Expert report review

What does a review of the opposing warranty damages expert report check?

A review of the opposing warranty damages report tests each figure against the statute and the record. The reviewer separates the difference in value under UCC 2-714 from incidental and consequential items under 2-715, checks the inputs the report must disclose under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) and compares the total with the price. In Winchester v. McCulloch Bros. Garage (Ala. 1980) a $20,000 verdict for an $8,225 Jeep could not stand.

Hands set a cracked appliance panel beside an intact one and a dark calculator

Which rules does the reviewer test the opposing damages figure against?

UCC 2-714 for the loss on accepted goods, UCC 2-715 for incidental and consequential items, and UCC 2-607 for notice and the buyer's burden of establishing the breach.

Section 2-714(2) sets the standard measure as a difference between two values fixed at the time and place of acceptance, 2-714(1) lets the loss be determined in any reasonable manner, and 2-714(3) admits incidental and consequential damages in a proper case. Each state enacts these sections in its own code, as Nebraska does. The review takes the measure from the governing enactment and asks one question about every number in the opposing report: where it came from and which subsection it belongs to.

What must the opposing damages report show about its inputs?

Under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) the report states every opinion with its basis and reasons, the facts or data the expert considered and the exhibits that will be used to summarize or support the figures.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) lists six parts of a retained expert's report. Three of them carry a damages calculation: item (i), "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them"; item (ii), "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them"; and item (iii), "any exhibits that will be used to summarize or support them." Item (vi) adds a statement of the compensation paid for the study and testimony.

For a damages figure those items become a list the reviewer checks line by line: the contract and the price, the invoice behind each expense, the repair estimate with its date and author, the market data behind any value, and the table that turns them into a total. A number that appears in the conclusion with no source in that list is the first point of the review.

Inputs supplied by counsel are not shielded. Rule 26(b)(4)(C) protects most communications between a party's attorney and its expert, but not those that "identify facts or data that the party's attorney provided and that the expert considered" or "identify assumptions that the party's attorney provided and that the expert relied on." A purchase date, a rental period or a lost contract taken from counsel goes into the review as an assumption, with a note of who supplied it.

Does the damages figure rest on sufficient facts or data?

Rule 702 admits the testimony only if the proponent persuades the court that it is more likely than not based on sufficient facts or data and applies a reliable method reliably to the facts of the case.

Rule 702(b) requires that "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data," and Rule 702(d) requires a reliable application of the principles and methods to the facts of the case. The committee note to the 2023 amendment adds that "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology."

Shoop v. DaimlerChrysler Corp., 371 Ill. App. 3d 1058, shows what a stated basis looks like. The buyer paid $28,000 for a 2002 Dodge Dakota. One of his witnesses put the loss at 35 percent of the value at the time of purchase after a visual inspection, a road test and a review of the service history and technical service bulletins. Another, working from the repair records, valued the truck at $22,300 at purchase. The Illinois Appellate Court held that their testimony created a genuine issue of material fact.

The review applies the same test to the opposing figure. For every value, percentage or cost it names the document or observation behind it and the date of that document. A percentage reduction or a guide value with no data about this item and this defect is recorded as a figure without a stated basis.

How does the reviewer check a repair estimate used as the measure?

By its author, date and scope. Winchester called cost to repair a useful measure of the difference in values where the goods are repairable, and the repair estimate in that case was about $1,200.

The Alabama court wrote that "where the goods are repairable, cost to repair is a useful measure of the difference in values." The repair estimate in Winchester was about $1,200. Because the jury awarded $20,000 on a repair cost of that size, the court reasoned that the jury must have found that the limited repair remedy had failed of its essential purpose.

A repair figure fits the statute only if the repair would bring the goods to the condition warranted. The review checks who prepared the estimate, whether it covers every defect the defect opinion names, whether it uses parts of the quality warranted, and whether the goods would still be worth less after repair because of their history. When the report adds a separate diminished value after repair, the review checks that the two figures do not count the same loss twice.

