Expert report review

Rebuttal medical expert: what can the physician testify about at trial?

A rebuttal physician may contradict, explain away or disprove what the other side's expert said, on the same subject. Opinions that the party needed to prove its own case, or that open a new theory, belong in the main disclosure and can be cut. Courts draw the line opinion by opinion, as the Southern District of Ohio did in 2021 when it kept part of a rebuttal pathology report and excluded the rest.

A physician seen from behind stands by a courtroom chair holding a thin closed folder

What makes a physician's testimony rebuttal rather than part of the case-in-chief?

Its target. Rebuttal testimony answers evidence the other side offered on the same subject matter. Testimony that proves an element of the party's own claim or defense is case-in-chief testimony, whatever label the disclosure gives it.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure describes rebuttal evidence as evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) or (C). The rule ties rebuttal to a subject the other side has already put in play through its own expert disclosure.

Courts phrase the same test in their own words. In Bereal v. Bajaj, a malpractice appeal decided by the Court of Appeals of Kansas on April 1, 2016 (No. 111,954), the court collected several formulations. Bleck v. City of Alamosa (D. Colo. 2012) required that rebuttal testimony relate to and rebut evidence or testimony on the same subject matter identified by another party. Crowley v. Chait (D.N.J. 2004) admitted rebuttal evidence that will explain, repel, counteract or disprove the evidence of the adverse party.

Kansas has its own rule, K.S.A. 60-226(b)(6)(C)(ii), which permits expert testimony intended solely to contradict or rebut other expert testimony. The court noted that the Kansas and federal rules are identical, so federal case law may guide the analysis.

Can a rebuttal physician address standard of care or causation?

Only as an answer to the other side's evidence on those subjects. A plaintiff's physician who first establishes the standard of care in rebuttal is filling a gap in the case-in-chief, and courts exclude that testimony.

The Eastern District of California drew the line in Medina v. Mapes (No. 1:21-cv-00844, order on motions in limine of August 10, 2025). On the plaintiffs' expert Daria Majzoubi, M.D., the court wrote: "By no stretch of the imagination can Dr. Majzoubi's designation be called rebuttal testimony. She speaks to standard of care only, which is an issue Plaintiffs must prove in their case in chief." It added that the fact that she disagreed with the defense experts did not make her a rebuttal expert.

The other side of the line was drawn in Bereal. The defense causation theory pointed at the injection equipment made by Medrad, a defendant the plaintiff had sued on products liability, and the plaintiff's rebuttal expert, Dr. Suzanne Parisian, a physician with expertise in FDA-approved radiological products, was offered to answer that theory. The trial court struck her, reasoning that whatever she had to say about the equipment should have been said in the original disclosure. The Court of Appeals disagreed. Quoting Taylor v. Mazzola (Colo. 1962), it held that "A party is not required to anticipate the testimony the opposing party will offer in defense."

The court also relied on People v. Welsh (Colo. 2003): rebuttal that explains, refutes, counteracts or disproves the other party's evidence is not stricken merely because it also supports the party's case-in-chief. It found Warden v. Exempla (Colo. 2012) persuasive, where the exclusion of a timely rebuttal expert was reversed. A rebuttal physician may therefore discuss causation when the defense has offered an alternative cause, but the testimony has to stay pointed at that alternative.

When must a rebuttal physician be disclosed?

On the court's schedule, or, absent a stipulation or order, within 30 days after the other party's expert disclosure. A rebuttal expert first named at trial is allowed only in limited circumstances.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D) requires expert disclosures at the times and in the sequence that the court orders. Absent a stipulation or a court order, affirmative disclosures are due at least 90 days before the date set for trial or for the case to be ready for trial, and rebuttal disclosures within 30 days after the other party's disclosure.

