Expert witnesses
Negligent security expert witness: what does the security expert assess, and when do courts admit the opinion?
A negligent security case asks whether a property owner should have foreseen a crime and taken measures that would have prevented it. The security expert answers the second part: what the property had, what practice in the field called for, and whether the gap mattered. Courts admit opinions grounded in an inspection and a stated standard and exclude guesses about an unknown attacker's mind. Since 2023, a Florida statute gives multifamily owners a presumption if they implement listed measures.

What does a negligent security claim require?
A duty to take security measures, which depends on how foreseeable the crime was, a failure to take reasonable measures, and proof that the missing measures were a substantial factor in causing the injury.
California's Supreme Court has set out the structure in two decisions. In Ann M. v. Pacific Plaza Shopping Center, 6 Cal.4th 666, decided December 16, 1993, the court treated foreseeability as a question of law for the court when it decides whether a duty exists and how far it extends. In Castaneda v. Olsher, decided July 30, 2007, the court described a sliding-scale balancing formula, following Delgado v. Trax Bar & Grill (2005): foreseeability is weighed against the burden of the measure the plaintiff says the owner should have taken, and where that burden is great, a high degree of foreseeability may be required.
Causation is a separate step. In Castaneda the evidence was insufficient to show that guards or brighter lights were a substantial factor in causing the plaintiff's injury. A plaintiff who proves a duty and a missing measure still has to show that the measure would have made a difference.
The security expert works on breach and causation. Duty and foreseeability are largely for the court, but the expert's account of prior incidents, the property and the measures in place supplies the record from which the court decides.
How do courts measure whether a crime was foreseeable?
Mostly by prior similar incidents on or near the property. California rarely, if ever, finds the foreseeability needed to require guards without prior similar violent crimes on the premises; Texas weighs proximity, recency, frequency, similarity and publicity of earlier crimes.
In Ann M., an employee of a photo processing store in a San Diego strip mall was raped in the store on June 17, 1985, by a man who entered pretending to be a customer. The center's owner controlled the common areas and had no guards. Tenants had complained about transients, and a merchants' association had decided against foot patrols because of cost. Justice Panelli wrote that the high degree of foreseeability needed to require security guards rarely, if ever, can be proven without prior similar incidents of violent crime on the landowner's premises. Evidence of transients and of crime in the area did not meet that threshold, and the court affirmed summary judgment for the owner.
Castaneda added that courts have focused on prior similar incidents, while other indications of a reasonably foreseeable risk of violent criminal assaults can serve the same role. In that case two earlier incidents were not enough: in August 1995 an unknown shooter fired a bullet through an occupied mobilehome, and in early 1996 shots were fired on adjacent property during a gang confrontation. Neither involved the occupants of the space where the shooter was a guest.
Texas uses the factors of Timberwalk Apartments, Partners, Inc. v. Cain, 972 S.W.2d 749 (Tex. 1998). In Mellon Mortgage Co. v. Holder, No. 97-1187, decided September 9, 1999, the Supreme Court of Texas applied them to a sexual assault by a police officer in a parking garage. The opinions describe the test as a risk so great that it is both unreasonable and foreseeable, and a concurring opinion lists the factors: proximity, recency, frequency and similarity of prior crimes, and whether they were publicized so the owner knew or should have known. The plurality noted 190 violent crimes reported near the garage in the two years before the attack and no similar violent crime inside it, and held that Mellon owed no duty because the victim was not a foreseeable victim. The court rendered judgment for Mellon.
What does the security expert assess at the property?
The measures in place on the date of the crime: lighting, cameras, access control, locks, patrols, staffing, policies and training, compared with the property's incident history and with practice in the field.
A security expert starts with a site inspection, ideally at the hour of the crime. The expert records lighting levels, sight lines, landscaping, fencing and gates, the location and coverage of cameras and how long footage was kept, door and window hardware, and where guards were posted and when they patrolled. The expert then reads the owner's security contracts, post orders, patrol logs, incident reports and complaints.
In Padgett v. Kmart Corp., No. CV 315-048, decided July 8, 2016, Magistrate Judge Brian K. Epps of the Southern District of Georgia admitted most opinions of the plaintiffs' premises security expert, Jeffrey Gross. The admitted opinions said the store had no security plan for the exterior and customer parking lot, that patrols were a customary practice, how patrols should have been timed, that visible patrols increase the risk of detection, that the store had no closed-circuit television, and that a patrol would likely have prevented the attack.
