Examinations
Goods damaged in shipping: who bears the loss, and what does the expert establish?
When goods arrive damaged, three questions decide who pays: when the risk of loss passed to the buyer under UCC 2-509, whether the goods were already defective when they left the seller, which keeps the risk on the seller under 2-510, and whether the carrier is liable under the Carmack Amendment. The second and third questions are technical, and an expert answers them by reading the damage.

Who bears the loss when goods arrive damaged?
It depends on when the risk passed under the contract and UCC 2-509, on whether the seller's tender was nonconforming under 2-510, and on whether the carrier is liable for the damage under 49 U.S.C. 14706.
A damaged delivery can involve three parties with different exposure. The seller bears the loss if the risk had not yet passed to the buyer, or if the goods were nonconforming when tendered. The buyer bears it if the risk had passed and the goods were conforming when they left. The carrier answers to whoever holds the claim if the damage happened while the goods were in its hands and it has no defense.
These questions are linked. A buyer who bore the risk under 2-509 still has a claim against the carrier. A buyer who can show that the goods were defective before shipment shifts the risk back to the seller under 2-510, whatever the shipping terms said. A carrier sued for the damage will argue that the cause was the goods themselves, which is the defense of inherent vice.
Each argument turns on the same fact: when and how the damage happened. That is the question a goods expert answers, from the goods, the packaging and the shipping records.
When does the risk pass in a shipment contract?
When the goods are duly delivered to the carrier. Under UCC 2-509(1)(a), if the contract does not require the seller to deliver them at a particular destination, the risk passes to the buyer at that moment.
Section 2-509(1) covers contracts that require or authorize the seller to ship the goods by carrier. Under (1)(a), "if it does not require him to deliver them at a particular destination, the risk of loss passes to the buyer when the goods are duly delivered to the carrier even though the shipment is under reservation (Section 2-505)."
In a shipment contract, therefore, damage that happens on the truck, the train or the ship falls on the buyer as between buyer and seller. The buyer pays the seller and pursues the carrier. The word "duly" ties the passing of risk to a proper delivery of the goods to the carrier.
Under 2-509(4) these rules "are subject to contrary agreement of the parties" and to the provisions on sale on approval and on the effect of breach. Shipping terms, incoterms in the purchase order and the seller's standard terms all bear on which subsection applies, and counsel reads them before the expert is asked when the damage occurred.
When does the risk pass in a destination contract or a local sale?
In a destination contract, when the goods are duly tendered at the destination so the buyer can take delivery. In other cases, on the buyer's receipt of the goods if the seller is a merchant, otherwise on tender of delivery.
Under 2-509(1)(b), if the contract "does require him to deliver them at a particular destination and the goods are there duly tendered while in the possession of the carrier, the risk of loss passes to the buyer when the goods are there duly so tendered as to enable the buyer to take delivery." Damage in transit under such a contract falls on the seller as between the two.
Subsection (2) covers goods held by a bailee, such as a warehouse, to be delivered without being moved. Subsection (3) is the catch-all: "In any case not within subsection (1) or (2), the risk of loss passes to the buyer on his receipt of the goods if the seller is a merchant; otherwise the risk passes to the buyer on tender of delivery."
The receipt rule matters for deliveries made by the seller's own trucks and for local pickups. Under subsection (3), when a merchant seller delivers with its own staff rather than by carrier, the risk stays with the seller until the buyer receives the goods, so damage during unloading at the buyer's dock can fall on either side depending on when receipt happened. The delivery record and the time of the damage become the decisive facts.
What if the goods were defective before they were shipped?
Then the risk stays with the seller. Under UCC 2-510(1), when a tender or delivery so fails to conform as to give a right of rejection, the risk of loss remains on the seller until cure or acceptance.
Section 2-510(1) provides: "Where a tender or delivery of goods so fails to conform to the contract as to give a right of rejection the risk of their loss remains on the seller until cure or acceptance." A buyer under a shipment contract who receives broken goods therefore asks a technical question first: were the goods already nonconforming when the seller handed them to the carrier?