The Sixth Circuit applied these rules in Mathis v. Roa, a medical malpractice and wrongful death appeal decided on October 30, 2019 (No. 18-4168). During trial the plaintiffs sought to call a pathologist they had retained, Dr. Gerald Penn, to answer the defense expert, Dr. Subinoy Das, on glial cells found in re-cut pathology slides. Citing Benedict v. United States (6th Cir. 1987), the court said that a party may call a previously undisclosed rebuttal expert after the opposing party's expert has testified, "but only under limited circumstances."

Those circumstances were missing. Das had released his report before March 2016 and had mentioned the pathology report from the first surgery. The plaintiffs had ample opportunity to rebut his testimony once they learned what he based his opinion on, but they never listed Penn before trial. The court of appeals said the late request amounted to "blindsiding" and affirmed the exclusion. The opinion also states that there was no justification for Penn's eleventh-hour testimony. The district court had remarked that a request made a month before trial would have led it to permit a deposition or allow either side another expert.

Does a rebuttal physician need a full written report?

Yes, if retained to testify. Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a signed report with every opinion and its basis, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications, prior testimony and compensation. The other side may then depose the physician.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) applies to a witness retained or specially employed to provide expert testimony, and a rebuttal physician hired for the case is such a witness. The report must contain a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, any exhibits, the witness's qualifications with a list of publications from the previous 10 years, a list of cases in which the witness testified as an expert during the previous 4 years, and a statement of compensation.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) a party may depose any person identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and where a report is required the deposition follows the report. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(E) the party seeking the deposition pays the expert a reasonable fee for the time spent, unless manifest injustice would result.

Communications between counsel and the rebuttal physician are protected under Rule 26(b)(4)(C), except to the extent they relate to compensation, identify facts or data that counsel provided and that the physician considered, or identify assumptions that counsel provided and that the physician relied on. A list of facts that counsel asked the physician to assume falls within the third exception.

Which rebuttal opinions do courts cut as beyond scope?

Opinions that leave the other expert's subject for a new one: the opposing party's conduct, a new standard of care, a new liability theory. In the 2021 hernia mesh litigation the court kept the slide opinions and cut the others.

In re Davol, Inc./C.R. Bard, Inc., Polypropylene Hernia Mesh Products Liability Litigation (S.D. Ohio, MDL No. 2846) gives an example. In Evidentiary Motions Order No. 16, entered in Johns v. C.R. Bard on August 16, 2021 (ECF No. 514), Judge Edmund A. Sargus, Jr. ruled on the defendants' motion to exclude the plaintiff's rebuttal expert, Tamas Nagy, DVM, Ph.D. Nagy had answered the defense expert's reading of pathology slides.

The court found Nagy qualified and his opinions reliable, then measured each opinion against his assignment. It wrote that his "rebuttal report is confined to responding to Dr. Badylak's review of the slides" and that the court "only permitted Dr. Nagy to respond to Dr. Badylak's report." On that basis it excluded his opinion that the defendants' possession of certain information showed that the duration of a hydrogel coating was known and not reported, because the opinion went beyond rebuttal and verged on the defendants' conduct. It also excluded any opinion that the defendants violated a standard of care by not following Good Laboratory Practice standards.

The court permitted his opinion that the hydrogel would have been noted on the slides if present, considering Good Laboratory Practices, because that opinion went to the accuracy of the defense expert's interpretation. Whether Nagy had disclaimed any Good Laboratory Practice opinion at his deposition was left for cross-examination, and the court declined to issue a broad order precluding opinions he did not appear to offer.

In the order, the opinions that survived were those tied to the defense expert's reading of the slides. A reviewing physician therefore pairs each rebuttal opinion with the defense opinion it answers and marks any opinion that has no pair.

Does Rule 702 apply to a rebuttal physician?

Yes. A rebuttal expert is an expert witness, and the proponent must show the court that each opinion more likely than not rests on sufficient facts or data and a reliable method reliably applied.

Rule 702 sets one standard for every expert. The witness must be qualified by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education, and the proponent must show the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion is a reliable application of those principles and methods to the facts of the case.

