Examinations
Boundary by acquiescence: when does an old fence become the legal boundary?
Boundary by acquiescence makes a fence or another visible line the legal boundary when adjoining owners treated it as the line for a period fixed by state law, even if a survey puts the deed line elsewhere. Iowa and Washington require 10 years, a Michigan appellate court applied 15 and Utah requires 20. Courts have rejected claims built on a livestock fence and on isolated survey markers.

What is boundary by acquiescence?
A state-law doctrine: a visible line that adjoining owners treated as their boundary for a set number of years becomes the legal boundary, even where the deeds and a survey place the line elsewhere.
Each state defines the doctrine through its own statutes and court decisions. Section 650.14 of the Iowa Code, titled "Boundaries by acquiescence established", provides that boundaries and corners found to have been recognized and acquiesced in for ten years are permanently established. The 2026 edition of the Code traces the section back to the Code of 1897.
In Saunders v. Snyder-Johnson, No. 21-0531, decided on August 3, 2022, the Court of Appeals of Iowa described acquiescence as "mutual recognition by two adjoining landowners for ten years or more." Both owners "must have knowledge of and consented to the asserted property line as the boundary line", and the line "must be known, definite, and certain, or known and capable of ascertainment." The party seeking the new boundary must prove acquiescence by clear evidence.
Washington states the rule as three elements. In Merriman v. Cokeley, No. 83700-7, decided on April 8, 2010, the Supreme Court of Washington required a line that was "certain, well defined, and in some fashion physically designated upon the ground", owners who "manifested in good faith a mutual recognition of the designated boundary line as the true line", and recognition lasting for the period needed to establish adverse possession, 10 years. The claimant proves these elements by "clear, cogent, and convincing evidence", which the court described as ultimate facts shown to be highly probable.
No new deed is signed. The survey stays in the record as evidence of where the deed line runs, and the court decides whether the owners' conduct fixed a different line.
How many years must neighbors treat a fence as the boundary?
The period depends on the state: 10 years in Iowa by statute and in Washington by reference to adverse possession, 15 years in a Michigan decision and at least 20 years in Utah.
Iowa writes the ten years into section 650.14. Washington borrows its period from adverse possession: in Merriman the court asked whether mutual recognition "continued for the period of time necessary to establish adverse possession (10 years)."
In Manring v. Turner, No. 193497, an unpublished per curiam opinion of October 17, 1997, the Michigan Court of Appeals wrote that when neighbors "acquiesce to a boundary line for a period of at least fifteen years, that line becomes the actual boundary line." The same opinion recognized a second route: acquiescence that follows "the resolving of a doubt as to where the line is or the settlement of a bona fide controversy."
Utah requires twice the Iowa period. In Anderson v. Fautin, 2016 UT 22, the Utah Supreme Court restated the test, and its fourth element reads: "for a period of at least 20 years."
Owners change during such periods, and the courts count the time of earlier owners. The Michigan court wrote that "the acquiescence of predecessors in title can be tacked on that of the parties." In Manring the predecessors, the Danielses, had owned the parcel for about twenty-seven years and never disputed the marker.
What kind of line on the ground can become the boundary?
A line both owners can see and follow, such as a fence, wall, pathway, row of buildings or natural feature. Scattered survey markers in overgrown ground did not qualify in Washington.
In the test as restated in Anderson, Utah's first element is "a visible line marked by monuments, fences, buildings, or natural features treated as a boundary." The Washington court asked for a line "in some fashion physically designated upon the ground."
Merriman turned on that element. The Merrimans bought their waterfront lot in 1996; Rita Willits owned the lot next door. In 1993 a survey had placed three markers on the line: at the road, at the top of a bluff and about midway between them. A few months later Ward Willits added wooden posts and a metal stake. Between 1993 and 2002 the strip became overgrown with blackberries, weeds and ivy. Only in 2002 did Willits put up a two-strand barbed wire fence on steel posts along the survey line, so the fence stood for a small part of the 10-year period.
In 2006 surveyors hired by the Cokeleys, who had bought the neighboring lot in 2004, found that the 1993 survey had plotted the line at an incorrect angle. The center marker was off by 11 inches and the bluff marker by 20 inches, which left a narrow triangle on the Cokeleys' side. The trial court quieted title in the Cokeleys, a divided Court of Appeals reversed, and the Supreme Court reinstated the trial court's judgment. It wrote that "more than isolated markers are required to prove a clear and well-defined boundary" where the ground is overgrown, and that "A fence, a pathway, or some other object or combination of objects clearly dividing the two parcels must exist."
A single marker can be enough if the owners relied on it. In Manring the line was marked by a three-quarter-inch gas pipe "specifically placed in the ground to serve as a boundary marker" when the parcel was bought in 1952. The court held that the pipe "was relied upon as the agreed property line" for at least the fifteen-year statutory period and "should not now be disturbed."
Does a fence built to hold livestock count as a boundary?
Not by itself. In a 2022 Iowa case the court looked at why the fence was built and where it ran, and a fence meant to keep horses off cropland did not fix the line.
