Expert report review

What errors does a physician reviewer find in medical expert reports?

A physician reviewer sorts the defects of a medical expert's report by the rule they break: an opinion without stated reasons, an opinion outside the expert's field, a basis that leaves out part of the chart, a treating physician's opinion disclosed without the required summary, and testimony that goes past the report. Since December 1, 2023, Rule 702 treats gaps in an expert's basis and in the application of the method as admissibility questions for the court.

A physician in a white coat marks pages of a chart and an expert report with colored tabs

Why is an opinion without stated reasons an error?

Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i) requires a complete statement of every opinion with its basis and reasons. A sentence such as "the delay caused the injury," with no chart entries or literature behind it, does not meet that requirement.

The first item of a retained expert's report under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2)(B) is "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them." A medical report that states conclusions in its summary and gives reasons for only some of them leaves the rest without a basis that the other side can test.

Experience does not replace reasons. The committee note to the 2000 amendment of Federal Rule of Evidence 702 says that a witness relying "solely or primarily on experience" must explain how that experience leads to the conclusion reached, why it is a sufficient basis for the opinion and how it is reliably applied to the facts. A line such as "in my 25 years of practice this would not have happened" names the experience and stops there.

The 2023 note adds a limit on conclusions: "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology." A report that finds a two-hour delay in one paragraph and a breach of the standard of care across the whole admission in the next has gone past that limit.

The reviewer lists each opinion, copies the reasons the report gives for it and marks opinions with no reason, or with a reason that does not reach the conclusion. That list becomes the first part of the review.

Can a medical expert give opinions outside his or her specialty?

Only with a foundation. Rule 702 qualifies an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education, and a New York court gave no weight to an affidavit from a physician with no shown training in the specialty he answered.

Rule 702 opens with "A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education." The qualification is measured against each opinion, so a physician can be qualified for one part of a report and not for another.

In Village Medical Supply v. GEICO, 2014 NY Slip Op 50069(U), decided January 3, 2014, the Civil Court of the City of New York, Kings County, looked at a dispute over the medical necessity of a lumbar sacral orthosis, a back brace. GEICO's peer reviewer was a board-certified orthopedic surgeon. The supplier answered with an affidavit from an anesthesiologist.

Judge Katherine A. Levine accepted that a physician from another specialty may oppose such a motion, but required that "a foundation must be laid tending to support the reliability of the opinion rendered." The anesthesiologist's CV showed familiarity with internal medicine and no orthopedic training, and his affidavit did not address the reviewer's specific findings. The court held that the affidavit "is of no probative value and summary judgment must be granted to defendant."

The same check applies to the opposing expert. The reviewer compares the qualifications listed under Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(iv) with each opinion. An emergency physician who comments on a surgeon's operative technique, or a general surgeon who interprets fetal heart rate tracings, has to show the training that covers that field. Where the report does not show it, the review names the opinion and the missing foundation.

What errors appear in the facts and data behind the opinion?

Records the expert never received, summaries used in place of source entries, and facts supplied by counsel without a source in the chart. Rule 702(b) requires sufficient facts or data, and Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) makes the expert list what was considered.

Under Rule 702(b), the proponent must show that "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data." Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) makes the expert list "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming" the opinions. The reviewer sets that list against the full record and writes down what is missing: nursing flowsheets, the medication administration record, the anesthesia record, the imaging itself rather than the radiologist's report.

Rule 703 permits an expert to rely on facts or data that experts in the particular field would reasonably rely on, even if they would not be admissible. A summary prepared for litigation by counsel or a paralegal is a different source from the chart it summarizes. When the report cites the summary, the reviewer checks every fact in it against the original entry.

Facts supplied by counsel are discoverable. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(C), communications between counsel and a reporting expert are protected except those that "identify facts or data that the party's attorney provided and that the expert considered" and those that "identify assumptions that the party's attorney provided and that the expert relied on." An opinion built on an assumed time of a phone call, a dose or a symptom that the chart does not record rests on counsel's version of events. The review marks each such fact and the page where the report uses it.

Does the report account for the patient's own disease?

A court may ask whether the expert accounted for obvious alternative explanations, a factor in the 2000 committee note to Rule 702. In a malpractice case the reviewer tests the natural course of the illness first.

The 2000 committee note lists, among further factors for reliability, "Whether the expert has adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations." The same note asks whether the expert unjustifiably extrapolated an accepted premise into an unfounded conclusion, and whether "the field of expertise claimed by the expert is known to reach reliable results for the type of opinion the expert would give."

In a malpractice report these questions take medical form. A patient with metastatic disease, a ruptured aneurysm or septic shock may have died with correct treatment. A causation opinion that measures the outcome against a healthy patient, or that never mentions the underlying condition, leaves the obvious alternative unanswered.

In a medical report, extrapolation takes a concrete form. A survival rate reported for a study population is applied to a patient of a different age, stage or comorbidity, and the report converts the population figure into a statement about this patient. The reviewer finds the study, reads its inclusion criteria and states whether the patient would have qualified.

