Expert report review

Land surveyor malpractice: what must the reviewing surveyor show?

A claim that a land surveyor got the line, the acreage or the house location wrong usually needs another surveyor to explain how the work fell short. Texas requires that surveyor's affidavit with the complaint, New Jersey within 60 days after the answer, Pennsylvania with the complaint or within 60 days after it. New York courts have also limited who may sue and for how long.

A surveyor in a reflective vest works a total station on a tripod beside a boundary post in a field

What does a claim against a land surveyor have to prove?

That the survey fell below the standard of care and that the shortfall caused the loss claimed. A New Jersey appellate court wrote that in a professional negligence case the standard of care is normally proven by expert testimony.

In Taylor v. DeLosso, 319 N.J. Super. 174, decided on March 9, 1999, the Appellate Division wrote: "In a professional negligence case, the standard of care must normally be established by expert testimony." The next sentence gave the reason: "This is so because a jury should not be allowed to speculate, without expert testimony, in an area where laypersons have insufficient knowledge or experience." The defendants in that case included a surveyor whose 1985 survey had located a thirty-inch maple tree, and the appeal turned on the architects' liability.

Claims against surveyors take several forms. In Gartrell v. Wren, decided by the Texas First Court of Appeals on December 8, 2011, the owners alleged that two surveys of their residential property, prepared in 2000 and 2001, falsely described the acreage, showed the house in the wrong place and included pipeline or other easements that did not exist. They sued in negligence and gross negligence.

In Pappas v. Haynes, decided by the Supreme Court of New York, Nassau County, on August 11, 2015, a buyer who had relied on a survey asserted five causes of action: breach of an agreement to provide an accurate survey, misrepresentation, negligence, a violation of General Business Law section 349 and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Whatever the label, the negligence theory rests on the standard of care, which Taylor said is normally proven by expert testimony.

Why does a claim against a surveyor need a second surveyor's review?

Because a judge or jury cannot measure survey practice without an expert. The reviewing surveyor compares the work with the standards in force, names the skipped step and explains how it moved the line, the area or the improvements.

The review produces two things a claimant needs. The first is the statement some states require at the start of the case, discussed below. The second is the expert testimony on the standard of care that Taylor described as normally required.

In Gartrell the claimants' affiant, a surveyor named Trusky, said that he had walked the property and prepared his own survey. The court held that "this statement provided the required factual basis" for the errors he attributed to the defendant. The court also held that a certificate of merit "need not include an express description of the applicable standard of care" to provide an adequate factual basis.

Pennsylvania's rule names the exception. Under Rule 1042.3(a)(3) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, the certificate of merit may state instead that "expert testimony of an appropriate licensed professional is unnecessary for prosecution of the claim." The other two options in Rule 1042.3(a) rest on a licensed professional's written statement or on the conduct of other professionals for whom the defendant is responsible.

Which states require a surveyor's affidavit at the start of the case?

Texas, New Jersey and Pennsylvania are three examples. Texas wants the affidavit filed with the complaint, New Jersey within 60 days after the answer, and Pennsylvania with the complaint or within 60 days after it.

Chapter 150 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code defines a "licensed or registered professional" to include a "registered professional land surveyor." Section 150.002(a) applies "in any action or arbitration proceeding for damages arising out of the provision of professional services," and under it "a claimant shall be required to file with the complaint an affidavit" of a third-party licensed professional. Gartrell applied the section to a surveyor.

New Jersey's affidavit of merit statute lists the licensed persons it covers. Item (l) of N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-26 is a land surveyor licensed under the same 1938 act that licenses engineers. Under N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27 the plaintiff provides each defendant an affidavit "within 60 days following the date of filing of the answer to the complaint by the defendant."

Pennsylvania Rule 1042.1 governs professional liability claims against a "licensed professional," and item (c)(1)(vi) of that rule reads "an engineer or land surveyor." Under Rule 1042.3(a), the plaintiff's attorney or the plaintiff "shall file with the complaint or within sixty days after the filing of the complaint" a certificate of merit.

Other states set their own rules. The claimant's counsel checks the statute of the state where the survey was made before the complaint is filed, because in Texas the affidavit is due with the complaint itself.

Who can sign the certificate or affidavit of merit?

