Expert report review
The handwriting examiner's opinion is inconclusive: what does that mean, and what does a reviewer check?
An inconclusive handwriting result is a defined conclusion. In the Department of Justice's uniform language it means that "no determination can be reached as to whether two or more bodies of writing were prepared by the same writer." It supports neither side. A reviewer checks which limitation produced it, whether the examiner documented that limitation as ANSI/ASB Standard 070 requires, and whether more known writing or the original document would remove it.

What does an inconclusive handwriting opinion mean?
That the examiner could reach no determination on whether one person wrote both the questioned and the known writing. It is neither support for genuineness nor support for forgery, and it is one of five defined conclusions.
The Department of Justice's Uniform Language for Testimony and Reports for Forensic Document Examination, approved on January 5, 2021 and effective July 5, 2021, lists five conclusions an examiner may offer: source identification, support for common source, inconclusive, support for different sources and source exclusion. "Inconclusive" is defined as the conclusion that "no determination can be reached as to whether two or more bodies of writing were prepared by the same writer."
The document states the basis as well: "the bodies of writing have limitations that prevent the examiner from providing any conclusion regarding probable authorship." The result therefore describes the material that was submitted. It does not describe the signature as probably genuine or probably forged.
Jan Seaman Kelly's paper Forensic Document Examiner Testimony of Inconclusive Examination Results, in the 2017 proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences, refers to the nine-level scale of ASTM E1658 and describes its middle: "The two sides are separated by the 'no conclusion' point."
Which limitations lead to an inconclusive result?
A short or simple questioned writing, too few known samples or samples that are not comparable, a copy in place of the original, disguise or simulation, and temporary conditions of the writer such as an injured hand.
Kelly's paper names the first group of factors as "lack of contemporaneous or comparable known standards," together with brevity of the writing, intentional disguise, and a lack of significant agreement or differences between the writings.
Ronald N. Morris's 2013 paper in the same proceedings, Some Reasons for Qualified Conclusions, adds detail. Certainty is limited by "a limited quantity of writing, copies of documents or writing that is not original." Of a copy he writes: "It is not always possible to say with certainty that the copied writing is an accurate reproduction" of the original. A sample can also be insufficient because of "evidence of simulation or tracing," or because the writings submitted are in "completely different styles." Transitory factors "can include, but are not limited to, injury to the writing hand, use of drugs."
ANSI/ASB Standard 070, Standard for Examination of Handwritten Items (first edition, 2022), lists among the factors that limit comparability "noncontemporaneousness" and "dissimilarities in text content" (section 6.5.2.1). Samples written years apart from the questioned document, or in a different style or wording, fall under that section.
What must the examiner do before reporting that no conclusion is possible?
Under ANSI/ASB Standard 070 the examiner assesses whether the questioned and known writing are suitable, requests additional known writing where comparability is insufficient, and documents the reason for stopping or limiting the examination.
The standard gives the examiner discretion to stop. Where an important feature is absent or the item lacks quality, quantity or comparability, the examiner may discontinue or limit the procedure, and "shall document the reason(s) for such a decision" (section 6.1).
It also sets steps that come before stopping. Where it cannot be established whether apparently distorted known writing is natural writing, section 6.4.4 says it should be determined whether additional known writing could be of assistance and, if so, it should be requested. If the known writing is not suitable for analysis or comparison, the examiner "shall discontinue these procedures and report accordingly." If the questioned and known writings are not sufficiently comparable, the examiner "shall request additional known writing per laboratory policy" (section 6.5.2.3). If the item is a reproduction that lacks clarity, "the examiner shall discontinue these procedures and report accordingly" (section 6.3.2).
The record has to carry the reasoning. "The bases and reasons for the conclusion(s) and opinion(s) shall be included in the examiner's documentation," and "Limitations shall also be documented if present" (section 6.6). Under section 6.7 the examiner reviews all the work and "shall consider alternative interpretations." Section 6.1 requires documentation detailed enough "to allow for an internal or external review and assessment" of the process.
What does a reviewer check in an inconclusive report?
Whether the report names the specific limitation, whether the file documents it, whether the examiner asked for what was missing, and whether the same material in fact supports a qualified opinion in one direction.
An inconclusive result can be correct, and it can also be an examination that stopped early. The reviewer reads the report and the examiner's file with these questions:
- Does the report name the limitation: quantity of questioned writing, number of known samples, comparability, a copy, distortion or disguise?
- Does the file contain the contemporaneous notes and the reason for stopping that section 6.1 of the standard requires?
- Was the original requested, and if only a copy was examined, does the report say so?
- How many known samples were used, what are their dates, and are they in the same style and wording as the questioned writing?
- Did the examiner request additional known writing under sections 6.4.4 and 6.5.2.3, and what was the answer?
- Does the report list the similarities and differences that were observed, or only the final word "inconclusive"?
