O-1

No appropriate peer group or union for an O-1: what happens then?

Under 8 CFR 214.2(o)(5)(i)(G), USCIS decides an O-1A petition on the evidence of record, without an advisory opinion, when the petitioner establishes that no appropriate peer group, including a labor organization, exists. The regulation lists no evidence for that showing, and its words do not cover a group that refused or never answered. An opinion from a person with expertise in the applicant's area meets 8 CFR 214.2(o)(5)(ii)(A) without proving a negative.

A bald man of about 60 with a white mustache runs a pencil down a printed list of organizations at a wooden desk in warm window light

What does 8 CFR 214.2(o)(5)(i)(G) say?

Paragraph (G) says that when the petitioner establishes that no appropriate peer group, including a labor organization, exists, USCIS decides the petition on the evidence of record, with no advisory opinion in the file.

The paragraph is one sentence: "In those cases where it is established by the petitioner that an appropriate peer group, including a labor organization, does not exist, the Service shall render a decision on the evidence of record." The regulation still calls USCIS "the Service." Quotations from 8 CFR 214.2 follow the 2022 annual edition of the Code of Federal Regulations on govinfo.gov.

"Established by the petitioner" puts the showing on the U.S. employer, the U.S. agent or the foreign employer acting through a U.S. agent, the only filers that 8 CFR 214.2(o)(2)(i) permits. The words "an appropriate peer group, including a labor organization" require that both be absent. Under (o)(3)(ii), a peer group is "a group or organization which is comprised of practitioners of the alien's occupation." A decision "on the evidence of record" is a decision without an advisory opinion: paragraph (D) lists (G) as an exception to the rule that every approved O petition contains written evidence of consultation.

The statute says the same in 8 U.S.C. 1184(c)(6)(C): "In those cases in which a petitioner described in subparagraph (A) establishes that an appropriate peer group (including a labor organization) does not exist, the Attorney General shall adjudicate the petition without requiring an advisory opinion." The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 7, repeats the rule in its consultation table: "If the petitioner establishes that no appropriate peer group exists, including a labor organization, USCIS renders a decision on the evidence of record."

Paragraphs (A) to (F) of (o)(5)(i) set the rule to which (G) is the exception.

How do the other paragraphs of (o)(5)(i) frame the exception?

Paragraphs (A) to (C) make consultation mandatory and require the petitioner to obtain a written opinion and file it with the petition. Paragraph (D) names (E) and (G) as the only exceptions.

Paragraph (A) reads: "Consultation with an appropriate U.S. peer group (which could include a person or persons with expertise in the field), labor and/or management organization regarding the nature of the work to be done and the alien's qualifications is mandatory before a petition for an O-1 or O-2 classification can be approved." Paragraph (C) gives the task to the petitioner, who "shall obtain a written advisory opinion," and fixes the moment: the opinion "shall be submitted along with the petition when the petition is filed."

Paragraph (D) states the general rule: "Except as provided in paragraph (o)(5)(i)(E) and (G) of this section, written evidence of consultation shall be included in the record in every approved O petition." Paragraph (E), the second exception, covers cases that USCIS finds to merit expeditious handling where the alien will be employed "in the field of arts, entertainment, or athletics." There USCIS requests the opinion itself and decides without it if no answer comes within 24 hours. Athletics is an O-1A field, so (E) can reach an O-1A athlete. It does not reach O-1A petitions in science, education or business.

Paragraphs (A), (B) and (C) contain a parenthetical that (G) lacks: there, a peer group "could include a person or persons with expertise in the field." The definition in (o)(3)(ii) speaks only of "a group or organization." In the final rule of August 15, 1994, the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) declined a request to put individuals into that definition. It read the statutory words "person or persons of its choosing" as "an alternate source for a consultation." Paragraph (G) does not repeat the parenthetical, and no paragraph says which reading of "peer group" (G) uses.

A petitioner with the opinion of one qualified person does not have to resolve that question, because (o)(5)(ii)(A) names "a person or persons with expertise in the area of the alien's ability" as a source.

Who has to prove that no peer group exists, and with what?

