Expert opinion letters

How do you ask for a recommendation letter for an EB-1A petition, and how much time should you allow?

No regulation tells an EB-1A applicant how to ask for a letter. Chapter 2 of the USCIS Policy Manual says that letters should explain "in specific terms" why the author holds the opinion and that the statements in them should be corroborated by documents in the record. In a 2013 NIW case the AAO gave letters built on draft samples "little credibility or probative value." The facts in each letter must exist when the petition is filed.

A person from behind writes a short note at a cafe table beside an open envelope

How do you ask for a recommendation letter for an EB-1A petition?

Write to each author separately, name the EB-1A criterion the letter supports, list the facts the author saw with dates, attach the documents and ask for a signed letter in the author's words by a set date.

An EB-1A petition is decided under 8 CFR 204.5(h). Paragraph (h)(2) defines extraordinary ability as "a level of expertise indicating that the individual is one of that small percentage" who have risen to the very top of the field. Paragraph (h)(3) asks for evidence of sustained national or international acclaim: a one-time major internationally recognized award, or evidence under at least three of ten criteria. If those criteria do not readily apply to the occupation, paragraph (h)(4) says "the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility."

Letters enter the record as evidence for those criteria. The ten criteria cover lesser prizes and awards, membership in associations that require outstanding achievements, published material about the applicant, judging the work of others, original contributions of major significance, scholarly articles, display at exhibitions, a leading or critical role for organizations with a distinguished reputation, high salary, and commercial success in the performing arts. A request that names the criterion tells the author which facts the officer will look for in the letter.

For letters about experience or training, 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1) sets the content: the writer's name, address and title, and a specific description of the duties. The regulation gives no form for a letter that states an opinion about the applicant's work. The applicant decides what to ask, and the author decides what to sign.

Each author receives a separate message. A group email to five authors with one shared description of the applicant puts the same sentences in front of all five, and in the AAO case described below, signed letters that repeated each other lost weight.

Whom should you ask for an EB-1A letter first?

The person who saw the fact a criterion needs: the editor who invited a review, an officer of the organization where the applicant led the work, a researcher or company that used the applicant's result.

Each criterion points to its own witness. For judging, the person who invited or assigned the review: a journal editor, a competition chair, a grant program officer. For a leading or critical role, an officer of the organization who can state the applicant's position, the unit the applicant ran and what it produced. For original contributions of major significance, people outside the applicant's employer who used the result: a company that licensed a method, a team that built on a paper, a hospital that adopted a protocol.

Chapter 2 of the USCIS Policy Manual names the criteria where such witnesses help most. For a leading or critical role, "letters from persons with personal knowledge of the significance of the person's leading or critical role can be particularly helpful to officers in making this determination, so long as the letters contain detailed and probative information that specifically addresses how the person's role for the organization, establishment, division, or department was leading or critical." For original contributions, "Detailed letters from experts in the field explaining the nature and significance of the person's contribution may also provide valuable context for evaluating the claimed original contributions of major significance, particularly when the record includes documentation corroborating the claimed significance."

An author who has never worked with the applicant can still write, provided the author knows the work: a reviewer who read the papers, an engineer who uses the product, a specialist who cites the results. The request to such an author names where the author met the work and attaches it. Chapter 2 adds that a person whose accomplishments have garnered sustained national or international acclaim would be expected to have received recognition "well beyond the circle of their personal and professional acquaintances."

The order of requests follows the criteria. The applicant first lists the three or more criteria the petition will claim, then the facts for each, then the person who can confirm each fact. A criterion without a witness is visible at this stage, before any author is asked.

What should the request to the author contain?

The category and criterion, the facts with dates and numbers, the list of attached documents, a request to state the author's credentials and relationship to the applicant, the signature details and the date the signed letter is due.

A short message with numbered attachments is enough. Each item below answers a question the officer asks when reading the letter: what the letter is for, what the author knows, how the author knows it, who the author is and whether the author signed it.

The facts in the request belong to the applicant. The opinion belongs to the author: what the work meant for the field, compared with what the author knows of others in it. A request that supplies the facts and leaves the opinion to the author keeps the letter in the author's words.

