Expert report review

Is an appraisal that does not comply with USPAP admissible in court?

No federal rule of evidence mentions USPAP. In Whitehouse Hotel v. Commissioner (2010) the Fifth Circuit held that the Tax Court could treat an IRS appraiser's alleged USPAP departures as a question of weight, not admissibility. District courts have excluded appraisal opinions where a departure left the value without a basis. Federal banking law, the charitable deduction regulations and state licensing rules impose USPAP compliance as a requirement of their own.

A commercial building appraisal with a facade photograph lies on a desk beside a pair of glasses

Does Rule 702 require an appraiser to follow USPAP?

No. Rule 702 asks whether the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and on reliable methods reliably applied. Courts have measured appraisals against USPAP but have refused to treat it as the only test.

Federal Rule of Evidence 702 lets a qualified witness give an opinion if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion is a reliable application of those methods to the facts of the case. The rule names no professional standard.

The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice come from the Appraisal Standards Board of the Appraisal Foundation. In a 2022 condemnation ruling the Southern District of Texas quoted Powell v. Tosh (W.D. Ky. 2013), which described USPAP as the standard that "represents the prevailing professional standards for real property appraisal" (United States v. 38.307 Acres of Land).

The same courts have declined to make compliance a condition of admission. In Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Qore, Inc., decided by the Northern District of Mississippi on January 28, 2009, the defendant moved to exclude the plaintiff's appraiser because his appraisal and updates did not follow USPAP methodology. Chief Judge Michael P. Mills agreed with Wal-Mart that "following the USPAP standards is not the only way that an appraisal might be reliable enough for admission" and denied the motion.

What did the Fifth Circuit decide in Whitehouse Hotel?

That the Tax Court acted within its discretion when it treated the IRS appraiser's alleged USPAP departures as bearing on the weight of his report. The court found no authority making USPAP compliance a prerequisite for admissibility.

Whitehouse Hotel Limited Partnership donated an easement over the Maison Blanche building in New Orleans in 1997 and claimed a $7.445 million charitable contribution deduction. The Commissioner's valuation expert, Dunbar Argote, had valued between 50 and 70 buildings intended for hotel use in New Orleans.

Whitehouse argued that Argote's report should have been held unreliable, and so inadmissible, because it did not comply with USPAP. It pointed out that both experts acknowledged they were bound by USPAP, that Louisiana law requires licensed appraisers to comply with it, and that the IRS treats USPAP as the applicable appraisal standards.

The Fifth Circuit decided the appeal on August 10, 2010 and reviewed the ruling for abuse of discretion. It quoted the Tax Court, which had found no authority "for the proposition that an appraiser's compliance with USPAP is the sole determining factor" of reliability, and held that the Tax Court "acted within its ample discretion in considering USPAP compliance as relevant to the weight" of the report. The court did not go through the alleged departures one by one.

Whitehouse still won on valuation. The court vacated the Tax Court's figure because it had failed to consider the effect of a pending condominium on fair market value and had declined to consider the highest and best use of the Maison Blanche and Kress buildings. The penalty ruling was vacated with the valuation.

Did the 2023 amendment to Rule 702 change the weight-or-admissibility line?

It narrowed it. The committee note to the 2023 amendment calls rulings that treat the sufficiency of an expert's basis and the application of the method as questions of weight an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a).

Whitehouse (2010), Qore (2009) and the Illinois ruling discussed below (2017) predate the amendment. The committee note to the 2023 amendment of Rule 702 reads: "many courts have held that the critical questions of the sufficiency of an expert's basis, and the application of the expert's methodology, are questions of weight and not admissibility. These rulings are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)."

A USPAP departure that leaves the value without sufficient data, or applies the approach in a way the data do not support, is an objection under Rule 702(b) or (d) that the court decides before the appraiser testifies. A departure in report format, or in a choice that USPAP leaves to the appraiser, stays a subject for cross-examination.

When has a USPAP departure led a court to exclude an appraisal opinion?

When the departure was material to the value. In Cooper v. Meritor (2019) a federal court in Mississippi excluded impaired-value opinions that took a contamination deduction without a basis for contamination above regulatory levels on each property.

