Expert report review
Machinery and equipment appraisal review: what does a reviewer check in the opposing appraisal?
An appraisal of machinery, equipment or other personal property is tested first against the question the law asks. A Chapter 13 plan values a truck at replacement value under 11 U.S.C. 506(a)(2), a secured lender's sale is judged by UCC 9-627, an estate reports household effects under 26 CFR 20.2031-6, and a charitable deduction needs a qualified appraisal under 26 CFR 1.170A-17. The reviewer then checks the item list, the condition, the method and the appraiser's field.

Which value does the case require for equipment or personal property?
The value set by the rule that governs the dispute. Bankruptcy values collateral in light of the purpose of the valuation, estate tax uses fair market value, and a secured party's sale is tested for commercial reasonableness.
Under 11 U.S.C. 506(a)(1) the value of a creditor's interest is determined in light of the purpose of the valuation and of the proposed disposition or use of the property. For an individual debtor in Chapter 7 or Chapter 13, section 506(a)(2) fixes the standard for personal property securing an allowed claim: replacement value as of the date of the petition, without deduction for costs of sale or marketing. For property acquired for personal, family or household purposes, replacement value is the price a retail merchant would charge for property of that kind, considering its age and condition at the time value is determined.
Estate tax asks a different question. Under 26 CFR 20.2031-6(a) household and personal effects are valued at fair market value, the price at which the property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither under compulsion and both with reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts.
The first line of a review compares the premise in the opposing appraisal with the premise the case needs. An appraisal of equipment prepared for an auction, a loan or insurance answers its own client's question. Offered in a 506(a)(2) dispute, it measures something the statute does not ask for, however carefully the numbers were derived.
Did the appraiser identify each item and its condition?
A qualified appraisal under 26 CFR 1.170A-17 describes the property in sufficient detail and states the physical condition of tangible personal property, the valuation effective date and the fair market value on that date.
Section 1.170A-17(a)(3)(i) lists four items about the property itself: a description in sufficient detail, the condition of real or tangible personal property, the valuation effective date and the fair market value on that date. Section 1.170A-17(a)(7) requires a separate appraisal for each item of property unless it is part of a group of similar items. These rules were written for charitable deductions, but they describe what any appraisal of a machine needs before its value can be checked.
The estate tax regulation goes further into detail. A room-by-room itemization is desirable, each article named and valued separately, and articles in one room may be grouped only if none of them is valued over $100 (26 CFR 20.2031-6(a)). Paragraph (d) adds instructions for specific classes: paintings are described by size, subject and artist, oriental rugs by size, make and general condition, silverware is weighed in troy ounces, and books in sets by standard authors are listed in separate groups.
For equipment the same discipline means a make, model, serial number, year and hours or mileage for each unit. A reviewer matches each line of the opposing list to the asset register, the invoices and the photographs. A machine valued from a schedule without an inspection, or a group of machines valued as one lot, is a point the review states and ties to the item it affects.
Which method did the appraiser use, and is the basis stated?
The appraisal names the approach and the specific basis for the value. Section 1.170A-17 lists the income approach, the market-data approach and replacement cost less depreciation, and requires the basis, such as comparable sales.
Section 1.170A-17(a)(3)(viii) requires the method of valuation used, for example the income approach, the market-data approach or the replacement-cost-less-depreciation approach. Item (ix) requires the specific basis for the valuation, such as specific comparable sales transactions or statistical sampling, with a justification and an explanation. The regulation also requires that a qualified appraisal be prepared under the substance and principles of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice developed by the Appraisal Standards Board of the Appraisal Foundation (1.170A-17(a)(2)).
A market-data appraisal of used equipment stands on its comparables. The reviewer asks where each sale was found, its date, the condition and configuration of the machine sold and the adjustment made for each difference. A replacement-cost appraisal stands on the cost of a new equivalent and on the deductions for physical deterioration and obsolescence. Each deduction is a figure with a source or an assumption, and the review lists those that have neither.