In Saunders the disputed fence did not follow a straight line between the farms. The court wrote: "The fence does not run across the whole property; it shifts north back into Connie's property on either end." Both parties agreed that the fence was meant to keep livestock, particularly horses, off the cropland to the south of it.
A survey done in 2019 placed the fence between 211 and 429 feet north of the southern boundary of Connie's property. The strip between the fence and that boundary covered about 7.9 acres. Connie paid the property taxes on that strip, which the court read as a further sign that she believed she owned it.
The court held: "Thus, the fence is not definite enough to form a boundary for the properties." It added: "Terrill also failed to establish both parties acknowledged and acquiesced to the fence serving as a boundary." The court reviewed for correction of errors at law, treated the district court's findings as binding where supported by substantial evidence, and affirmed.
The Arkansas Court of Appeals put the same idea in one sentence in Stacy v. Dixon, 2014 Ark. App. 314: "it is the agreement and acquiescence, not the fence itself, that controls." The Stacy court decided the case on how the owners had treated the old fence over the years.
Must both neighbors use their land up to the fence?
Not in Utah. In 2016 the Utah Supreme Court held that the claimant must show occupation up to the visible line on his or her own side only.
Anderson v. Fautin, No. 20140664, was filed on May 31, 2016, with an opinion by Chief Justice Durrant. The two parcels lie in Piute County, with Anderson's land directly south of Fautin's. A fence about 2,000 feet long divides them. John A. Hansen installed it before 1930, and the Hansen family owned the Fautin parcel between 1930 and 1957, spending summers there and keeping milk cows.
Fautin bought her parcel in 1987, used it for grazing and replaced the fence in 2000; the parties did not dispute that she had occupied her land up to the fence since the purchase. Anderson bought his parcel in 1968 and did nothing with it for 26 years, until he retired in 1994; he said he was mostly at sea during that time. In 2005 he had the land surveyed, the survey showed that the fence did not follow the legal boundary, and in 2007 he sued to quiet title to the strip between the fence and the surveyed line.
The question was whether Anderson's side of the fence also had to be occupied. The district court granted summary judgment to Fautin, the court of appeals affirmed, and the Supreme Court affirmed on the single question it took. The test "does not require a claimant to prove occupancy on both sides of a visible line." Instead, "a claimant must show occupation up to a visible line on his or her property only." Referring to the mutual-occupancy requirement in earlier decisions, the court wrote: "we here expressly disavow any such requirement."
The opinion explained that older Utah cases had blended boundary by acquiescence with boundary by agreement, and that the occupation element should track adverse possession more closely. The finding of mutual acquiescence was not appealed.
Can silence count as acquiescence?
Courts infer acquiescence from conduct over many years, so an owner who never objects to a fence can be found to have accepted it. The claimant still carries a heightened burden of proof.
Stacy v. Dixon, No. CV-13-782, was decided by the Arkansas Court of Appeals on May 21, 2014, in an opinion by Chief Judge Robert J. Gladwin. The court wrote: "A boundary line by acquiescence is inferred from the landowners' conduct over many years." Adjoining owners who "mutually recognize and acquiesce in" a line for a long period of time are bound by it.
Jimmie Dixon's parents had bought the land in 1968. The old fence had been in place for a significant time, and the Dixons thought that they owned the property to the fence line. New fences put up in 1998 and 2003 along two other lines of the property were placed on the surveyed line; the disputed line was re-fenced only in 2006, and that fence did not follow the survey. The circuit court found that the Dixons owned the disputed strip, and the Court of Appeals affirmed. It wrote that "title by virtue of a boundary by acquiescence is the more appropriate basis" for that finding, while noting that the Dixons would also prevail under adverse possession.
Silence works against the absent owner in Anderson as well. Anderson left his parcel unused for 26 years, and the district court's finding of mutual acquiescence stood because he did not appeal it.
The burden differs in wording by state. Iowa requires clear evidence, and Washington requires clear, cogent and convincing evidence. In Saunders the claim failed against an owner who paid the taxes on the strip.
How does acquiescence differ from adverse possession and a boundary agreement?
Adverse possession rests on one owner's possession under a claim of right, acquiescence on both owners' recognition of a line, and a boundary agreement on a settled dispute. One case can raise all three.
The doctrines overlap in practice. Washington measures acquiescence by the adverse possession period, and in Merriman the claimants relied on both theories; the trial court found that neither was proven by clear and convincing evidence.
In Stacy the Arkansas court affirmed on acquiescence and said that adverse possession would have reached the same result. The same opinion left in place the circuit court's answer to the Stacys' claim of an oral boundary agreement: even assuming an agreement, "there was never possession of the land in question following any such agreement, as no new fence was built on the survey line."
Michigan treats a settled controversy as its own route to a fixed line: acquiescence after "the settlement of a bona fide controversy" fixes the line without waiting for the fifteen years. Utah went the other way in Anderson and separated acquiescence from boundary by agreement, which had produced the requirement of occupation on both sides.
For the surveyor the difference changes the questions. Adverse possession asks what the claimant did on the strip. Acquiescence asks where the line on the ground runs, how long it has been there and how both owners treated it.
