Examinations
Can a patent attorney testify as an expert witness, and about what?
A patent attorney or former USPTO official can testify in district court about how the Patent Office works and what happened during prosecution. Courts in Delaware and Texas excluded the same experts when they spoke about a party's intent, an examiner's thinking or inequitable conduct as a conclusion. A patent attorney without skill in the art may not give technical opinions, and the PTAB does not admit testimony on patent law at all.

Can a patent attorney be an expert witness?
Yes, if the court finds the testimony meets Rule 702. District courts have admitted a former Commissioner for Patents, a former Acting Director of the USPTO and a former examiner on Patent Office practice and procedure.
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 702, a witness "qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education" may testify if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion applies those methods reliably to the facts of the case.
In the three cases below, the experts qualified through work at the Patent Office. In W.L. Gore & Associates v. C.R. Bard the expert was Nicholas Godici, a former Commissioner for Patents who is not an attorney. In Network-1 Technologies v. Alcatel-Lucent it was John Doll, a former Acting Under Secretary and Acting Director of the USPTO. In Wright Asphalt Products v. Pelican Refining it was Eric Steffe, who examined applications at the Patent Office in 1989 through 1991 and later worked as a patent practitioner.
Each court admitted testimony on Patent Office practice and excluded the parts of the report on intent, on what the examiner would have done or on legal conclusions.
What may a patent law expert testify about in district court?
General Patent Office practice and procedure and a summary of the prosecution history of the patent in suit. One court also allowed an opinion on materiality based on the expert's experience with Patent Office policy and practice.
In W.L. Gore & Associates, Inc. v. C.R. Bard, Inc., No. 11-515-LPS-CJB (D. Del.), Magistrate Judge Christopher J. Burke granted in part Bard's motion to exclude Godici on November 20, 2015. Testimony on general PTO practice and procedure and a summary of the asserted patent's prosecution history stayed in: the court called it "harmless" and said it "could be helpful" to the fact finder.
In Wright Asphalt Products Co. v. Pelican Refining Co., No. H-09-1145 (S.D. Tex. May 29, 2012), Judge Lee H. Rosenthal wrote: "Steffe may provide expert testimony at trial, but limited to Patent Office practices and procedures generally."
Network-1 Technologies, Inc. v. Alcatel-Lucent USA, Inc., No. 6:11-cv-492 (E.D. Tex. Sept. 21, 2017), went a step further. Magistrate Judge K. Nicole Mitchell allowed Doll to opine on the materiality of the defendants' broadening contentions, but only on the basis of his experience with PTO policy, practice and procedure, not on any expertise in the technology at issue.
What do courts exclude from a patent law expert's report?
Conclusions on inequitable conduct, opinions on a party's intent, statements about what an examiner thought or would have done, and speculation that the Patent Office made errors in granting the patent.
In Gore the court excluded the rest of Godici's report, his analysis of the undisclosed references. It found that those opinions addressed materiality, intent and what the examiner would have done, which is legal opinion or speculation about another person's state of mind. Godici agreed that his analysis concerned "what would have happened in the [PTO]" had the information been disclosed. The court stated its practice: "experts in patent cases may not opine on whether a party engaged in inequitable conduct."
In Network-1 the court ruled that Doll "may not opine about the mental thought processes of a PTO examiner" and "may not opine as to Network-1's subjective intent." He could point to the record and the evidence bearing on intent. A paragraph calling Network-1's statements reasonable was struck because the conclusion depended on the legal standard of materiality.
In Wright Asphalt the court wrote: "Steffe cannot speculate about possible errors in the approval of the patent at issue in the case." In a footnote it added that it would exclude the rest of his report as unhelpful on legal issues.
Can a patent attorney give opinions on infringement or invalidity?
Not without ordinary skill in the art of the patent. The Southern District of Texas excluded a patent practitioner's opinions on noninfringement, anticipation and enablement, citing the Federal Circuit's 2008 decision in Sundance.
Pelican also offered Steffe on noninfringement and invalidity. Judge Rosenthal excluded those opinions because he lacked ordinary skill in the relevant art. Studying the declarations of skilled people did not make him qualified. The court wrote: "The technical expert must have the skill. Steffe does not."
The order relied on Sundance, Inc. v. DeMonte Fabricating Ltd., 550 F.3d 1356, decided by the Federal Circuit on December 24, 2008. There the district court let Daniel Bliss, a patent attorney offered only as a patent law expert, testify on noninfringement and invalidity, including obviousness, although he had no relevant technical experience in tarps or covers, the technology of the patent. In an opinion by Judge Moore the Federal Circuit held that "it is an abuse of discretion to permit a witness to testify as an expert on the issues of noninfringement or invalidity" unless the witness is qualified as an expert in the pertinent art.
The practical result is two experts. A technical expert of ordinary skill or more compares the claims with the product and the prior art. A patent law expert, where one is needed, explains the procedure that produced the patent. A patent attorney who also holds a technical degree and practical experience in the field can do the first job, but the court tests that skill separately.
Does the PTAB accept testimony on patent law?
No. Under 37 CFR 42.65(a), testimony on United States patent law or patent examination practice will not be admitted in PTAB trials, and expert testimony without the underlying facts or data gets little or no weight.
Section 42.65(a) states: "Testimony on United States patent law or patent examination practice will not be admitted." The same paragraph gives little or no weight to expert testimony that does not disclose the underlying facts or data on which the opinion is based.