The effective date matters as much as the method. Under 506(a)(2) it is the date of the petition. For a charitable deduction, under 1.170A-17(a)(5), a report dated before the gift uses an effective date no earlier than 60 days before the contribution and no later than its date. Prices of used equipment move, and comparables from another period need an explanation and an adjustment.
Does the price paid for equipment settle its value?
Not by itself. In JD Norman Industries v. City of Leslie the Michigan Court of Appeals wrote in 2015 that the selling price of property is not conclusive evidence of its value.
JD Norman Industries bought industrial equipment in November 2011 in an asset purchase of Len Industries, an automotive supplier that was losing money, and appealed the 2012 assessment of the equipment. The assessor had set a true cash value of $6,219,900 using historic cost less depreciation, and the taxpayer argued for a value based on its purchase price. The Michigan Tax Tribunal excluded one appraisal as unduly repetitious of other evidence. In an unpublished per curiam opinion of June 23, 2015, No. 321314, the Court of Appeals affirmed.
The court wrote that the selling price of a particular piece of property is not conclusive evidence of its value, that the price here had to be viewed in the context of the purchase of a whole business from a struggling company, and that the taxpayer had offered only vague and conclusory statements that the state of the automotive industry affected the value of the equipment. For a reviewer the case sets the order of proof: the price of a whole business does not by itself give the value of each machine in it, and an appraiser who relies on an allocation of that price has to support the allocation with market data.
A review of an appraisal built on a purchase price checks three things: how the price was allocated among the assets, whether the sale was between unrelated parties under no compulsion, and whether the appraisal tested the allocated figure against market data for comparable machines.
How is a secured lender's sale of equipment tested?
By commercial reasonableness under UCC 9-627. A disposition in the usual manner on a recognized market, at the current price in that market or in conformity with dealers' reasonable practices is commercially reasonable.
When a lender repossesses and sells equipment, the debtor's deficiency depends on the sale. UCC 9-627(a) provides that the fact that a greater amount could have been obtained at a different time or by a different method is not of itself sufficient to preclude the secured party from establishing that it acted in a commercially reasonable manner. Under 9-627(b) a disposition is commercially reasonable if it is made in the usual manner on any recognized market, at the price current in any recognized market at the time of the disposition, or otherwise in conformity with reasonable commercial practices among dealers in the type of property.
Approval by a court, a bona fide creditors' committee, a creditors' representative or an assignee for the benefit of creditors makes a disposition commercially reasonable (9-627(c)), but approval need not be obtained, and its absence does not make the disposition unreasonable (9-627(d)).
Section 9-615(f) deals with insider sales. When the buyer is the secured party, a person related to it or a secondary obligor, and the proceeds are significantly below the range a complying sale to an outside buyer would have brought, the surplus or deficiency is calculated on the amount such a sale would have realized. That makes the value of the equipment a contested fact, and the appraisal of that range is the evidence a review tests.
What does an estate need for art, jewelry and collections?
An expert appraisal under oath filed with the estate tax return when articles of marked artistic or intrinsic value total more than $3,000, with the executor's statement on the appraiser's disinterest and qualifications.
Under 26 CFR 20.2031-6(b), if the household and personal effects include articles of marked artistic or intrinsic value with a total value over $3,000, the appraisal of an expert, made under oath, is filed with the return. The regulation gives examples: jewelry, furs, silverware, paintings, etchings, engravings, antiques, books, statuary, vases, oriental rugs and coin or stamp collections. The executor adds a written statement, under penalties of perjury, on the completeness of the itemized list and on the disinterested character and qualifications of the appraiser.
Paragraph (c) covers sales before the IRS looks at the property. If the executor wants to distribute or sell effects before an investigation, the district director is informed, with a sworn appraisal and the executor's statement, so that the IRS can inspect before the property is gone.
Paragraph (d) states that appraisers should be reputable and competent in the specific class of property. A furniture dealer valuing a coin collection, or a general equipment appraiser valuing paintings, gives the review its first question before any figure is read.