The petitioner must establish it under (G) and 8 U.S.C. 1184(c)(6)(C). Neither text lists documents; the 1994 rule preamble, discussing P petitions, named affidavits or letters from practitioners in the field.

Both texts use the same verb: the regulation says "it is established by the petitioner," and the statute says the petitioner "establishes." Chapter 7 of the Policy Manual keeps the wording, and none of the three gives the task to USCIS or to a consulting organization.

No paragraph of 8 CFR 214.2(o)(5) lists the evidence for this showing. The nearest guidance is in the preamble to the 1994 final rule, in the part on consultation for P nonimmigrants under 8 CFR 214.2(p)(7). Answering 29 commenters who asked for a procedure for establishing that a labor organization does not exist, INS wrote: "The Service does not wish to add a provision into the final regulation establishing a formal procedure for determining if a labor organization exists since the procedure may differ for various fields of endeavor." It went on: "the easiest method of establishing the nonexistence of a labor organization would be to submit affidavits or letters from practitioners in the field or from a related labor organization stating that a labor organization does not exist." And it added: "The Service, obviously, has the final say as to whether the evidence submitted is sufficient to establish the non-existence of a labor organization."

That passage was written about P petitions and labor organizations. The part of the same preamble on O consultation names no method of proof.

Paragraph (o)(5)(v) says that the Service "will list in its Operations Instructions those occupations or fields of endeavor where the nonexistence of an appropriate consulting entity has been verified." The Address Index that USCIS publishes contains three tables of organizations and no table of such fields, so a petition that relies on (G) builds the showing from its own exhibits.

If a practitioner who signs such a letter has expertise in the applicant's area, the same person can write the advisory opinion under (o)(5)(ii)(A), and the petition no longer depends on (G).

Is a peer group that refused or did not answer the same as no peer group?

No paragraph treats them alike. Paragraph (G) covers a peer group that "does not exist." The silence rules in (E) and (F) apply only to organizations that USCIS itself contacts after the petition is filed.

A group that declines to write still exists, and (G) speaks of existence. No paragraph of (o)(5) mentions a refusal, a fee or a group that writes only for its members. The Address Index lists such groups without comment: its entry for the United States Polo Association reads "Sport of polo. Note: Members only." Neither the Index nor the regulation says what a petitioner outside the membership should file.

Under (E), in expedited arts, entertainment or athletics cases, the organization that USCIS contacted has 24 hours, and then "the Service shall render a decision on the petition without the advisory opinion." Under (F), the labor organization that received the forwarded petition has 15 days, and "If the labor organization does not respond within 15 days, the Director will render a decision on the record without the advisory opinion." The statute sets the same 15 days in 8 U.S.C. 1184(c)(6)(D) for "Any person or organization receiving a copy of a petition." Each of these deadlines starts with a request sent by USCIS. None of them covers a letter that the petitioner asked for before filing.

For the petitioner's own request, (C) governs: the petitioner "shall obtain a written advisory opinion." If the chosen group refuses or stays silent, the petition still needs the written evidence of consultation that (D) requires, from another source listed in (o)(5)(ii)(A): another peer group, a labor organization or a person with expertise. A letter of refusal proves that the group exists and was asked. It is not evidence that no appropriate peer group exists.

A negative opinion is a third case: the group answered and disagreed. Paragraphs (C) and (o)(5)(ii)(A) require such an opinion to "set forth a specific statement of facts which supports the conclusion reached in the opinion." For forwarded petitions the statute builds in a rebuttal step: USCIS adjudicates "Once the 15-day period has expired and the petitioner has had an opportunity, where appropriate, to supply rebuttal evidence."

What does the regulation say about an opinion that does not arrive in time?

For an opinion the petitioner requested, one rule: it "shall be submitted along with the petition when the petition is filed." The time limits in (o)(5) for late answers bind only organizations that USCIS contacts.

No paragraph of (o)(5) deals with an opinion that the petitioner requested and received after filing, and none gives the petitioner extra time to wait for a peer group. For an O-1A petitioner, the sentence in (C) quoted above is the only timing rule in (o)(5). Under (o)(2)(i), the petition itself "may not be filed more than one year before the actual need for the alien's services."