In Texas, a third-party surveyor with the same license as the defendant, licensed in Texas and practicing in the defendant's area. In New Jersey, a professional licensed in any state with particular expertise and no financial interest in the case.

Section 150.002(a) requires that the affiant "hold the same professional license or registration as the defendant" and practice in the defendant's area of practice, with testimony based on knowledge, skill, experience, education, training and practice. Section 150.002(b) adds that the affiant "shall be licensed or registered in this state" and actively engaged in practice. When Gartrell was decided in 2011, the statute required an affiant "knowledgeable in the area of practice of the defendant"; the current text speaks of practicing in that area.

Gartrell also answered an objection about independence. The defendant argued that the affiant had worked for the claimants before. The court wrote that "nothing in the statute expressly precludes" a third-party fact or expert witness from serving as the affiant.

In New Jersey the affiant "shall be licensed in this or any other state" and must have "particular expertise in the general area or specialty involved in the action," shown by "board certification" or by devoting the practice substantially to that area "for a period of at least five years." The affiant "shall have no financial interest in the outcome of the case under review," which does not bar him from serving as an expert witness.

In Pennsylvania the certificate of merit is signed by the attorney or the party, not by the surveyor. It states that "an appropriate licensed professional has supplied a written statement," and the surveyor's opinion is in that statement.

What must the reviewing surveyor's statement say?

In Texas, the error for each theory of recovery and its factual basis. In New Jersey and Pennsylvania, that there is a reasonable probability the work fell outside acceptable professional standards, with causation added in Pennsylvania.

Section 150.002(b) reads: "The affidavit shall set forth specifically for each theory of recovery for which damages are sought" the negligence, "if any, or other action, error, or omission of the licensed or registered professional," and the factual basis for each claim. A complaint for negligence and gross negligence, like the one in Gartrell, needs the error and its basis stated for each.

Under N.J.S.A. 2A:53A-27 the affidavit states that there is a reasonable probability that the care, skill or knowledge exercised in the work "fell outside acceptable professional or occupational standards or treatment practices."

Pennsylvania Rule 1042.3(a)(1) requires a written statement that "there exists a reasonable probability" that the care, skill or knowledge exercised "in the treatment, practice or work" that is the subject of the complaint "fell outside acceptable professional standards" and "that such conduct was a cause in bringing about the harm."

A review written for these purposes names the survey, its date and its client, lists the records and field evidence the reviewer examined, and states each departure with the measurement or document that proves it. Gartrell accepted a statement resting on the affiant's own survey of the same property.

What does the reviewer compare the survey with?

The state's surveying rules and the scope the client ordered. In Texas, board rules require adequate record research, connection of boundaries to monuments of record dignity and citation of adjoining record instruments on the drawing.

Title 22, section 138.85 of the Texas Administrative Code sets the rules for boundary construction. The surveyor must respect junior and senior rights, follow the footsteps of the original surveyor and follow the intent of the record. Under 138.85(3)(B) the surveyor undertakes "such research of adequate thoroughness to support the determination of the location of the boundaries." Under 138.85(3)(C), "All boundaries shall be connected to identifiable physical monuments related to corners of record dignity." Under 138.85(3)(D) the record instruments of adjoining properties are reviewed and cited on the drawing.

Section 138.91 governs the drawing, description and report. A description must "provide a definite and unambiguous identification of the location of such boundaries" and describe the monuments found or placed. Courses are referenced to an identifiable monumented line or to an established geodetic system, and the drawing notes the record monuments relied on to establish the corners.

The reviewer takes each rule in turn and records where the survey meets it and where it does not. Then the reviewer measures the effect. A missed adjoining deed may move a corner by inches or by feet, and the claim depends on which. For the errors alleged in Gartrell the effect is stated in acres, in the distance between the shown and the actual house location, and in the easements that should not appear on the plat.

What happens if the affidavit is missing or late?

In Texas the complaint is dismissed, possibly with prejudice, and the order can be appealed at once. New Jersey and Pennsylvania each permit an extension of up to 60 days for good cause.

