Examinations
How do you calculate speed from skid marks, and when will a court accept the result?
A locked-wheel skid mark records the distance over which the tires slid, and that distance, together with the friction of the road surface, gives the speed lost during the skid. Courts have admitted such estimates for decades and have excluded them when the friction value came from the wrong vehicle or the evidence did not support the braking assumed. The calculation needs a measured mark, a drag factor for the actual surface and an account of how the skid ended.

What formula does a reconstructionist use for speed from skid marks?
The skid formula: speed in mph equals the square root of 30 times the skid distance in feet times the drag factor, multiplied by the braking efficiency when not all wheels locked.
The Superior Court of the Virgin Islands set out the formula in Government of the Virgin Islands v. Jackson, 47 V.I. 123, a memorandum opinion of July 6, 2005: S = √(30 × D × f × N). D is the length of the skid in feet, f is the coefficient of friction between the tires and the road, and N is the percentage of braking. In that case the officer measured f with a drag sled, as f = F/W: the force needed to pull the sled divided by its weight. The Vermont Supreme Court in State v. Scott called the same value the drag factor.
The number 30 comes from the units. Friction does work over the length of the skid until the speed it removes is gone, and kinetic energy grows with the square of speed, so v² = 2 × g × f × d. With speed in miles per hour, distance in feet and g at 32.2 feet per second squared, the constants reduce to about 30.
In Jackson the court found the scientific testimony of the government's witness Brill "both relevant and reliable" under Rule 702, Daubert and Kumho Tire. It wrote that the methods give results "accurate within a high probability of scientific certainty" when they are performed correctly.
Where does the drag factor come from?
From tests on the road surface where the vehicle skidded: test skids with a vehicle or a weighted drag sled. A test made two months later with a police cruiser led the Supreme Court of Virginia to reject one opinion.
In Lemieux v. Bishop, 209 N.W.2d 379, decided by the Supreme Court of Minnesota on June 22, 1973, a deputy measured 107 feet of skid marks from the defendant's car. The plaintiff's expert, registered mechanical engineer Lloyd Brenna, began his investigation about five months after the accident. He made six test runs with a test vehicle at the scene and measured a coefficient of .89 instead of taking one from a general chart. With that value the skid marks gave 52 mph.
The Vermont Supreme Court decided State v. Scott, No. 2012-186, on October 18, 2013. The State's reconstructionist pulled a weighted drag sled over the road and over grass and computed a drag factor for each surface. He treated each vehicle as if its front wheels were locked because of the front-end damage and used momentum, working backward with the vehicles' final positions, to reach a speed of 61 mph. The court called the use of the sled on grass "a well-reasoned but novel application of a traditionally accepted technique" and held that concerns about the estimates "go to the weight to be granted the proffered evidence, not to its admissibility." At sentencing the trial court found a speed of 50 to 55 mph.
The Supreme Court of North Dakota was less satisfied in Stein v. Ohlhauser, 211 N.W.2d 737, decided October 23, 1973. The expert testified that tread design had no significant effect on friction and that bald tires produce more friction. The court set those claims against a published National Cooperative Highway Research Program report that stresses stating the conditions of each friction test.
Which length of mark goes into the formula?
The full measured length of each locked-wheel mark, including its faint start. When the marks of different wheels differ widely in length, using the longest mark or the average gives an incorrect result.
In Jackson the government's expert testified that a shadow appears just before the distinct black skid mark starts, running from the point where the driver applies the brakes to the point where the brakes lock. He testified that the scientific standard is to include it in the measurement and that "there is always a portion of the shadow that cannot be detected which could comprise 8 to 12 percent of the skid mark." Speed grows with the square root of distance, so a mark measured 10 percent short gives a speed about 5 percent low.
Peter Bergh described three common ways of handling marks of unequal length in Collision: The International Compendium for Crash Research (vol. 4, no. 1, 2009, pp. 40-43): put the longest mark into the standard formula, put the average length into it, or split the skid into steps, each with its own braking efficiency, and combine the speed losses of the steps. According to the abstract, the first two methods give similar results when the lengths are close and are incorrect when the lengths vary widely, and the article recommends against them.
What if the skid ends in a collision?
Then the skid formula gives only the speed lost before impact. The impact speed is calculated separately, and the two are combined as the square root of the sum of their squares, not added together.
