Expert report review

Rebutting a cargo seal examination report: what does the reviewer check?

A seal examination report in a cargo loss case answers whether the seal that reached the consignee was the seal applied at origin and whether anyone opened and reclosed it. A rebuttal tests each step: the seal records, the seal's class under ISO 17712, the examination of the bolt or cable, the line between the cut made at delivery and any earlier cut, and the wording of the conclusion. In federal court the rebuttal report is due within 30 days.

Gloved hands hold a cut plastic cargo seal beside a container door latch in a warm warehouse

What does a review of a cargo seal examination report check?

Whether the seal is tied to the shipment by its number, whether its class and design were identified, whether the examiner looked inside the seal, how the delivery cut was separated from tampering, and how the conclusion is worded.

A seal examination turns on two questions. The first is identity: was the seal on the doors at delivery the seal applied at loading? The second is integrity: did anyone open the doors and reclose them with the same seal or a substitute? An opposing report that answers the second question without settling the first has no foundation.

The reviewer reads the report against the records and the physical evidence. The seal number in the report is compared with the bills of lading, the seal log and the delivery receipt. The description of the seal is compared with its class and design. The examiner's notes and photographs show whether the seal was taken apart and examined inside or only looked at from outside.

Each finding in the review is linked to a page of the opposing report or to a photograph, and to a standard, a rule or a ruling. That form lets counsel put the findings to the opposing examiner at deposition and turn them into a rebuttal report.

Which records tie the examined seal to the shipment?

The seal number on the bill of lading, the seal log, records of any replacement seal and the delivery receipt. CBP's CTPAT criteria require written seal procedures, a seal log and a check of the number against shipping documents.

The CTPAT Minimum Security Criteria for consolidators, issued by U.S. Customs and Border Protection in October 2021, describe the records a member keeps. Criterion 6.1 requires "detailed, written high-security seal procedures that describe how seals are issued and controlled," with the issuance of seals recorded in a log and seals tracked through the log. If a seal is broken in transit, the driver notifies dispatch and the carrier notifies the shipper, broker and importer of the replacement seal number, which the shipper records in the seal log.

Criterion 6.7 sets the verification steps known as VVTT: view the seal and the container locking mechanisms and check that they are in order, "Verify seal number against shipment documents for accuracy," "Tug on seal to make sure it is affixed properly," and "Twist and turn the bolt seal to make sure its components do not unscrew." Criterion 6.6 requires audits that reconcile seal inventories against seal logs and shipping documents.

Where these records exist, the reviewer checks whether the opposing examiner used them. A report that examines a seal without saying where its number appears in the shipping file, or that ignores a replacement seal recorded in transit, has examined an object whose link to the shipment is unproven.

What class of seal was it, and why does that matter?

ISO 17712:2013 classifies container seals as indicative, security or high-security by their barrier capability. The class tells the reviewer how much force the seal resists; it says nothing about how hard the seal is to tamper with.

ISO 17712:2013, Freight containers, Mechanical seals, "establishes uniform procedures for the classification, acceptance, and withdrawal of mechanical freight container seals." It is the second edition, which replaced ISO 17712:2010, was prepared by ISO/TC 104 and has the status "International Standard confirmed." An indicative seal is made of material "that can easily be broken by hand or by using a simple snipping tool or shear." A high-security seal is made of material "such as metal or metal cable."

Clause 5.1.1 states that the class terms "refer to the barrier capabilities of the seal," and the standard adds that the class names "do not imply any differences in security against tampering." A report that treats a high-security bolt seal as proof that nobody could have opened the container confuses resistance to force with tamper evidence.

The standard defines tamper evidence as a "tell-tale indication that an attempt has been made to open or remove and then replace or reconstruct" the seal. CTPAT criterion 6.2 requires members' seals to meet or exceed the latest ISO 17712 standard and to be placed on the secure cam position where available, and criterion 6.5 requires members to document compliance, for example with a laboratory testing certificate. The reviewer checks whether the opposing report identified the seal's make, class and certificate before drawing conclusions about it.

Can a bolt seal be opened and reclosed so that it looks intact?

Yes. In AIG Europe v. Locust Point Terminal, the seals on two containers of leather skins were found intact at pickup, and a later inspection established that they had been removed and reattached.

The Fourth Circuit decided the appeal on January 5, 1998, in an unpublished per curiam opinion that affirmed the judgment of the Eastern District of Virginia. The cargo was tanned and dyed leather skins, shipped through Naples and Norfolk to I.L. USA in Randleman, North Carolina. The first container carried a steel band-type seal applied by the shipper and a bolt-type security seal that the ocean carrier, MSC, placed on the doors before loading. Two of ten pallets were missing from the first shipment and six of nineteen from the second. The motor carrier's driver and a terminal guard found the seals intact when the containers were picked up.

Footnote 4 of the opinion records what a closer look showed: "Subsequent inspection of the seals from both shipments established that they were removed and reattached." The court found that "somewhere between Naples and Randleman the containers were broken into and cargo stolen." The check at pickup, which looked at the seals from outside, had recorded them as intact.

A reviewer takes the minimum from such a case: an opinion that a bolt seal was not tampered with needs an examination of the bolt and the receptor, beyond the "twist and turn" check of CTPAT criterion 6.7; a photograph of the closed seal is not enough. If the opposing examiner did not separate the parts, the report does not support a finding of no tampering.

How is the cut made at delivery told apart from an earlier cut?

By the record of who cut the seal at delivery, with what tool and where, and by comparing the cut surfaces with that tool. A report that does not identify the delivery cut cannot attribute any other cut to tampering.

