For attorneys

Derogatory information under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(i): when must USCIS disclose it before denying a petition, and how is it rebutted?

USCIS may not deny a petition on information the petitioner has never seen without first saying so. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(i), when an adverse decision rests on derogatory information that the petitioner does not know about, USCIS advises the petitioner and offers an opportunity to rebut it before deciding. The exceptions that let USCIS keep information from the petitioner concern classified information, and a separate provision lets USCIS hold a case during an investigation.

An attorney from behind holds a notice face down beside a blank pad

What does 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(i) require?

If an adverse decision will rest on derogatory information USCIS considered and the petitioner does not know about, USCIS must advise the petitioner and offer a chance to rebut it first. The rebuttal goes into the record.

Paragraph (b)(16) of 8 CFR 103.2 opens with a right of inspection: "An applicant or petitioner shall be permitted to inspect the record of proceeding which constitutes the basis for the decision, except as provided in the following paragraphs." Subparagraph (i), titled "Derogatory information unknown to petitioner or applicant," is the first of those paragraphs.

Its text: "If the decision will be adverse to the applicant or petitioner and is based on derogatory information considered by the Service and of which the applicant or petitioner is unaware, he/she shall be advised of this fact and offered an opportunity to rebut the information and present information in his/her own behalf before the decision is rendered, except as provided in paragraphs (b)(16)(ii), (iii), and (iv) of this section."

The rule has three conditions. The decision will be adverse. It is based on derogatory information that the Service considered. The petitioner is unaware of that information. When all three are present, two obligations follow: USCIS advises the petitioner of the fact, and USCIS offers an opportunity to rebut and to present information before it decides.

The last sentence of (b)(16)(i) fixes what happens to the answer: "Any explanation, rebuttal, or information presented by or in behalf of the applicant or petitioner shall be included in the record of proceeding." The rebuttal becomes part of the record on which the decision, and any later appeal or motion, is made.

What counts as derogatory information unknown to the petitioner?

The regulation does not define derogatory information. Its text reaches information that USCIS considered, that cuts against the request and that the petitioner is unaware of. Material the petitioner filed is not information of which the petitioner is unaware.

Section 103.2 gives no definition of the term. The words of (b)(16)(i) set the limits: the information is derogatory, the Service considered it, the decision is based on it and the petitioner is unaware of it.

The last condition separates two kinds of adverse material. Weaknesses in the petitioner's own filing, such as a missing document or a letter that does not explain its author's basis, are in the record the petitioner submitted. The petitioner knows them, and USCIS addresses them through the evidence rules of 103.2(b)(8): a request for evidence, a notice of intent to deny or a denial. Information that comes from outside the filing, and that the petitioner has not seen, falls under (b)(16)(i).

For an employment-based petition the outside information can concern any part of the case: the petitioner, the beneficiary, the employer, the documents or the people who wrote letters in support. The regulation does not limit (b)(16)(i) to any category of information. What matters is that the decision rests on it and that the petitioner has not seen it.

Attorneys who receive a notice under (b)(16)(i) read it for two things: what the information is and what part of the decision it supports. The response is built around both.

Can USCIS decide statutory eligibility on information it does not disclose?

No, apart from classified information. Under 103.2(b)(16)(ii) a determination of statutory eligibility is based only on information in the record of proceeding that is disclosed to the petitioner.

Subparagraph (ii) reads: "A determination of statutory eligibility shall be based only on information contained in the record of proceeding which is disclosed to the applicant or petitioner, except as provided in paragraph (b)(16)(iv) of this section."

Subparagraph (ii) governs the determination of statutory eligibility, and subparagraph (iii) governs decisions made in the exercise of discretion. For the first, the record that counts is the disclosed record. Information that stays undisclosed cannot support it, except classified information handled under (b)(16)(iv).

This links (ii) to (i). If USCIS intends to rely on outside information to find a petitioner ineligible, the information has to be in the disclosed record, and (i) requires that the petitioner be told about it and allowed to answer before the decision.

What changes for discretionary decisions and classified information?

A discretionary decision may rest on classified information kept out of the record and away from the petitioner, if the USCIS Director or a designee finds it relevant. It is disclosed only with the classifying authority's written consent.

