Expert witnesses

Standard of care in medical malpractice: how does the expert prove it?

The standard of care is the measure a jury applies to the defendant's conduct, and in most malpractice cases only an expert can tell the jury what it was. Florida defines it in section 766.102(1) as the care that reasonably prudent similar health care providers recognize as acceptable and appropriate. Michigan ties it to the community for general practitioners and to the specialty for specialists. The expert has to state that measure and show where the care departed from it.

A physician from behind compares two closed protocol binders at a clinic counter, a stethoscope on the hook.

What is the standard of care in a medical malpractice case?

The level of care, skill and treatment that reasonably prudent similar health care providers recognize as acceptable and appropriate in light of all relevant surrounding circumstances. That is Florida's statutory definition in section 766.102(1).

Section 766.102(1) of the Florida Statutes puts the burden on the claimant to prove, by the greater weight of evidence, that the alleged actions of the health care provider represented a breach of the prevailing professional standard of care for that provider. The statute then defines that standard as the level of care, skill and treatment which, in light of all relevant surrounding circumstances, is recognized as acceptable and appropriate by reasonably prudent similar health care providers.

Three parts of the definition shape the expert's work. The comparison group is similar providers, so a surgeon is measured against surgeons. The test is what those providers recognize as acceptable and appropriate. And the surrounding circumstances count: the patient's presentation, what the provider knew at the time, the setting and the resources at hand.

Michigan writes the same idea in two branches. Under MCL 600.2912a(1), a general practitioner is held to the recognized standard of acceptable professional practice or care in the community in which the defendant practices or in a similar community. A specialist is held to the recognized standard of practice or care within that specialty, as reasonably applied in light of the facilities available in the community or other facilities reasonably available under the circumstances. In both branches the plaintiff proves the breach "in light of the state of the art existing at the time of the alleged malpractice."

Why does a malpractice claim need an expert on the standard of care?

Because a bad outcome proves nothing by itself. Florida's section 766.102(3)(b) says the existence of a medical injury creates no inference or presumption of negligence, so someone qualified has to state the standard and the breach.

Section 766.102(3)(b) reads: "The existence of a medical injury does not create any inference or presumption of negligence against a health care provider." The claimant keeps the burden of proving that the injury was caused by a breach of the prevailing professional standard of care. A complication, a death or a disappointing result opens the question and does not answer it.

Section 766.102(5) then limits who may answer it. Testimony on the prevailing professional standard of care may come only from a licensed health care provider who has completely reviewed the pertinent medical records and meets the specialty and practice requirements of the statute. A juror, a lawyer or a fact witness cannot fill that role.

Florida also excludes one theory by statute. Under section 766.102(4), the failure of a health care provider to order, perform or administer supplemental diagnostic tests is not actionable if the provider acted in good faith and with due regard for the prevailing professional standard of care. A standard-of-care expert who criticizes a missing test has to address that subsection as well as the clinical facts.

Is the standard of care national or local?

It depends on the state and the defendant. Michigan applies the community standard to general practitioners and the specialty standard, adjusted for available facilities, to specialists. Florida compares the defendant with similar providers.

The old locality rule measured a physician against physicians in the same town. Michigan keeps a version of it only for general practitioners: MCL 600.2912a(1)(a) refers to the community in which the defendant practices or a similar community. For specialists, subsection (1)(b) refers to the standard within the specialty as applied in light of the facilities available in the community or other facilities reasonably available under the circumstances.

Under the facilities clause, the expert has to know what equipment, staff and services the defendant's hospital had on the date of care and which other facilities were reasonably available, for example by transfer. A specialty standard that assumes resources the hospital lacked is applied in light of the facilities that existed.

Florida's section 766.102(1) does not use the word community. It compares the defendant with reasonably prudent similar health care providers in light of all relevant surrounding circumstances, and section 766.102(5) requires the testifying expert to share the defendant's specialty and to have practiced, taught or done research in it within 3 years before the occurrence.

Does following common practice always meet the standard of care?

Usually, but a court can hold otherwise. In Helling v. Carey (1974) the Washington Supreme Court found negligence as a matter of law although both sides' experts said the test was not routine.

Barbara Helling consulted the ophthalmologists Thomas Carey and Robert Laughlin from 1959, mostly about contact lenses, through 1968. She was 32 when Dr. Carey first tested her eye pressure in October 1968. The test found primary open angle glaucoma, and she had already lost most of her peripheral vision.

Experts for both sides testified that the profession did not require routine pressure tests for patients under 40, and the incidence of glaucoma under 40 was about one in 25,000. The trial court entered a defense verdict and the Court of Appeals affirmed. On March 14, 1974, the Washington Supreme Court reversed and held that "reasonable prudence required the timely giving of the pressure test to this plaintiff." It sent the case back for a new trial on damages only.

The court quoted an older rule: "What usually is done may be evidence of what ought to be done". Three justices concurred on a different ground and acknowledged that their approach came close to strict liability. Helling is a 1974 decision of one state court, and its reasoning was tied to a simple and harmless test. Florida's statute today measures the defendant against what reasonably prudent similar providers recognize as acceptable, so a Florida expert speaks to that recognition, with the custom of the specialty as part of the evidence.

Is the standard of care judged with hindsight?

No. The care is measured by what was known and available at the time. Michigan's MCL 600.2912a refers to the state of the art at the time of the alleged malpractice, and Florida's definition to the surrounding circumstances.

MCL 600.2912a(1) requires the plaintiff to prove the breach "in light of the state of the art existing at the time of the alleged malpractice." A guideline published after the treatment date, or a diagnosis that became clear only after later imaging, does not set the standard for the earlier decision.

