Expert report review
Vehicle damage consistency report: how does a reviewer check whether the damage fits the claimed crash?
A damage consistency report answers one question: could the damage on a vehicle have come from the collision the claimant reported? Insurers rely on such reports to deny claims, and defense experts use them to argue that damage came from another event or that a crash was staged. A review checks the heights, directions, transfer marks, photographs and recorder data behind each finding, and marks each place where the report turns a physical finding into a conclusion about fraud.

What does a damage consistency report claim, and what does the review check?
It claims that the damage does or does not match the reported collision. The review checks each comparison behind that claim: location, height, direction, depth, transferred material, the age of the damage and the data used.
Shady Attalla and Liam Rodgers, forensic engineers, wrote in Claims Journal on November 17, 2023 that fraud in auto claims takes two forms: either the driver reports a crash that never happened, or the driver is intentionally involved in an accident to cover up pre-existing issues. In both cases, they wrote, proper analysis relies heavily on the physical evidence, including the damage to the vehicles.
Their list of observations gives a reviewer a starting checklist. Does the damage sit at the locations the reported crash would produce? What are the height, direction and depth of each dent, and does a mark begin low on the vehicle and extend continuously higher? How much paint was transferred, and is it automotive paint? Are there tire marks deposited on the vehicle? Is there damage that was not reported as part of the claim?
The review breaks the opposing conclusion into these comparisons and writes next to each one what the expert measured, what was taken from photographs and what was assumed. It then states how many independent comparisons support the opposing opinion and which of them rest on measurements.
Does the height of the damage match the other vehicle?
Height is compared first. Damage on one vehicle has to line up with a part of the other vehicle that could have made it, and the review checks how both heights were obtained.
Wayne Denham, BSME, ACTAR, a senior engineer at ARCCA, described a hit-and-run claim in PropertyCasualty360 in 2012. The damage on the claimant's Dodge Caravan was located 32 to 50 inches above the ground, most deformation sat high on the rear, and there was little to no damage on the lower section of the vehicle. The investigators compared the front profiles of SUVs, and even the tallest were still 7 to 10 inches below the highest damage.
The damage consisted of multiple concentrated-force damage points that were discontinuous. Denham reported that the impact damage was inconsistent with the claimant's description and came from multiple sources rather than a single vehicular impact.
A reviewer asks how each height in the opposing report was obtained: measured on the vehicle from the ground, scaled from a photograph, or taken from the published dimensions of an exemplar. The reviewer then checks the load in each vehicle, the suspension and whether either vehicle was braking, because each of these changes the height of a bumper at the moment of contact. A report that compares a loaded, braking vehicle with the static height of an empty exemplar is listed with the height difference it leaves unexplained.
Do the marks and the transferred paint fit contact with another vehicle?
That depends on direction and material. Published indicators treat non-automotive paint, heavy paint transfer, vertical damage of even depth and wood or cement residue as signs of contact with a stationary object.
Attalla and Rodgers wrote that excessive paint transfer is often a strong sign that the vehicle contacted a painted stationary object. Transferred paint can be compared with the known chemical composition of paints used in the automotive industry over the past 20 to 30 years to confirm whether it is automotive. Their figures contrast sharp scratches left by a wall or pole with scuffs and rotational tire marks left by a vehicle-to-vehicle sideswipe.
The Insurance Corporation of British Columbia (ICBC) publishes cause of loss indicators for its collision repair partners. For a reported hit and run, indicators that damage is consistent include single-directional damage caused by a striking vehicle passing the struck vehicle, straight-line damage to a wheel, tire or hubcap indicating that the struck vehicle was stationary, and bumper-height damage. Indicators that damage is not consistent include damage that extends vertically and has the same depth at top and bottom, non-automotive paint in the damaged area, wood, cement or other abrasive residue, fresh undercarriage damage or debris caught underneath, rotation marks on wheels or tires, and numerous scratches caused by branches.
The reviewer checks whether the opposing expert examined the transfer on the vehicle or only in photographs, whether a paint sample was taken and analyzed, and how the direction of each scratch was read. A finding of non-automotive paint with no sample and no analysis is recorded as an observation from photographs, together with the photographs it rests on.
Was some of the damage there before the reported crash?
The review separates old damage from fresh damage zone by zone. Rust, earlier repairs and unreported damage can date part of the damage before the loss, but they do not exclude new damage in another zone.
ICBC lists damage whose age is not consistent with the stated date of loss, shown by rust, among the indicators that damage is not consistent with a reported hit and run. Attalla and Rodgers note that a thorough examination can reveal additional damage that was not reported as part of the claim, and add that unrelated issues with the vehicle do not immediately indicate fraudulent behavior.
