those of the New Jersey statute. Whether a federal court will enforce them after Berk is a question the opinion does not answer, because it addresses only the Delaware law.

How does IAE find a physician for a New Jersey affidavit of merit?

Choose the case type Medical malpractice and write New Jersey and the court in the State and court field. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

The IAE medical malpractice expert witness page names surgeons, obstetricians, anesthesiologists, emergency physicians, nurses and geriatricians among six specialties, and IAE matches the expert to the defendant's specialty and the state's requirements. The page notes that specialty rules and the deadline for the first expert opinion differ by state, so the request names the state and the court.

The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties with their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. For a New Jersey case the description can give the specialty stated in the defendant's answer, the date of the treatment and the date the answer was filed, so the 60-day period and the look-back year are visible. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.

Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that specialty by the deadline. The search is paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee.

The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy, the affidavit and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case