Expert report review

Lost or obliterated corner: how does a reviewer check the opposing surveyor's corner restoration?

A corner whose monument is gone is either obliterated or lost, and the answer moves the line. An obliterated corner goes back to its original spot on the strength of accessories, field-note calls and testimony. A lost corner is restored by proportionate measurement from other corners. In Cornia v. Putnam the Utah Supreme Court reversed a boundary judgment in 1971 because the trial court never decided which of the two the missing corner was.

A surveyor kneels by a shallow hole where a corner stone is missing

What is the difference between an existent, an obliterated and a lost corner?

An existent corner is identified from its monument or accessories. An obliterated corner has no traces left but can still be recovered beyond reasonable doubt. A lost corner cannot, and is restored from other corners.

The Bureau of Land Management states the three classes in Restoration of Lost or Obliterated Corners and Subdivision of Sections, a 1974 supplement to its Manual of Surveying Instructions reprinted by the Government Printing Office in 1979. "An existent corner is one whose position can be identified by verifying the evidence of the monument, or its accessories." A corner also counts as existent when its point can be located from an acceptable supplemental survey record, physical evidence or testimony.

"An obliterated corner is one at whose point there are no remaining traces of the monument, or its accessories," but whose location has been perpetuated or can be recovered beyond reasonable doubt. "A lost corner is a point of a survey whose position cannot be determined, beyond reasonable doubt," and it can be restored only by reference to one or more interdependent corners.

The Interior Board of Land Appeals applied the same definitions, citing paragraphs 5-5, 5-9 and 5-20 of the Manual, in Robert W. Delzell and Betty Simpson, 158 IBLA 238, decided on January 29, 2003. State courts draw the same line. The Utah Supreme Court wrote in Cornia v. Putnam that "An obliterated corner may be defined as one where no visible evidence remains" of the original surveyor's work, and cited its 1937 decision in Henrie v. Hyer for the definition of a lost corner.

Why does the classification change where the boundary runs?

Because each class has its own method. An obliterated corner is put back where the evidence places the original, while a lost corner is placed by proportionate measurement between other corners, which can land somewhere else.

For a lost corner the BLM guide prescribes proportionate measurement from interdependent corners. In Cornia v. Putnam the Utah Supreme Court quoted the 1963 edition of the same guide: "A lost interior corner of four sections will be restored by double proportionate measurement." An obliterated corner needs no such computation, because its original position is recovered from the evidence.

The difference can be measured on the ground. In Cornia the defendant's surveyor asked local landowners, who said the monument had stood where a fence corner now is, and then used a single proportionate measurement to locate a sixteenth corner. He placed the sixteenth corner 22 feet west of the fence line and testified that he would still treat the fence line as the actual dividing line.

The guide sets the order of work. Before resorting to proportionate measurement for restoration of lost corners, "the other calls of the field notes should be considered," and its retracement steps place proportionate measurement third, after the physical and collateral evidence has been checked and the corner has been found lost. A report that goes straight to proportionate measurement skips the first two steps.

When may a surveyor treat a corner as lost?

Only after every means of identifying the original position has been tried. The BLM guide says a corner is not lost if a witness with dependable knowledge of the original location can still place it.

"Decision that a corner is lost should not be made until every means has been exercised that might aid in identifying its true original position," the 1974 supplement states. It adds that a corner is not lost if its position can be recovered through the testimony of one or more witnesses who have dependable knowledge of the original location.

California's Third District Court of Appeal applied the same order in Reid v. Dunn on March 20, 1962. The Calaveras County Surveyor, hired by the defendants, had found two section corners lost and reset them by double proportionate measurement. The appellants argued that the corners were existent or at most obliterated. Citing Cragin v. Powell and California decisions, the court said that corners should be reestablished wherever possible by the natural objects called for in the original field notes, and that the proportional method must not be used unless the line cannot be retraced that way. The surveyor had found discrepancies of 300 to 700 feet between the field-note distances and the ground and testified that the corners could not be fixed by the natural objects in the notes. The court accepted that the corners were lost and affirmed the judgment.

Before the Interior Board of Land Appeals the burden fell on the party who claimed an original monument. In Delzell a BLM dependent resurvey approved on April 19, 1989 treated a section corner set in 1882 as lost and restored it by double proportionate measurement. Landowners argued that a stone found in 1981 was the original. The Board compared the stone, 24 by 7 by 5 inches with no notches or mound, with the 17 by 11 by 5 inches recorded in the 1882 field notes. It held that a corner is regarded as lost where the appellant fails to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that the monument is original, and that "a difference of opinion or speculation" is not enough.

Which evidence can recover an obliterated corner?

Accessories such as bearing trees and pits, field-note calls to line trees and natural objects, buried marked stones, later survey records and testimony of witnesses. Fences and roads count only with supporting evidence behind them.

The BLM supplement names the acts and testimony of interested landowners, competent surveyors or other qualified local authorities, and of witnesses, as ways in which a corner's position is perpetuated or recovered. Field notes record the species and diameter of bearing trees and line trees, and agreement with the recorded distances to natural objects, stream crossings, line trees and off-line tree blazes supports a position on the ground. When roads were built, corner positions were often preserved by buried marked stones or other durable material, and the supplement calls these exceptionally important evidence of the position of the corner, when duly recovered and verified.