The court tied each admitted opinion to a basis. Gross relied on his experience, the defendants' interrogatory answers and his inspection of the site, and for the timing of patrols on simulated patrols he ran on site. The court called his testimony on customs reliably based on his more than thirty-six years of experience and treated objections to his hotel-focused career as challenges to weight, not admissibility.
Which security opinions do courts exclude?
Opinions about the unknown attacker's state of mind, facts dressed as expert opinions, conclusions any juror could reach, and claims that an industry standard exists without saying what the standard is.
In Padgett the court excluded three opinions. One said the assailant was watching the lot for a victim, another that he chose the spot for privacy and a rapid escape. The court called inferences into the mindset of the unknown assailant speculative and unreliable and noted that Gross had no evidence of when the assailant arrived or what he did beforehand. The third said the defendants made no effort to learn the scope of crime over ten years; the court called it a mere fact improperly clothed in expert regalia, because Gross had no contact with the defendants and did not know what they knew.
In Dunlap v. Choice Hotels International, Inc., No. 5:20-cv-00159, the Western District of Kentucky excluded a hotel security expert entirely on December 28, 2021. The expert said the hotel's procedures were not consistent with those a reasonable lodging operator would use but never described those procedures. The court wrote that claiming that an industry standard exists is not the same as discussing that standard, and that the ipse dixit of the expert alone is not sufficient to permit the admission of an opinion. Opinions that the hotel should have checked its surveillance footage, and the significance of the property's crime history, were matters the jury could weigh without expert help.
Together the two orders mark the line. An expert who inspected the property, named the practice and explained how its absence mattered was admitted. An expert who asserted a standard without content, or speculated about the criminal, was not.
What does Florida's 2023 law change for apartment and condominium owners?
Section 768.0706 gives the owner or principal operator of a multifamily residential property a presumption against liability for third-party crimes on the premises if it substantially implements listed security measures, a CPTED assessment and staff training.
Florida enacted section 768.0706 in chapter 2023-15, section 8. It applies to multifamily residential property, defined as a residential building or group of buildings, such as apartments, townhouses or condominiums, with at least five dwelling units on one parcel. An owner or principal operator that substantially implements the required measures has a presumption against liability in connection with criminal acts on the premises committed by third parties who are not its employees or agents.
Subsection (2)(a) lists the measures: a security camera system at points of entry and exit that retains footage for at least 30 days; parking lot lighting averaging at least 1.8 foot-candles per square foot at 18 inches above the surface between dusk and dawn; dusk-to-dawn lighting in walkways, laundry rooms, common areas and porches; at least a 1-inch deadbolt in each dwelling unit door; locking devices on windows, exterior sliding doors and other doors not used for community purposes; locked gates with key or fob access along pool fence areas; and a peephole or door viewer on each dwelling unit door without a window or a window next to it.
Subsection (2)(b) requires, by January 1, 2025, a crime prevention through environmental design assessment no more than 3 years old, performed by a law enforcement agency or by a Florida CPTED practitioner designated by the Florida Crime Prevention Training Institute, and continued substantial compliance with it. Subsection (2)(c) requires crime deterrence and safety training for current employees by January 1, 2025, and for new employees within 60 days of hire. Under subsection (3) the owner must prove substantial implementation to receive the presumption, and subsection (5) states that the section does not establish a private cause of action.
How does a security expert address the Florida presumption?
By checking each statutory measure against the property on the date of the crime: lighting in foot-candles, camera coverage and 30-day retention, locks, pool gates, the CPTED assessment and training dates.
The statute turns several questions into measurements. Parking lot lighting has a number: an average of 1.8 foot-candles per square foot at 18 inches above the surface. A lighting survey taken at night, at the same fixtures and with the same lamps, tells whether the lot met it. Camera coverage and retention are checked against the system's settings and the footage actually kept.
Documents answer the rest. The CPTED assessment must be no more than 3 years old and performed by a law enforcement agency or a designated Florida CPTED practitioner; the expert checks its date, its author and whether the owner followed it. Training records show whether each employee was trained by the statutory date or within 60 days of hire.
Because subsection (3) puts the burden on the owner, the defense expert documents substantial implementation and the plaintiff's expert looks for gaps. Neither side's expert decides whether implementation was substantial; that is for the court and the jury on the evidence the experts assemble.
How is fault shared with others under Florida law?
In a suit against a property owner or operator by a person injured there by a third party's crime, section 768.0701 directs the trier of fact to consider the fault of all persons who contributed to the injury.
