Examinations

Forensic accounting vs auditing: what is the difference, and which one does a court case need?

An auditor tells the readers of financial statements whether the statements as a whole are free of material misstatement, and does so with reasonable assurance, not certainty. A forensic accountant answers the questions of a dispute or an investigation: how much was lost, where the money went, what the books showed on a given date. The two jobs follow different standards, and an audit opinion does not answer a court's questions.

Two people from behind compare a bound statement with a box of receipts

What is the difference between an audit and forensic accounting?

An audit ends in an opinion on whether financial statements are free of material misstatement. Forensic accounting answers specific questions in litigation or an investigation, for a judge, a jury or a regulator.

The audit standard of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, AS 1015, describes the auditor's goal in two sentences. The auditor obtains "reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement," and "the independent auditor's objective is to obtain sufficient appropriate evidential matter" to support an opinion. The same paragraph adds that in most cases the auditor relies on evidence that is "persuasive rather than convincing."

Forensic work starts from a different question. The AICPA adopted Statement on Standards for Forensic Services No. 1 (SSFS No. 1) for engagements accepted on or after January 1, 2020. As the Journal of Accountancy reported on September 1, 2019, the standard covers two kinds of engagements. "Investigation is a service performed in response to concerns of wrongdoing." "Litigation is an actual or potential legal or regulatory proceeding before a trier of fact or a regulatory body."

So the audit looks at a whole set of statements for a reporting period and asks whether a reader can rely on them. A forensic engagement looks at the transactions, accounts and dates that a lawsuit or an investigation puts in issue. A forensic accountant who must trace a payment or compute lost profits works from the records behind each figure he reports.

The audience differs too. The forensic accountant in litigation works for a party or its counsel, and the other side tests his opinion in deposition and at trial.

Why can an audit miss a fraud?

Because an audit gives reasonable, not absolute, assurance. AS 1015 states that absolute assurance is not attainable because of the nature of audit evidence and the characteristics of fraud.

AS 1015 is direct about the limits. "Absolute assurance is not attainable because of the nature of audit evidence and the characteristics of fraud." Paragraph .12 continues: "Because of the characteristics of fraud, a properly planned and performed audit may not detect a material misstatement."

The standard names two reasons. Collusion can lead an auditor to "conclude that evidence provided is persuasive" when it is false. And "management has the ability to directly or indirectly manipulate accounting records," including by overriding controls.

Paragraph .13 then closes the point: "The auditor is not an insurer and his or her report does not constitute a guarantee." A misstatement discovered later does not by itself prove that the auditor failed to obtain reasonable assurance.

For a party in a lawsuit this means a clean audit report on the year in which money disappeared is not evidence that nothing disappeared. The auditor tested whether the statements as a whole were materially right. Whether a specific transfer to a specific person was authorized is a question the audit may never have asked.

Does a forensic accountant decide whether fraud occurred?

No. SSFS No. 1 bars AICPA members from opining on the occurrence of fraud. The accountant reports what the records show, and the judge or jury decides whether the conduct was fraud.

The Journal of Accountancy summary of SSFS No. 1 lists among its requirements "prohibitions on opining on the occurrence of fraud." Fraud is a legal conclusion about intent. The accountant can document that an invoice has no matching delivery, that the same vendor's bank account belongs to an employee, or that cash receipts were recorded days after deposit, and leave the label to the trier of fact.

Federal Rule of Evidence 702 sets the frame for that testimony. A witness qualified by "knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education" may give an opinion if the expert's specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or determine a fact in issue, the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and the principles and methods are reliably applied to the facts of the case.

Since the amendment of December 1, 2023, the party offering the expert has to establish each of these conditions to the court as more likely than not. The committee note states that "the preponderance standard applies to the three reliability-based requirements added in 2000."

Which professional standards govern each engagement?

Audits follow auditing standards such as PCAOB AS 1015 on due professional care. Litigation and investigation work by AICPA members follows SSFS No. 1 for engagements accepted from January 1, 2020.

AS 1015 asks the auditor to exercise professional skepticism, which the standard describes as a questioning mind and a critical assessment of audit evidence. Paragraph .09 says the auditor should neither assume that management is dishonest nor assume unquestioned honesty.

SSFS No. 1, as the Journal of Accountancy describes it, applies "to all AICPA members, AICPA member firms, and employees of AICPA member firms." Early adoption was permitted. Beyond the bar on opinions about fraud, it prohibits "performing certain forensic services for a contingent fee."

A forensic accountant who is not an AICPA member is not bound by SSFS No. 1 as a professional rule, but Rule 702 still applies to his testimony in federal court, and the other side can ask in deposition which standard he followed.

Can the company's own auditor testify as its forensic accountant?

Not for a public audit client without losing independence. SEC Rule 2-01 of Regulation S-X treats an expert service advocating an audit client's interests in litigation as impairing the auditor's independence.

