Expert report review

Medical expert in a criminal case against a physician: what does the defense reviewer check?

When a physician is prosecuted in federal court for prescribing controlled substances, the government's medical expert testifies about the usual course of professional practice. Since Ruan v. United States (2022), the government must also prove that the physician knowingly or intentionally acted without authorization. Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure requires a complete, signed disclosure of the expert's opinions and reasons, and a defense physician reviews each opinion against the patient files.

A white coat hangs by an empty courtroom chair, a closed chart and a stethoscope on the rail, no faces.

What makes a prescription a federal crime?

A prescription for a controlled substance is lawful only if a practitioner issues it for a legitimate medical purpose in the usual course of professional practice. Outside those limits it is not a prescription under the Controlled Substances Act.

Section 841(a) of title 21 of the U.S. Code makes it unlawful, except as authorized, for any person knowingly or intentionally to manufacture, distribute or dispense a controlled substance. A licensed physician registered to prescribe is authorized, within limits set by regulation.

The limits are in 21 CFR 1306.04(a). A prescription for a controlled substance, to be effective, "must be issued for a legitimate medical purpose by an individual practitioner acting in the usual course of his professional practice." The regulation places a corresponding responsibility on the pharmacist who fills it. An order issued not in the usual course of professional treatment is not a prescription within the meaning of section 309 of the Act, and the person issuing it is subject to the penalties for violations of the law relating to controlled substances.

The usual course of professional practice is a medical question. That is why both sides in these prosecutions call physicians: the government's expert describes what the usual course required and where the defendant departed from it, and the defense physician tests that description against the charts.

What did Ruan v. United States decide about the physician's state of mind?

That the words knowingly or intentionally in section 841 apply to the exception for authorized conduct. Once the defense produces evidence of authorization, the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the physician knowingly or intentionally acted without it.

The Supreme Court decided Ruan v. United States together with Kahn v. United States on June 27, 2022. Both petitioners were physicians licensed to prescribe controlled substances and were convicted under section 841 of prescribing outside the authorized scope. Ruan was sentenced to more than 20 years in prison, and Kahn to 25 years.

Justice Breyer wrote for six justices: "§841's 'knowingly or intentionally' mens rea applies to the 'except as authorized' clause." After a defendant produces evidence that he or she was authorized to dispense, the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knowingly or intentionally acted in an unauthorized manner. The Court vacated both judgments and remanded the cases.

The government had proposed a standard of an objectively reasonable good-faith effort. The Court rejected it, because such a test "would turn a defendant's criminal liability on the mental state of a hypothetical 'reasonable' doctor." The Court added that objective criteria, such as a legitimate medical purpose, remain relevant as circumstantial evidence of what the physician knew. Justice Alito, joined by Justice Thomas and in part by Justice Barrett, concurred in the judgment.

For the medical expert the result is a change of role. Testimony that a prescription fell below professional norms still matters, but it is evidence from which the jury may infer knowledge. It no longer decides guilt by itself.

What must the government disclose about its medical expert?

At the defendant's request, a written disclosure with a complete statement of all opinions, their bases and reasons, the expert's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, and prior testimony from the previous 4 years, signed by the expert.

Rule 16(a)(1)(G) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure requires the government, at the defendant's request, to disclose in writing any expert testimony it intends to use in its case-in-chief, or to rebut a timely defense expert disclosure. The disclosure contains a complete statement of all opinions the government will elicit, the bases and reasons for them, the witness's qualifications including a list of all publications authored in the previous 10 years, and a list of all other cases in which the witness testified as an expert at trial or by deposition during the previous 4 years.

The court sets the time for the disclosure by order or local rule, and it must come "sufficiently before trial to provide a fair opportunity for the defendant to meet the government's evidence." The witness must approve and sign the disclosure, unless the government states why it could not obtain the signature after reasonable efforts, or the witness has already signed a report containing the same information. The government supplements or corrects the disclosure as Rule 16(c) requires.

The 2022 amendment wrote these requirements into the rule. The committee note names the problems it addressed: the "lack of adequate specificity regarding what information must be disclosed" and the absence of an enforceable deadline. Its aim is to give both sides "a fair opportunity to prepare to cross-examine expert witnesses" and to secure opposing expert testimony if needed.

What does the defense physician check in the government's disclosure?

Whether each opinion names the patient, the prescription and the professional standard it applies, whether the bases are the full charts, and whether any opinion goes to the physician's state of mind, which Rule 704(b) forbids.

The reviewer starts with the statement of opinions. Each opinion should identify which patients and which prescriptions it covers, what the usual course of professional practice required for them and in which respect the defendant departed from it. A general opinion that a practice was a pill mill, without findings for each patient, falls short of the complete statement of opinions with bases and reasons that the rule requires.

Then the bases. The reviewer compares the materials listed in the disclosure with the complete files: intake notes, examinations, imaging and laboratory results, prior treatment records, consent and treatment agreements, drug screening results and the dates of each visit. If the expert reviewed only some of the patients, the reviewer asks how they were chosen.