- Were alternative explanations considered, as section 6.7 requires: genuine writing under unusual conditions, simulation, disguise?
- Was the result described elsewhere in the case in terms the report does not use, such as "could not be excluded"?
Is an inconclusive opinion evidence for either side?
By its definition it makes neither authorship nor forgery more probable. Its use is narrower: it tells the court that the document was examined and what prevented a determination.
Rule 401 of the Federal Rules of Evidence defines relevant evidence: "it has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without the evidence" and "the fact is of consequence in determining the action." A result defined as "no determination can be reached" has no tendency in either direction on who wrote the signature.
Kelly's paper states what the result does convey: "The issuance of an inconclusive opinion lets the jury and the judge know the evidence was examined." Her survey of forensic document examiners asked how often they had testified to such results, and she reported that "examiners provide testimony regarding inconclusive examination results."
The reviewer therefore watches the wording around the result. A brief that turns "inconclusive" into "the expert found no forgery" or "the expert could not rule out the defendant" states a conclusion the examiner did not reach. The DOJ document also bars the opposite overstatement: an examiner shall not "assert that forensic document examinations are infallible or have a zero error rate."
How is a signature proved when the examiner cannot reach a conclusion?
By the other routes in Rule 901: a witness who saw the signing, a person familiar with the handwriting from before the litigation, comparison by the trier of fact with an authenticated specimen, or the document's distinctive characteristics.
Rule 901(a) requires evidence "sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is." An expert is one way to supply it. Rule 901(b) lists others.
Under Rule 901(b)(1), "Testimony that an item is what it is claimed to be" from a witness with knowledge, such as a person present at the signing. Under Rule 901(b)(2), "A nonexpert's opinion that handwriting is genuine, based on a familiarity with it that was not acquired for the current litigation." Under Rule 901(b)(3), "A comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert witness or the trier of fact." Under Rule 901(b)(4), "The appearance, contents, substance, internal patterns, or other distinctive characteristics of the item, taken together with all the circumstances."
An inconclusive expert result leaves all four in place. The party that carries the burden on the signature then relies on witnesses, on the circumstances of the document, and on the specimens that the judge or jury can compare.
What can change an inconclusive result?
More known writing from the period of the questioned document, in the same style and wording, and the original document in place of a copy. Rule 34 reaches both when the other side holds them.
The limitations in the report point to the remedy. Where the report cites too few or non-comparable samples, the party collects course-of-business writing from the relevant period: checks, applications, contracts, signed receipts. Where it cites a copy, the party looks for the original.
Rule 34 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure lets a party request "to produce and permit the requesting party or its representative to inspect, copy, test, or sample" documents and tangible things in the other side's possession, custody or control. The request "must specify a reasonable time, place, and manner for the inspection and for performing the related acts."
Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) requires the expert report to list "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming" the opinions, which for a handwriting report is the list of questioned and known items. A reviewer compares that list with what exists in the case. Samples that were available and were not sent to the examiner are the first point of the review.
With new material the examination is done again, by the same examiner or by another, and the review states which limitation the new material removes.
What does IAE prepare when the opposing handwriting report is inconclusive or qualified?
A review of the opposing handwriting examiner's report against Rule 26(a)(2)(B) and ANSI/ASB Standard 070. The format, cost, deadline and reviewer are confirmed within one business day; the signed PDF follows in up to 5 business days.
The reviewer reads the report and the examiner's file and sets out each point for a rebuttal report, the deposition or a Rule 702 motion. Each point of the review cites a page of the report and a section of a standard or rule. For the file, the reviewer asks for the bench notes, the images and the list of known writing.
The client sends the report with its exhibits and describes what to check. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the reviewer and the CV before work starts. A 48-hour rush is available for cases with tight deadlines.
The work is done by members of the public IAE registry, who can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. A review is evidence that the court weighs together with the other materials, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Justice, Uniform Language for Testimony and Reports for Forensic Document Examination (approved Jan. 5, 2021, effective July 5, 2021)
- ANSI/ASB Standard 070, Standard for Examination of Handwritten Items, First Edition, 2022 (AAFS Standards Board)
- Kelly, J. S., Forensic Document Examiner Testimony of Inconclusive Examination Results, paper J4, Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences, 2017, pp. 1193-1194
- Morris, R. N., Some Reasons for Qualified Conclusions, paper J17, Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences, 2013
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 401 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 901 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Comparison charts in the opposing handwriting report: what does a reviewer check?
The part of a handwriting report that a judge or jury remembers is often the chart: questioned letters set beside matching letters from the known
The report says the signature was written under unusual conditions: what does that mean, and how is it reviewed?
A handwriting report may find that a questioned signature was written under unusual conditions: slowly, with tremor, poor line quality or an odd
Auto-forgery: how is a finding that the signer disguised his own signature reviewed?
When a person denies a signature, the other side's examiner may answer that the person wrote it with deliberate changes, so that it could later beExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