  • State the category, EB-1A, and the criterion or criteria under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) that the letter supports.
  • List the facts the author knows first-hand: what the applicant did, when, with whom and what followed, with numbers where they exist.
  • Attach the document behind each fact, such as the paper, the patent, the license, the review invitation or the citation report, and number the attachments.
  • Ask the author to say how and since when he or she knows the applicant or the work.
  • Ask for the author's CV or a short statement of positions and publications to file with the letter.
  • Ask for a dated and signed letter with the author's full name, title, organization and address.
  • Give the date the signed letter is needed and the planned filing date.

What documents should you send the author?

The applicant's CV and the document behind each fact the letter will state. Chapter 2 of the Policy Manual says that the statements made in letters of support "should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record."

The section of Chapter 2 on letters of support starts from their place in the record. Such letters are "not without weight," but "the statements made by the witnesses should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record." Where they "merely make general assertions about the beneficiary," letters at most "indicate that the beneficiary is a competent, respected figure within the field of endeavor" if "the record lacks sufficient, concrete evidence supporting such statements."

In its section on exceptional ability, the USCIS Policy Manual chapter on EB-2 says that formal recognition "in the form of certificates and other documentation that are contemporaneous" with the achievements "may have more weight than letters prepared for the petition recognizing the beneficiary's achievements."

An EB-1A letter that describes an award or a contribution can therefore point the officer to the document from the time of the event. The author can cite it only if the author has it. A working packet for an author holds the CV, the list of publications with citation counts, patents and licenses, articles about the applicant with author and date, contracts, and evidence of use outside the employer, each with the exhibit number it will carry in the petition.

The packet has limits. An author who receives only a CV writes about the CV. An author who receives two hundred pages without a list of facts writes about whatever he or she finds first. The list of facts in the request tells the author which documents carry each fact.

Can you send the author a draft of the letter?

No regulation forbids it. The AAO gave NIW letters with similar and at times identical language "little credibility or probative value," and on motion, decided December 30, 2013, counsel stated that the authors had received draft samples.

The case concerned an administrator in early childhood multicultural education who asked for classification as an alien of exceptional ability with a national interest waiver. The Texas Service Center denied the petition, and the AAO upheld the denial on July 18, 2013. Addressing letters that contained "similar, and at times, identical" language, the AAO wrote: "These similarities across the various letters suggest that the language in the letters is not the authors' own." It concluded: "Because the letters appear to have been drafted by someone other than the purported authors, the letters possess little credibility or probative value."

On motion, counsel explained: "As a courtesy, petitioner did provide draft sample letters to the professionals who supported her NIW petition." According to counsel, "Each writer was free to edit, add to, or delete any part of the sample letter," and each signed the letter as his or her opinion. The AAO answered that the argument was "not supported by any pertinent precedent decisions" showing a wrong application of law or policy, and on December 30, 2013 it dismissed the motion. The petition remained denied.

The AAO cited Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm'r 1988): USCIS may use statements submitted as expert testimony as advisory opinions, and it makes the final decision on eligibility itself. Given the extensive similarities among the letters, the AAO wrote that it could give them less weight.

A draft gives every author the same sentences. A list of facts gives every author the same facts and leaves the sentences to each of them. If an author asks for a starting text, the list of facts with exhibit numbers gives the author the material without the wording.

How do you keep several letters from reading alike?

Give each author a different part of the record and ask each to describe what he or she saw. Before filing, compare the signed letters with each other and return any letter that repeats another's sentences.

Chapter 2 of the Policy Manual sets the bar for each letter: "Letters that merely reiterate USCIS' definitions relating to this classification or make general and expansive statements regarding the beneficiary and the beneficiary's accomplishments are generally not persuasive." Letters written from one shared description of the applicant carry the same general statements, while letters built on what each author saw carry different facts.

In the case decided on motion on December 30, 2013, counsel named the source of the shared wording: draft sample letters given to every author. A request that gives each author the facts of a different project, review assignment or product leaves each author a different event to describe.

The split can follow the criteria in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3). One author covers the judging work, which (h)(3)(iv) describes as participation "as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field." A second covers the role, which (h)(3)(viii) requires to be "a leading or critical role for organizations or establishments that have a distinguished reputation." A third and a fourth describe the contribution from the side of those who used it, and a fifth, with no ties to the applicant, assesses the contribution against the field.