A repair estimate prepared years after acceptance raises a question of date, because 2-714(2) fixes the values at the time and place of acceptance. The report should say whether the prices are those of the date of acceptance or of a later date, and why.

Can the damages figure exceed the price of the goods?

Not in Winchester. The court held that without proven consequential damages the total award could not exceed the $8,225 price, and it upheld the order requiring a remittitur of the $20,000 verdict or a new trial.

Winchester v. McCulloch Bros. Garage, Inc., No. 78-754, was decided by the Supreme Court of Alabama on September 26, 1980, in an opinion by Chief Justice Torbert. The buyer paid $8,225 for a 1978 Jeep Honcho. The rear leaf spring came loose and the drive shaft broke at the universal joint when the Jeep had 692 miles on it, and, as the dissent noted, it was never repaired.

The jury in Winchester returned a verdict of $20,000. The court found it excessive: even if the vehicle could not be repaired and had no salvage value, "the total award could not exceed $8,225" because no consequential damages were proven to add to that figure. It affirmed the trial judge's order requiring a remittitur or a new trial. Two justices dissented and would have set damages at $10,781.

The arithmetic follows from the measure. The court wrote that "The purchase price is evidence of the value of the goods as warranted," and the value of the goods as accepted could not fall below zero, so the difference could not exceed the price. Any larger figure has to come from 2-714(3) and 2-715, with its own proof.

A review compares the opposing total with the price and with the 2-714(2) difference the report itself states. Where the total is larger, the review asks the report to show which items make up the excess and under which subsection each is claimed.

The review checks the price itself before using it as the ceiling. A price paid under a discount, a trade-in allowance or a bundled deal may differ from the value of conforming goods, and the review asks the report to say what the price included.

Which incidental expenses can be added to the difference in value?

Expenses reasonably incurred because of the breach: inspection, receipt, transportation and care of goods rightfully rejected, the costs of effecting cover, and any other reasonable expense incident to the delay or other breach.

Section 2-715(1) defines incidental damages as including "expenses reasonably incurred in inspection, receipt, transportation and care and custody of goods rightfully rejected," commercially reasonable charges, expenses or commissions in connection with effecting cover, "and any other reasonable expense incident to the delay or other breach." Under 2-714(3) such items may be added to the difference in value "in a proper case."

The statute sets two conditions for each expense: it was incurred because of the breach, and it was reasonable. The review asks for the invoice, its date and its link to the defect. An expense dated before the defect appeared, or a storage charge that runs past the date the buyer disposed of the goods, does not meet the first condition.

Winchester applied the same reasoning to a substitute vehicle. The buyer claimed the cost of renting one, and because he "borrowed, then bought, another car," the court held that the rental cost of a substitute car was not an item of damage.

When can consequential losses be added to the damages figure?

When the seller had reason to know of the buyer's needs at contracting and the loss could not reasonably be prevented by cover or otherwise, or when the breach caused injury to person or property.

Under 2-715(2)(a), consequential damages include "any loss resulting from general or particular requirements and needs of which the seller at the time of contracting had reason to know and which could not reasonably be prevented by cover or otherwise." Under 2-715(2)(b) they include "injury to person or property proximately resulting from any breach of warranty."

Each clause gives the review a question of fact. For a lost contract or lost production, the reviewer looks for evidence of what the seller knew when the contract was made: the purchase order, the specification, correspondence about the intended use. For the second condition the reviewer checks whether the report considered cover or other steps that could have prevented the loss, and what it says about them.

Winchester shows what happens without that proof. The court held that "no includable consequential damage was shown," and the total stayed within the price. A consequential item without evidence on both conditions stays out of the total, whatever label the report gives it.

Can the costs of the lawsuit be built into the damages figure?

Not as consequential damages under Winchester. The buyer had spent $1,000 on an expert witness, and the Supreme Court of Alabama held that expenses of trial preparation are not consequential damages.

