For employers
Is pre-employment testing legal, and what do Title VII and the Uniform Guidelines require of a skills test?
Federal law permits employers to test candidates. Section 703(h) of Title VII lets an employer give and act on a professionally developed ability test unless the test, its administration or the use of its results is designed, intended or used to discriminate. Since Griggs v. Duke Power Co. (1971), a test that screens out one group more often has to be job related, and the Uniform Guidelines in 29 CFR part 1607 describe how an employer proves that.

Is it legal to test candidates before hiring?
Yes. Under section 703(h) of Title VII an employer may give and act on a professionally developed ability test, provided the test is not designed, intended or used to discriminate because of race, color, religion, sex or national origin.
The text is in 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(h): it is not an unlawful employment practice for an employer "to give and to act upon the results of any professionally developed ability test provided that such test, its administration or action upon the results is not designed, intended or used to discriminate because of race, color, religion, sex or national origin." Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 applies to an employer with fifteen or more employees for each working day in each of twenty or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year (42 U.S.C. 2000e(b)).
The Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (1978), now 29 CFR part 1607, were adopted jointly by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), the Civil Service Commission, the Department of Labor and the Department of Justice (1607.1(A)). Under 1607.2(B), they "apply to tests and other selection procedures which are used as a basis for any employment decision." Employment decisions include, among others, hiring, promotion, demotion, membership, referral, retention, and licensing and certification. Section 1607.2(C) does not treat recruitment practices as selection procedures. Where a test has no adverse impact, the Guidelines do not require a validity study of it (1607.1(B)).
What did the Supreme Court decide in Griggs v. Duke Power?
On March 8, 1971 the Court held that Title VII bars practices "fair in form, but discriminatory in operation." A test "must measure the person for the job and not the person in the abstract."
The Duke Power Company plant in the case had five operating departments: Labor, Coal Handling, Operations, Maintenance, and Laboratory and Test. From 1955 the company required a high school education for initial assignment to any department except Labor. On July 2, 1965, the day Title VII became effective, it added a condition for new employees: placement in any department but Labor also required satisfactory scores on two professionally prepared aptitude tests. From September 1965 incumbent employees without a high school education could qualify for transfer out of Labor or Coal Handling into an inside job by passing two tests, the Wonderlic Personnel Test and the Bennett Mechanical Comprehension Test.
Chief Justice Burger wrote the opinion of the Court, and Justice Brennan took no part in the case. The opinion says that the Act proscribes practices that are "fair in form, but discriminatory in operation," and that "the touchstone is business necessity." Tests "must measure the person for the job and not the person in the abstract," and the EEOC's interpretation of the Act "is entitled to great deference."
Footnote 6 cites an EEOC decision of December 2, 1966 on a battery of tests that included the Wonderlic and Bennett tests. In that case 58% of whites passed the tests, compared with 6% of Blacks.
What is adverse impact, and how does the four-fifths rule work?
Under 29 CFR 1607.4(D), the federal enforcement agencies generally regard a selection rate for any race, sex or ethnic group below four-fifths (80%) of the highest group's rate as evidence of adverse impact.
The rule compares selection rates. If 60 of 100 applicants in one group pass a test (60%) and 20 of 50 applicants in another group pass (40%), the second rate is two-thirds of the first, about 67%. That is below 80%, and the federal enforcement agencies will generally regard it as evidence of adverse impact. A rate above four-fifths will generally not be regarded as such evidence.
Section 1607.4(D) also covers differences on both sides of the 80% line. Smaller differences may still be adverse impact "where they are significant in both statistical and practical terms" or where the employer's actions discouraged applicants disproportionately on grounds of race, sex or ethnic group. Larger differences may not be adverse impact where they are based on small numbers and are not statistically significant, or where special recruiting or other programs made the pool of minority or female candidates atypical of the normal pool from that group.
Under 1607.4(A) and (B), the employer keeps records by sex and by these groups: Blacks, American Indians (including Alaskan Natives), Asians (including Pacific Islanders), Hispanics, and whites other than Hispanic, with totals. Under 1607.4(C), when the selection process as a whole has no adverse impact, the agencies generally will not expect the employer to evaluate each component. When it has adverse impact, the components are evaluated one by one.
Who has to prove what when a test screens out one group?
The complaining party proves that the test causes a disparate impact, and the employer must then prove that the test is job related and consistent with business necessity. Refusing a proven alternative practice also makes the employer liable.
Under 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(k)(1)(A)(i), an unlawful employment practice based on disparate impact is established when the complaining party proves that the employer "uses a particular employment practice that causes a disparate impact" on the basis of race, color, religion, sex or national origin, and the employer fails to prove that the practice "is job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity." Clause (k)(1)(A)(ii) adds a second route: the complaining party proves an alternative employment practice under subparagraph (C), and the employer refuses to adopt it. Subparagraph (C) ties that showing to "the law as it existed on June 4, 1989."