Is the opposing appraiser qualified for this type of property?
The test in 26 CFR 1.170A-17(b) is verifiable education and experience in valuing the type of property appraised: coursework in valuing that type plus two years of experience, or a recognized appraiser designation for it.
Section 1.170A-17(b)(1) defines a qualified appraiser as an individual with verifiable education and experience in valuing the type of property being appraised. Under (b)(2) the individual has either successfully completed professional or college-level coursework in valuing that type of property and has at least two years of experience valuing it, or holds a recognized appraiser designation for that type of property. The type of property is the category customarily valued by appraisers in the field (b)(3), and the appraisal states the appraiser's education and experience and declares that the appraiser is qualified (b)(4).
The regulation also lists who may not appraise. Excluded are the donor, the donee, a party to the transaction in which the donor acquired the property, with a narrow exception, persons related to them, and an appraiser barred from practice before the IRS during the three years ending on the signing date (1.170A-17(b)(5)). An appraisal fee based on the appraised value is prohibited (1.170A-17(a)(9)).
A litigation review uses these rules as a checklist even outside a tax case: field of property, coursework, years of experience in that field, designation, and any tie to a party or to the result.
What does a review of the opposing equipment appraisal contain?
A list of departures tied to the governing rule and to the record: the wrong premise of value, missing items or conditions, an unstated basis for adjustments, the wrong effective date and gaps in the appraiser's qualifications.
The review follows the order of the appraisal under review. For each conclusion it states what the appraisal says, which document in the record supports or contradicts it and which rule or standard the point rests on. A point without a document or a rule behind it stays out of the review.
Where the opposing appraiser used a premise the case does not require, the review says which premise applies, under 506(a)(2), 20.2031-6 or 9-627, and what changes. Where items are missing or grouped, it lists them by serial number. Where comparables cannot be traced, it names each one. The same list becomes the outline for questions to the appraiser at deposition.
What does IAE do when the opposing party relies on an equipment or personal property appraisal?
An appraiser from the IAE registry reviews the opposing appraisal against USPAP Standards 3 and 4 or prepares a rebuttal valuation report, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE valuation review is written for attorneys facing the other side's appraisal. The reviewer recomputes the opposing valuation step by step, writes a rebuttal report under Rule 26 or Tax Court Rule 143 and turns the findings into questions for the appraiser's deposition. Under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 the review gives an opinion on the quality of the opposing appraisal: comparables, adjustments, discount rate, effective date and the support for each conclusion. The page names appraisals of real property, businesses and ownership interests; for equipment or other personal property the client describes the property and the task in the request.
The client sends the appraisal or the case materials. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The report under review, the property and the valuation date are confirmed before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, and the Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- 11 U.S.C. 506, Determination of secured status (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 26 CFR 20.2031-6, Valuation of household and personal effects (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 26 CFR 1.170A-17, Qualified appraisal and qualified appraiser (LII, Cornell Law School)
- UCC 9-615, Application of proceeds of disposition; liability for deficiency (LII, Cornell Law School)
- UCC 9-627, Determination of whether conduct was commercially reasonable (LII, Cornell Law School)
- JD Norman Industries v. City of Leslie, Michigan Court of Appeals, No. 321314, June 23, 2015 (opinion text)
Read also
All articles
Partition action appraisal: how is a co-owner's share valued for a buyout, and how is the court-ordered appraisal challenged?
In a partition action one co-owner asks the court to sell or divide the property, and the others may want to buy that share. Under the partition acts
Low appraisal on a mortgage: how does a reconsideration of value work, and what evidence does the lender accept?
When an appraisal comes in below the contract price, the borrower can ask the lender for a reconsideration of value. Five federal agencies issued
Deficiency judgment after foreclosure: how is fair market value set, and how is the lender's appraisal reviewed?
After a foreclosure sale the lender's claim for the rest of the debt turns on one figure: the fair market value of the property on the sale date. NewExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

