Examinations

How do you prove goods are counterfeit, and what does the product expert compare?

Under the Lanham Act a counterfeit is a spurious mark that is identical with, or substantially indistinguishable from, a registered mark. Whether a shipment of handbags, transceivers or spare parts carries such a mark is a factual question, and a buyer, a seller, an importer or a brand owner answers it with evidence. The core of that evidence is a documented comparison of the suspect goods with genuine ones by a person qualified to make it.

Hands compare two nearly identical unmarked bottles, one seam slightly uneven, on linen

What makes goods counterfeit under US law?

A mark identical with, or substantially indistinguishable from, a mark registered on the Principal Register for those goods. Goods made by a manufacturer authorized to use the mark fall outside the definition.

15 U.S.C. 1127 defines a counterfeit as a spurious mark which is identical with, or substantially indistinguishable from, a registered mark. For seizure orders, 15 U.S.C. 1116(d)(1)(B) defines a counterfeit mark as a counterfeit of a mark that is registered on the Principal Register of the US Patent and Trademark Office for the goods or services sold, offered for sale or distributed, and that is in use, whether or not the person against whom relief is sought knew the mark was so registered.

The same subsection excludes any mark used on goods whose manufacturer or producer was, at the time of manufacture, authorized by the holder of the right to use the mark for the type of goods so made. That exclusion turns a product question into a legal one: goods from an authorized factory that were sold through an unauthorized channel are not counterfeit under section 1116(d), even if the brand owner objects to the sale.

Three facts therefore need proof. The first is that the mark on the goods is the registered mark or one substantially indistinguishable from it, for the same type of goods. The second is that the mark is spurious, meaning the goods did not come from the brand owner or an authorized manufacturer. The third, for damages and criminal cases, is what the seller knew. The product expert works on the second fact.

How does an expert compare suspect goods with genuine ones?

Side by side, against reference items whose origin is documented: construction, materials, printing, labels, security features, serial and lot codes and packaging. Each difference is photographed, measured and tied to the reference item it was compared with.

The comparison starts with the reference. A genuine item of the same model and production period, bought from an authorized source with a receipt or supplied by the brand owner with a statement of origin, gives the expert a fixed point. An item of unknown origin cannot serve as the reference, and a report that does not say where its reference came from has an open gap.

The expert then works through the item from the outside in. Packaging: the board, the print, the fonts, the barcodes and the inserts. Labels and tags: the material, the stitching or adhesive, the printing method and the position. Security features: holograms, serialized labels, microtext and tamper seals. Codes: serial numbers, date codes and lot codes, and whether they follow the brand's format and match the box. Construction and materials: weight, dimensions, finish, hardware, internal components and, for electronics, the board layout and the firmware identifiers.

Each finding is recorded with a photograph next to the reference, a scale and a measurement where one applies. A single difference in a font may come from a production change. Several independent differences that point the same way carry more weight, and the report says which differences the expert treats as decisive and why.

For a large seizure the expert also has to say how many items were examined and how they were chosen. A conclusion about hundreds of units drawn from a handful of items is an extrapolation, and the report states the selection method so that the court can judge it.

Who is qualified to testify that a product is counterfeit?

A witness whose knowledge, skill, experience, training or education covers the product and its authentication, under Rule 702. In a 2020 order the District of Massachusetts struck a hologram expert's opinions that transceivers were counterfeit.

Federal Rule of Evidence 702 lets a qualified expert give an opinion if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion will help the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, comes from reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the facts of the case.

In Integrated Communications & Technologies, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Financial Services Co., No. 16-10386-LTS, Judge Leo T. Sorokin of the US District Court for the District of Massachusetts ruled on motions about experts on whether seized transceivers were counterfeit in an order filed August 13, 2020. The plaintiffs' expert, Dr. Nicholas Fang, had examined the labels on each of the 779 seized transceivers, compared them to label images in a verification report and a security bulletin, and concluded that a majority showed indicia of counterfeiting.

The court found him qualified to testify generally about holograms but struck his opinions that the transceivers were counterfeit. It wrote that his testimony provides no evidence that the seized transceivers are counterfeit. He was not an expert in brand identification or counterfeit goods, and he conceded that he did not know whether the counterfeiting indicia in the security bulletin were true. The court also held the security bulletin itself to be inadmissible hearsay and struck his reliance on it.

The defendants' expert, Shelley Raina, survived the plaintiffs' motion to exclude. The court held that his alleged bias and methodological shortcomings went to the weight and credibility of his testimony, not to admissibility. In this order a witness qualified on one feature of the product, its hologram labels, was not allowed to testify that the transceivers themselves were counterfeit.

Can the expert rely on the brand owner's authentication guide?

Only with care. A guide or bulletin is a statement by the brand owner, and in the 2020 Massachusetts order the court held a security bulletin to be inadmissible hearsay. The expert should test its markers against documented genuine items.