The SEC independence rule, 17 CFR 210.2-01, lists non-audit services that impair independence. Paragraph (c)(4)(x), headed "Expert services unrelated to the audit," covers "providing an expert opinion or other expert service for an audit client, or an audit client's legal representative, for the purpose of advocating an audit client's interests in litigation or in a regulatory or administrative proceeding or investigation."

The same paragraph keeps one door open. Independence "shall not be deemed to be impaired if the accountant provides factual accounts, including in testimony, of work performed or explains the positions taken or conclusions reached during the performance of any service provided by the accountant for the audit client." The auditor can describe the audit. He cannot become the company's advocate on damages.

The preliminary note to the rule explains the logic through four questions. The Commission asks whether a service creates a mutual or conflicting interest, places the accountant in the position of auditing his or her own work, results in the accountant acting as management or an employee, or "places the accountant in a position of being an advocate for the audit client."

For the other side, the rule is a line of cross-examination. An auditor who signed the statements now in dispute is testifying about his own work, and Rule 2-01 names that position as one of the four tests of independence.

Does a clean audit opinion prove that the company was solvent?

No. In the Revstone Industries bankruptcy the court held in 2019 that an audit opinion without a going concern statement was not enough to rebut an expert's detailed findings of insolvency.

On January 10, 2019, Judge Brendan Linehan Shannon of the Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware decided an adversary proceeding that the trustee in the Revstone Industries bankruptcy brought against AMI Morton Fabrication (No. 14-50979). The trustee's expert, Mr. Lukenda, concluded that Revstone was insolvent when value was transferred.

The defendant argued that the 2010 audit opinion lacked a statement of substantial doubt about Revstone's ability to continue as a going concern, so a reasonable jury could find Revstone solvent. The court was "not persuaded." It wrote that "the fact that an Audit Opinion lacks a going concern statement is not sufficient to rebut the detailed and specific findings in the Lukenda Report," and added that even if Revstone had a going concern value at the time of the transfers, "it does not necessarily follow that Revstone was solvent."

The court found Mr. Lukenda qualified to perform the analysis and found that he applied generally accepted methodologies, relying on values paid for the assets and on values that independent auditors had assigned to them. The court assigned little weight to two lay declarations that gave a dollar value without explanation or supporting evidence, and granted summary judgment to the trustee on insolvency.

The audit report did play a part: the expert used values the auditors had assigned. It did not answer the legal question of solvency on the transfer dates.

What does a forensic accountant give the court that an audit report does not?

A report written for the case. Under FRCP 26(a)(2)(B) it states every opinion with its basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications, prior testimony and compensation.

A retained expert in federal court discloses a written report "prepared and signed by the witness." Rule 26(a)(2)(B) lists six items: "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them"; "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them"; "any exhibits that will be used to summarize or support them"; the witness's qualifications, "including a list of all publications authored in the previous 10 years"; a list of cases in which, during the previous 4 years, the witness testified as an expert at trial or by deposition; and "a statement of the compensation to be paid for the study and testimony in the case."

The 1993 committee note says the report is "intended to set forth the substance of the direct examination." An audit opinion is written for another purpose. Under AS 1015 it rests on reasonable assurance about the financial statements, and it lists none of these six items.

Once the report is served, the other side may depose the expert (Rule 26(b)(4)(A)). Communications between counsel and the expert are protected, except those about compensation, facts or data counsel provided and the expert considered, and assumptions counsel provided and the expert relied on (Rule 26(b)(4)(C)).

When does a dispute need a forensic accountant rather than an auditor?

When the case asks about particular transactions, dates or amounts: a damages figure, a tracing of funds, the debtor's condition on a transfer date. An audit opinion speaks to the statements of a reporting period.

Partners who suspect that one of them diverted revenue need the deposits traced to the ledger and the ledger to the tax returns, entry by entry. A buyer who claims that the seller inflated earnings needs the adjustments rebuilt and the effect on the price computed. A trustee who sues over a transfer needs the balance sheet as of the day of that transfer.

In each case the audit can still be a source. The forensic accountant may use the audited statements and, if they are produced in discovery, the auditor's workpapers, and the auditor may give a factual account of the work under the SEC rule quoted above. The opinion itself answers a question nobody in the lawsuit asked.

The 2000 committee note to Rule 702 adds a point about experience. Nothing in the rule suggests that experience alone may not provide a sufficient foundation, but a witness "relying solely or primarily on experience" must explain how that experience leads to the conclusion, why it is a sufficient basis, and how it is reliably applied to the facts. A former auditor who testifies as a forensic accountant answers those three questions about the method of the forensic work, not about years of audits.

What does IAE do when a case needs forensic accounting work?

A forensic accountant from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing expert's damages report, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE forensic accounting page lists three groups of questions. On solvency, the expert measures value received against value given and tests solvency on each transfer date. On tracing, the expert follows funds between accounts through bank statements and ledgers. On damages, the expert rebuilds lost profits from ledgers and tax returns. The page covers commercial, bankruptcy and partnership disputes.

The client sends the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member