The other time limits run after USCIS receives the petition. In a routine case under (F), USCIS forwards the petition within 5 days of receipt, the labor organization has 15 days, and "Once the 15-day period has expired, the Director shall adjudicate the petition in no more than 14 days." The Director may shorten this time "for emergency reasons, if no unreasonable burden would be imposed on any participant in the process."

Outside expedited cases under (E), paragraphs (C) and (D) leave a petitioner who is still waiting for a peer group on the filing date two routes. One is to file the written opinion of another source listed in (o)(5)(ii)(A). The other is to establish under (G) that no appropriate peer group exists. The text describes no other route.

Why is an opinion from a person with expertise usually the safer route?

Paragraph (o)(5)(ii)(A) names a person or persons with expertise in the applicant's area as a source. Filing such an opinion meets the consultation rule directly; (G) asks for proof of a negative that USCIS may find insufficient.

Paragraph (o)(5)(ii)(A) reads: "Consultation with a peer group in the area of the alien's ability (which may include a labor organization), or a person or persons with expertise in the area of the alien's ability, is required in an O-1 petition for an alien of extraordinary ability." Chapter 7 of the Policy Manual names the same sources in its row for O-1A and O-1B (Arts). Their history, including the statutory words "person or persons of its choosing," is covered in the guide The O-1 advisory opinion under 8 CFR 214.2(o)(5): who can write it?

The two routes ask the petitioner to prove different things. For an expert's opinion, the petitioner proves a fact about the author: expertise in the area of the applicant's ability, which (o)(5)(i)(B) frames as expertise "in the specific field involved." For (G), the petitioner proves that no U.S. group of practitioners of the applicant's occupation and no appropriate labor organization exists. The regulation gives no test for that.

The files also differ. Under (G), the file contains no advisory opinion, so no consultation addresses the points that (o)(5)(ii)(A) asks a favorable opinion to cover: the applicant's ability and achievements, the duties of the position and whether the position requires a person of extraordinary ability. With an expert's opinion, the file contains the written evidence of consultation that (D) requires.

Two things stay the same on either route. Under (D), "Consultations are advisory and are not binding on the Service." And if an appropriate labor organization exists for the applicant's occupation, USCIS forwards the petition to it under (o)(5)(i)(F) when the opinion comes from another source.

Who can be a person with expertise, and what should the letter contain?

The regulation sets one test, expertise in the area of the applicant's ability and in the specific field involved, and names no title, degree or number of authors. The Policy Manual lists what a favorable opinion should describe.

Paragraph (o)(5)(ii)(A) speaks of "a person or persons with expertise in the area of the alien's ability," and (o)(5)(i)(B) of expertise "in the specific field involved." Neither the regulation nor Chapter 7 of the Policy Manual defines expertise. In a new or narrow field, the test comes down to two descriptions in the file: the area of the applicant's ability as the petition states it, and the author's expertise as the letter states it.

For content, the Policy Manual row for O-1A and O-1B (Arts) repeats (o)(5)(ii)(A): a favorable opinion should "describe the beneficiary's ability and achievements in the field of endeavor, describe the nature of the duties to be performed, and state whether the position requires the services of an alien of extraordinary ability." An unfavorable one "must set forth a specific statement of facts which supports the conclusion reached in the opinion."

Chapter 7 states a separate standard for affidavits filed as evidence of ability: "Affidavits written by present or former employers or recognized experts certifying to the recognition and extraordinary ability or extraordinary achievement of the beneficiary must specifically describe the beneficiary's recognition and ability or achievement in factual terms and set forth the expertise of the affiant and the manner in which the affiant acquired such information." The sentence speaks of affidavits, and the consultation part of the chapter does not repeat it. An advisory opinion that states the author's own expertise and how the author knows the applicant's work gives USCIS the facts for the test in (o)(5)(i)(B).

In a decision of July 6, 2015 (file JUL062015_01D8101), the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) refused to count an advisory opinion toward the criteria. The petitioner for an O-1 taekwondo master instructor had filed an advisory opinion letter as "other comparable evidence." The AAO accepted that the letter "satisfies the petitioner's burden to submit a written advisory opinion from an appropriate consulting entity pursuant to 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(o)(2)(ii)(D)," and held that "it cannot be used for the dual purpose of satisfying the regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. § 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(B)."