The rule closes the PTAB to the testimony that district courts admit within limits. In an inter partes review the parties' declarants therefore address technical questions: what a reference discloses and how a person of ordinary skill would read it.
Section 42.65(b) adds that a party relying on a technical test or data must file an affidavit explaining why the test is used, how it was performed and the data generated, how the data is used to determine a value and how the test is regarded in the relevant art.
Who may represent a party before the PTAB?
Lead counsel must be a registered practitioner. Back-up counsel may be an attorney admitted pro hac vice for good cause, and the Board may disqualify counsel for cause after notice and a hearing.
Under 37 CFR 42.10(a), a party represented by counsel designates a lead counsel, who must be a registered practitioner, and at least one back-up counsel. The Board may waive the back-up requirement for good cause, for example where a party shows it cannot afford both. A power of attorney accompanies the designation (42.10(b)).
Under section 42.10(c)(1), the Board may recognize counsel who is not a registered practitioner pro hac vice for good cause, provided a registered practitioner is lead counsel. The rule gives as an example an experienced litigation attorney with an established familiarity with the subject matter. Paragraph (c)(2) sets a streamlined route for attorneys admitted before, and (c)(3) requires notice to the Board within five business days of sanctions, suspension or loss of good standing.
Under 42.10(d), a panel may disqualify counsel for cause after notice and opportunity for a hearing, and under 42.10(e) counsel may not withdraw without the Board's authorization. A patent attorney who acts as counsel in the proceeding argues the case; the declarations on technical questions come from witnesses.
What must a patent law expert's report contain?
The six items of Rule 26(a)(2)(B), and for a patent law expert the list of facts and assumptions supplied by counsel matters most, because communications identifying them are not protected from discovery.
A retained expert's report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) contains a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, the exhibits, the witness's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, the cases with trial or deposition testimony in the previous 4 years, and the compensation.
Rule 26(b)(4)(C) protects communications between the party's attorney and the expert, with three exceptions: communications about compensation, communications identifying facts or data the attorney provided and the expert considered, and communications identifying assumptions the attorney provided and the expert relied on. A patent law expert usually works from the file history and from facts selected by counsel, so the other side will see which facts and assumptions were supplied.
The cases above give the drafting rule. Each opinion is tied to a Patent Office rule or a document in the file history, and none states what a party intended or what an examiner was thinking.
When does a case need a patent law expert at all?
Where the outcome turns on how the Patent Office handled the application: inequitable conduct defenses, disputes over what the prosecution history shows, and broadening or reexamination questions like those in Network-1.
In Gore and Network-1 the patent law experts were offered in disputes about conduct before the Patent Office: undisclosed references in Gore, broadening contentions and reexamination in Network-1. In Wright Asphalt the expert was offered to describe Patent Office practice and alleged irregularities in the handling of the patent in suit.
In each case the court treated the testimony as background for the judge or jury and kept the conclusions for the fact finder. A party that needs the conclusion, for example that a reference was material, builds it from the documents and the technical expert's analysis, and uses the patent law expert to explain the procedure.
Before the PTAB the same need does not arise, because section 42.65(a) excludes the testimony. A party there spends its expert budget on the technical declaration.
What does IAE do for patent disputes?
An IAE expert in the technical field of the patent prepares an infringement or validity report or reviews the opposing technical expert's report, for district court and PTAB proceedings, in up to 5 business days.
The IAE patent expertise page describes the work as technical: claim charts that map each claim element to the accused product, equivalents element by element, prior art searches before the effective filing date and obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103. IAE chooses the expert by the technical field of the patent and confirms the patent, the asserted claims and the questions before work starts. The page notes, as the PTAB rule does, that testimony on patent law or examination practice is not admitted before the Board.
The client sends the patent number, the asserted claims, the description of the accused product and, where they exist, the claim construction order and the opposing expert's report. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the expert from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. A 48-hour rush is available for tight deadlines.
Every expert is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and states in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court or the Board weighs with the other evidence; neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 37 CFR part 42, Trial Practice Before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, sections 42.10 and 42.65 (CFR, 2020 edition, GovInfo)
- USPTO, Expanding Opportunities to Appear Before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, final rule amending 37 CFR 42.10(a) and (c), 89 FR, October 10, 2024 (GovInfo)
- W.L. Gore & Associates, Inc. v. C.R. Bard, Inc., No. 11-515-LPS-CJB (D. Del. Nov. 20, 2015), memorandum order
- Network-1 Technologies, Inc. v. Alcatel-Lucent USA, Inc., No. 6:11-cv-492 (E.D. Tex. Sept. 21, 2017), Doc. 972 (Justia)
- Wright Asphalt Products Co. v. Pelican Refining Co., No. H-09-1145 (S.D. Tex. May 29, 2012), Doc. 122 (Justia)
- Sundance, Inc. v. DeMonte Fabricating Ltd., Nos. 2008-1068, -1115 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 24, 2008), opinion (copy of the court's PDF)
Read also
All articles
Prior user rights: what must an accused infringer prove under 35 U.S.C. 273, and what does the technical expert compare?
A company that has run a process in its plant for years can be sued when someone else later patents the same process. Section 273 of the Patent Act
Patent inventorship dispute: who is an inventor, and how does the technical expert map each contribution to the claims?
An inventorship dispute asks who conceived what the claims cover. A former employee, a university collaborator or a supplier's engineer says he
Process patent infringement: how is it proved that a product was made by the patented method?
A process patent is infringed when someone performs the claimed method in the United States, or imports, sells or uses a product made by itExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