In Lemieux the expert estimated a minimum impact speed of 29 mph, took 52 mph from the skid marks and added the two figures to reach a minimum of 81 mph just before braking. The defendants argued that speeds must be combined by taking the square root of the sum of their squares, which, they conceded, would give about 59.5 mph. The Minnesota court did not decide which method was accurate. It held that a calculation error or a faulty assumption "goes to the weight of the testimony, not to its admissibility," noted that 81 mph "seems exceedingly high" and affirmed because the jury could find excessive speed on other evidence.
The defendants' method follows from energy. The energy spent in the skid and the energy left at impact add up, and each is proportional to the square of a speed, so the speed at the start of braking is √(52² + 29²), about 59.5 mph.
The impact speed is the harder figure. In Stein the expert put the speed before braking at just over 51 mph from 39 feet of skid marks and the vehicle damage. The North Dakota court held that the testimony on speed based in part on crash damage "lacked sufficient foundation," wrote that "the formula related to computing stopping distances from skidmarks only," and found nothing in the record "to show that there is any scientific way to determine speed from crash damage." It affirmed the order granting a new trial. The reconstructionist in Scott, forty years later, worked the impact step through momentum and the vehicles' rest positions.
How is speed calculated from curved yaw marks?
From the radius of the arc the mark describes and the drag factor. In Thorpe v. Commonwealth such a calculation gave a minimum speed of 54.03 mph, and the Supreme Court of Virginia held it inadmissible.
Thorpe v. Commonwealth, 223 Va. 609, was decided on June 18, 1982 in an opinion by Justice Cochran. Officer Hank Hughes estimated the minimum speed of Thorpe's truck just before impact at 54.03 mph. He based the figure on curved yaw scuff marks left by the truck, not on straight skid marks, and used two inputs: the radius of the arc and a drag factor.
The drag factor came from a skid test that another officer made about two months after the accident, driving a police cruiser at 45 mph. The record did not show the weather or road conditions during the test or the measurements of the test skid marks, and the Commonwealth conceded this. Hughes never examined the truck and did not know the condition of its brakes, tires or suspension or how its load was distributed, although there was evidence that it left the quarry 4,060 pounds over the legal weight limit. He considered the size and weight of the test vehicle unimportant and assumed that the truck's brakes were never applied, which witness testimony contradicted.
The court held that "there are too many missing variables to permit the expert to give his opinion as to speed," called the opinion "no more than mere inadmissible speculation," found that the trial court had abused its discretion and reversed the conviction for a new trial.
Can speed be calculated from marks when the car had ABS?
Usually not from skid length. A 1990 SAE study found that ABS-equipped cars leave no discernible skid marks in emergency braking on dry pavement, so the speed has to come from other evidence.
L. Daniel Metz and Roland L. Ruhl presented Skidmark Signatures of ABS-Equipped Passenger Cars (SAE Technical Paper 900106) at the International Congress and Exposition in Detroit in February 1990. Their abstract states that such cars "produce no discernable skidmarks under emergency, dry pavement braking conditions" and that reconstruction methods based on measured skid lengths "have to be abandoned" under those conditions. The authors braked five ABS-equipped cars and one control car without ABS from 65 mph on asphalt and brushed concrete.
State v. Wisowaty, No. 2014-300, decided by the Vermont Supreme Court on July 24, 2015, shows what happens when the gap is filled with assumptions. The State's reconstructionist treated the motorcycle's ABS skid mark as roughly the point where the defendant could first see the other vehicle and worked backward from zero at the final resting place. He used estimated friction coefficients for each surface crossed, roadway, grass strip, bike path and high grass, and arrived at a top speed of about 99 mph.
The court found that the calculation assumed continuous braking until the motorcycle reached the tall grass, "a presumption not supported by logic or the evidence." The defense expert's distance-over-time estimate of about 48 mph was "equally unreliable," and the trial judge's own calculation, made with the Pythagorean theorem on an unmeasured point and an unscaled diagram, "bridge[d] evidentiary gaps with speculation." The court reversed and remanded "for entry of a judgment of acquittal on the charges of excessive speed and negligent operation."
When will a court accept a speed estimate from tire marks?
When the expert has enough measured data to reconstruct the crash without guesswork. Under Rule 702 the proponent must show the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion rests on sufficient facts and reliable methods.
Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence requires the party offering an expert to show the court that it is "more likely than not" that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data," that it "is the product of reliable principles and methods," and that the opinion applies those principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case. State courts apply their own versions; Vermont applied its Rule 702 together with Daubert in Scott.
