Examinations

Freedom to operate analysis: what does it check, and what does it change if the product is later sued?

A freedom to operate analysis asks whether a product can be made and sold in a given country without infringing patents held by others. The analyst finds the patents and published applications that could cover the product, compares their claims with it element by element, and dates the conclusion. If the product is later sued, the analysis bears on willfulness, because Halo v. Pulse (2016) measures culpability by what the company knew when it acted.

An engineer from behind sets a small prototype beside a shelf of bound patents

What does a freedom to operate analysis answer?

Whether the planned product, made, used, sold or imported in a given country, would fall within a claim of a patent in force there. It is a question about other people's patents, country by country.

In the United States the acts are defined by 35 U.S.C. 271(a): "whoever without authority makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells any patented invention, within the United States or imports into the United States any patented invention during the term of the patent therefor, infringes the patent." The same acts appear on the other side of the grant in 35 U.S.C. 154(a)(1), which gives the patent owner "the right to exclude others from making, using, offering for sale, or selling the invention throughout the United States" and from importing it.

Two limits in that language define the analysis. The acts must happen within the United States, so a U.S. patent matters for products made, sold or imported there, and a separate review is needed for each other market. The acts must happen during the term of the patent, so expired patents drop out, while pending applications that may still issue stay in view.

The Russian national standard on patent research defines the same property for a technical object. GOST R 15.011-2024 calls patent clearance a legal property of an object, consisting in the fact that it can be used in a given country without infringing, on its territory, third-party rights in industrial property protected there. The standard took effect on March 1, 2024, replacing the 2022 version.

Which patents and applications does the analysis cover?

Patents in force in the target country, applications that are published and may still issue, and documents that have lapsed but can be restored. The term of each patent is computed from its filing date.

Under 35 U.S.C. 154(a)(2), a U.S. patent term ends "20 years from the date on which the application for the patent was filed in the United States." If the application refers to earlier applications under the listed sections, the term runs from "the date on which the earliest such application was filed." Section 154(b), headed "Adjustment of Patent Term," can extend that date, so the analyst reads the expiration date from the patent record instead of adding twenty years to the filing date.

Published applications count before they issue. Section 154(d)(1) gives the patent owner a right to obtain "a reasonable royalty from any person who" makes, uses, sells or imports the invention after the application is published, if that person "had actual notice of the published patent application." Under 154(d)(2), the right exists only if the invention as claimed in the patent is "substantially identical" to the invention as claimed in the published application. An application found in the search is therefore tracked until its claims are allowed.

The Russian standard lists the same categories. Section 5.7 of GOST R 15.011-2024 requires the search to consider national and regional patents, including Eurasian and European ones, international applications, and applications for which the possibility of claiming convention or exhibition priority has not been exhausted. Table 1 includes protective documents that have lapsed but whose rights can be restored.

How is it different from a patentability or invalidity search?

A patentability or invalidity search compares a claimed invention with the prior art. A freedom to operate analysis compares the company's own product with the claims of other people's patents. One product can pass the first and fail the second.

Patentability turns on 35 U.S.C. 103: a patent may not be obtained if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art would have made it obvious to a person of ordinary skill before the effective filing date. The question is whether the company's idea is new and non-obvious. Infringement turns on section 271: whether the product falls within someone else's claim.

The two questions are independent. A company can hold its own patent on an improvement and still infringe an earlier patent whose claims its product meets. The Russian Supreme Court described the same situation in paragraph 125 of Plenum Resolution No. 10 of April 23, 2019: if the defendant's independent claim contains all the features of the plaintiff's independent claim plus other features, the defendant's invention is dependent, and using the plaintiff's patent without consent can be infringement even if the defendant also uses its own patent. The same paragraph sets the opposite rule for two patents with different priority dates on identical inventions: until the later patent is invalidated, its owner's use is not infringement of the earlier one.

The Russian standard also keeps the types apart. GOST R 15.011-2024 lists four kinds of patent research in section 5.1: the state of the art and development trends, patentability, patent clearance, and targeted research. Clearance has its own tasks, its own search regulation and its own conclusion.

How is each patent compared with the product?

Claim by claim and element by element. The analyst reads each independent claim as a person of ordinary skill would, using the specification and prosecution history, then marks each element present or absent.

Claim meaning comes first. In InTouch Technologies, Inc. v. VGo Communications, Inc. (Fed. Cir. May 9, 2014), the court restated that "a claim term is given the ordinary and customary meaning as understood by a person of ordinary skill in the art," that the specification is "the single best guide to the meaning of a disputed term," and that "[a] court should also consider the patent's prosecution history, if it is in evidence."

The comparison then goes element by element. A chart lists each element of each independent claim, the part, material or step of the product that corresponds to it, and the drawing, specification or test that proves it. An element that the product lacks takes the claim out of play for that product, unless an equivalent is present; dependent claims are checked only where the independent claim is met.