How do you check the USCIS Address Index for the applicant's field?

Compare the applicant's occupation with the occupations column of each of the three tables. If nothing matches, the Index proves nothing alone: USCIS calls it "not an exhaustive list," and (o)(5)(v) names other sources, such as publications.

The Address Index for I-129 O and P Consultation Letters opens with this statement of scope: "The following is a list of known organizations that have agreed to provide consultation letters. This is not an exhaustive list. We plan to update this list on a quarterly basis." Below it are three tables, and the last column of each names what an organization covers: "Covered Occupations" in the first, "Industries covered" in the second and "Serviced Occupations" in the third.

The first table lists 19 organizations, among them Actors' Equity Association, SAG-AFTRA and the National Basketball Players Association. The second lists two producers' associations. Most entries in the third, the longest, cover the arts and sport; a few name other occupations.

  • The American Society for Nutrition covers "Research in the fields of animal and human nutrition."
  • The American Psychiatric Association covers psychiatrists, and The American Institute of Architects covers architects.
  • The Institute for Certification of Computing Professionals covers "Professionals in the computer industry."
  • The International Game Developers Association covers "Video/computer game developers."

What should you compare in each entry?

The occupations column is the part to compare. The definition in (o)(3)(ii) asks for "practitioners of the alien's occupation," so an organization listed for an industry in which the applicant's employer works is not, by that fact, a peer group for the applicant. Some entries carry conditions in their own text, such as "Members only."

What if the applicant's occupation is not in the Index?

Paragraph (o)(5)(v) says of the USCIS list of consulting organizations that it "will not be an exclusive or exhaustive list," and "The Service and petitioners may use other sources, such as publications, to identify appropriate peer groups, labor organizations, and management organizations." Absence from the Index is therefore not proof under (G).

The next step under the text is a search of such sources for a U.S. group whose members practice the applicant's occupation. If one exists and agrees to write, an authorized official signs its opinion under (o)(5)(i)(C). If none exists or none agrees, the petitioner can still file the opinion of a person with expertise under (o)(5)(ii)(A).

What if a union exists, but not for the applicant's occupation?

The labor organization rules follow the occupation. USCIS forwards a copy of the petition to the appropriate union "if any exists," and the regulation names as appropriate the bargaining representative in the applicant's occupational classification.

Paragraph (o)(5)(i)(F) sets the procedure: "In a routine processing case where the petition is accompanied by a written opinion from a peer group, but the peer group is not a labor organization, the Director will forward a copy of the petition and all supporting documentation to the national office of the appropriate labor organization within 5 days of receipt of the petition." Chapter 7 of the Policy Manual words it more broadly: "If an advisory opinion is submitted from a group other than a labor organization, USCIS must submit a copy of the petition and supporting documents to the national office of the appropriate union (if any exists)." In 8 U.S.C. 1184(c)(6)(B), the copy goes out "unless the petitioner submits with the petition an advisory opinion from an appropriate labor organization," whatever the source of the opinion.

Paragraph (F) ties the choice of union to the occupation: "If there is a collective bargaining representative of an employer's employees in the occupational classification for which the alien is being sought, that representative shall be the appropriate labor organization for purposes of this section." Neither (F) nor the Policy Manual says that a union representing the employer's staff in other occupations is the appropriate labor organization for the applicant.

If the employer's staff in the applicant's occupational classification have a bargaining representative, that representative is the appropriate labor organization. An opinion from it, filed with the petition, removes the forwarding step. If the opinion comes from any other source, USCIS forwards the petition to that representative, which has 15 days to answer.

If the only unions in view cover other occupations, nothing in (F) or in Chapter 7 directs USCIS to send them the petition.

A petition that relies on (G) has to deal with both halves of the phrase "an appropriate peer group, including a labor organization." Where the employer has a union, the petition can state which occupational classifications that union represents and that the applicant's classification is not among them.

What should a petition contain when it claims that no peer group exists?

The regulation lists nothing for this showing. The items that follow from its words are a description of the occupation, a record of the search for groups and unions, statements from practitioners and the full O-1A evidence.