In Winchester the buyer "spent $1,000 for an expert witness" and claimed it with his damages. The court wrote that "expenses of trial preparation are not consequential damages." Under that holding, fees for the damages expert and for work done only to prepare for trial stay out of the damages total.

The line can be fine. An inspection the buyer paid for to find out what was wrong with the goods may count as a reasonable expense incident to the breach under 2-715(1), while an inspection ordered to support the claim is trial preparation. The review records who ordered each inspection, when and for what purpose.

What does the damages figure assume about breach and notice?

That the buyer will establish the breach and gave notice. Under UCC 2-607 a buyer who does not notify the seller within a reasonable time is barred from any remedy, and the buyer carries the burden of establishing breach.

Under 2-607(3)(a) the buyer "must within a reasonable time after he discovers or should have discovered any breach notify the seller of breach or be barred from any remedy," and under 2-607(4) "The burden is on the buyer to establish any breach with respect to the goods accepted." Section 2-714(1) speaks of a buyer who has accepted goods and given notification.

A damages report usually takes the defect as given. The review records that dependence: if the defect opinion fails, every figure built on it falls with it. It also checks whether any loss in the report starts before the date the defect was found or before notice, and whether the report explains why.

What does a review check in the opposing damages figure?

The source and date of every input, the basis of each value, the repair estimate, the total against the price, the legal basis and evidence for each item under 2-715, and costs of the lawsuit placed in the total.

The checks follow the structure of the opposing report.

  • The reviewer lists every input of the calculation with its source and date and marks the inputs supplied by counsel.
  • The reviewer checks the basis of each value against Rule 702: inspection data, repair records or market data for this item and this defect.
  • The reviewer checks who prepared the repair estimate, whether it covers every defect in the defect opinion and whether a diminished value after repair counts the same loss twice.
  • The reviewer compares the total with the price and with the 2-714(2) difference the report itself states.
  • The reviewer matches every added item with 2-715(1) or 2-715(2) and with the invoice or other evidence behind it.
  • The reviewer removes expert fees and other trial preparation costs from the damages total.
  • The reviewer checks that the defect opinion the figure depends on is supported, because under 2-607(4) the buyer carries the burden of establishing the breach.

How is the review used against the opposing damages expert?

As the basis for a rebuttal report, for deposition questions and for a Rule 702 motion. A rebuttal report on the same subject is due within 30 days after the other side's disclosure, absent a stipulation or court order.

Under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), absent a stipulation or court order, evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter" is due "within 30 days after the other party's disclosure." A reviewer who will testify serves a report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) with the same six parts as the report under review.

Rule 26(b)(4)(A) provides: "A party may depose any person who has been identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial." The review supplies the questions: where each input came from, which assumptions counsel supplied, why a repair estimate was used in place of a difference in value, and which subsection of 2-715 each added item relies on.

A figure with no stated basis supports a motion under Rule 702, because the proponent has to show that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data. A figure with a thin basis goes into the cross-examination outline.

What does IAE do when the opposing warranty damages figure needs a review?

IAE prepares a review of the opposing expert's report, or an expert report on the client's questions, for warranty and supply disputes in US courts. The signed document is issued within up to 5 business days.

One of the questions on the IAE product defect page is what the goods were worth as accepted. The page states the rule the expert applies: under UCC 2-714(2) damages are the difference between the value of the goods as accepted and their value as warranted, and the expert sets both values at the time and place of acceptance. A review of the opposing report lists the tests the expert did not run and the conclusions the data do not support.

The client sends the opposing report with its exhibits and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The draft is checked for facts, and the signed PDF is issued within up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Registry members passed the council's collegial attestation under the published Criteria Matrix. The Member ID in the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status on the status check page or by QR code, and the specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case.

Materials are sent through the form on the contact page or by email and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A review is evidence that the court weighs together with the other materials, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member