What evidence proves how long a line has been treated as the boundary?
Testimony of the owners and their predecessors, old surveys, deeds and plats, tax records, photographs and community reputation that arose before the dispute. In federal court Rule 803(20) admits reputation about boundaries.
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 803(20), the rule against hearsay does not exclude a reputation in a community concerning boundaries of land in the community or customs that affect the land, if the reputation arose before the controversy. The advisory committee note adds: "The reputation is required to antedate the controversy, though not to be ancient." Accounts gathered after the neighbors started arguing about the fence fall outside the exception.
Old papers come in under other exceptions. Rule 803(16) covers "A statement in a document that was prepared before January 1, 1998, and whose authenticity is established." The 2017 committee note says the exception was limited to documents prepared before that date. Rule 803(14) covers the record of a document that purports to establish or affect an interest in property, if the record is admitted to prove the content of the original recorded document, the record is kept in a public office and a statute authorizes recording documents of that kind there. A state court applies its own rules of evidence.
The cases above were decided on such evidence. In Anderson the court traced the fence to John A. Hansen before 1930 and to the Hansen family's use of the land between 1930 and 1957. In Manring the gas pipe dated from the 1952 purchase, and the predecessors' twenty-seven years without objection counted toward the period. In Saunders the court weighed the shape of the fence, the purpose for which it was built and Connie's tax payments on the strip. In Merriman the dates decided the issue: the fence went up in 2002, nine years after the 1993 markers, so the case turned on whether the markers alone formed a clear line.
What does a surveyor show in an acquiescence case?
Where the deed line runs, where the fence or other visible line runs, how far apart they are and what area lies between them. Whether the owners' conduct moved the boundary is for the court.
In every case in this article a survey measured the gap. In Merriman the 2006 survey found the angle error of 11 and 20 inches. In Saunders the 2019 survey put the fence between 211 and 429 feet north of the southern boundary of Connie's property and the strip at about 7.9 acres. In Manring the survey placed the defendant's western boundary about 132 feet west of the gas pipe. In Anderson the 2005 survey showed that the 2,000-foot fence did not follow the legal boundary.
The measurements frame the claim: how much land is at stake, whether the fence runs straight along the parcel or bends back as in Saunders, and whether the markers are continuous or isolated as in Merriman. The court then decides, from the history of the line, which line is the boundary.
A surveyor's report in a federal case discloses the facts or data considered under Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii). For an acquiescence claim that list includes the deeds and plats of both parcels, prior surveys, field measurements of the fence and the dates of the documents used to show its age.
What does IAE prepare when an old fence and the deed line disagree?
For boundary, quiet title and encroachment cases in US courts, an IAE surveyor prepares an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing surveyor's report, in up to 5 business days.
The IAE land survey page describes the work. The surveyor collects deeds, recorded plats and original field notes for the parcel and its neighbors, searches for the original monuments, measures with GNSS and a total station and compares measured bearings and distances with the calls in each deed. Both parties' descriptions are plotted on one map; the surveyor computes the area of each overlap or gap and locates fences, driveways and buildings relative to the line.
Where neighborhood reputation about the line is offered under Rule 803(20), the surveyor records who gave each account and when, so the court can see that it predates the dispute. With the request the client sends the deeds, plats and any prior surveys. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Delivery is in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and there is a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
The specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; whether to plead acquiescence, adverse possession or a boundary agreement is a question for the client's attorney.
Sources
- Iowa Code (2026), section 650.14, Boundaries by acquiescence established (Iowa Legislature)
- Saunders v. Snyder-Johnson, No. 21-0531 (Iowa Ct. App. Aug. 3, 2022), case page (Iowa Judicial Branch)
- Saunders v. Snyder-Johnson, No. 21-0531 (Iowa Ct. App. Aug. 3, 2022), opinion text (Hall Approved)
- Merriman v. Cokeley, No. 83700-7 (Wash. Apr. 8, 2010) (Justia)
- Anderson v. Fautin, 2016 UT 22, No. 20140664 (Utah May 31, 2016) (Justia)
- Manring v. Turner, No. 193497 (Mich. Ct. App. Oct. 17, 1997) (unpublished) (Michigan Courts)
- Stacy v. Dixon, 2014 Ark. App. 314, No. CV-13-782 (Ark. Ct. App. May 21, 2014) (Arkansas Judiciary)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 803, Exceptions to the Rule Against Hearsay, with committee notes (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Neighbor removed the survey markers: is it illegal, who pays to reset them, and what does the surveyor document?
A survey is finished, the corners are pinned, and a week later the pins are gone. In Washington intentionally disturbing a survey monument is a gross
Tree on the property line: who owns it, and how does a surveyor show where the trunk stands?
In California ownership of a tree follows its trunk: a tree whose trunk stands wholly on one lot belongs to that owner, and a tree whose trunk stands
Road right of way and the property line: where does the public road end and my lot begin?
Where a lot meets a public road, the line is the edge of the right of way or a line the deed sets, not the edge of the pavement. In Florida a roadExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