That puts the chart in the center of the expert's work. The expert builds a timeline of what the provider saw: vital signs, nursing notes, laboratory results with the time each came back, imaging reports with the time each was read, consultations and orders. Each criticism in the report is tied to an entry the provider had in front of him or her when the decision was made.

The same rule cuts the other way for the defense. A defense expert who relies on a later change in guidelines to excuse the care faces the same objection: the question is what was acceptable and appropriate on the date of treatment.

How do clinical guidelines and textbooks reach the jury?

Through an expert. Under Rule 803(18), a statement in a reliable treatise or periodical may be read into evidence when an expert relies on it or faces it on cross-examination, but never becomes an exhibit.

Federal Rule of Evidence 803(18) admits a statement in a treatise, periodical or pamphlet if the statement is called to the attention of an expert witness on cross-examination or relied on by the expert on direct examination, and if the publication is established as a reliable authority by the expert's admission or testimony, by another expert's testimony or by judicial notice. If admitted, the statement may be read into evidence but not received as an exhibit.

The Advisory Committee explained the limit: it restricts the use of treatises as substantive evidence "to situations in which an expert is on the stand" and available to explain and apply the material. A clinical practice guideline handed to the jury without an expert is the use the rule was written to avoid.

For the expert, two tasks follow. The expert identifies the edition or version in force on the date of care and lays the foundation that it is a reliable authority in the specialty. On cross-examination, the expert must be ready for the other side's publications, because under Rule 803(18) counsel may read a statement of an established authority to the expert on cross-examination and into the record.

What must the standard-of-care opinion contain in federal court?

Under Rule 26(a)(2)(B), a complete statement of each opinion with its basis and reasons and the facts or data considered. Under Rule 702, the proponent proves the opinion rests on sufficient facts and reliably applies a reliable method.

A retained expert's written report states the opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, the exhibits, the expert's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, the cases in the previous 4 years in which the expert testified, and the compensation (Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i)-(vi) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure). A standard-of-care opinion therefore names the standard, the specific act or omission and the records on which each point rests.

Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony will help the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies those methods reliably to the facts of the case. An opinion that says only that the physician should have done better, without the standard and the chart entries, fails the second and fourth requirements.

Rule 703 lets the expert rely on facts or data that experts in the field would reasonably rely on, even if they are not admissible, and Rule 705 lets the expert state the opinion without first testifying to the underlying facts. The other side may require the expert to disclose those facts on cross-examination, so every source in the report has to be one the expert can defend.

Who can testify about a specialist's standard of care?

In Florida, a licensed provider in the same specialty who practiced, taught or did research in it within 3 years before the occurrence. In Michigan, since 2024, specialties are matched at the board level.

Florida's section 766.102(5)(a) requires an expert against a specialist to specialize in the same specialty and to have devoted professional time to it within the 3 years before the occurrence, through active clinical practice or consulting, teaching in an accredited program or clinical research. Against a Florida physician the expert also needs a Florida license or an expert witness certificate (section 766.102(12)).

Michigan matches specialties under MCL 600.2169. On July 25, 2024, the Michigan Supreme Court decided Stokes v Swofford together with Selliman v Colton and overruled Woodard v Custer in part. The court held that specialist and specialty in the statute refer to specialties recognized by umbrella certifying bodies such as the ABMS, the AOA and the ABPS, and that "The statute does not require matching of subspecialties." In Stokes the defendant was a diagnostic radiologist whose certificate of added qualification in neuroradiology had lapsed; the court held that diagnostic radiology was the one most relevant specialty, so the plaintiff's neuroradiologist expert qualified.

Selliman went back to the trial court. The defendant was certified in otolaryngology and in facial plastic and reconstructive surgery, and the plaintiff's expert held the same certifications and spent about 10 percent of his time on cosmetic rhinoplasty. The trial court has to decide whether facial plastic and reconstructive surgery is a subspecialty for purposes of the matching rule.

Is proving a breach of the standard of care enough to win?

No. The plaintiff also proves that the breach caused the injury. Michigan requires proof that the injury more probably than not was proximately caused by the negligence, and bars recovery for a lost opportunity of 50 percent or less.

MCL 600.2912a(2) states the causation burden: the plaintiff must prove that he or she more probably than not suffered an injury proximately caused by the negligence of the defendant. The same subsection bars recovery for loss of an opportunity to survive or to achieve a better result unless the opportunity was greater than 50 percent.

Florida's section 766.102(1) speaks of a breach of the prevailing professional standard of care, and section 766.102(3)(b) keeps the burden on the claimant to prove that the injury was proximately caused by such a breach. The standard-of-care expert and the causation expert are often different physicians: the first speaks for the defendant's specialty, and the second may be a specialist in the disease or the injury.

A report that blends the two questions draws objections on both. The standard-of-care section names what the provider should have done and when; the causation section explains, with the patient's own data, what would have happened if the provider had done it.

How does IAE find a standard-of-care expert?

In the request choose Medical malpractice, write the state and court and name the defendant's specialty. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

The IAE medical malpractice expert witness page names surgeons, obstetricians, anesthesiologists, emergency physicians, nurses and geriatricians among six medical malpractice specialties, and IAE matches the expert to the defendant's specialty and the state's requirements. The page notes that in Florida the expert shares the defendant's specialty and devoted professional time to it in the 3 years before the occurrence (s. 766.102(5)), and that Michigan checks the majority of professional time in 1 year and board certification (MCL 600.2169).

The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties with their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. For a standard-of-care expert, the field of expertise can name the defendant's board specialty and the setting of care, such as a community hospital emergency department, and the description can give the date of treatment. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.

Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that specialty by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. Candidate names and CVs come after the $2,000 search fee is paid in advance. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee.

The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, and the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case