For employers

Work sample test or structured interview: which should an employer use, and what does each require?

A work sample asks the candidate to do a piece of the job. A structured interview asks every candidate the same job-based questions and scores the answers against fixed benchmarks. The U.S. Office of Personnel Management describes both as valid methods with different costs and uses. Under Title VII, as the EEOC explains it, either one has to be job related and consistent with business necessity if it disproportionately excludes a protected group.

Hands sort blank envelopes while two people interview at a table behind

What is the difference between a work sample test and a structured interview?

A work sample has the candidate perform tasks that mirror the job, and trained assessors score the result. A structured interview asks set questions tied to job competencies and rates each answer against benchmarks of proficiency.

OPM defines work samples as methods that "require applicants to perform tasks or work activities that mirror the tasks employees perform on the job." Scores come from trained assessors who observe behavior or measure the outcome of the task. Broader performance tests built the same way can measure fundamental competencies such as problem solving or communication.

A structured interview, in OPM's description, uses "rules for eliciting, observing, and evaluating responses." The rules limit the discretion of each interviewer, and interviewers agree with each other more often as a result. Questions are written in advance from the competencies of the job, every candidate hears the same questions, and answers are scored against benchmarks.

The two methods collect different evidence. A work sample records what the candidate does with a task in front of them. An interview records what the candidate says about past situations or about a hypothetical one. OPM lists both among its assessment methods, next to job knowledge tests, situational judgment tests, assessment centers and others.

What makes an interview structured?

Questions based on job competencies identified through job analysis, the same questions for every candidate, scoring against benchmarks and, usually, a panel whose members rate each answer separately before they compare ratings.

OPM names two types of questions. Situational questions "ask applicants to describe what they would do" in a scenario like one on the job. Behavioral description questions "ask applicants to describe a past behavior" that shows a target competency; they rest on behavioral consistency, the principle that past behavior predicts future behavior. OPM notes that behavioral questions showed higher validity for highly complex jobs and that both formats have proven effective.

Both formats rely on job-related critical incidents. Questions built on competencies identified through job analysis, OPM writes, yield high validity, rater reliability and rater agreement. Highly structured interviews are "scored according to benchmarks of proficiency," which describe what a weak, an adequate and a strong answer contains.

Scoring is usually done by a panel. OPM: "Structured interviews are usually scored by a panel in which each member rates applicant responses individually," after which the panel discusses significant scoring discrepancies. The interview can be held in person, by telephone or by video conference, one candidate at a time.

An interview without these elements, where each interviewer picks questions and forms a general impression, is what OPM calls less structured. OPM notes that interviewers and applicants tend to prefer less structured formats.

What does a work sample test look like in practice?

The candidate does a real task of the job under observation: for an administrative assistant, transcribing a memo in a word processor or filing papers; for a broader skill, a role-play with a trained actor.

OPM gives two examples. For an administrative assistant, applicants might "transcribe an internal memo using a word processor" or file paperwork. A broader exercise could be "an interactive role-play between the applicant and a well-trained actor," scored for problem solving and communication.

The work is hands-on and takes place in a simulated work environment. OPM notes that work samples are often administered to one candidate at a time and that assessors observe and sometimes rate each applicant. For written work the task can be a document, a calculation or a case analysis; for manual work it can be an operation on equipment.

The tasks are taken from the job itself. OPM's first consideration for work samples reads: "Tasks applicants are asked to perform are very representative of the tasks performed on the job." That closeness is the basis of the method and the reason it fails when the job content changes. OPM adds that work samples may need periodic updating.

Which method predicts job performance better?

OPM's pages give no single number for either. They describe work samples as very representative of the job and structured interviews as having high content and criterion-related validity, with validity added beyond other measures.

For structured interviews OPM lists high content validity and criterion-related validity and "moderate relationships with measures of cognitive ability and personality." It adds that interviews provide incremental validity: they predict performance beyond what other measures already predict. The page cites research by Huffcutt and Arthur (1994) on interview validity for entry-level jobs and by Huffcutt and others (2001) on situational and behavioral questions for higher-level positions.

For work samples OPM bases validity on representativeness of the tasks and cites, among others, Schmidt and Hunter (1998), "The validity and utility of selection methods in personnel psychology," and Robertson and Kandola (1982), "Work sample tests: Validity, adverse impact and applicant reaction." The OPM pages do not quote validity coefficients from these studies.