Under section 150.002(e), failure to file the affidavit "shall result in dismissal" of the complaint against the defendant, and the dismissal "may be with prejudice." Under 150.002(f), an order granting or denying a motion to dismiss "is immediately appealable as an interlocutory order." Section 150.002(c) makes an exception when the limitations period will expire within 10 days of filing and the claimant alleges that the affidavit could not be prepared in time: the claimant then has 30 days after filing to supplement the pleadings, and the court may extend that period for good cause after a hearing.

In New Jersey, "The court may grant no more than one additional period, not to exceed 60 days," and only "upon a finding of good cause."

Pennsylvania Rule 1042.3(d) provides that the court, "upon good cause shown, shall extend the time for filing a certificate of merit" for up to sixty days. The motion must be filed by the thirtieth day after the notice of intention to enter judgment of non pros on a professional liability claim.

Licensing rules add their own consequences. In Colorado a licensed professional land surveyor must report to the board a malpractice claim that ends in a settlement or judgment, within sixty days of its effective date.

Can a neighbor who did not hire the surveyor bring the claim?

Not always. A New York appellate court dismissed neighbors' malpractice claims against a surveyor they had not hired, for lack of privity, and Pennsylvania's certificate rules cover claims by a patient or client of the professional.

In Walker v. Chiauzzi, 57 A.D.3d 1353, decided on December 31, 2008, the Appellate Division, Third Department, affirmed summary judgment for a licensed land surveyor. The plaintiffs were neighbors of the owners who had hired him, and they alleged that his survey was inaccurate. The court held that no privity of contract, "or the functional equivalent thereof," existed between the plaintiffs and the surveyor, and their negligence claims based on his survey failed.

Pennsylvania Rule 1042.1(a) defines its scope as a civil action in which a professional liability claim is asserted "by or on behalf of a patient or client of the licensed professional." A neighbor's claim against the other owner's surveyor falls outside that definition.

Texas section 150.002(a) is written more broadly. It applies to "any action or arbitration proceeding for damages arising out of the provision of professional services" and does not limit itself to claims by the client.

The neighbor's dispute over the line itself is with the adjoining owner. The same review of the survey can then support the neighbor's expert report on where the line runs.

How long after the survey can a claim be filed?

It depends on the state. In New York a malpractice claim must be filed within three years of completion of the survey, and Texas bars suits more than 10 years after completion, with two more years after a written claim.

In Pappas v. Haynes the court wrote: "An action for professional malpractice must be commenced within three years of the date of accrual," and "A claim accrues when the malpractice is committed, not when the client discovers it." The court applied CPLR 214(6). The survey had been issued on July 2, 2010, so the period ended on July 2, 2013. The buyer filed on April 15, 2015, and the malpractice claims were dismissed as time-barred.

Texas section 16.011 requires suit for damages caused by "an error in a survey" to be brought "not later than 10 years after the date the survey is completed" for surveys completed on or after September 1, 1989. If the claimant presents a written claim for damages to the surveyor during that period, the period is extended two years from the date the claim is presented. Subsection (c) states: "This section is a statute of repose and is independent of any other limitations period."

Under the rule stated in Pappas, the period starts when the survey is completed, whatever the date on which the error is found. It can expire while the boundary dispute with the neighbor is still pending, so the review that supports a claim against the surveyor is ordered while the period is open.

What does IAE do in a claim against a land surveyor?

For US cases IAE prepares expert reports on the line, overlaps and encroachments and reviews the opposing surveyor's report. The signed document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The surveyor collects the deeds, recorded plats and original field notes for the parcel and its neighbors, searches for the original monuments, measures with GNSS and a total station and compares measured bearings and distances with the calls in each deed. Both parties' descriptions are plotted on one map, the area of each overlap or gap is computed, and fences, driveways and buildings are located relative to the line.

When the other side's surveyor has disclosed a report, IAE checks that field notes, control points and record documents appear on the list of facts or data considered and that each opinion follows from them. The client sends the deeds, plats and any prior surveys with the request.

Every review answers six questions: whether the method fits the object and the questions and was followed at every stage; whether all objects, materials and questions were examined; whether the conclusions follow from the examination; whether the surveyor's education, specialty and experience match the subject; whether the report meets the form and procedure of the jurisdiction; and whether it can be relied on.

The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush. Specialists are members of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirm in the document that they have no interest in the outcome. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member