The comparison before filing is mechanical. Put the signed letters side by side, mark every sentence that appears in two of them with the same or nearly the same words, and send those passages back to the authors. The same check catches a sentence copied from the request into the letter.

What should the author say about his or her own expertise?

Who the author is, which positions, publications or work give the author knowledge of the field, and how the author knows the applicant. USCIS treats such letters as advisory opinions and may give less weight to questionable ones.

The rule on expert statements comes from Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm'r 1988), decided on October 28, 1988 in an H-1 case. The Commissioner wrote that the Service "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities, professional organizations, or other sources submitted in evidence as expert testimony." Because the Service makes the final decision, "where an opinion is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable, the Service is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence." The AAO applied that rule to NIW letters in the decision of December 30, 2013.

Under Matter of Caron the officer may give less weight to an opinion that is in any way questionable, and an author whose credentials are not in the record is open to that question. The request therefore asks for the author's CV, and the letter itself states the author's current position, field, years in it and the work that gives the author a basis for the opinion. Chapter 2 of the Policy Manual asks the same of letters on original contributions: they "should specifically describe the person's contribution and its significance to the field and should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise."

The relationship goes into the first paragraph: colleague, supervisor, co-author, client, reviewer, or a specialist who knows the work only through its publications or products. The officer reads every statement in the letter in the light of that relationship, so an author who leaves it out leaves the officer to guess. Chapter 2 states it directly: "The relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness is also a factor the officer should consider when evaluating the significance of witnesses' statements."

The author's field and the applicant's field have to meet. If a professor of mechanical engineering writes about a data scientist's models, or a hospital director about software the hospital never used, the opinion falls outside the author's own work, and under Matter of Caron the officer may give it less weight.

How much time should you allow for a recommendation letter?

No rule sets a period for the author. Count backward starting at the filing date and include reading and writing, one round of factual corrections, the signature, and a certified translation if the letter is not in English.

The filing date is fixed by 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1): "An applicant or petitioner must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing." The letters go into the package filed on that date, and the facts they describe must have happened by then. A letter that arrives after the filing misses the package. It can be filed later in response to a request for evidence, if the officer sends one.

The plan counts five steps for each author: the request with materials, the author's reading and writing, the applicant's check of facts and dates against the exhibits, the author's corrections and signature, and the translation where the letter is not in English. Each exchange with an author who travels, teaches or works in another time zone adds days. An author who asks questions about the materials adds another exchange.

All requests go out on the same day. Letters that arrive on different dates hold the filing to the date of the last one, and the petition cannot be filed in parts. A reserve author for each criterion avoids a gap if one author declines or stops answering.

The applicant's own check takes time as well. Every date and number in each letter is compared with the CV and the exhibits, every letter with every other letter, and every foreign-language letter with its translation.

What if the letter is needed for an RFE response?

The request for evidence sets the deadline. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv) the response period cannot exceed twelve weeks, a notice of intent to deny gives at most thirty days, and all requested materials go in one submission.

8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv) states that "in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks," "nor shall the maximum response time provided in a notice of intent to deny exceed thirty days." Paragraph (b)(11) adds: "All requested materials must be submitted together at one time." A letter that misses the package cannot follow it later in the same response.

A letter written for the response carries a date after the filing. The facts it reports still have to predate the filing, because 103.2(b)(1) requires eligibility at the time of filing. A letter about an award received after the filing date does not prove eligibility on that date.

Chapter 2 of the Policy Manual gives the standard a new letter has to meet: letters "should explain in specific terms why the witnesses believe the beneficiary to be of the caliber of a person with extraordinary ability." A request in the response period follows the same rule as before the filing: separate facts for each author.

The RFE names the officer's finding. The new letter answers that finding with facts and exhibit numbers, and the request to the author quotes the finding so the author knows what the officer did not accept.

What if the author writes in another language?

The letter goes in with a full English translation that the translator certifies as complete and accurate, plus the translator's certification of competence, under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3). The translation adds a step to the schedule.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3), a document in a foreign language must be accompanied by "a full English language translation which the translator has certified as complete and accurate," together with the translator's certification that he or she is competent to translate from the foreign language into English. The original letter is filed with the translation.

