Examinations
Lost profits calculation methods: how does a forensic accountant build the number, and what do courts test?
A lost profits calculation projects the revenue a business would have earned without the harmful event and subtracts the costs it would have incurred to earn it. The benchmark can be the business's own history, another business or a model of the market. Two Seventh Circuit cases mark the boundary. In one, a dispute over the base period of a growth projection was left to the jury; in the other, a projection resting on expertise alone was excluded.

What does a lost profits calculation measure?
The net profit the business would have earned but for the harmful event: lost revenue minus the costs it would have spent to earn that revenue. Costs the business keeps paying anyway are treated separately.
The calculation starts from a counterfactual: what the business would have earned if the breach, the tort or the loss had not happened. The difference between that figure and what the business actually earned is the lost revenue. Lost profit is what remains after the costs that the business would have incurred to earn that revenue, and saved because it did not earn it, are deducted.
Manpower, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of the State of Pennsylvania, decided by the Seventh Circuit on October 16, 2013, shows the arithmetic in an insurance policy. Part of a building at 65 rue de la Victoire in Paris collapsed on June 15, 2006. The offices of Manpower's subsidiary Right Management were not physically damaged, but the Paris public safety department barred occupancy. Under the master policy, the loss was "the net profit lost because of the business" interruption, adjusted for costs and expenses paid during the interruption period that "would have been paid even if no loss had occurred," which the opinion calls continuing expenses.
The forensic accountant, Eric Sullivan, computed the loss by "calculating lost revenues minus non continuing expenses" and estimated the business interruption loss at 5,125,830 euros, within a total of 7,503,576 euros that included extra expenses. The structure is the same in a contract or tort case: a revenue projection, a list of the costs that would have varied with that revenue, and a period over which the loss runs.
How does the before-and-after method work?
It uses the business's own results before the event, and sometimes after it, as the benchmark for the damage period. In growth rate extrapolation the accountant measures growth in a base period and applies it to the damage period.
In Manpower, Sullivan projected Right Management's revenue for the period of the interruption with growth rate extrapolation. He compared revenue for January through May 2006, the five months before the collapse, with the same months of 2005 and derived a growth rate of 7.76 percent. The Seventh Circuit wrote that Sullivan "applied an accepted methodology (growth rate extrapolation)."
The method rests on one assumption the accountant must defend: that the base period represents what the business would have done during the damage period. The before period can be the months right before the event, a longer history, or both sides of the event when the business recovered later. Each choice moves the result, which is why the base period was the whole fight in Manpower.
After the projection, the accountant subtracts the costs that would have been incurred to earn the projected revenue. Expenses that continue regardless of revenue are handled according to the measure of loss the case uses. In Manpower the policy itself adjusted the loss for continuing expenses.
Who decides whether the base period fits?
The jury, if the method is reliable. In Manpower the Seventh Circuit held that the choice of data inputs is separate from the reliability of the methodology and vacated the exclusion of the accountant's opinion.
Sullivan had data back to 2003 but chose the short period because Right's managers attributed a turnaround to "the recent acquisition of Right by Manpower and the enactment of new policies," changes that had "turned the company around by the end of 2005." The district court excluded his opinion. It wrote that "Sullivan is not an expert on business management," found that he "did little more than assume" recent growth would continue, and noted "a negative average annual growth rate of 4.79% during the period of 2003 to 2009." Without the testimony Manpower could not prove business interruption damages, and the insurer won summary judgment on that claim.
The Seventh Circuit, in an opinion by Judge Tharp of the Northern District of Illinois sitting by designation, vacated the exclusion and reversed the summary judgment on the business interruption claim. It wrote that "the selection of data inputs to employ in a model is a question separate from the reliability of the methodology" and that "Whether Sullivan selected the best data set to use, however, is a question for the jury, not the judge." In its view "the district court set the bar too high" and exercised its gatekeeping role "with too much vigor." The remedy for weak inputs is in the trial: "Our system relies on cross examination to alert the jury" to them.