Subparagraph (iii) covers discretion: "Where an application may be granted or denied in the exercise of discretion, the decision to exercise discretion favorably or unfavorably may be based in whole or in part on classified information not contained in the record and not made available to the applicant, provided the USCIS Director or his or her designee has determined that such information is relevant and is classified under Executive Order No. 12356 (47 FR 14874; April 6, 1982) as requiring protection from unauthorized disclosure in the interest of national security."

Subparagraph (iv) governs the classified material itself. The petitioner "shall not be provided any information contained in the record or outside the record which is classified" under that Executive Order "unless the classifying authority has agreed in writing to such disclosure."

The same subparagraph builds in a partial notice. Whenever the Director or designee believes it can be done "consistently with safeguarding both the information and its source," the Director or designee should direct that the petitioner "be given notice of the general nature of the information and an opportunity to offer opposing evidence." The authorization to use classified information is made part of the record, and a decision based on it "shall state that the information is material to the decision."

These exceptions concern information classified under Executive Order No. 12356 in the interest of national security. Information that is not classified under that order falls outside (iii) and (iv), and the general rule of (b)(16)(i) applies to it.

How is the petitioner told: an RFE, a NOID or another notice?

Paragraph (b)(16)(i) requires that the petitioner be advised and given an opportunity to rebut, without naming a form. The evidence rules of 103.2(b)(8) describe requests for evidence and notices of intent to deny, sent by regular or electronic mail.

The text of (b)(16)(i) states the obligation, not the format: the petitioner "shall be advised of this fact and offered an opportunity to rebut." The format comes from paragraph (b)(8), which describes how USCIS handles evidence.

Under (b)(8)(iii), when the evidence does not establish eligibility, USCIS may deny the benefit request for ineligibility, request more information or evidence, or issue a notice of intent to deny that states the proposed basis for the denial and gives a period for the response. A notice of intent to deny that cites outside information is the form that fits the words "advised of this fact and offered an opportunity to rebut" most closely, because it states the basis the officer proposes to use.

Under (b)(8)(iv) a request for evidence or a notice of intent to deny "will be communicated by regular or electronic mail." The same paragraph caps the periods: "in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks," the response period in a notice of intent to deny may not exceed thirty days, and "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted."

The deadline in the notice is therefore final. An attorney who needs a third-party document, such as a statement from a letter author or an employer, plans its delivery inside that period from the day the notice arrives.

How should the response to a notice of derogatory information be built?

As one complete package within the period, answering each item of information with evidence. Under 103.2(b)(11) all requested materials are submitted together, and a partial response is treated as a request for a decision on the record.

Paragraph (b)(11) sets the form of the response: "All requested materials must be submitted together at one time, along with the original USCIS request for evidence or notice of intent to deny." The petitioner may "submit a complete response containing all requested information at any time within the period afforded." The paragraph adds: "Submission of only some of the requested evidence will be considered a request for a decision on the record." A second package after the first does not reopen the period.

Silence has its own consequences. Under (b)(13)(i), if the petitioner does not respond by the required date, "the benefit request may be summarily denied as abandoned, denied based on the record, or denied for both reasons." Under (b)(14), failure to submit requested evidence "which precludes a material line of inquiry shall be grounds for denying" the request. Under (b)(15), a denial due to abandonment may not be appealed, but the petitioner may file a motion to reopen under 103.5.

Inside the package each item of derogatory information gets its own answer. The response states what the notice says, what the petitioner says about it and which documents support the answer. Where the information concerns a person, such as a letter author or a former employer, the answer can come from that person in writing with documents, because (b)(16)(i) lets the petitioner "present information in his/her own behalf" and requires that it be included in the record.

The response also addresses the decision the information was meant to support. If the notice links the information to one criterion of the visa category, the response shows what remains of that criterion if the information is accepted, and what other evidence in the record supports it.

What if the derogatory information concerns an expert letter or its author?

The same rule applies: if the denial will rest on outside information about the author that the petitioner has not seen, USCIS advises the petitioner first. The rebuttal documents the author's identity, knowledge and independence.

Expert opinion letters are evidence in the record like any other document. Outside information about a letter, for example that its author holds a different position than the letter states or has a tie to the beneficiary that the letter does not mention, is information that can support an adverse decision on the criterion the letter addresses.