When one translator handles several letters, the translations share that translator's vocabulary. The originals in the authors' language, filed with them, carry the authors' own sentences, so the check for shared wording is made on the originals.

An author abroad who writes in English needs no translation. The letter still states the author's position, organization and address, so the officer can place the author in the field and the country.

What do you check when the signed letter arrives?

That every fact matches an exhibit, dates agree with the CV, the author's position and relationship are stated, the letter is signed and dated, and no sentence repeats another letter in the package.

A wrong date in one letter can cost more than that letter. In Matter of Ho, 19 I&N Dec. 582 (BIA 1988), the Board held that doubt cast on one part of the petitioner's proof may lead to a reevaluation of the reliability of the rest of the evidence, and that the petitioner must resolve inconsistencies in the record with independent objective evidence. An explanation without such evidence is not enough.

The check runs in a fixed order and takes one pass per letter.

  • Compare every date, title and number in the letter with the CV and the exhibits.
  • Find the document in the package for each fact the letter names, and write its exhibit number next to the fact.
  • Check that the letter states the author's position, field and how the author knows the applicant.
  • Check the signature, the date and the author's full name, organization and address.
  • Compare the letter with every other letter in the package, sentence by sentence.
  • For a letter in another language, attach the original and the certified translation under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3).

Is a letter from an employer requested differently?

Yes. A letter about experience must give the writer's name, address and title and a specific description of the duties under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1), and EB-1A also needs clear evidence of continuing work under (h)(5).

Under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1), evidence of qualifying experience or training takes the form of letters from current or former employers or trainers and must include "the name, address, and title of the writer, and a specific description of the duties performed by the alien." The request to an employer lists those items and asks for dates of employment and the job title for each period.

Chapter 2 of the USCIS Policy Manual applies the same rule to EB-1A: in its discussion of the leading or critical role criterion it states that "Evidence of experience must consist of letters from employers." For exceptional ability, 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(ii)(B) lists "letter(s) from current or former employer(s)" showing at least ten years of full-time experience in the occupation, and Chapter 5 of the Policy Manual repeats that criterion.

EB-1A has its own requirement about the future. Under paragraph (h)(5) the petition needs "clear evidence that the alien is coming to the United States to continue work in the area of expertise." The regulation lists what such evidence may include: letters from prospective employers, evidence of prearranged commitments such as contracts, or a statement from the beneficiary detailing plans to continue the work in the United States. The request to a prospective employer asks for the role, the start date and the work the applicant will do.

A letter for the leading or critical role criterion is also an employer letter in substance. The request asks an officer of the organization to state the applicant's position, the unit and its size, the decisions the applicant made, the results with numbers, and the organization's standing in its field, with documents for each.

How does IAE prepare an expert opinion letter, and how long does it take?

An expert from the public IAE registry in the applicant's field signs a letter of up to 15 pages; you approve the expert and CV first. The standard turnaround is 10 business days, 5 on rush.

Send the applicant's CV and the petition category through the expert opinion letters page. The secretariat confirms the expert, the fee and the turnaround within one business day, and the fee depends on the category and the volume of materials. The letter runs up to 15 pages with an analysis under the criteria of the category, for EB-1A, EB-1B, EB-2 NIW, O-1, H-1B or L-1B, and the expert's CV and declaration of independence are attached.

The work runs in three steps. On the first day the secretariat receives the CV, a description of the achievements and the draft petition and asks for anything missing. On the second day an expert from the registry in the subject area is selected, and you approve the candidate and the CV. In up to 8 business days the secretariat prepares the draft from your documents, the expert checks it, changes it and signs, and the applicant and the attorney make factual corrections, with one round included. The signed letter and CV come as a PDF, with a paper original on request.

The rules on the expert's independence are set out in the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002). The applicant and the attorney make factual corrections to the draft, and the expert's conclusions remain independent.

The standard turnaround is 10 business days and the rush option 5, counted from payment and receipt of all materials. The expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by QR code and Member ID. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the expert influences the decision: USCIS weighs the letter with the rest of the record.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert opinion letters

Ready to strengthen your petition with an expert opinion letter?

Send the applicant's CV and the petition category: the expert, cost and timeline within one business day.

Quote request

Received

Expert, cost and timeline within one business day

CategoryEB‑1A
ExpertIn the applicant's field
Timeline10 business days