For attorneys

Withdrawing a petition before USCIS decides: what happens to the fee and the priority date, and when is refiling the better route?

A petitioner may withdraw a benefit request at any time until USCIS issues a decision, and a withdrawal cannot be taken back. That is 8 CFR 103.2(b)(6). The fee stays with USCIS, the priority date of the withdrawn petition does not carry over to a new one, and the facts of the first filing remain material to the second. For an approved I-140 the 180-day rule of 8 CFR 205.1 decides whether the approval survives.

An attorney from behind slides a petition binder back into a courier envelope

When can a petitioner withdraw a petition filed with USCIS?

At any time until USCIS issues a decision, and for an approved petition until the beneficiary is admitted or granted adjustment or change of status on it. The withdrawal cannot be retracted.

Paragraph 103.2(b)(6) reads: "An applicant or petitioner may withdraw a benefit request at any time until a decision is issued by USCIS or, in the case of an approved petition, until the person is admitted or granted adjustment or change of status, based on the petition. However, a withdrawal may not be retracted."

The rule gives two windows. A pending petition can be withdrawn until USCIS issues a decision. An approved petition can be withdrawn until the beneficiary uses it: admission to the United States, adjustment of status or change of status based on that petition.

The person who withdraws is the applicant or petitioner. In an employer's petition that is the employer; in a self-petition, such as an EB-1A filed by the beneficiary under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(1), it is the beneficiary. An attorney of record files the withdrawal on the client's instruction.

Paragraph 103.2(b)(6) does not prescribe a form. For an approved employment-based petition, 8 CFR 205.1(a)(3)(iii)(C) speaks of "written notice of withdrawal filed by the petitioner to any officer of USCIS who is authorized to grant or deny petitions." A written, signed request that identifies the receipt number puts the withdrawal on the record.

Can a withdrawal be taken back?

No. Paragraph 103.2(b)(6) states that a withdrawal may not be retracted, and USCIS's acknowledgement of a withdrawal may not be appealed under 103.2(b)(15). After a withdrawal, the only way forward is a new filing.

The last sentence of (b)(6) is categorical: "However, a withdrawal may not be retracted." Paragraph (b)(15) closes the other route: "The USCIS acknowledgement of a withdrawal may not be appealed."

The AAO applied the same principle in a non-precedent decision of October 30, 2015, Matter of C-S-, Inc., on an EB-2 petition for a network consulting engineer. The AAO wrote: "The withdrawal may not be retracted," citing 8 CFR 103.2(b)(6).

A withdrawal letter therefore goes out only after the client has decided, in writing, and has understood that the petition will not come back. If the decision rests on a deadline, such as an RFE response date, the attorney sets the date of the client's instruction well before that deadline.

What happens to a withdrawal filed while an appeal is pending?

In Matter of C-S-, Inc. (AAO, October 30, 2015) the petitioner withdrew during its appeal of a denial. The AAO found the issues moot and dismissed the appeal on the basis of the withdrawal.

The facts were short. The Director of the Nebraska Service Center denied an I-140 petition under section 203(b)(2) of the Act, and the petitioner appealed to the AAO. On October 14, 2015, before the AAO decided, the petitioner asked to withdraw the petition.

The AAO stated that "an application or petition may not be withdrawn once a decision is issued by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services." It added that even if the grounds for denial were overcome on appeal, the withdrawal would make the petition subject to automatic revocation under 8 CFR 205.1(a)(3)(iii)(C) "without prior notice." It concluded that "the issues in this proceeding are now moot" and that "The appeal will be dismissed based on its withdrawal by the Petitioner."

The current text of 103.2(b)(6), quoted above, permits withdrawal "until a decision is issued by USCIS" and, for an approved petition, until the beneficiary is admitted or granted adjustment or change of status on it. Matter of C-S-, Inc. is a non-precedent decision, so an attorney who considers withdrawal during an appeal reads it together with the current text of the regulation.

Is the filing fee refunded after a withdrawal?