When such information is the basis of a proposed denial and the petitioner has not seen it, (b)(16)(i) requires notice and an opportunity to rebut before the decision. The rebuttal is built from the author's side: a current CV, documents that confirm the position and affiliations stated in the letter, a list of the materials the author reviewed and a statement of any relationship with the beneficiary.

If the letter contains an independence statement, the rebuttal can add a signed declaration by the author on the specific point the notice raises. If the information proves correct and the letter cannot stand, the response says so and points to the other evidence for the same criterion, so that the decision on the record does not rest on the withdrawn letter.

A letter whose author's credentials, position and independence are documented in the filing leaves less room for outside information to contradict it.

Can USCIS hold the case instead of disclosing the information?

Yes, during an investigation. Under 103.2(b)(18) USCIS may withhold adjudication if an investigation relates to eligibility or discretion and disclosure would prejudice it, with a review after one year and abeyance of up to six months at a time.

Paragraph (b)(18) reads: "USCIS may authorize withholding adjudication of a visa petition or other application if USCIS determines that an investigation has been undertaken involving a matter relating to eligibility or the exercise of discretion, where applicable, in connection with the benefit request, and that the disclosure of information to the applicant or petitioner in connection with the adjudication of the benefit request would prejudice the ongoing investigation."

The paragraph sets review points. "If an investigation has been undertaken and has not been completed within one year of its inception, USCIS will review the matter and determine whether adjudication of the benefit request should be held in abeyance for six months or until the investigation is completed, whichever comes sooner." If the case is held in abeyance, USCIS reviews that determination every six months.

For the petitioner, withholding adjudication means a petition that stays pending without a decision. The duty under (b)(16)(i) returns when USCIS decides: if the adverse decision is based on information the petitioner does not know about, the petitioner is advised and allowed to rebut, subject to the classified information exceptions.

What can the attorney do with the record after a decision?

Inspect it. Under 103.2(b)(16) the petitioner may inspect the record of proceeding that constitutes the basis for the decision, apart from the classified information exceptions. The rebuttal filed under (b)(16)(i) is part of that record.

The inspection right in the opening sentence of (b)(16) covers "the record of proceeding which constitutes the basis for the decision." The exceptions are in the paragraphs that follow it, and the ones that keep information from the petitioner are the classified information rules of (iii) and (iv).

A decision that relies on outside information therefore has to be traceable in the record. An attorney who prepares an appeal or a motion compares the decision with the record: what information the decision cites, whether a notice under (b)(16)(i) was sent and what the rebuttal said.

Where the petitioner is represented, paragraph (b)(19)(ii) has USCIS send original notices both to the petitioner and to the authorized attorney or representative. The attorney of record receives the notice of derogatory information directly and calendars the response period from its date.

How does IAE prepare expert letters whose authors can be checked?

Each IAE letter is signed by a member of the public IAE registry in the beneficiary's field, with a declaration of independence. You receive the expert's CV and registry record before the invoice and may decline the candidate.

The expert is matched by field: the specialization in the registry record matches the beneficiary's field, and the record opens by number and QR code. Before the invoice is issued you receive the expert's CV, degree, memberships and publications and may decline the candidate.

In every letter the expert confirms no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary; if there is one, the expert declines the order. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition, so a package of three letters is signed by three experts. Before delivery the letter passes the IAE checklist: facts, dates and quotations are checked against the beneficiary's documents, and text from earlier letters is not reused except section headings.

An expert letter takes 10 business days, 5 on rush. An answer to an RFE or NOID takes 5 business days, 3 on rush, and the expert answers each point of the request. State the response deadline when you send the case: within one business day the Secretariat replies, free of charge, which letters make sense for the case, who the expert is, the cost and the deadline.

Send the beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline through the page for attorneys; for a response, attach the notice. The service agreement and the non-disclosure agreement are published in advance. The letter does not guarantee approval: USCIS weighs it together with the other evidence.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Request

Send your first case

The beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline. The expert, the CV, the cost and the deadline within one business day.

Case for assessment

Received

Expert, cost and deadline within one business day

CategoryEB‑2 NIW
Beneficiary's fieldGeotechnics
RFE response duein 30 days