Under 1607.3(A) of the Uniform Guidelines, a selection procedure with adverse impact "will be considered to be discriminatory" unless it has been validated under the Guidelines or the conditions of section 6 of the Guidelines are met.
Section 1607.3(B) deals with two procedures that both serve the employer's legitimate interest in efficient and trustworthy workmanship and are substantially equally valid for a given purpose. The employer should use the one shown to have the lesser adverse impact, and a validity study called for by the Guidelines should include an investigation of suitable alternative procedures.
How does an employer prove that a test is job related?
With a validity study under 29 CFR 1607.5: criterion-related, content or construct. Each starts from information about the job, and for content validity, the closer the test is to a work sample, the stronger the case.
Under 1607.5(B), a criterion-related study gives empirical data that the test is predictive of or significantly correlated with important elements of job performance. A content study gives data that the content of the test "is representative of important aspects of performance on the job." Section 1607.14(B) asks for criteria that represent important or critical work behaviors or work outcomes. A test is generally considered related to the criterion when the relationship is statistically significant at the 0.05 level, meaning a probability of no more than one in twenty that it occurred by chance.
Under 1607.14(A), validity studies "should be based on review of information about the job." Paragraph (C)(1) states that a content strategy can support a test to the extent that the test is a representative sample of the content of the job, and that a test of knowledge, skills or abilities may in certain circumstances be justified by content validity. Under the same paragraph, a content strategy is not appropriate for tests of traits or constructs such as intelligence, aptitude, personality, common sense, judgment, leadership or spatial ability, or for skills that an employee will be expected to learn on the job. Construct validity is, in the words of the Guidelines, "a more complex strategy than either criterion-related or content validity."
The way the score is used needs support too. Under 1607.5(G), evidence that supports a test for screening "may be insufficient" for ranking candidates by score. Under 1607.5(H), cutoff scores "should normally be set so as to be reasonable and consistent with normal expectations of acceptable proficiency within the work force."
The EEOC fact sheet on employment tests and selection procedures says that a vendor's documentation of validity may be helpful, and that the employer stays responsible for the validity of its tests under the Uniform Guidelines.
Can an employer adjust scores or set aside test results?
Adjusting is barred: section 703(l) forbids adjusting scores, using different cutoffs or altering results by race, color, religion, sex or national origin. Setting results aside for racial reasons requires a strong basis in evidence of disparate impact liability.
Under 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(l), it is unlawful, in the selection or referral of applicants or candidates for employment or promotion, "to adjust the scores of, use different cutoff scores for, or otherwise alter the results of, employment related tests on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin."
In Ricci v. DeStefano the employer refused to certify test results. In 2003, 118 New Haven firefighters took promotion examinations: 77 completed the lieutenant examination and 41 the captain examination, with the written part counting for 60 percent and the oral part for 40 percent. Eight lieutenant positions and seven captain positions were vacant. Under the rule of three, all 10 candidates immediately eligible for lieutenant were white. The Civil Service Board deadlocked 2 to 2, "resulting in a decision not to certify the results."
On June 29, 2009 the Supreme Court reversed and remanded by 5 votes to 4. Justice Kennedy wrote for the Court that race-based action like the City's is impermissible under Title VII unless the employer has a "strong basis in evidence" that it would otherwise have been liable under the disparate impact provision.
What does the ADA require when a candidate with a disability takes a test?
A test that screens out people with disabilities has to be job related and consistent with business necessity. It must also be given so that the result measures the skill tested, not an impaired sensory, manual or speaking skill.
42 U.S.C. 12112(b)(6) treats as discrimination the use of "qualification standards, employment tests or other selection criteria that screen out or tend to screen out an individual with a disability" unless the test, as used, is job related for the position and consistent with business necessity. Paragraph (b)(7) covers the way the test is given. When the candidate has a disability that impairs sensory, manual or speaking skills, the results must measure the skills, aptitude or other factor the test is meant to measure, except where the impaired skills are the factors the test measures.
The EEOC fact sheet adds the duty to make reasonable accommodations, "including in the administration of tests," unless the accommodation would impose an undue hardship. Its example is EEOC v. Daimler Chrysler Corp., brought for applicants with learning disabilities who needed reading accommodations during a pre-employment test for hourly unskilled manufacturing jobs. The settlement provided monetary relief for 12 identified individuals and required a reasonable accommodation on that test.
The same fact sheet gives the age rules under the ADEA. Giving a physical agility test only to applicants over 50 is intentional age discrimination, and a neutral test with a discriminatory impact on applicants aged 40 or older is permitted only if the action is based on a reasonable factor other than age.
What happens when a test fails these rules?
The EEOC fact sheet lists payments and court findings. Ford paid $8.55 million over a written cognitive test for an apprenticeship program, and a court found that Dial's strength test violated Title VII.
The fact sheet was issued on December 1, 2007 as EEOC-NVTA-2007-2. In EEOC v. Ford Motor Co. and United Automobile Workers of America, the test was the Apprenticeship Training Selection System (ATSS), "a written cognitive test that measured verbal, numerical, and spatial reasoning." The ATSS had been validated in 1991, and it still "continued to have a statistically significant disparate impact" on African American applicants. Ford paid $8.55 million in monetary relief.