For the accountant, the lesson is in the record. Sullivan's report gave a reason for the base period, the managers' account of the turnaround, and the reason was testable against the 2003-2009 data. A report that tests the result against other base periods and explains the choice gives the court a methodology to review and the jury a dispute about inputs.
Can lost profits be projected from another company's results?
Yes, but the comparison has to be tested. In Zenith v. WH-TV the expert projected a broadcaster's growth from DirecTV's growth in San Juan without data from other markets, and the court excluded the projection.
Comparison methods, often called yardstick methods, take the benchmark from another business, another location or the market instead of the plaintiff's own history. A plaintiff with little history of its own, such as a new business, has no other benchmark to offer. The question the court asks is whether the comparison is close enough and whether the differences have been accounted for.
Zenith Electronics Corp. v. WH-TV Broadcasting Corp., decided by the Seventh Circuit on January 20, 2005 in an opinion by Judge Easterbrook, involved a digital television broadcaster in San Juan, Puerto Rico, that bought set-top boxes from Zenith. WH-TV wanted boxes meeting the DVB standard; Zenith meant the 1995 version and WH-TV assumed the 1998 version. WH-TV counterclaimed for lost profits. Its expert, Peter Shapiro, projected rapid growth for WH-TV that paralleled DirecTV's growth in San Juan from 2002 through 2008. He did not use DirecTV's data from other markets or MMDS data from other markets and called San Juan "unique."
The court wrote that the estimate "must be testable" and that "Someone else using the same data and methods must be able to replicate the result." It pointed to standard tools such as "the multivariate regression" that can account for differences between markets. A comparison with one company in one market, with no adjustment for the differences, gave the court nothing to test.
What happens when the expert's projection has no method behind it?
It is excluded. In Zenith the expert answered questions about his method with variants of "my expertise," and the Seventh Circuit upheld the exclusion: an expert who supplies only a bottom line supplies nothing of value.
Asked at his deposition what methods he had used, Shapiro repeatedly answered with variants of "my expertise." The court wrote that "Shapiro's method, 'expert intuition,' is neither normal among social scientists nor testable" and that "He was relying on intuition, which won't do." It repeated a line from its earlier decision in Mid-State Fertilizer: "An expert who supplies nothing but a bottom line supplies nothing of value to the judicial process." Of Shapiro's extrapolation it wrote, quoting the Supreme Court's decision in Joiner, that the court need not admit opinion evidence "connected to existing data only by the ipse dixit of the expert."
The plaintiff's own business plans fared no better. The court found that WH-TV's internal projections "rest on its say-so rather than a statistical analysis" and described them as "hopes rather than the results of scientific analysis." The district court's exclusion under Rule 702 was affirmed, and Zenith prevailed.
The two Seventh Circuit cases set out the line. In Manpower the accountant used a recognized method and the fight was over an input; the jury decides that. In Zenith the expert had no method that anyone else could repeat; the judge excludes that.
What does Rule 702 require of a lost profits model?
That the opinion will assist the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data and applies reliable methods reliably, each more likely than not. The 2023 amendment put that burden expressly on the proponent.
Under Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence a qualified expert may testify if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion is a reliable application of those principles and methods to the facts of the case. The committee note to the 2023 amendment states that the rule was amended to clarify and emphasize that expert testimony may not be admitted unless the proponent makes that showing.
Manpower was decided in 2013, before the amendment. It quoted Rule 702(b), "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data," and described Daubert as "essentially codified in the current version of Rule 702." A lost profits model offered today has to meet each element of the amended rule, and the proponent should be ready to prove that the base data are sufficient as well as that the method is accepted.
Rule 703 covers the facts the model is built on. An expert may rely on facts or data that experts in the field would reasonably rely on, even if those facts are not admissible themselves. Management interviews, internal budgets and industry data fall here, and the report should say which of them the projection uses and how each was checked.