Subsection (2) covers the buyer who accepted and later rightfully revokes acceptance: such a buyer "may to the extent of any deficiency in his effective insurance coverage treat the risk of loss as having rested on the seller from the beginning." Subsection (3) works the other way when the buyer repudiates or is in breach before the risk passes on conforming goods already identified to the contract.
The expert's task under 2-510 is to separate damage caused in transit from a condition the goods had before shipment. A crack that starts at a casting defect, corrosion that began in the seller's warehouse, or a part missing in a sealed carton point to the seller. Crushed corners, punctured packaging and impact marks that line up with damage to the goods point to handling in transit.
When is the carrier liable for goods damaged in transit?
Under the Carmack Amendment, 49 U.S.C. 14706, a motor carrier is liable for the actual loss or injury to property it carries. The shipper proves good condition at delivery to the carrier, damaged condition on arrival and the damages.
Section 14706(a)(1) requires a carrier to "issue a receipt or bill of lading for property it receives for transportation under this part," and makes the receiving carrier and the delivering carrier liable "to the person entitled to recover under the receipt or bill of lading." It states: "The liability imposed under this paragraph is for the actual loss or injury to the property caused by" the receiving carrier, the delivering carrier or another carrier over whose route the property is transported.
The Supreme Court described the shape of such a claim in Missouri Pacific Railroad Co. v. Elmore & Stahl, decided May 4, 1964, in an opinion by Justice Stewart: "the shipper establishes his prima facie case when he shows delivery in good condition, arrival in damaged condition, and the amount of damages." Then "the burden of proof is upon the carrier to show both that it was free from negligence" and that the damage was "due to one of the excepted causes relieving the carrier of liability."
The excepted causes the Court listed are "(a) the act of God; (b) the public enemy; (c) the act of the shipper himself; (d) public authority; (e) or the inherent vice or nature of the goods." For a goods expert, two of them are common in practice: the act of the shipper, which includes inadequate packaging, and inherent vice, which means the goods deteriorated or failed because of what they were.
What did the Supreme Court decide about the damaged melons?
That a carrier found free of negligence was still liable for a carload of honeydew melons that arrived damaged, because the jury refused to find that the damage was caused solely by the melons' inherent vice.
A carload of honeydew melons left Rio Grande City, Texas, for Chicago. The melons were in good condition when the carrier received them and arrived damaged. Elmore & Stahl, the shipper, sued the railroad in a Texas court. The jury found that the carrier and its connecting carriers had performed their services without negligence, but it refused to find that the damage was caused solely by inherent vice, the natural tendency of the melons to deteriorate.
The Texas courts entered and affirmed judgment for the shipper, and the Supreme Court affirmed. Freedom from negligence was not enough; the carrier also had to prove that an excepted cause produced the damage. Justice Douglas, joined by Justice Black, dissented.
The case shows why expert evidence about the goods decides cargo claims. A carrier that wants the inherent vice defense needs proof that the goods' own condition caused the damage. A shipper that wants to defeat it needs proof that the goods were sound when tendered and that transit conditions explain the damage. Both proofs come from the goods and the records of their handling.
How long does a buyer have to file a cargo claim?
The carrier may set limits, but under 49 U.S.C. 14706(e)(1) not less than 9 months to file a claim and not less than 2 years to sue, counted from the carrier's written notice disallowing the claim.
Section 14706(e)(1) bars a carrier from providing "a period of less than 9 months for filing a claim against it under this section" and "a period of less than 2 years for bringing a civil action against it under this section." The period for bringing a civil action is computed from the date the carrier gives written notice that it has disallowed any part of the claim.
The bill of lading or the carrier's tariff sets the actual periods, and they can be the minimums. A buyer who spends months arguing with the seller about whether the goods were defective can lose the claim against the carrier in the meantime.
The seller's claim follows its own rules. Under UCC 2-607(3)(a), as the product defect page notes, a buyer who has accepted goods must notify the seller of the breach within a reasonable time after discovering it or lose any remedy. Prompt notice to both the seller and the carrier, with photographs and the delivery record, preserves both routes.
How does an expert tell transit damage from a defect that existed before shipment?
By matching the damage to the goods with the condition of the packaging and the handling record, reading fracture surfaces and corrosion for their age and origin, and comparing the damaged units with sound units from the same lot.
