Expert witnesses

ITC Section 337 domestic industry: what does the economic expert have to prove?

A patent owner can ask the U.S. International Trade Commission to exclude infringing imports only if an industry in the United States relating to the articles protected by the patent exists or is being established. Section 337(a)(3) of the Tariff Act measures that industry by investment and employment. The economic expert puts numbers on it, and since Lelo v. ITC (2015) those numbers decide the question.

Hands count plain unmarked units on a packing table in a workshop, aprons hanging and a clipboard face down.

What is the domestic industry requirement in a Section 337 case?

A condition for relief against infringing imports. Under 19 U.S.C. 1337(a)(2), the patent remedies apply only if an industry in the United States relating to the protected articles exists or is in the process of being established.

Section 337(a)(1)(B) of the Tariff Act of 1930, codified at 19 U.S.C. 1337, makes unlawful the importation and sale of articles that "infringe a valid and enforceable United States patent." Unlike a district court, the Commission cannot award damages. It decides whether imports violate the statute and, if so, whether to keep them out.

Section 337(a)(2) limits that remedy. The patent, copyright, trademark, mask work and design provisions apply only if an industry in the United States relating to the articles protected by the right "exists or is in the process of being established." A foreign patent owner with no activity in the United States cannot use the Commission against an importer.

Section 337(a)(3) defines when an industry exists. There must be, in the United States, with respect to the articles protected by the patent: "(A) significant investment in plant and equipment;" "(B) significant employment of labor or capital; or" "(C) substantial investment in its exploitation, including engineering, research and development, or licensing." The three clauses are alternatives, and a complainant may rely on any one of them.

What are the technical prong and the economic prong?

The technical prong asks whether the domestic articles are protected by the patent. The economic prong asks whether the investments and employment under section 337(a)(3) are significant or substantial.

Both prongs come from the statute and appear in the Commission's pleading rule. 19 CFR 210.12(a)(9)(ix) requires the complaint to include "A showing that an industry in the United States, relating to the articles protected by the patent exists or is in the process of being established," made "by appropriate allegations, and when practicable, by a chart that applies an exemplary claim of each involved U.S. patent to a representative involved domestic article."

The technical prong is the work of a technical expert, who charts the complainant's own product against a patent claim in the same way an infringement expert charts the accused product. The economic prong is the work of the economic expert, who identifies the domestic investments and employment tied to those protected articles and explains why they are significant.

The two prongs are decided separately. In Lashify, Inc. v. International Trade Commission, decided by the Federal Circuit on March 5, 2025, the court affirmed the finding that Lashify's utility patent failed the technical prong and vacated the Commission's economic-prong determination for all three patents in the case.

What must the complaint say about the domestic industry?

A detailed description of the industry with facts showing significant or substantial investment and employment, including the relevant operations of any licensees, under 19 CFR 210.12(a)(6).

Section 210.12(a)(6)(i) requires a complaint based on patent infringement under section 337(a)(1)(B) to "include a statement as to whether an alleged domestic industry exists or is in the process of being established as defined in section 337(a)(2)."

For an existing industry, the complaint gives "a detailed description of the relevant domestic industry as defined in section 337(a)(3) that allegedly exists including facts showing significant/substantial investment and employment, and also including the relevant operations of any licensees." Relevant information "includes but is not limited to" significant investment in plant and equipment, significant employment of labor or capital, and substantial investment in the exploitation of the patent, "including engineering, research and development, or licensing."

These facts are in the complaint before any discovery. The economic expert therefore often starts before filing, with the complainant's accounting records, payroll, leases and license agreements, and the report written later in the investigation builds on the numbers the complaint first stated.

Licensees count. The rule twice refers to "the relevant operations of any licensees," so a patent owner that does not make the product itself may rely on the domestic activities of a licensee, and the expert needs that licensee's data as well.

Does "significant" require numbers?

Yes. In Lelo v. ITC (2015) the Federal Circuit held that qualitative factors alone cannot show significant investment or employment and that the statute requires a quantitative analysis.

Lelo Inc. v. International Trade Commission, 786 F.3d 879, was decided on May 11, 2015, with Judge Reyna writing for a panel of Judges Moore, Clevenger and Reyna. The complainant was Standard Innovation. The court noted: "Neither Standard Innovation nor Standard U.S. manufactures in the United States."