Which assumptions behind the calculation will the other side see?
Facts or data that counsel supplied and the expert considered, and assumptions counsel supplied and the expert relied on, are discoverable. Other communications between counsel and a retained expert are protected.
Rule 26(b)(4)(C) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure protects communications between a party's attorney and a retained expert, but not to the extent they "relate to compensation for the expert's study or testimony," "identify facts or data that the party's attorney provided and that the expert considered," or "identify assumptions that the party's attorney provided and that the expert relied on."
A lost profits model usually depends on several such assumptions: the length of the damage period, the date the business would have opened, the volume of a lost contract, the share of a market. Each one supplied by counsel or by management is disclosed and can be attacked. In Manpower the district court's criticism that the accountant relied on managers rather than on his own analysis was an attack on exactly that kind of input.
The report itself follows Rule 26(a)(2)(B): a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, the exhibits that will summarize or support them, the witness's qualifications, the cases of the previous 4 years in which the witness testified, and the compensation. For a lost profits model the exhibits are the projection schedules, the base data and the cost analysis.
What should a lost profits report show so the court can test it?
The benchmark and why it was chosen, the alternatives tested, the costs deducted and why they vary with revenue, the damage period, and enough data for another accountant to replicate the result.
The Zenith test of replication sets the minimum: someone else using the same data and methods must be able to reach the same number. That means the report gives the source of every input, the formula, the period and the adjustments, and attaches the schedules.
The Manpower dispute adds a second requirement: the base period is explained and tested. A report that shows the result under the chosen period and under the longer history, and explains why the chosen one represents the damage period, turns a possible exclusion motion into a cross-examination about facts.
The costs are the third. Lost revenue is not lost profit. The report lists the costs the business would have incurred to earn the projected revenue and the costs it kept paying, and treats each as the governing measure of loss requires. A report on the other side that skips this step, or deducts costs that do not vary with revenue, is one of the first things a review checks.
What does IAE do when a case turns on a lost profits calculation?
A forensic accountant from the IAE registry writes an expert report on your questions or a review of the opposing expert's damages report, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE forensic accounting service covers lost profits and other damages, solvency on the date of a transfer, and tracing of funds in commercial, bankruptcy and partnership disputes. The expert rebuilds lost profits from ledgers and tax returns, and the questions are framed from the ledgers, tax returns and bank statements in the record and confirmed before work starts. Assumptions that counsel supplied and the expert relied on are discoverable under FRCP 26(b)(4)(C)(iii).
Send the opposing damages report if there is one, the financial statements, ledgers and tax returns for the base period and the damage period, the contract or the policy that defines the loss, and the disclosure deadlines. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and you approve the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix; the Member ID in the document can be checked by QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. Neither IAE nor the specialist guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- Manpower, Inc. v. Insurance Co. of the State of Pennsylvania, No. 12-2688 (7th Cir. Oct. 16, 2013) (Justia)
- Zenith Electronics Corp. v. WH-TV Broadcasting Corp., Nos. 04-1635, 04-1790 (7th Cir. Jan. 20, 2005) (FindLaw)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with committee notes (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 703, Bases of an Expert (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Preference claim in bankruptcy: how does a forensic accountant test the ordinary course and new value defenses?
A vendor paid in the 90 days before its customer's bankruptcy can be sued for the money under 11 U.S.C. 547. The defenses are arithmetic. In Sparrer
Ponzi scheme clawbacks: how does a forensic accountant calculate who is a net winner and how much must be returned?
When a Ponzi scheme collapses, the receiver or trustee sues investors who took out more than they put in. The figure in each claim comes from
Forensic accountant in a divorce: how are hidden income and assets found under Florida law?
In a Florida divorce each spouse must serve a financial affidavit, three years of tax returns, twelve months of bank and brokerage statementsExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