ICBC also tells repair shops what to do when vehicle damage is not consistent with the reported loss type: document the issues and contact ICBC before beginning any repairs. Under that procedure, last updated on October 28, 2021, the estimate carries an explanation such as Damage appears to be inconsistent with loss type, please advise, the shop uploads images, and an ICBC estimator may contact the shop. Shop notes, estimates and images taken before repair are documents a party can request in discovery under Rule 34(a)(1)(A), which covers photographs and images.
For each damage zone the review records the evidence of age that the opposing report relied on, such as rust in a fracture, paint over a dent or a repair invoice dated before the loss, and the evidence that the zone is fresh. When old and new damage overlap in one zone, the review states which lines of the estimate belong to which event, so the dispute narrows to those lines.
Can a consistency opinion rest on photographs alone?
It can, with limits the review lists: how each dimension was scaled from an image, which vehicle was never inspected, and what changed before the photographs. Rule 34 lets a party request inspection and testing of the other vehicle.
Rule 34(a)(1) lets a party serve a request to inspect, copy, test or sample items in the responding party's possession, custody or control: designated documents or electronically stored information, including photographs and images, and any designated tangible things. A vehicle is a tangible thing. The party served must respond in writing within 30 days after being served (Rule 34(b)(2)(A)).
Time works against the evidence. A Gettysburg Times explainer republished by InsuranceNewsNet on October 21, 2026 lists the losses: vehicles moved before photography lose their original rest positions, partial repairs erase the deformation that engineers need to measure, and a sale can destroy recorder data along with the vehicle.
For each measurement the reviewer notes its origin: taken on the vehicle, scaled from a photograph against an object of known size, or read from manufacturer data. A height measured on a photograph taken at an angle to the damaged panel, or with no reference object in the frame, is listed with the uncertainty it carries. If the opposing expert saw only one vehicle, the review says which comparisons rest on photographs of the other vehicle or on an exemplar.
What can event data recorder data add, and what can't it prove?
A recorded event whose values fit the damage supports the reported crash. A missing event proves less, because a recorder stores data only while the vehicle is powered and only when an impact crosses its threshold.
Attalla and Rodgers write that the recorder will only record data when the vehicle is powered on. If the damage is consistent with a relatively severe collision and no event is recovered, they treat the reported sequence of events as likely untruthful. In the same passage they note that there could also be no event because the impact was not severe enough to reach the recording threshold.
The InsuranceNewsNet explainer describes the same limit: a recorder locks data only when a collision crosses a set severity threshold, minor impacts may leave no stored event, and a later crash can overwrite an unlocked one.
The reviewer asks for the download report itself, the tool and software used, the date of the download and the vehicle's mileage on that date, and checks whether later driving or a later impact could have overwritten an unlocked event. An opinion that treats a missing event as proof that the crash did not happen is listed together with the threshold question the opposing report left unanswered.
How consistent are damage assessments between investigators?
Not fully. In a 1974 SAE study, about half of investigators' Vehicle Deformation Index ratings matched the control ratings exactly, and about 75% matched or differed by only one character.
J. Robert Cromack and Scott N. Lee reported the study in SAE Technical Paper 740299, published on February 1, 1974. In an international accident investigation program begun in November 1970, 33 teams from nine European and North American nations classified vehicle damage with the Vehicle Deformation Index, and Southwest Research Institute, consultant to the project leader, collected 520 case reports. Excluding SwRI's own cases, one-half of the team ratings compared identically with the control ratings, and approximately 75% compared identically or differed by only one character.
In Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals (June 28, 1993) the Supreme Court listed the known or potential rate of error among the factors a trial judge may consider. The committee note to the 2023 amendment of Rule 702 says the amendment is especially pertinent to the testimony of forensic experts in both criminal and civil cases, and that forensic experts should avoid assertions of absolute or one hundred percent certainty.
The reviewer reads how the opposing report states its conclusion. A finding that the damage could not have resulted from the reported collision, given with no range for the measured heights and no discussion of other contact positions, is listed next to the measurements and their uncertainty. The 2000 committee note to Rule 702 asks whether the expert has adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations, such as a second impact in the same event or a change in the vehicles' positions during contact.
Can the engineer tell the jury the claim was staged?
Rule 704(a) permits an opinion on an ultimate issue, but under Rule 702 each opinion must stay within what the expert's basis and method support. A physical mismatch is engineering; intent is a separate question the review flags.