The items below follow from the words of (G), (o)(3)(ii), (o)(5)(i)(B), (o)(5)(v) and (o)(2)(ii) and from the 1994 preamble. USCIS has not published them as a list, and Chapter 7 of the Policy Manual gives none.

Under (G), USCIS decides "on the evidence of record," and no advisory opinion will describe the duties or say whether the position requires a person of extraordinary ability. In such a file, the contract, the explanation of the activities and the itinerary filed under (o)(2)(ii)(B) and (C) are the documents that describe the work.

  • The petition describes the applicant's occupation and area of ability. The definition of peer group turns on "practitioners of the alien's occupation," so each later item depends on that description.
  • The petition records the search for organizations in the Address Index and in other sources, such as publications, which (o)(5)(v) names.
  • Each organization found is listed with the facts that place it outside the definition: it is not a U.S. group, its members do not practice the applicant's occupation, or it lacks expertise in the specific field involved under (o)(5)(i)(B).
  • The petition states whether the employer's employees in the applicant's occupational classification have a collective bargaining representative and which national unions, if any, cover the occupation. Paragraph (G) requires the absence of an appropriate labor organization as well.
  • Affidavits or letters from practitioners in the field, or from a related labor organization, state that no such organization exists. INS named this method in 1994 when discussing P petitions.
  • The rest of the petition is complete under (o)(2)(ii)(A) to (C), with the criteria evidence, the contract and the explanation of activities.

Which mistakes in these petitions conflict with the text?

Each mistake below conflicts with a quoted rule: a refusal or absence from the Address Index treated as nonexistence, no consultation filed, a foreign group, an unauthorized signature, an author from another field, and the opinion used as criteria evidence.

Each item names the mistake and the rule it conflicts with.

  • The petition treats absence from the Address Index as proof that no peer group exists. USCIS calls the Index "not an exhaustive list."
  • The petition treats a refusal or an unanswered request as nonexistence, while (G) covers a peer group that "does not exist."
  • The petition contains neither a written consultation nor a showing under (G). Paragraph (D) requires written evidence of consultation in every approved O petition outside (E) and (G).
  • The opinion comes from a foreign organization. Paragraph (A) speaks of "an appropriate U.S. peer group."
  • An organization's opinion is signed by someone without authority to sign for it, although (C) requires a signature by "an authorized official of the group or organization."
  • The author's expertise lies in another field. Paragraph (B) asks for expertise "in the specific field involved."
  • The petition counts the advisory opinion toward the O-1A criteria, which the AAO refused to do in the decision of July 6, 2015.
  • The petition overlooks a labor organization in the applicant's occupation. When the opinion comes from another source, USCIS forwards the petition to it under (F) and waits up to 15 days for an answer.

Where does an IAE association letter fit when no peer group can be found?

The association letter is filed as the written advisory opinion of a professional association, so the petition need not rely on (G). At least two IAE members in the applicant's field assess the record before the letter is signed.

IAE is a professional association of experts and is not a labor organization. The association letter is the institutional opinion of IAE on the applicant's achievements, prepared for petitions. At least two IAE members in the applicant's field assess the record against the IAE Certification Criteria Matrix. The letter is issued on the association's letterhead and signed by the IAE leadership. The signatory, the letter and the association's status can be checked by Member ID on the IAE status check page.

Where the law requires a consultation with a labor organization, as (o)(5)(iii) does for motion picture and television cases, the association letter does not replace it, and the letter says so. If an appropriate labor organization covers the applicant's occupation, USCIS forwards the petition to it under (o)(5)(i)(F) when the opinion comes from another source. USCIS weighs the association letter together with the rest of the petition and makes the decision.

The association letter is prepared within 5 business days, or within 2 business days when ordered as urgent, counted after payment and receipt of all materials. The IAE service for a letter from one expert of the IAE registry, written under the IAE Impartiality Policy, is expert letters.

Sources

All guides

Guides

Case assessment in 1 business day

Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.

Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

Case for assessment

Sent

Secretariat reply within one business day

CategoryEB-1A
Letters neededIn the reply
AssessmentFree