The Commission had relied on four components bought in the United States: a backbone material, a rubber, microcontrollers and a pigment. The court wrote that "The total purchase prices accounted for less than five percent of the total raw cost of the devices," and that "[t]here is no evidence of any investment made in capital or labor as a result of the purchased components." The Commission had conceded "a relatively modest proportion of domestic content" but found the components qualitatively significant.

The Federal Circuit rejected that approach: "Qualitative factors cannot compensate for quantitative data that indicate insignificant investment and employment." It explained that "the terms 'significant' and 'substantial' refer to an increase in quantity, or to a benchmark in numbers," and that under the plain text of section 337 the question whether an investment in plant and equipment is significant calls for a quantitative analysis. The court reversed the Commission's final determination.

Lelo is the reason a domestic industry case needs an economist or accountant. Someone has to find the dollars and the employees, tie them to the protected articles, and compare them with a benchmark that the Commission can accept.

Do sales, marketing, warehousing and distribution count as labor or capital?

Yes, since Lashify (2025). The Federal Circuit held that clause (B) has no exclusion for labor spent on sales, marketing, warehousing, quality control or distribution, and that the Commission's contrary approach was counter to the statutory text.

Lashify relied on its sales, marketing, warehousing, quality control and distribution activities in the United States. The Commission had excluded those expenses, treating them as similar to those "incurred by mere importers." Judge Taranto, writing for a panel of Judges Prost, Taranto and Chen, rejected the exclusion.

The court wrote: "There is no exclusion from labor when the human activity employed is for sales, marketing, warehousing, quality control, or distribution, which are common aspects of providing goods or services." It added: "The Commission's holdings attribute limitations to clause (B) not found there," and "Accordingly, the Commission's approach is counter to the statutory text." The court found that the Commission's reliance on the importer comparison amounted to a domestic manufacturing requirement that Congress had rejected in 1988.

The disposition was "AFFIRMED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, AND REMANDED." The economic-prong determination was vacated for all three patents, and the case went back for the Commission to decide whether there is "significant employment of labor or capital" for the two design patents. On February 4, 2026, the same panel recalled the mandate to correct the opinion's statement of the standard of review and wrote that the correction "changes nothing about the case-specific analysis set forth or result reached in the opinion."

For the economic expert, Lashify widens the inputs. Payroll for sales and customer service staff, warehouse leases and logistics costs in the United States can now be counted under clause (B), as long as they relate to the protected articles and the expert can show they are significant in quantity.

What counts as investment in exploitation under clause (C)?

Investment focused on putting the patent into practice, which the statute says includes engineering, research and development, or licensing. Lashify contrasted that functional clause with the input-based clauses (A) and (B).

Clause (C) reads: "substantial investment in its exploitation, including engineering, research and development, or licensing." The word is "substantial," where clauses (A) and (B) use "significant," and the object is the exploitation of the patent rather than plant, equipment, labor or capital.

The Lashify court described clause (C) as one "which does not specify particular inputs but instead speaks only of a functionally defined enterprise activity," covering "efforts focused directly on putting a patent into practice." It observed: "That functional language is conspicuously missing from clauses (A) and (B)." The court did not decide whether Lashify met clause (C).

Clause (C) is where licensing companies and research-based firms make their case. The expert identifies engineering hours, research budgets or licensing activity directed at the asserted patent, separates them from work on other products, and states the amounts. The rule for the complaint asks for the same: substantial investment in the exploitation of the subject patent, including engineering, research and development, or licensing.

Can a complainant rely on an industry that is still being established?

Yes. Section 337(a)(2) covers an industry that exists or is in the process of being established, and the complaint must show active steps toward exploitation and a significant likelihood that the industry will be established.

Under 19 CFR 210.12(a)(6)(i)(B), a complaint alleging an industry in the process of being established gives "a detailed description of the relevant domestic industry that is in the process of being established including facts showing that complainant is actively engaged in the steps leading to the exploitation of its intellectual property rights and that there is a significant likelihood that an industry will be established in the future," with the relevant operations of any licensees.

The expert's material changes in this case. There may be no sales yet, so the analysis rests on committed spending: contracts, hiring plans carried out, equipment ordered, development milestones reached. The two questions are the ones the rule states: whether the complainant is actively taking the steps, and whether the industry is significantly likely to follow.

How does the domestic industry work in a trade secret case?