Florida enacted section 768.0701 in chapter 2023-15, section 7. It applies to an action for damages against the owner, lessor, operator or manager of commercial or real property brought by a person lawfully on the property who was injured by the criminal act of a third party. Notwithstanding section 768.81(4), the trier of fact must consider the fault of all persons who contributed to the injury.
For the security expert this means the causation opinion is read next to other conduct. An opinion that a patrol would likely have prevented the attack, of the kind admitted in Padgett, speaks to how much the missing measure contributed. The allocation of fault among the owner and others is for the trier of fact.
What should counsel send the security expert?
Incident reports and complaints, police calls for service at the address, security contracts and post orders, patrol and access logs, camera settings and footage, lighting records, any CPTED assessment and training records.
Foreseeability depends on prior incidents, and the courts in Ann M., Castaneda and Mellon looked hardest at incidents on the property itself and their similarity to the crime at issue. The owner's own incident reports, tenant complaints and police calls for service at the address are the first records to obtain. Area crime statistics without incidents on the premises did not carry the plaintiff's burden in Ann M.
Measures and practice come next: the security vendor's contract, post orders, patrol logs and guard schedules, access control and key fob logs, camera locations and settings, maintenance records for lighting, and policies on reporting and responding to incidents. In Florida multifamily cases, add the CPTED assessment and employee training records under section 768.0706.
The expert's inspection should take place before the property changes. Lights are replaced, cameras are added and gates are repaired after a serious crime, and the condition on the date of the crime has to be documented from photographs and records if the site no longer shows it.
How does Rule 702 apply to a security expert?
The proponent must show that the expert's knowledge will help the jury, that the opinion rests on sufficient facts, and that reliable methods were reliably applied. Experience can qualify an expert; the opinion must still explain the standard.
Federal Rule of Evidence 702 requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion applies those methods reliably to the facts of the case.
Padgett and Dunlap apply those conditions to the same kind of witness with opposite results. In Padgett, experience plus an inspection, the defendants' answers and simulated patrols supplied the facts and the method. In Dunlap, experience alone, an unnamed standard and opinions a juror could reach without help did not.
The committee note to the 2023 amendment says that some challenges go to weight rather than admissibility once the court finds the rule's requirements met. In Padgett objections to the expert's hotel background and to alternative causes went to weight. State courts apply their own evidence rules, and counsel names the state and court when retaining the expert.
How does IAE find a security expert for a negligent security case?
In the request choose the case type Personal injury and name premises security in the field. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.
The IAE personal injury expert witness page covers car and truck crashes, falls, workplace injuries and wrongful death and lists eight personal injury specialties in three groups: accident mechanics, medicine, and damages and falls. In the field of expertise the firm names premises security and the type of property.
The form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties and their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. For a negligent security claim the description can name the kind of property, the crime and whether Florida's section 768.0706 is in issue. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.
Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee.
The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option at +$100 per hour. IAE is not a law firm, and case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- Florida Statutes section 768.0706 (Florida Senate)
- Florida Statutes section 768.0701 (2025)
- Ann M. v. Pacific Plaza Shopping Center (1993) 6 Cal.4th 666 (Justia)
- Castaneda v. Olsher, No. S138104 (Cal. July 30, 2007) (SCOCAL, Stanford Law School)
- Mellon Mortgage Co. v. Holder, No. 97-1187 (Tex. Sept. 9, 1999) (FindLaw)
- Padgett v. Kmart Corp., No. CV 315-048, Doc. 65 (S.D. Ga. July 8, 2016) (Justia)
- Dunlap v. Choice Hotels International, Inc., No. 5:20-cv-00159, Dkt. 79 (W.D. Ky. Dec. 28, 2021) (Justia)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, with committee notes (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Dram shop expert witness: what can a toxicologist prove about visible intoxication, and what do courts require of the opinion?
A dram shop claim asks a court to hold a bar or restaurant liable for what an intoxicated patron did after leaving. The crash is usually undisputed
Construction accident expert witness: which safety rules does the expert apply, and when do they decide the case?
A fall from a scaffold, a collapsed trench or a ladder that kicked out ends up in court as a question about safety rules. The construction safety
Traumatic brain injury expert witness: what can a neuropsychologist and brain imaging prove in court?
A mild traumatic brain injury often leaves nothing a standard scan can show, so the case turns on experts: the treating physiciansExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