The 2023 committee note adds that each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology. A rebuttal physician who answers a defense causation opinion by saying it is wrong, without stating what in the chart or the literature shows it to be wrong, gives the court nothing to measure under Rule 702(b) and (d).

Rule 703 lets an expert base an opinion on facts or data in the case that the expert has been made aware of or personally observed. For a rebuttal physician those facts are usually the chart, the imaging, the pathology and the defense expert's report and deposition. In the Davol order the court decided qualification and reliability for the rebuttal expert first and turned to scope after that.

What if the defense expert offers a new opinion at trial?

Object when the testimony is given and state the ground. If the opinion departs from the report, the court may exclude it or allow a response, but a party that stays silent may lose the point.

Rule 103(a)(1) of the Federal Rules of Evidence preserves a claim of error in admitting evidence only if a party, on the record, timely objects or moves to strike and states the specific ground, unless it was apparent from the context. Under Rule 103(b), once the court rules definitively on the record, a party need not renew the objection.

In Mathis the Sixth Circuit said that an expert must submit a report setting forth the opinions he is offering, and that testimony at trial exceeding the scope of that report or setting forth a new theory is subject to exclusion under Rule 37. When an expert's opinion departs from his report, the opposing party may respond through rebuttal expert testimony of its own. The court found no inconsistency between Das's report and his testimony, and called the plaintiffs' failure to object when he testified a problematic failure, because a party that claims surprise should alert the district court when the expert testifies.

A reviewing physician who sits through the defense expert's testimony with the report and deposition at hand can tell counsel at once whether an opinion is new. That moment decides whether the answer is an objection, a request to call a rebuttal witness, or cross-examination.

What happens when a rebuttal physician is excluded or disclosed late?

Rule 37(c)(1) bars a witness not disclosed as Rule 26 requires unless the failure was substantially justified or harmless. Wrongly excluding a timely rebuttal physician can lead to a new trial, as in Bereal.

Rule 37(c)(1) provides that a party that fails to identify a witness as Rule 26(a) or (e) requires is not allowed to use that witness to supply evidence on a motion, at a hearing or at a trial, unless the failure was substantially justified or is harmless. In addition to or instead of that sanction, the court may order payment of the reasonable expenses caused by the failure, inform the jury of the failure or impose other appropriate sanctions.

In Medina v. Mapes the court had granted the plaintiffs several extensions solely for the purpose of designating a rebuttal expert to respond to the opinions of the defendant's retained infectious disease expert. It did not find the failure to designate Dr. Majzoubi timely to be "substantially justified or harmless" and granted the motion to exclude.

The reverse error is reviewed for abuse of discretion, and it can undo a verdict. In Bereal the Court of Appeals held that Dr. Parisian's testimony was intended solely to rebut the defense expert's causation theory and was not cumulative of the plaintiff's other experts. It rejected the argument that the exclusion was harmless, because the jury might have reached a different result had it heard her, and it affirmed in part, reversed in part and remanded for a new trial.

What does IAE do when a party needs a rebuttal to the opposing medical expert?

A physician from the IAE registry in the specialty of the care at issue tests each opposing opinion against the chart and Rule 702 and writes a review or a rebuttal report in up to 5 business days.

The review tests each opinion of the opposing medical expert against the chart, and each check rests on a rule of evidence or of civil procedure. The review questions are agreed with the client before work starts.

While the physician only consults, Rule 26(b)(4)(D) ordinarily bars discovery of facts known and opinions held by an expert retained in anticipation of litigation who will not testify. If counsel decides to use the physician at trial, the physician is disclosed, signs a report with the items of Rule 26(a)(2)(B) and can be deposed after the report is served. At trial the reviewer compares live testimony with the report.

IAE confirms receipt the same day and the format, cost, deadline and the physician within one business day, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees how the court will rule.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member