For an employer the practical answer depends on the job. OPM rates the return on investment of both methods as high when applicants need specific, critical competencies upon entry. For interviews it notes a lower return when the competencies can be learned on the job or are not critical. A work sample measures a skill the candidate already has; an interview can also probe judgment, motivation and how the candidate handled earlier situations.

When is a work sample the wrong tool?

When the job will teach the skill after hire. OPM says work samples should be used only where applicants are expected to possess the competencies, and the Uniform Guidelines bar content validity for skills learned on the job.

OPM states that work samples "should only be used in situations where applicants are expected to possess the required competencies," and that if training is provided after selection, the method "may not be appropriate." A junior role with an onboarding program, where the employer plans to teach the software or the procedure, gives a work sample nothing fair to measure.

The Uniform Guidelines say the same in legal terms. Under 29 CFR 1607.14(C)(1) a content validity strategy is not appropriate for knowledge, skills or abilities "which an employee will be expected to learn on the job." The same paragraph says content validity is not appropriate for traits or constructs, "such as intelligence, aptitude, personality," which a work sample does not measure directly.

A work sample also does not fit competencies that appear only over time, such as managing a team through a year of projects. A structured interview with behavioral questions asks how the candidate handled such situations before and scores the answer against benchmarks.

What do the Uniform Guidelines require to defend each method?

A job analysis of the important work behaviors and a procedure that is a representative sample of the job, for content validity; or a statistically significant relationship with job performance at the 0.05 level, for criterion-related validity.

Section 1607.14(C)(2) requires "a job analysis which includes an analysis of the important work behavior(s)" and their relative importance. Under 1607.14(C)(1) a procedure can be supported by content validity to the extent it is "a representative sample of the content of the job," and under 1607.14(C)(4) the support is stronger the closer "the content and the context of the selection procedure are to work samples or work behaviors." A work sample sits at the strong end of that scale by design.

For an interview the same test applies: its questions and benchmarks have to come from the job analysis and describe observable work behavior. When the questions target traits such as intelligence, aptitude or personality, 1607.14(C)(1) rules content validity out, and the employer needs a criterion-related study.

A criterion-related study compares scores with later job performance. Under 1607.14(B)(5) the relationship is generally treated as established when it is "statistically significant at the 0.05 level of significance." If higher scores are likely to mean better performance, 1607.14(C)(9) permits the results to be used "to rank persons who score above minimum levels."

The EEOC's technical assistance document "Employment Tests and Selection Procedures" (2007) lists work samples among its examples of sample job tasks and states that Title VII, the ADA and the ADEA prohibit discriminatory use of tests and selection procedures. Its best practices leave the employer responsible for validity under the Uniform Guidelines, even when a test vendor supplies documentation.

Which method produces less adverse impact?

OPM reports little or no difference between men and women on work samples, depending on the competencies, and little or no difference by sex or race on structured interviews, with less adverse impact the more structured the interview.

For work samples OPM writes: "Generally little or no performance differences are found between men and women," and adds that the result depends on the competencies assessed. For structured interviews it reports little or no difference between men and women or among racial groups, with some differences in interviewer ratings that depend on the race of the candidate and the interviewer, the complexity of the job and the type of question. More structured interviews show less adverse impact.

Adverse impact has a legal meaning. The EEOC fact sheet describes disparate impact as the use of "neutral tests or selection procedures that have the effect of disproportionately excluding persons" in a protected group. Such a procedure must then be job related and consistent with business necessity, which the EEOC says an employer can show by proving the procedure is "necessary to the safe and efficient performance of the job."

Even then the employer can lose if a less discriminatory alternative exists. The EEOC asks: "is another test available that would be equally effective in predicting job performance?" The EEOC's best practices ask the employer to determine whether an equally effective alternative procedure with less adverse impact exists. For a method that produces a large gap between groups, the other method is one candidate for that comparison.

The scoring procedure is part of the method. A panel that rates answers individually against written benchmarks leaves less room for the rating differences OPM describes than an interviewer who forms a general impression.

What does each method cost to build and to run?

OPM rates structured interviews as generally low in development cost and not costly to administer. Work samples may be costly to develop in time and money and time consuming and expensive to administer.

