Expert report review

Defense medical examination report: what does the plaintiff's reviewing physician check?

A defense medical examination report is answered with the medical record and a physician who compares the two. New York's rule 202.17 and California's Code of Civil Procedure sections 2032.220 to 2032.610 set when the defense may examine the plaintiff, who may watch, and when each side must hand over its reports. The reviewing physician checks the examiner's history, findings, tests and causation statement against the chart and against those rules.

A physician from behind reads a defense exam report with an empty table behind

What is a defense medical examination in a personal injury case?

An examination of the plaintiff by a physician the defense selects, on the injuries the plaintiff claims. Courts and lawyers often call it an independent medical examination, or IME, although the defense retains the examiner.

In federal court the examination is ordered under Rule 35(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The court may order a party whose physical condition is in controversy to submit to an examination by a suitably licensed or certified examiner, on motion for good cause, and the order specifies the time, place, manner, conditions and scope of the examination and the examiner. Under Rule 35(b) the party examined may obtain the examiner's detailed written report, which sets out the findings, "diagnoses, conclusions, and the results of any tests."

State courts hear most personal injury cases, and their rules differ from Rule 35 in timing, notice and who may attend. New York handles the examination by notice under section 202.17 of the Uniform Civil Rules, title 22 of the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations. California provides for one physical examination by demand under section 2032.220 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The name does not change who pays the examiner. In Whitley v Tsegay a New York court used the common term itself, writing that "completion of discovery is not required for an independent medical examination (IME)." The examiner is still the defense's physician, and the plaintiff's side reads the report as the opinion of the other side's expert.

When can the defense examine the plaintiff in New York?

After joinder of issue and service of the bill of particulars. The examination is held 30 to 60 days after the notice unless the parties agree otherwise, and a motion to vacate is due within 10 days.

Section 202.17 governs actions for "personal injuries, disability or death" unless the court directs otherwise. Under subdivision (a), after joinder of issue and service of a bill of particulars, a party may serve a notice fixing the time and place of the examination, which is held "not less than 30 nor more than 60 days after service of the notice" unless the parties stipulate otherwise. A party may move to modify or vacate the notice within 10 days after receiving it.

Whitley v Tsegay, 2015 NY Slip Op 25270, decided by Justice Thomas A. Stander of the Supreme Court, Monroe County, on July 31, 2015, shows how strictly the timing reads. The plaintiff served the notice herself, and the defendant moved to vacate it, arguing that he had not had an opportunity to complete discovery. The court denied the motion. Under the rule the notice may be served at any time after joinder of issue and service of a bill of particulars, and discovery does not have to be finished first.

The court also weighed prejudice. The plaintiff had exhausted her no-fault medical benefits, so delay would hurt her, and the defendant had about two and a half months to complete the discovery he needed. The court ordered the defendant to hold the examination within 30 to 60 days of the decision.

What must the plaintiff serve before a New York examination?

At least 20 days before the examination, reports of the treating and examining providers that recite the injuries and conditions for trial, with a description, a diagnosis and a prognosis, plus authorizations for hospital and other records.

Under section 202.17(b)(1) each report must contain "a recital of the injuries and conditions as to which testimony will be offered at the trial," together with a description of the injuries, a diagnosis and a prognosis. Under (b)(2) the party to be examined also delivers signed authorizations for hospital and other records.

Subdivision (b) fixes the timing. The reports and authorizations are served "at least 20 days before the date of such examination, or on such other date as the court may direct." The defense examiner therefore has the plaintiff's own account of the injuries, the diagnoses and the prognoses before the plaintiff walks in, and the examiner's report can be compared with what the examiner had in hand.

Subdivision (j) gives both sides a remedy when a report falls short. Any party "may move to compel compliance or to be relieved from compliance with this rule or any provision thereof," but "motions directed to the sufficiency of medical reports must be made within 20 days of receipt of such reports." A report that recites an injury without a diagnosis or a prognosis is the kind of defect such a motion reaches, and the 20 days run from the day the report arrives.

For the reviewing physician the plaintiff's own reports are the baseline. The defense examiner's report is compared with the injuries, diagnoses and prognoses recited in them, and every condition the plaintiff will rely on at trial has to appear there first.

When does the plaintiff receive the examiner's report in New York?

Within 45 days after the examination is completed. The examiner's report must meet the same content requirements as the plaintiff's reports, and conditions or providers left out of the exchanged reports can be excluded at trial.

Under section 202.17(c) the reports of the examining providers are served "within 45 days after completion of the examination" and must comply with subdivision (b)(1). The defense examiner therefore has to recite the injuries and conditions, describe them and give a diagnosis and a prognosis.

New injuries follow subdivision (g). If the examined party intends to offer evidence of additional injuries, a supplemental report is served within 30 days after their discovery and no later than 30 days before trial. The report specifies a time, not more than 10 days later, and a place for a further examination, and the examining provider's reports are due within 10 days after that examination.

Subdivision (h) sets the sanction. Unless the court orders otherwise, or the trial judge finds good cause in the interests of justice, the party seeking recovery "shall be precluded at the trial from offering in evidence" records not made available under the rule, evidence of injuries or conditions not set forth in the exchanged reports, and the testimony of treating or examining medical providers whose reports were not served. The reviewing physician's comparison of the reports with the chart is how a party finds a gap before the trial judge does.