The expert starts with the packaging, because it travels with the goods and records what happened to them. Crushed or punctured cartons, broken pallets, water stains, shifted bracing and tripped shock or tilt indicators are evidence of handling events. Damage to the goods that lines up with damage to the packaging points to transit. Damage inside an intact package points elsewhere.
Then the goods themselves. The expert reads fracture surfaces, wear and repair marks to tell a manufacturing flaw from damage caused later, as the product defect page describes the method. A fracture through a casting void, a crack with old corrosion on its faces or a weld that never fused existed before shipment. A fresh overload fracture at the point of an impact did not. Where testing is likely to change the item, the expert follows ASTM E860-22 for testing that alters evidence and documents the condition first.
Last, the comparison. Sound units from the same lot, the seller's outbound inspection records and photographs taken at loading show what the goods looked like when they left. For perishables or goods sensitive to temperature, the expert also looks at temperature records, because inherent vice and transit conditions are the competing explanations in that kind of case.
What should the buyer do when a damaged shipment arrives?
Note the damage on the delivery receipt, photograph the goods and packaging before unpacking further, keep the packaging, notify the seller and the carrier in writing, and file the cargo claim in time.
The delivery receipt is the first record of condition at arrival. A receipt signed without remarks supports the carrier's position that the goods arrived in good order, and a notation of visible damage supports the buyer. Photographs of the shipment on the truck, the pallets, the cartons and the goods, taken before the packaging is discarded, preserve what the expert will need.
The packaging and the damaged goods should be kept and not repaired until the other side has had a chance to inspect them, because the carrier and the seller will each want to examine them. An inspection with both invited, recorded in photographs and notes, avoids a later dispute about what was found.
The buyer then gives written notice to the seller under 2-607(3)(a) and files a claim with the carrier within the period in its bill of lading or tariff, which under 14706(e)(1) cannot be shorter than 9 months. If the expert's examination later shows a defect that existed before shipment, the notice to the seller is what keeps the 2-510 argument open.
What does IAE do when goods arrive damaged and the cause is disputed?
IAE prepares an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing expert's report. The format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed within one business day, and the signed PDF follows in up to 5 business days.
On the product defect page the expert's questions are whether the goods were defective when delivered, whether the failure came from manufacturing or from misuse, and what the goods were worth as accepted. The expert reads fracture surfaces, wear and repair marks to tell a manufacturing flaw from later damage, follows ASTM E860-22 when testing is likely to change the item, and sets values under UCC 2-714(2) at the time and place of acceptance.
The client sends the request and describes the goods and the dispute: what was shipped, the shipping terms, the carrier, when and how the damage was found, and what is attached, such as the purchase order and invoice, the bill of lading and delivery receipt with any notations, photographs of the goods and the packaging, the seller's outbound inspection records, the carrier's inspection report and any report from the other side. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The questions are confirmed with the client before work starts.
The specialist prepares the report, and the draft is checked for facts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, depending on the volume of materials. For cases with tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; which party to claim against and under which rule are questions for the client's attorney. An expert report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- Uniform Commercial Code, section 2-509, Risk of Loss in the Absence of Breach (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Uniform Commercial Code, section 2-510, Effect of Breach on Risk of Loss (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 49 U.S.C. 14706, Liability of carriers under receipts and bills of lading (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, uscode.house.gov)
- Missouri Pacific Railroad Co. v. Elmore & Stahl, 377 U.S. 134 (1964) (FindLaw, full text)
Read also
All articles
Goods damaged in a warehouse: who is liable, and what does the goods expert establish?
Goods go into a warehouse sound and come out wet, crushed, spoiled or short. Under UCC 7-204 the warehouse answers for damage caused by its failure
How do you prove goods are counterfeit, and what does the product expert compare?
Under the Lanham Act a counterfeit is a spurious mark that is identical with, or substantially indistinguishable from, a registered mark. Whether
Implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose: what must the buyer prove, and what does the expert test?
Under UCC 2-315 a seller that has reason to know the buyer's particular purpose, and that the buyer is relying on the seller's skill to pick suitableExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