Brand owners issue guides that list the features of genuine goods: label layouts, hologram types, code formats. These documents are useful starting points. They are also written by an interested party, and they describe particular production periods.

An expert who copies the guide's conclusions without checking them reports what the brand owner says and adds nothing of his or her own. In the Integrated Communications order, the expert's admission that he did not know whether the bulletin's indicia were true was one of the reasons the court struck his counterfeit opinions.

The safer method is to treat each marker in a guide as a hypothesis. The expert checks it on genuine items whose origin is documented, notes the production period it applies to and only then uses it on the suspect goods. The report names the guide, its date and the genuine items used to test it.

What happens when US Customs detains goods as counterfeit?

Under 19 CFR 133.21 CBP may detain suspect goods for up to 30 days, notifies the importer within five business days and gives it seven business days to answer. Seized goods are forfeited unless the mark owner consents.

19 CFR 133.21(a) defines a counterfeit mark as a spurious mark that is identical with, or substantially indistinguishable from, a mark registered on the Principal Register of the US Patent and Trademark Office. Under section 133.21(b)(1), CBP may detain goods suspected of bearing a counterfeit version of a recorded mark for up to 30 days after they are presented for examination; goods not released by then are deemed excluded.

Under section 133.21(b)(2), CBP notifies the importer in writing within five business days of the decision to detain. The importer then has seven business days to show that the goods do not bear a counterfeit mark. If the importer does not answer, or the answer is not enough, CBP may disclose to the mark owner unredacted information, photographs or samples, which may include serial numbers, manufacturing dates, lot codes and UPCs. Samples go out under a bond and must be returned on demand or after testing.

If CBP decides that the goods bear a counterfeit mark, it seizes them, and they are forfeited unless the mark owner consents in writing to another disposition. Within 30 business days of the seizure notice CBP discloses the names and addresses of the manufacturer, exporter and importer, and the importer may petition for relief under 19 CFR part 171.

The seven business days are where an importer's expert evidence matters first. A short report that compares the detained goods with documented genuine items, and explains codes and features the officer questioned, is the importer's answer to CBP. The same comparison later goes into a petition or a court case.

Why does the counterfeit finding matter for damages?

Because the Lanham Act gives counterfeiting its own remedies: treble damages for knowing use under 1117(b) and statutory damages under 1117(c) of $1,000 to $200,000 per counterfeit mark per type of goods, and up to $2,000,000 if willful.

Under 15 U.S.C. 1117(b), where a person knowingly and intentionally uses a counterfeit mark in selling, offering or distributing goods, or knowingly supplies goods meant for such use, the court must generally award three times the greater of profits or damages, together with a reasonable attorney's fee, unless it finds extenuating circumstances. The court may also award prejudgment interest.

Under section 1117(c), the plaintiff may elect, at any time before final judgment, statutory damages instead of actual damages and profits. The amount is not less than $1,000 and not more than $200,000 per counterfeit mark per type of goods or services sold, offered for sale or distributed, as the court considers just. If the court finds the use willful, the limit rises to $2,000,000 per counterfeit mark per type of goods.

These figures turn on counts the expert's report supplies: how many distinct marks appear on the goods, how many types of goods are involved and how many units carry each mark. A report that lists each mark, each product type and the units examined gives the court the numbers it needs. A report that says only that the goods are fake leaves the count open.

How does a party get access to the goods and the reference items?

Through Rule 34, which lets a party inspect, test and sample tangible things in the other side's possession, custody or control. The response is due in writing within 30 days after service.

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 34(a)(1) lets a party request that the other side produce and permit it to inspect, copy, test or sample designated documents, electronically stored information and tangible things in the responding party's possession, custody or control. Under Rule 34(b)(2)(A) the response is due in writing within 30 days after service.

Both sides of a counterfeit dispute use the rule. The accused seller requests the brand owner's reference items, its authentication guides and the records of its own test purchases. The brand owner requests the seller's inventory, invoices and supplier records, which bear on the authorized manufacturer exclusion. Any test that damages an item, such as opening a sealed unit or removing a label, is agreed in a protocol before it is done, with both experts present or with video.

What does IAE do when the authenticity of goods is disputed?

IAE prepares an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing expert's report. The format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed within one business day, and the signed PDF follows in up to 5 business days.

On the product defect page the expert's questions are whether the goods were defective when delivered, whether the failure came from manufacturing or from misuse, and what the goods were worth as accepted. The same examination of construction, materials and markings applies when one side says the goods are not what the contract or the label promised. The expert follows ASTM E860-22 when testing is likely to change the item and sets values under UCC 2-714(2) at the time and place of acceptance.

The client sends the request and describes the goods and the dispute: what was bought or seized, from whom, the invoices and shipping documents, photographs of the goods, labels and packaging, any genuine items available for comparison, the brand owner's or customs notices and any report from the other side. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The questions are confirmed with the client before work starts.

The specialist prepares the report, and the draft is checked for facts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, depending on the volume of materials. For cases with tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. An expert report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member