The consignee removes the seal when the doors are opened at delivery. In AIG Europe, an employee of I.L. USA, the receiving company, cut the seals at delivery and found pallets missing. The delivery cut is the one cut whose time, place and tool can be known.

The reviewer asks whether the opposing report names the person who cut the seal at delivery and the tool used, whether the examiner examined that tool or made test cuts with it, and whether the report describes more than one cut on the bolt or cable. A second cut, a cut with different tool marks, or a section of a different bolt inside the receptor are observations; a report that records none of them and still concludes tampering, or no tampering, rests on the conclusion alone.

CTPAT criterion 6.1 tells members to "retain altered or tampered seals to aid in investigations," to investigate the discrepancy and to document it. A party that kept the seal and its parts can give both examiners the same object; a party that discarded them leaves only photographs, and the reviewer states what the photographs can and cannot show.

What may an examiner conclude about cut pieces and toolmarks on a seal?

Under the DOJ fracture examination ULTR, effective August 16, 2023, an examiner may report a fracture fit, an exclusion or an inconclusive result, and may not claim uniqueness, exclusion of all other sources or absolute certainty.

The Department of Justice Uniform Language for Testimony and Reports for firearms and toolmarks fracture examination governs DOJ examiners who decide whether two or more items were originally joined together. A fracture fit is the conclusion that fractured items were once joined, and it requires that the items physically fit or that a comparison of their corresponding surfaces reveals a fit. Exclusion is the conclusion that they were not joined. Inconclusive means that "no determination can be reached."

The same document bars basing a fit or an exclusion on uniqueness, using the words "individualize" or "individualization," claiming a common source to the exclusion of all other sources, giving statistics without relevant and appropriate data, and claiming absolute or 100 percent certainty. The number of examinations an examiner has done may describe experience, not the accuracy of a conclusion.

A seal examiner retained by a party is not bound by DOJ rules, but the ULTR gives the reviewer a published scale for the wording. A report that says the two halves of a cable could have come from no other seal goes beyond what a DOJ examiner may say, and the 2023 committee note to Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence tells forensic experts to avoid assertions of absolute certainty when the method is subjective.

Does an intact seal settle who is liable for the shortage?

No. In AIG Europe the ocean carrier was not liable because the plaintiff did not show it delivered less than intact containers; the motor carrier, which issued clean bills of lading with gross weights, was liable under the Carmack Amendment.

Against the ocean carrier, Mediterranean Shipping Company, the ocean bills of lading were governed by the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act. The record showed that both containers were delivered intact to MSC in Naples, but the Fourth Circuit wrote that "AIG fails to establish that MSC delivered less than the intact containers to Norfolk," and it found no error in the ruling that MSC was not liable.

Against the motor carrier, Locust Point Terminal Corporation, trading as Marine Freight Company, the claim arose under the Carmack Amendment. "Upon receiving the containers, Marine Freight issued clean bills of lading specifying the gross weight of the containers," and the containers arrived short. Marine Freight did not prove an excepted cause, and the Fourth Circuit held that the district court "did not err in finding Marine Freight liable for the loss of cargo." It also upheld the denial of prejudgment interest.

A seal report is one piece of such a case. The review tells counsel whether that piece holds; who bears the loss is decided by the court under the statute and the shipping documents.

When is the rebuttal report due, and what must it contain?

Absent a stipulation or court order, within 30 days after the other side's disclosure, if it only contradicts or rebuts evidence on the same subject matter. It contains the same six parts as any retained expert's report.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires disclosures "at the times and in the sequence that the court orders." Absent a stipulation or order, rebuttal evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party" is due "within 30 days after the other party's disclosure."

A rebuttal on a seal examination contains the opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, the reviewer's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, prior testimony from the previous 4 years and compensation, as Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires. Under Rule 26(e)(2), the duty to supplement covers both the report and the deposition, and additions are due by the time pretrial disclosures under Rule 26(a)(3) are due.

A new theory, such as an opinion on where the theft happened, goes beyond rebuttal. The reviewer keeps the report to the subject of the opposing report and flags any new opinion so counsel can disclose it on the schedule for affirmative experts.

What does the reviewer need from the other side?

The seal and its parts or the examiner's photographs, the examiner's notes, the bills of lading and seal log, the delivery receipt, and the name of the person who cut the seal at delivery and the tool used.

The opposing report is the start. The reviewer also needs the material the report rests on: photographs of the seal on the doors, of the cut surfaces and of the parts after disassembly, the examiner's notes and any test cuts or comparison seals of the same make.

The shipping file comes next: the bill of lading with the seal number, the shipper's seal log, any record of a replacement seal in transit, the delivery receipt and the surveyor's report. Where the seal is held by the other side, counsel can ask for both examiners to see it.

Counsel also sends the questions. Whether the seal is the one applied at origin, whether it was opened and reclosed, and whether the opposing conclusion is worded within published limits are three questions, and the review answers each one separately.

What does IAE do when a party needs a seal examination report reviewed?

IAE reviews the opposing examiner's report on locks and seals, or prepares an expert report on the client's questions, for US cargo loss and criminal cases, in up to 5 business days or 48 hours on rush.

Toolmarks on lock cylinders and seals are compared with test marks made by the suspect tool, and freight container seals are classified under ISO 17712:2013, confirmed in 2023. The review checks the case file against the standard for that kind of mark, including whether the verification is recorded and who performed it. Each point is tied to a page of the report or the bench notes and to a standard, a DOJ rule or a ruling.

IAE confirms the questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs a review with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member