Some causation questions have no answer in the literature. If no published data compare outcomes with and without the omitted step, an opinion that the step would have changed the outcome rests on the expert's assertion, and the review says so.

When does a treating physician's opinion need more than a summary?

A treating physician who was not retained discloses under Rule 26(a)(2)(C): the subject matter and a summary of facts and opinions. A missing summary, or opinions beyond it, gives the other side an objection under Rule 37(c)(1).

Rule 26(a)(2)(C) covers a witness who "is not required to provide a written report." Unless otherwise stipulated or ordered, the disclosure must state "the subject matter on which the witness is expected to present evidence under Federal Rule of Evidence 702, 703, or 705" and "a summary of the facts and opinions to which the witness is expected to testify."

The committee note to the 2010 amendment explains who these witnesses are. Such a witness "may both testify as a fact witness" and give expert testimony, and "Frequent examples include physicians or other health care professionals." The disclosure "is considerably less extensive than the report required by Rule 26(a)(2)(B)," and "Courts must take care against requiring undue detail."

The reviewer looks for two errors. The first is a disclosure that names the treating physician and the topic, for example "will testify about her care and treatment," without any summary of opinions. The second is a summary that stays with treatment while the physician, at deposition or trial, gives opinions on another provider's standard of care or on causation that the summary never mentioned.

The note also says Rule 26(b)(4)(C) "does not itself protect communications between counsel and other expert witnesses, such as those for whom disclosure is required under Rule 26(a)(2)(C)." Counsel's communications with a treating physician who will give opinions can therefore be explored in discovery, and the reviewer reads them with the summary.

What happens when the expert testifies beyond the report?

Testimony outside the report can be excluded under Rule 37(c)(1). In Mathis v. Roa, decided in 2019, the Sixth Circuit added that a party claiming surprise should object when the expert gives the testimony.

Rule 37(c)(1) provides that a party that fails to provide information as Rule 26(a) or (e) requires "is not allowed to use that information or witness to supply evidence on a motion, at a hearing, or at a trial, unless the failure was substantially justified or is harmless."

Mathis v. Roa, No. 18-4168, decided October 30, 2019, was a medical malpractice and wrongful death case. The plaintiffs argued that the defense expert had offered a theory not found in his report and sought to call a late-disclosed rebuttal expert. The district court excluded that expert, and the Sixth Circuit affirmed.

The court of appeals said a testifying expert "must submit an expert report setting forth the opinions he is offering," and testimony beyond the scope of that report "is subject to exclusion under Rule 37." The plaintiffs had not objected when the testimony was given, and the court found no difference between the report and the trial testimony. It also repeated that "the whole premise of the discovery rules [is] to make sure neither party gets surprised."

For the reviewer, the case sets a task for trial. The reviewer keeps the report and the deposition next to the transcript or the live testimony and tells counsel at once when an opinion appears that neither document contains. An objection made at that moment preserves the issue.

Are gaps in the expert's basis a question of weight or admissibility?

Of admissibility first. The 2023 amendment to Rule 702 requires the proponent to show each condition more likely than not, and the committee note calls rulings that treat basis and application as weight questions an incorrect application of the rules.

Since December 1, 2023, Rule 702 admits expert testimony only if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that each condition in subdivisions (a), (b), (c) and (d) is met. The burden rests on the party offering the expert.

The committee note to the 2023 amendment addresses the earlier practice directly. It says "many courts have held that the critical questions of the sufficiency of an expert's basis, and the application of the expert's methodology, are questions of weight and not admissibility," and adds: "These rulings are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)."

The same note asks forensic experts to "avoid assertions of absolute or one hundred percent certainty" when the method is subjective. A medical report that states every conclusion "with absolute certainty" invites the question of what method could support that level of confidence.

For the objecting party, the review turns errors into the elements of a motion. A missing record goes to subdivision (b), an unexplained method to (c), and a conclusion that the chart does not support to (d). The court decides whether the expert is excluded, limited or heard, and the jury then weighs what remains.

What does IAE do when a party needs to check a medical expert's report?

A physician in the relevant specialty from the IAE registry writes a review of the opposing expert's report or an expert report on your questions, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The medical expertise page covers standard of care, causation and the medical record in malpractice, wrongful death and personal injury cases. The physician builds a timeline from orders, vital signs, nursing notes and imaging and compares each decision with the specialty's guidelines in force at the time of care. On causation, the expert separates general and specific causation. On the record, the expert checks the record set for missing notes and gaps in orders.

In a review, the IAE reviewer checks each opinion of the other side's expert against the chart and against Rule 702: sufficient facts, a reliable method and its reliable application to this patient. IAE frames the questions from the chart, the operative notes and the opposing expert's report and confirms them before work starts.

The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the physician from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. Materials go through the contact form or to info@iaexperts.com and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs the review with the other evidence. Neither IAE nor the physician guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member