Trade secret cases arise under section 337(a)(1)(A), which requires a threat or effect of destroying or substantially injuring an industry in the United States. In TianRui (2011) the domestic industry did not have to use the secret process.

Section 337(a)(1)(A) reaches unfair methods of competition and unfair acts in importing articles where the effect is to "destroy or substantially injure an industry in the United States." The economic question there is injury to the domestic industry, in addition to its existence. Under 19 CFR 210.12(a)(6)(ii), the complaint includes "a detailed description of the domestic industry affected, including the relevant operations of any licensees."

TianRui Group Co. v. International Trade Commission, decided on October 11, 2011, concerned imported cast steel railway wheels and the domestic industry of the owner of a misappropriated trade secret. Judge Bryson wrote for the majority, and Judge Moore dissented. The administrative law judge had held "that it was not essential that the domestic industry use the proprietary process." The majority agreed, relied on evidence that the imported wheels could compete directly with wheels produced in the United States by the trade secret owner, and concluded: "In sum, we conclude that the Commission did not err in defining the domestic industry in this case."

For the expert, a trade secret case under (a)(1)(A) adds injury: lost sales, price effects or the threat of them in the domestic industry that competes with the imports.

How fast does a Section 337 investigation move, and who decides?

An administrative law judge holds the hearing, the Commission makes the final determination and must set a target date within 45 days after institution. Orders become final 60 days after issuance unless disapproved for policy reasons.

Under section 337(b)(1), the Commission must conclude its investigation "at the earliest practicable time" and, "within 45 days after an investigation is initiated, establish a target date for its final determination." The USITC page on Section 337 states that "The hearings are held before an administrative law judge (ALJ)" and that the parties include "the USITC attorney representing the public interest."

The remedies are orders, not money. Under section 337(d)(1), infringing articles may be excluded from entry into the United States, but before ordering exclusion the Commission considers the effect "upon the public health and welfare," among other public interest factors. Under section 337(f)(1), it may issue an order "directing such person to cease and desist from engaging in the unfair methods or acts involved."

Section 337(j)(2) gives the President 60 days to disapprove a determination "for policy reasons." The USITC page states that the orders "become final 60 days after issuance unless disapproved for policy reasons by the U.S. Trade Representative within that 60-day period."

The schedule shapes the expert's work. Domestic industry data must be ready when the complaint is filed and defended at the hearing, and the respondents' economic expert attacks the allocation of costs to the protected articles and the benchmark used to call them significant.

What does the economic expert put in a domestic industry analysis?

The domestic activities tied to the protected articles, with amounts in dollars and employees, the allocation method, the clause of section 337(a)(3) each item supports, and the benchmark against which the amounts are significant.

The analysis follows the statute. The expert lists the investments in plant and equipment, the employment of labor or capital and the investments in exploitation, and assigns each item to clause (A), (B) or (C). After Lashify, sales, marketing, warehousing, quality control and distribution labor belongs under clause (B).

Each item is tied to the articles protected by the patent. Where a facility or a team works on several products, the expert explains the allocation, for example by revenue, units or hours, and states why it is reasonable. Where licensees contribute, their operations are added with their own records, because the Commission's rule refers to the relevant operations of any licensees.

Lelo requires the result in numbers. The expert states the amounts and compares them with a benchmark: the complainant's total costs for the product, its worldwide activities, or the value added in the United States. The report explains why that comparison shows significance. Qualitative points, such as the importance of a domestic component, can support the numbers but, as Lelo held, cannot replace them.

The respondents' expert reviews the same records. The usual points of attack are costs that relate to other products, activities abroad counted as domestic, and benchmarks chosen to make small numbers look large.

How does IAE find a domestic industry expert for an ITC case?

In the request, choose the case type Intellectual property, name the ITC and describe the domestic industry work in the field line. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and prior testimony.

The IAE page on intellectual property expert witnesses lists six specialties, among them damages economists, and electrical and mechanical engineers and chemists from the patent's field who compare products with each claim element. A domestic industry case needs both: an economic expert for section 337(a)(3) and a technical expert who charts the complainant's own product against the patent.

The page notes that state courts and the PTAB apply their own rules to expert testimony, so the request names the forum. The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance. Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by the deadline. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. If no candidate fits, the second search is free.

The firm chooses the expert, who bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm: case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case