Cooper v. Meritor, Inc. consolidated property damage claims by owners of land in the Eastern Heights subdivision of Grenada, Mississippi, arising from decades of operation of a manufacturing facility. Judge Debra M. Brown of the Northern District of Mississippi ruled on the appraisal experts on February 11, 2019.

The court started from state law. Under Broadhead v. Bonita Lakes Mall (Miss. 1997), "material breaches of the USPAP render an appraisal invalid," and the court concluded that "a material breach of the USPAP would render an appraiser's opinion irrelevant under Daubert."

USPAP Advisory Opinion 9 addresses the appraisal of real property that may be impacted by environmental contamination. As the court read it, a deduction for remediation cost applies only to contamination above regulatory levels. The plaintiffs' appraiser did not establish that each property was contaminated above those levels: the groundwater report she relied on "includes no opinion that these super-regulatory levels exist on each and every property." The court called this "a failure indisputably material to her appraisal opinion" and excluded her impaired-value and diminution-of-value opinions. A second appraiser's impaired-value opinions fell for the same missing basis. Both appraisers' unimpaired values were admitted.

Which USPAP objections have courts left for cross-examination?

Objections to choices that USPAP leaves to the appraiser and to the form of the report. Courts admitted appraisals without location adjustments, without interior inspections, and appraisals written on a less detailed report form.

In the same Cooper ruling the defendants argued that the unimpaired values departed from USPAP because the appraiser inspected only the exteriors and made no location adjustment to her comparable sales. The court found that location adjustments are discretionary under USPAP and that such "challenges to location adjustments go to their weight rather than their admissibility." It called the inspection argument misplaced: "the USPAP does not require an interior inspection," and the defendants' own appraisal expert had not inspected interiors either.

In Qore the appraiser valued a Wal-Mart Supercenter building in Starkville, Mississippi, without the land, using only the cost approach. The court agreed that his failure to consider the income and sales comparison approaches "undermines Parker's conclusion," treated it as a matter of weight and let the jury hear him. It held that the departure of his update reports from the USPAP form did not affect their admissibility.

In Buchanan Energy (N), LLC v. Lake Bluff Holdings, LLC (N.D. Ill., April 4, 2017) a purchase option priced the property at the average of three appraisals, one from each side's appraiser and one from a joint appraiser. Each side accused the other's appraiser of USPAP violations, and Lake Bluff said that Currier violated USPAP by using a less detailed report form. Magistrate Judge Young B. Kim noted that the state appraisal board had found no USPAP violation, admitted both appraisers and wrote: "Where, as here, Currier used a reliable method to appraise the Property, his testimony is admissible."

Where is USPAP compliance a legal requirement?

In federal rules for appraisals in federally related transactions, in the qualified appraisal required for charitable contribution deductions, and in state licensing law that binds licensed appraisers. There the departure is tested against the statute or regulation.

Section 1110 of Public Law 101-73 (1989), codified at 12 U.S.C. 3339, requires each federal financial institutions regulatory agency to prescribe standards for real estate appraisals in federally related transactions. At a minimum the rules must require appraisals performed under generally accepted appraisal standards "as evidenced by the appraisal standards promulgated by the Appraisal Standards Board of the Appraisal Foundation," written appraisals, and review for compliance with USPAP.

For charitable contributions, 26 CFR 1.170A-17(a)(1) defines a qualified appraisal as one prepared by a qualified appraiser "in accordance with generally accepted appraisal standards." Paragraph (a)(2) defines those standards as "the substance and principles of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice." The section applies to contributions made on or after January 1, 2019.

State licensing law adds a third layer. In Whitehouse the taxpayer relied on Louisiana law requiring licensed appraisers to comply with USPAP. In Atlantic Coast Pipeline, LLC v. 0.07 Acre (W.D. Va., June 19, 2019) the court noted that the Virginia Real Estate Appraiser Board requires all licensed Virginia appraisers to comply with USPAP, and the Cooper court described USPAP as the "minimum standards for appraisal practice" in Mississippi.

Florida takes a different route. Section 475.628, Florida Statutes (2026), has the Florida Real Estate Appraisal Board adopt standards of professional practice and permits it to adopt standards other than those of the Appraisal Standards Board for nonfederally related transactions. In those assignments the appraiser must still comply with the Ethics and Competency Rules of the Appraisal Standards Board standards and with the board's other requirements.