Rule 704(a) says that an opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue. The committee note to the 2023 amendment of Rule 702 adds that each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology. In General Electric Co. v. Joiner (December 15, 1997) the Supreme Court wrote that a court may conclude that there is simply too great an analytical gap between the data and the opinion proffered.
The published examples keep the two steps apart. In Denham's hit-and-run example the engineering finding was that the damage came from multiple sources rather than a single vehicular impact. Charges for insurance fraud were then filed against the claimant, who later agreed to a plea bargain that included withdrawal of six bodily injury claims and reimbursement of the property damage claim.
The review marks every sentence in the opposing report that turns a physical finding into a statement about what the claimant knew or intended, and every finding that rests on the claimant's credibility instead of on measurements. Those sentences are listed separately for counsel, each with the physical findings it relies on.
What must the opposing report disclose, and when is a rebuttal due?
A retained expert's report states every opinion with its basis and reasons, the facts or data considered and the exhibits. Absent a stipulation or court order, a rebuttal on the same subject is due within 30 days after that disclosure.
Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, exhibits, the witness's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, a list of cases with trial or deposition testimony in the previous 4 years, and the compensation for the study and testimony. For a damage consistency opinion the facts or data considered include the photographs, the measurements, the exemplar data, the estimates and any recorder download.
Communications between counsel and the expert are protected except those about compensation, those identifying facts or data counsel provided and the expert considered, and those identifying assumptions counsel provided and the expert relied on (Rule 26(b)(4)(C)). A summary of the claimant's account written by counsel, or an instruction to assume the vehicle was parked, falls within those exceptions. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) the expert may be deposed only after the report is provided, and under Rule 705 the expert may be required to disclose the underlying facts or data on cross-examination.
A report intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter is due within 30 days after the other party's disclosure (Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii)). A party that fails to provide information or identify a witness as Rule 26(a) or (e) requires is not allowed to use that information or witness on a motion, at a hearing or at a trial, unless the failure was substantially justified or is harmless (Rule 37(c)(1)).
What does IAE do when the other side's damage consistency report is in dispute?
An engineer from the IAE registry reviews the opposing report against the photographs, measurements, scene evidence and recorder data and lists what counsel should have measured and downloaded, in up to 5 business days.
The IAE accident reconstruction page covers how the vehicles moved before impact, what the event data recorder shows about speed and braking, and whether the damage on each car fits the claimed crash, for injury and property damage cases in US courts. On vehicle damage, the engineer compares each line of the repair estimate with photos and the crash mechanics and marks damage that came from an earlier or a different impact. A review asks whether the opposing reconstructionist applied the intellectual rigor that practice in the field requires: inputs, reaction times, calculations, tests and the limits of engineering opinion.
The client sends the opposing report or the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix. The Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- Shady Attalla and Liam Rodgers: Viewpoint: Accident Reconstruction in Insurance Fraud Investigations, Claims Journal, November 17, 2023
- Wayne Denham, BSME, ACTAR (ARCCA): forensic analysis of an alleged hit and run, PropertyCasualty360, 2012
- ICBC (Insurance Corporation of British Columbia), Material damage procedures: Indicators to confirm the cause of loss
- ICBC, Material damage procedures: Manage inconsistent damage versus loss type at a collision repair facility (last updated October 28, 2021)
- J. Robert Cromack, Scott N. Lee: Consistency Study for Vehicle Deformation Index, SAE Technical Paper 740299, February 1, 1974
- How Insurance Companies Reconstruct a Crash Without Ever Visiting the Scene, The Gettysburg Times via InsuranceNewsNet, October 21, 2026
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34, Producing Documents, Electronically Stored Information, and Tangible Things (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 37, Failure to Make Disclosures or to Cooperate in Discovery; Sanctions (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes on the 2000 and 2023 amendments (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 704, Opinion on an Ultimate Issue (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 705, Disclosing the Facts or Data Underlying an Expert's Opinion (LII)
- Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (June 28, 1993) (LII)
- General Electric Co. v. Joiner, 522 U.S. 136 (December 15, 1997) (LII)
Read also
All articles
Left-turn collision: how does a reviewer check the opposing reconstruction of the oncoming vehicle's speed and the turning driver's gap?
In a left-turn crash each side blames the other: the turning driver failed to yield, or the oncoming driver was speeding. State statutes require
The police accident report is wrong: how is it checked, and what weight does it carry in court?
A police crash report is written by an officer who usually arrived after the vehicles stopped moving. It records what the officer saw, measured
Rear-end collision: how does a reviewer check the opposing reconstruction of a sudden stop or chain crash?
In a rear-end crash the law starts against the rear driver: New York treats the collision as a prima facie case of negligence, and Florida presumesExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