Fences get a warning. According to the supplement, a surveyor should not accept the location of roads and fences as prima facie evidence of the original survey without supporting evidence, such as an intervening survey record or the testimony of people acquainted with the facts. In Cornia the defendant's own surveyor computed a sixteenth corner 22 feet west of the fence line that landowners had pointed to.

Some states define accessories by statute. In the 2021 Florida Statutes, section 177.503(6) defines a corner accessory as "any exclusively identifiable physical object whose spatial relationship to the corner is recorded" and lists bearing trees, bearing objects, monuments, reference monuments, line trees, pits, mounds, blaze marks and steel or wooden stakes among them.

What did the court do in Cornia v. Putnam when the surveyors disagreed?

The Utah Supreme Court reversed and ordered a new trial, because the trial court never decided whether the missing corner of Section 22 was lost or obliterated, the question on which the two sets of surveys turned.

The dispute was over the southwest corner of Section 22, once marked by a sandstone monument that had disappeared. Cornia sued to make Putnam remove a fence, and Putnam counterclaimed to have the boundary fixed. The plaintiff's two surveyors ran courses and distances from government monuments still in place, one starting at a Section 16 corner and the other at a Section 33 corner. One of them admitted that he did "not arrive at the southwest corner of Section 22 by following the field notes." The defendant's surveyors followed Bureau of Land Management procedures.

Chief Justice Callister wrote for the court on October 15, 1971 that "the primary issue is whether the southwest corner of Section 22 is obliterated or lost" and that "the trial court failed to determine whether the southwest corner of Section 22 was lost or obliterated." The court also noted that the trial court made no findings on the parties' claims of boundary by acquiescence. The judgment was reversed and the case remanded for a new trial. The citation is 26 Utah 2d 354, 489 P.2d 1001.

Justice Ellett dissented. In his view the field notes left no doubt or uncertainty, the location of the line was for the trial court under the evidence, and a new trial would impose an undue hardship. A reviewer puts the majority's question to any restoration: which class did the surveyor assign to the corner, and on what evidence?

Which records show how the opposing surveyor classified and restored the corner?

The original field notes and plat, the surveyor's own field notes and computations, any corner record filed with the state, and the facts or data listed in the expert report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B).

In Florida a certified corner record is "a document prepared by a surveyor and mapper when a public land survey corner is used as control in his or her survey or resurvey" (section 177.503(9), Florida Statutes 2021). The instruction manual of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection says that such records have been required since 1977 and are filed within 90 days after the survey is complete. The form asks whether the corner is existing, obliterated or lost, describes the evidence found and the method used, and lists at least three accessories in the immediate vicinity of the corner, each with a bearing and a distance in feet.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires the report of a retained testifying expert to contain a complete statement of all opinions with the basis and reasons for them and the facts or data considered in forming them. For a restored corner these include the original field notes the surveyor compared with the ground, the evidence he searched for and found, the witnesses he interviewed and the computations of any proportionate measurement.

When the review needs to see the corner itself, Rule 34(a)(2) lets a party request entry onto land that the other party possesses or controls to inspect, measure, survey and photograph it. The request specifies a reasonable time, place and manner, and the written response is due within 30 days after service.

What does a review of a corner restoration check?

Whether the surveyor classified the corner before choosing a method, what he searched for and found, whether he followed the field notes, and whether proportionate measurement came only after the evidence ran out.

The reviewer reads the opposing report with its plats, field notes and computations and tests each disputed corner against the definitions and decisions above.

Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence in its current text requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data and is the product of reliable principles and methods, reliably applied. A restoration that declares a corner lost without a recorded search for the evidence that the field notes call for gives the reviewer a specific point under Rule 702(b): the facts the method itself requires were never gathered.

  • The reviewer checks that the report states for each disputed corner whether it is existent, obliterated or lost, and why.
  • The reviewer compares any monument or stone found with its description in the original field notes, as the Interior Board of Land Appeals did with the dimensions of the stone in Delzell.
  • The reviewer checks whether the surveyor searched for accessories, line trees and other field-note calls before treating the corner as lost.
  • The reviewer looks for interviews with landowners and earlier surveyors, because testimony from a witness with dependable knowledge can keep a corner from being lost.
  • The reviewer checks that a fence or road used as evidence of a corner has a survey record or testimony of people acquainted with the facts behind it.
  • The reviewer recomputes any proportionate measurement from the corners the surveyor accepted and states how far the result lies from the fence or other line on the ground.

What does IAE do when the opposing survey restores a missing corner?

IAE prepares a review of the opposing surveyor's report, a rebuttal survey report and deposition questions for boundary, quiet title and encroachment cases, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The reviewer checks which records the survey used, which monuments it found and how its measurements compare with the record. For a restored corner that means the class assigned to the corner, the evidence searched for and found, and the computations of any proportionate measurement.

A rebuttal report is due within 30 days after the opposing disclosure unless the court sets other dates. The client sends the opposing survey with its field notes, plats and record documents, together with any corner records filed for the disputed corners.

IAE is not a law firm, and case strategy stays with the client's attorney. A review is evidence, and the court decides how much weight to give it.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member