Which standard applies to an appraisal in a federal condemnation case?

Federal land acquisitions have their own Uniform Appraisal Standards, known as the Yellow Book. The Court of Federal Claims has held that they apply only to appraisers hired by the federal government for condemnation purposes.

In United States v. 38.307 Acres of Land, Judge Micaela Alvarez of the Southern District of Texas ruled on February 22, 2022 on the experts in a taking of two tracts within and next to Sharyland Plantation, a master-planned community in the McAllen Division, where the parties disputed the effect of the border wall on the value of the remainder. She quoted Hardy v. United States, 141 Fed. Cl. 1 (2018): the Yellow Book "applies only to appraisers hired by the federal government for condemnation purposes" and "is not mandatory with respect to appraisers not hired by the government."

The court denied the landowner's motion to exclude the government's appraiser, denied the government's partial motion against the landowner's experts and granted the landowner's request for a jury to decide just compensation. In a taking the reviewer first identifies which side hired the appraiser, because that decides which set of standards the appraisal is measured against before Rule 702 is applied.

Can an appraiser be excluded for what the report leaves out?

Yes, under Rule 26. In Gordon v. New England Central Railroad (2019) a federal court in Vermont barred an appraiser whose restricted-use report omitted the sources and data he relied on.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a retained expert's report to contain "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them" and "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them." Under Rule 37(c)(1), a party that fails to provide that information may not use it or the witness at trial "unless the failure was substantially justified or is harmless."

Gordon v. New England Central Railroad, Inc. arose from a July 1, 2017 embankment collapse that damaged a mixed-use building at 68 Old River Road in Hartford, Vermont. The railroad's appraiser, Stephen O'Toole, gave an "as is" value. He multiplied $45 by 6,492 square feet, a figure that covered the main building and left out two garages, and his restricted-use report did not disclose the interviews and work file information behind his opinion. He testified: "the report was prepared for my client. I didn't prepare it for the court or anybody else."

On August 27, 2019 Judge Christina Reiss wrote that she "would be hesitant to exclude Mr. O'Toole's opinion solely because he erred" on the area, but held that the report violated Rule 26(a)(2)(B) and that "Mr. O'Toole is precluded from offering expert testimony at trial." The railroad kept the right to offer other evidence of the property's value.

Two months earlier, in Atlantic Coast Pipeline, the pipeline company had framed a missing larger parcel analysis as a violation of both Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i) and USPAP. Senior Judge Norman K. Moon noted that the company cited no USPAP provision requiring that analysis, found the report sufficient under Rule 26 and did not exclude the testimony on that ground.

How does a review present USPAP departures in litigation?

Departure by departure, with the page of the appraisal, the requirement it departs from, its effect on value and the condition of Rule 702 it touches. Departures in form are listed apart from those that change the number.

Each finding in the review answers three questions. Which requirement does the appraisal depart from: a Standards Rule, an advisory opinion, a regulation or the disclosure rule? What happens to the value if the departure is corrected? Which condition of Rule 702 does it go to: the facts or data, the method or the application?

The cases above supply the sorting. A deduction or adjustment without a factual basis, as in Cooper, goes to the sufficiency of the data and supports a motion. A discretionary choice such as a location adjustment, or a report form, as in Cooper, Qore and Buchanan, goes to cross-examination. An omitted basis goes to Rule 26, as in Gordon. Whitehouse, Qore and Buchanan show the outcome of an objection framed as USPAP compliance alone: the opinion was admitted and the departures were left to the factfinder.

Two settings call for an extra check. In a charitable deduction dispute the reviewer reads the appraisal against 26 CFR 1.170A-17, because the question there is whether the document is a qualified appraisal at all. In a lending dispute the reviewer checks whether the transaction was federally related, which brings in the agency rules required by 12 U.S.C. 3339.

What does IAE do when the opposing appraisal departs from USPAP?

An appraiser from the IAE registry reviews the opposing appraisal against USPAP or writes an expert report on value, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE valuation page covers the market value of real property and the fair market value of a business or an ownership interest as of the date the case needs, for estate and gift tax disputes, divorce, condemnation and shareholder cases. A review under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 gives an opinion on the quality of the opposing appraisal: comparables, adjustments, discount rate, effective date and the support for each conclusion.

The client sends the appraisal or the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix. The Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member