As a rule, no. Under 8 CFR 103.2(a)(1) filing fees generally are non-refundable regardless of the outcome or of how long adjudication takes, and any refund is at USCIS's discretion. A new petition carries a new fee.

Paragraph 103.2(a)(1) states: "Filing fees generally are non-refundable regardless of the outcome of the benefit request, or how much time the adjudication requires, and any decision to refund a fee is at the discretion of USCIS."

Paragraph (b)(15) confirms the cost of the second attempt: "Withdrawal or denial due to abandonment does not preclude the filing of a new benefit request with a new fee."

For the client the budget of a withdraw-and-refile plan therefore includes the full fees of the new petition, any premium processing fee chosen for it and the cost of the new evidence. The fee already paid for the withdrawn petition is not part of that budget, since it is not expected back.

What happens to the priority date of a withdrawn I-140?

It is lost for a petition withdrawn before approval. Under 103.2(b)(15) the priority date of a withdrawn request may not be applied to a later petition, and the new I-140 receives its own date when it is properly filed.

Paragraph 103.2(b)(15) states: "However, the priority or processing date of a withdrawn or abandoned benefit request may not be applied to a later application petition."

For an I-140 without a labor certification, 8 CFR 204.5(d) sets the priority date as "the date the completed, signed petition (including all initial evidence and the correct fee) is properly filed with USCIS." The refiled petition gets the date of its own proper filing.

Retention of a priority date works only from an approved petition. Under 204.5(e)(1), "A petition approved on behalf of an alien" accords the priority date of the approved petition to later petitions in the first, second or third preference, and under 204.5(e)(3), "A denied petition will not establish a priority date." A pending petition that is withdrawn was never approved and has nothing to pass on.

For a beneficiary from a country with a long wait for visa numbers, every month between the first and the second filing date adds a month to the wait. The attorney weighs this before advising withdrawal of a pending petition that might still be approved after an RFE response.

What if the employer withdraws an approved I-140?

Under 8 CFR 205.1(a)(3)(iii)(C), a withdrawal filed less than 180 days after approval revokes the approval, unless adjustment has been pending 180 days. A petition withdrawn 180 days or more after approval remains approved, but the job offer is rescinded.

Section 205.1(a) lists cases in which approval of a petition "is revoked as of the date of approval." For employment-based preference petitions, subparagraph (a)(3)(iii)(C) covers "written notice of withdrawal filed by the petitioner" filed "less than 180 days after approval of the employment-based preference petition, unless an associated adjustment of status application has been pending for 180 days or more."

The second sentence protects older approvals: "A petition that is withdrawn 180 days or more after its approval, or 180 days or more after the associated adjustment of status application has been filed, remains approved unless its approval is revoked on other grounds."

The job offer does not survive. "If an employment-based petition on behalf of an alien is withdrawn, the job offer of the petitioning employer is rescinded and the alien must obtain a new employment-based preference petition" to seek adjustment or an immigrant visa, unless the alien is eligible to adjust under section 204(j) of the Act and 8 CFR 245.25.

The priority date follows 204.5(e). An approval that remains in place keeps its priority date for later petitions, and 204.5(e)(2) lists the grounds on which it is not retained: revocation for fraud or willful misrepresentation of a material fact, revocation or invalidation of the permanent labor certification, or a material error in the approval. Under 205.1(b), when approval is automatically revoked, the director sends notice to the consular office and mails a copy to the petitioner's last known address.

After an RFE or NOID, should the petitioner withdraw or respond?

Paragraph 103.2(b)(11) gives three options within the response period: a complete response, a partial response with a request for a decision on the record, or withdrawal. Silence leads to denial for abandonment, on the record or both.

The text of (b)(11): "In response to a request for evidence or a notice of intent to deny, and within the period afforded for a response, the applicant or petitioner may: submit a complete response containing all requested information at any time within the period afforded; submit a partial response and ask for a decision based on the record; or withdraw the benefit request."