In EEOC v. Dial Corp., women "were disproportionately rejected for entry-level production jobs because of a strength test." The fact sheet records two findings: "the test was considerably more difficult than the job," and "the reduction in injuries occurred two years before the test was implemented." The Eighth Circuit upheld the trial court's finding of a Title VII violation.
How long must an employer keep test records?
At least one year. Under 29 CFR 1602.14, hiring records are kept for one year from the date of the record or the personnel action, whichever is later, and until final disposition if a discrimination charge is filed.
Section 1602.14 covers "any personnel or employment record made or kept by an employer," including application forms and requests for reasonable accommodation. The period is one year from the date the record was made or the personnel action was taken, whichever occurs later. For an employee who is involuntarily terminated, the personnel records are kept for one year from the date of termination.
Where a charge of discrimination has been filed, the employer keeps all personnel records relevant to the charge until final disposition of the charge or the action. The section names "application forms or test papers completed by an unsuccessful applicant" among those records.
Separate records are kept under 1607.4(A): the employer should maintain data on the impact of its tests by sex, race and ethnic group and have them available for inspection. With large numbers of applicants and frequent testing, a sample of adequate size may be kept instead.
How does the IAE written exam work for employers?
IAE runs an online written exam of up to 2 hours in the candidate's field. An examiner with no ties to the company approves the result within 5 business days, and the company decides on hiring.
The company registers on the employer page and receives a link to the company cabinet within one business day. In the cabinet it adds a candidate with a name, an email and an exam field. The candidate fills in a questionnaire on experience, education and a project, which only the IAE Secretariat sees, and chooses the exam day within 14 days. Before the exam the candidate uploads a photo of an ID document and takes a snapshot, and the Secretariat checks them manually.
The exam has 8 tasks, each with its own timer: 5 questions of 10 minutes, 2 cases of 25 minutes and a 10-minute question about the candidate's own project. It is taken in one sitting and cannot be paused. Pasting from the clipboard is disabled, a typing log records how each answer was typed and how often the candidate left the tab, and each candidate gets different figures and circumstances in the cases. If the log shows a doubtful answer, the candidate receives one more written question with 5 minutes to answer.
Answers are scored against the rubric of the field. The program for each of the 18 open fields is published with its sections and weights, version 1.0. The tasks are standard IAE tasks, and the candidate does no work for the company. In the registration form a company can ask for tasks written for its own roles.
The company sees the status of each candidate, the total score out of 100, the score on each rubric criterion (correctness, reasoning, risks, clarity) in each task and the certificate PDF if the exam is passed. The candidate confirms this before the exam starts. The company does not see the questionnaire, the CV, the answers or the reason for refusal, which appears as Not admitted, with no reason.
In the pilot, a company that registers by December 31, 2026 tests up to 5 employees free of charge. Outside the pilot, an exam costs $250 per person on an invoice to the company, with no subscription. The certificate is valid for 3 years. The company decides on the interview and on hiring. Under the EEOC fact sheet, the employer stays responsible for the validity of its tests under the Uniform Guidelines, including a test that comes from a vendor.
Sources
- 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2, Unlawful employment practices (U.S. Code, 2023 edition, govinfo)
- 42 U.S.C. 2000e, Definitions (U.S. Code, 2022 edition, govinfo)
- Griggs v. Duke Power Co., 401 U.S. 424 (1971) (LII)
- 29 CFR 1607.1, Statement of purpose (LII)
- 29 CFR 1607.2, Scope (LII)
- 29 CFR 1607.3, Discrimination defined (LII)
- 29 CFR 1607.4, Information on impact (LII)
- 29 CFR 1607.5, General standards for validity studies (LII)
- 29 CFR 1607.14, Technical standards for validity studies (LII)
- 29 CFR 1602.14, Preservation of records made or kept (LII)
- 42 U.S.C. 12112, Discrimination (Americans with Disabilities Act) (LII)
- EEOC, Employment Tests and Selection Procedures, EEOC-NVTA-2007-2
- Ricci v. DeStefano, 557 U.S. 557 (2009), United States Reports (govinfo)
- Supreme Court of the United States, Docket No. 07-1428
Read also
All articles
Does an employer have to pay for required training, certification exams and study time?
Under the Fair Labor Standards Act the hours an employee spends in training are working time unless four conditions are met together: the training
NYC Local Law 144: when does an AI hiring tool need a bias audit, and what must the employer publish and tell candidates?
Since January 1, 2023, New York City has barred employers and employment agencies from using an automated employment decision tool to screen
Are personality tests legal in hiring, and when does the ADA treat a personality test as a medical examination?
The ADA bars medical examinations of job applicants before a conditional offer, and a psychological test that can identify a mental disorder isPilot until December 31, 2026
Register your company
Free for up to 5 people. A link to the company cabinet arrives by email within one business day.