For work samples OPM writes that they "may be costly to develop, both in terms of time and money," may need periodic updating, and "may be time consuming and expensive to administer" because assessors observe and sometimes rate each applicant. A role-play needs a trained actor; a hands-on task needs equipment and a place to use it.

For structured interviews OPM rates development costs as generally low, depending on the complexity of the job, the number of questions, the dimensions measured and the training of raters. Administration is typically not costly, though it depends on interviewer training, rater time and the number of applicants.

The two methods also sit at different points of the hiring process. OPM notes that structured interviews are often used late in the process as a final screen or when the applicant pool is moderate or small, and that work samples are best used for positions where the measured competencies are highly critical for successful performance.

OPM adds a general warning for its methods: "Most of the assessment methods in this section require considerable test development and measurement expertise to develop in-house." An employer without that expertise either builds the method with outside specialists or uses an assessment prepared by an outside provider.

How do candidates react to each method?

OPM reports that applicants often see work samples as very fair. Interviews draw more favorable reactions than other popular selection measures, though applicants and interviewers tend to prefer less structured formats.

OPM's page on work samples reads: "Applicants often perceive work samples as being very fair." The page cites Gilliland (1995) on fairness from the applicant's perspective. A candidate who does a task of the job sees the link between the test and the work.

For interviews OPM states that they generally produce more favorable applicant reactions than other popular selection measures. The structure itself is less popular: interviewers and applicants tend to prefer less structured formats. A candidate who expects a conversation and meets a fixed list of questions with a scoring panel may find it formal.

OPM lists applicant reactions as a separate consideration for each method, next to validity, adverse impact and cost. An employer that tells candidates in advance what each step measures and how it is scored removes the surprise of a fixed format.

Can an employer use both methods, and in which order?

Yes. OPM describes structured interviews as often used late in the process as a final screen. A skills task earlier in the process narrows the pool, and the interview then probes what the task showed.

Many hiring processes combine methods. OPM notes that interviews add incremental validity beyond other measures, so an interview after a skills task adds information the task did not collect. The task shows how the candidate handles the work; the interview asks about decisions, past situations and motivation.

The order follows cost and pool size. An interview with a panel takes the time of several employees per candidate, which is why OPM places it late, when the pool is moderate or small. A task that every applicant can complete without an assessor in the room can come earlier.

The EEOC's best practices apply to each step. Employers should administer tests "without regard to race" and other protected characteristics, validate them for the specific positions and purposes, keep them current as job requirements change, and understand each test's effectiveness and limits before using it. An employer that uses a provider's test remains responsible for its validity, even when the provider supplies documentation.

How does the IAE written exam fit before the interview?

IAE runs an online written exam of up to 2 hours in the employee's field. The company receives the total score and the rubric criterion scores for each task, and the interview panel can use them to choose its questions.

The exam has 8 tasks, each with its own timer: 10 minutes per question and 25 minutes per case, taken in one sitting without a break. Answers are typed in the exam form, pasting from the clipboard is disabled, and the system records how each answer was typed and how many times the candidate left the tab. Each candidate receives their own figures and circumstances in the cases, and one question is about a project from the candidate's questionnaire: the decisions taken, the figures and the outcome. If the log shows a doubtful answer, the candidate receives one more written question with 5 minutes to answer.

Answers are scored against the rubric of the field, and the result is approved by an examiner with no ties to the employee or the company, within 5 business days of the exam. Before the exam the candidate uploads a photo of an ID document and takes a snapshot, and the IAE Secretariat checks them manually. The company sees in its cabinet the status, the total score, the rubric criterion scores for each task and the certificate PDF if the exam is passed. It does not see the questionnaire, the CV or the reason for refusal.

Everything runs on the website and by email, with no calls or meetings. A company registers through the page for employers and receives a link to the company cabinet within one business day; in the cabinet it adds candidates with name, email and exam field, and each candidate has 14 days to choose the exam day. The registration form lets a company ask for tasks for its own roles. In the pilot, companies that register by December 31, 2026 test up to 5 employees free of charge.

The exam program and terms are published. The decision to hire stays with the employer, and under the EEOC's guidance the employer remains responsible for how it uses any test in its own selection process.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Pilot until December 31, 2026

Register your company

Free for up to 5 people. A link to the company cabinet arrives by email within one business day.

Company registration

Received

Cabinet link within one business day

Employees5
FieldSoftware and data
Pilotuntil Dec 31, 2026