Then the standard itself. The reviewer checks which professional sources the expert used to describe the usual course of practice for the specialty and the date of the prescriptions, and whether the expert reads those sources the way the specialty does. Under Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, the government as proponent must satisfy the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data, uses reliable principles and methods and applies them reliably to the facts.

Finally the reviewer compares the qualifications and the testimony list of the past 4 years with the opinions. An expert who practices in a different specialty from the defendant, or who has testified for the government in a series of similar prosecutions, is a subject for cross-examination.

Can the government's expert tell the jury that the physician knew the prescriptions were unauthorized?

No. Rule 704(b) bars an expert in a criminal case from stating an opinion about whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state that is an element of the crime. That question is for the jury alone.

Under Rule 704(a) of the Federal Rules of Evidence, an opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue. Rule 704(b) makes an exception for criminal cases: an expert witness must not state an opinion about whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state or condition that constitutes an element of the crime charged or of a defense, and those matters are for the trier of fact alone.

After Ruan, knowledge or intent that the prescribing was unauthorized is an element the government must prove. An expert may describe the objective facts in the charts, such as dose escalation, early refills or missing examinations, and explain what the usual course of practice would have required. Phrases such as the doctor knew, the doctor must have realized or the doctor intended are opinions about mental state of the kind Rule 704(b) bars.

The defense reviewer marks such phrases in the disclosure, so that counsel can move in limine before trial to keep them out of the testimony.

How is the expert's basis tested at trial?

Through the disclosure and cross-examination. Under Rule 705 the expert may state an opinion without first giving the underlying facts, but may be required to disclose them on cross-examination.

Under Rule 705, unless the court orders otherwise, an expert may state an opinion and give the reasons for it without first testifying to the underlying facts or data, but may be required to disclose those facts or data on cross-examination. For the defense, the Rule 16 disclosure is the map: each basis listed there is a line of questions.

Rule 703 lets an expert rely on facts or data that experts in the field would reasonably rely on, even if those facts are not admissible. If they are otherwise inadmissible, the proponent may disclose them to the jury only if their probative value in helping the jury evaluate the opinion substantially outweighs their prejudicial effect.

Rule 16(a)(1)(F) gives the defense a parallel tool. At the defendant's request, the government must permit the defendant to inspect and copy the results or reports of any physical or mental examination and of any scientific test or experiment, if the item is within the government's possession, custody or control, the attorney for the government knows or could know of it, and it is material to the defense or the government intends to use it in its case-in-chief.

Does the defense have to disclose its own medical expert?

Yes, if the government asks after it has complied with the defendant's request under Rule 16(a)(1)(G). The defense disclosure under Rule 16(b)(1)(C) has the same four parts and the same signature rule.

Rule 16(b)(1)(C) requires the defendant, at the government's request, to disclose in writing any expert testimony the defendant intends to use in the case-in-chief, if the defendant requested disclosure under Rule 16(a)(1)(G) and the government complied, or if the defendant has given notice under Rule 12.2(b) of an intent to present expert testimony on the defendant's mental condition. The contents mirror the government's disclosure: opinions, bases and reasons, qualifications with publications of 10 years and prior testimony of 4 years.

The rule covers expert testimony the defendant intends to use, so a physician who only reviews the government's disclosure for counsel and will not testify falls outside it. If counsel decides that the physician will testify, the physician signs a disclosure with the four parts, and the government will read the physician's publications and prior testimony the same way the defense read those of the government's expert.

What if the government's expert disclosure is late or incomplete?

The defense can ask the court for a remedy under Rule 16(d)(2): an order to disclose, a continuance, exclusion of the undisclosed evidence or any other just order. Rule 16(c) requires prompt disclosure of additional material.

Rule 16(c) imposes a continuing duty: a party that discovers additional evidence or material before or during trial must promptly disclose its existence to the other party or the court, if the other party previously requested it or the court ordered its production.

If a party fails to comply with Rule 16, the court under Rule 16(d)(2) may order that party to permit the discovery or inspection and specify its time, place and manner; grant a continuance; prohibit that party from introducing the undisclosed evidence; or enter any other order that is just under the circumstances.

A defense review that lists the specific missing items, such as the patients behind each opinion or the sources of the standard, gives counsel a concrete basis for such a motion.

What does IAE do when a physician faces a criminal case?

A physician from the IAE registry in the defendant's specialty reviews the government's medical expert disclosure against the patient files and the rules of evidence and writes the review in up to 5 business days.

The IAE expert examinations page covers out-of-court examinations and expert opinions and reviews of forensic expert reports in civil, arbitration and criminal cases. The page on review of the opposing medical expert report describes the medical review: a registry physician in the specialty of the care at issue tests each opinion against the chart and Rule 702. The review answers questions about the method, the completeness of the materials, the soundness of the conclusions and the expert's competence.

Counsel sends the disclosure, the patient files the expert relied on and the indictment or the list of counts, and describes the task. IAE confirms receipt the same day and the format, cost, deadline and physician within one business day, and counsel approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees how the court will rule.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member