What are the rules for a defense examination in California?

Any defendant may demand one physical examination of a plaintiff who claims personal injury, with no painful, protracted or intrusive tests, within 75 miles of the plaintiff's residence and at least 30 days after the demand.

Section 2032.220 of the California Code of Civil Procedure applies when the plaintiff seeks damages for personal injuries. In that case "any defendant may demand one physical examination of the plaintiff" without leave of court, after being served or appearing, whichever comes first. The examination may not include any diagnostic test or procedure that is "painful, protracted, or intrusive" and must be conducted "within 75 miles of the residence of the examinee." It is scheduled at least 30 days after service of the demand, unless the court shortens the time.

Section 2032.510 governs who is in the room. The examinee's attorney, or that attorney's representative authorized in a signed writing that names the representative, may attend and observe a physical examination conducted for discovery purposes and may record the words spoken to or by the examinee by stenographer or audio technology. The observer "shall not participate in or disrupt it."

The observer may suspend the examination to seek a protective order if the examiner becomes abusive or attempts unauthorized diagnostic tests or procedures, and the examiner may suspend it if the observer participates or disrupts. The audio recording and the observer's notes give the reviewing physician a second account of what the examiner asked, what the plaintiff answered and which tests were done.

How does the plaintiff get the examiner's report in California?

By written demand under section 2032.610. The defense delivers a detailed report of the history, examinations, findings, test results, diagnoses, prognoses and conclusions, plus earlier reports on the same condition, within 30 days or 15 days before trial.

Under section 2032.610(a) the party who submitted to the examination may demand "a detailed written report" setting out the history, the examinations and the findings of the examiner, including the results of all tests made, diagnoses, prognoses and conclusions. The same demand reaches reports of "earlier examinations of the same condition," made by that examiner or any other.

Under subdivision (b) the reports are due within 30 days after service of the demand, or within 15 days of trial, whichever is earlier. Under subdivision (c) making the demand has a price: the protection for work product is waived for the examiner's writings and reports and for the examiner's testimony. Rule 35(b)(4) in federal court has a similar effect on privilege for a party who requests and obtains the examiner's report.

The demand decides what the reviewer receives. A report that lists the history, findings and tests separately lets the physician test each conclusion against its basis. A report that gives conclusions without the findings behind them is itself a point for the deposition of the examiner.

What does the reviewing physician check in the examiner's report?

The history the examiner recorded, the examination findings, the tests and their results, the diagnoses and the causation and apportionment opinions, each compared with the chart, the plaintiff's exchanged reports and the recording of the examination.

The history comes first. The examiner's account of the accident, prior injuries and treatment is compared with the records produced under the authorizations. A history that leaves out treatment the chart shows, or adds a prior injury the records do not show, carries into every conclusion built on it.

Then the findings and tests. California's section 2032.610 lists findings, test results, diagnoses and prognoses as separate parts of the report, and New York's section 202.17 requires a description, a diagnosis and a prognosis. The reviewer checks whether each diagnosis follows from a recorded finding or test, whether imaging and test results cited in the report match the records, and whether the examination stayed within what the demand or order allowed.

Causation and apportionment come last. The examiner may attribute the condition to degeneration or to an earlier event, and the treating physician to the accident. The reviewer identifies which records support each side's attribution and which do not.

If the examiner will testify as an expert, the opinion also has to pass the reliability requirements of the forum. In federal court Rule 702 requires sufficient facts or data and a reliable application of reliable methods. The review lists the facts or data the examiner did not have, such as records produced after the examination.

What happens if the examiner's report is late or incomplete?

The court can order delivery and exclude the examiner's testimony under Rule 35(b)(5) in federal court. In New York, subdivision (h) of rule 202.17 excludes unexchanged evidence unless good cause is shown.

Under Rule 35(b)(5) the court, on motion, may order a party to deliver the examiner's report on just terms, and if the report is not provided the court may exclude the examiner's testimony at trial. Under Rule 35(b)(6) the subdivision also applies to examinations made by agreement of the parties unless the agreement says otherwise.

In New York the deadlines in section 202.17 run both ways: 45 days for the examiner's report under subdivision (c), 30 days for supplemental reports under subdivision (g), and the preclusion in subdivision (h) unless the court orders otherwise or finds good cause in the interests of justice. In California the report demanded under section 2032.610 is due within 30 days after the demand or within 15 days of trial.

A review written when the report arrives records what the report contains and what it omits, with dates. That record supports a motion to compel, an objection at trial to an opinion the report did not contain, or a request for a further examination after a supplemental report.

What does IAE do when a party needs a review of a defense medical examination report?

A physician from the IAE registry in the specialty of the care at issue reviews the examiner's report against the chart and Rule 702 and issues a signed review in up to 5 business days.

The IAE page on reviews of the opposing medical expert report is written for counsel who have received the other side's report in a malpractice, wrongful death or personal injury case. The reviewing physician tests each opinion against the chart and against Rule 702: sufficient facts or data, a reliable method and a reliable application of it to this patient. The review can be followed by a rebuttal report.

The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the physician from the registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines, which matters when a 45-day or 30-day exchange deadline is running.

Registry members passed the collegial attestation of the council under the published Criteria Matrix and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The physician confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees how the court will rule.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member