Doing nothing is a fourth outcome. Under (b)(13)(i) a request may then be "summarily denied as abandoned, denied based on the record, or denied for both reasons." A denial due to abandonment may not be appealed, though the petitioner may file a motion to reopen under 103.5. A denial keeps no priority date under 204.5(e)(3).

A complete response keeps the petition and its priority date alive. It works when the evidence asked for existed on the filing date, because 103.2(b)(12) requires that a request be denied where the response "does not establish filing eligibility at the time the benefit request was filed." If the missing qualification arose only after filing, such as a publication, an award or a role acquired later, a response cannot rely on it, and a new petition can.

Withdrawal makes sense when the record on the filing date cannot be repaired and a new filing will be stronger. It costs the fee and the priority date of the first petition, and the facts of that petition remain material to the second.

Does the withdrawn petition affect the new one?

The withdrawal itself does not, but its facts do. Paragraph 103.2(b)(15) states that withdrawal shall not itself affect the new proceeding, while the facts and circumstances of the prior request remain material to the new one.

The last sentence of (b)(15) reads: "Withdrawal or denial due to abandonment shall not itself affect the new proceeding; but the facts and circumstances surrounding the prior benefit request shall otherwise be material to the new benefit request."

The new petition is therefore read against the old one. If the first petition described the beneficiary's role, salary or achievements in one way and the second describes them differently, the difference needs an explanation in the new filing. Letters from the same authors that change their account without a reason create the same question.

An RFE or NOID on the first petition is part of those facts and circumstances. The new petition answers the points it raised, with evidence, even though no officer has yet asked about them in the new proceeding.

What must the refiled petition show?

Eligibility on its own filing date, with all initial evidence. Under 103.2(b)(1) the petitioner must be eligible at the time of filing and through adjudication, so achievements gained after the first filing can support the second.

Paragraph 103.2(b)(1) states: "An applicant or petitioner must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing the benefit request and must continue to be eligible through adjudication. Each benefit request must be properly completed and filed with all initial evidence required by applicable regulations and other USCIS instructions."

The new filing date moves the cut-off. Articles published, awards received, judging done and roles taken after the first filing but before the second count for the new petition. For an EB-1A self-petition the criteria of 204.5(h)(3) are measured against the record as it stands on the new date.

Expert letters are rewritten for the new record. A letter written for the first petition describes the evidence as it stood then; the letters for the new petition describe the new record, answer the points raised in any RFE or NOID on the first petition and carry a date after the new evidence they discuss.

How does IAE prepare expert letters for a refiled petition or an RFE response?

A member of the public IAE registry in the beneficiary's field writes each letter from the current record, with a declaration of independence. An RFE or NOID response takes 5 business days, rush 3; a new letter 10, rush 5.

Send the beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline through the page for attorneys; for a refiled petition, attach the RFE, NOID or decision on the first one. Within one business day the Secretariat replies, free of charge, which letters make sense for the case, who the expert from the IAE registry in the beneficiary's field is, the cost and the deadline.

You receive the expert's CV, degree, memberships and publications and a link to the registry record before the invoice, and may decline the candidate. In every letter the expert confirms no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary; if there is one, the expert declines the order. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition, so a package of three letters is signed by three experts.

The Secretariat prepares the draft from the beneficiary's documents, the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. Before delivery the letter passes the IAE checklist: facts, dates and quotations are checked against the beneficiary's documents, and text from earlier letters is not reused except section headings. One round of factual edits is included; the expert's conclusions remain the expert's own.

A firm with several cases receives one Secretariat thread per case, the case number in the email subject, the letter and the invoice, and an invoice to the firm or to the client. The letter does not guarantee approval: USCIS weighs it together with the other evidence.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Request

Send your first case

The beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline. The expert, the CV, the cost and the deadline within one business day.

Case for assessment

Received

Expert, cost and deadline within one business day

CategoryEB‑2 NIW
Beneficiary's fieldGeotechnics
RFE response duein 30 days