The Russian standard describes the same step as a comparative analysis of the object with the identified protective documents, followed by an analysis of the likelihood of infringing third-party exclusive rights in the territory (Table 1). Russian law states the test in paragraph 123 of Plenum Resolution No. 10: an invention is used if the product contains each feature of the independent claim or an equivalent feature known as such in the field before the priority date.

What does a freedom to operate analysis change if the product is sued?

It bears on willfulness. Under Halo v. Pulse (2016), enhanced damages up to three times are reserved for egregious cases, and culpability is measured against what the infringer knew at the time of the conduct.

Section 284 of the Patent Act provides that the court "may increase the damages up to three times the amount found or assessed." In Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., decided on June 13, 2016, Chief Justice Roberts wrote for the Court that the Federal Circuit's earlier Seagate test was not consistent with section 284 and replaced it with the district court's discretion.

The Court described the conduct that can warrant enhancement as "willful, wanton, malicious, bad-faith, deliberate, consciously wrongful, flagrant," or characteristic of a pirate, and said such punishment "should generally be reserved for egregious cases typified by willful misconduct." It held that "culpability is generally measured against the knowledge of the actor at the time of the challenged conduct."

The Court also set the procedure. Enhancement is proved by a preponderance of the evidence, because "patent-infringement litigation has always been governed by a preponderance of the evidence standard," and the district court's decision "is to be reviewed on appeal for abuse of discretion."

A dated analysis records what the company knew and why it concluded that a claim was not met or not in force. It does not decide infringement, which the court decides on the full record; it is evidence of the company's state of mind when it launched.

Is a company required to obtain a freedom to operate opinion?

No. Under 35 U.S.C. 298, the failure to obtain advice of counsel, or to present it in court, may not be used to prove that the accused infringer infringed willfully or intended to induce infringement.

Section 298 reads: "The failure of an infringer to obtain the advice of counsel with respect to any allegedly infringed patent, or the failure of the infringer to present such advice to the court or jury, may not be used to prove that the accused infringer willfully infringed the patent or that the infringer intended to induce infringement of the patent."

The statute removes one inference: the absence of an opinion is not proof of willfulness. It does not make an analysis that was done irrelevant. A company that obtained an analysis decides whether to rely on it in litigation; if it does, the analysis and the facts behind it become part of the case.

For the analyst, this shapes the document. The report states the patents reviewed, the claims compared, the product version described, the sources used for each element and the date. A conclusion that can be traced to those materials is easier to defend than a short letter that names a patent and says it is not infringed.

How long does a freedom to operate conclusion hold?

Only as of its date. New patents issue, published applications change their claims and the product changes. The Russian standard requires the clearance conclusion to state the date up to which it holds.

Section 7.4 of GOST R 15.011-2024 requires the conclusion to state the date for which the finding of the research is current. The rule fits any jurisdiction, because the inputs keep moving.

In the United States, provisional rights under 154(d) can arise from a published application once its claims issue in substantially identical form. An update before launch and after design changes keeps the conclusion tied to the product that is actually sold.

The same applies to the product side. The analysis describes a specific version, with drawings, specifications or a bill of materials. If engineering changes a part that was the reason a claim element was absent, the conclusion for that claim has to be checked again.

What does the analyst need for the work?

A technical description of the product version, the target countries, the planned launch date, any patents already known, and the search regulation: databases, classification codes, keywords and search depth.

GOST R 15.011-2024 builds the search on a regulation (section 6.3 and Appendix B). It defines the object, the countries, the patent and non-patent databases, keywords, classification headings such as IPC and CPC, and the retrospective depth of the search. Under section 6.3.1, the list of countries is determined by the executor of the research. The regulation is signed by the executor and agreed with the person who drew up the research task (section 6.3.2).

The search report follows Appendix V of the standard, with tables for patent documents, scientific and technical documents, and components requested from suppliers. The full report follows GOST 7.32 and includes the task, the search regulation and the search report as mandatory appendices.

Components bought from suppliers are part of the picture. The standard's report form has a separate table for them, because a purchased module can carry a patent risk that the company's own design does not. Where the supplier's documentation is incomplete, the analyst records what was missing.

What does IAE do when a product needs to be checked against a patent?

An IAE expert prepares a report on whether the product meets each element of the identified patent claims, literally or by equivalents, and can assess the validity of a blocking patent over the prior art. Up to 5 business days.

The patent expertise page describes the infringement work as claim charts that map each claim element to the product, with equivalents tested element by element, and the validity work as a prior art search before the effective filing date with an obviousness analysis for a person of ordinary skill. For a freedom to operate question, the client names the patents found in the search or the competitor patents of concern, and the expert charts them against the product version.

IAE chooses the expert by the technical field of the patent and confirms the patent, the claims and the questions before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the expert from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Every expert is a member of the public IAE registry, verifiable by Member ID or QR code, and states in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that a court weighs with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not give legal opinions on infringement liability.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member