The Minnesota court in Lemieux stated the older test in terms that still describe the work. Lay eyewitness testimony on speed is preferred; where it is nonexistent or unsatisfactory, a qualified expert may give an opinion based on skid marks if there is "sufficient factual data to assure a reasonably complete and accurate reconstruction" without speculation. Such testimony "should be offered and received only if the trial court determines it will aid the triers of fact."
In these cases the outcome turned on the inputs. The opinions that failed rested on a friction test with a different vehicle and unrecorded conditions (Thorpe), on an assumption of continuous braking that the evidence did not support (Wisowaty), and on crash damage without a method (Stein). The opinions that went to the jury used friction values measured on the surfaces involved (Lemieux, Scott) or a method the court could examine step by step (Jackson).
What does the reconstructionist need from the scene and the vehicle?
Measured and photographed marks with their faint starts, a friction test on the same surface, the vehicle's brakes, tires and load, the rest positions and weights of the vehicles, and evidence on when braking began.
The cases above give a working list of what a speed calculation from marks needs. Each item answers a defect that a court found in one of them.
- The length, start and end of each mark, measured at the scene and photographed with a scale; in Jackson the expert testified that the undetectable part of the shadow before the mark could be 8 to 12 percent of the mark.
- A friction test on the same surface with its conditions recorded; in Thorpe the record did not show the weather, the road condition or the test skid measurements.
- The vehicle itself, with its brakes, tires, suspension and load; the officer in Thorpe never examined the truck.
- The rest positions and the weights of the vehicles, which the reconstructionist in Scott used in the momentum calculation.
- Evidence of whether and when the brakes were applied; Thorpe assumed no braking against witness testimony, and Wisowaty assumed continuous braking that the evidence did not support.
What does IAE do in disputes over speed before a crash?
IAE prepares accident reconstruction expert reports on the client's questions for injury and property damage cases in US courts. The engineer matches crush on both vehicles with tire marks, gouges, the police diagram and video and sets pre-crash speeds.
The accident reconstruction service answers how the vehicles moved before impact, what the event data recorder shows about speed and braking, and whether the damage on each car fits the claimed crash. The engineer sets the point of impact, the impact angle and pre-crash speeds from crush on both vehicles, tire marks, gouges, the police diagram and video.
Where a vehicle has an event data recorder, the engineer checks the download against the scene evidence. Under 49 CFR 563.7 the recorder keeps speed, accelerator position and brake on or off for 5 seconds before the crash; a 20-second interval is phased in for vehicles built from September 1, 2028. For the other side's vehicle the engineer lists for counsel what needs to be measured and downloaded at an inspection under Rule 34(a)(1)(B).
The questions are confirmed with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV, the draft is checked for facts, and the signed PDF is issued within up to 5 business days; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID in the document can be checked by QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Neither IAE nor the engineer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- Government of the Virgin Islands v. Jackson, 47 V.I. 123 (Super. Ct. V.I. July 6, 2005)
- Lemieux v. Bishop, 209 N.W.2d 379 (Minn. June 22, 1973)
- Stein v. Ohlhauser, 211 N.W.2d 737 (N.D. Oct. 23, 1973)
- State v. Scott, No. 2012-186 (Vt. Oct. 18, 2013)
- State v. Wisowaty, No. 2014-300 (Vt. July 24, 2015)
- Thorpe v. Commonwealth, 223 Va. 609 (Va. June 18, 1982)
- L. D. Metz, R. L. Ruhl, Skidmark Signatures of ABS-Equipped Passenger Cars, SAE Technical Paper 900106 (1990)
- P. Bergh, Calculating Speed from Skidmarks, Collision: The International Compendium for Crash Research, vol. 4, no. 1 (2009), TRID record
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (Cornell LII)
- 49 CFR 563.7, Data elements (Cornell LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34 (Cornell LII)
Read also
All articles
Sideswipe or lane-change crash: how does an expert establish which vehicle left its lane?
Two cars travelling in the same direction touch sides, and each driver says the other drifted over. Traffic codes put the duty on the driver who
Motorcycle accident reconstruction: how does the expert find speed, position and visibility without a car's data recorder?
In 2024, 6,228 motorcyclists were killed on US roads, 16 percent of all traffic deaths, according to NHTSA. Many of these crashes turn on three
Who ran the red light? How does an accident reconstructionist analyze signal timing?
When two drivers each say the light was green, the answer comes from timing: when each signal phase changed, where each vehicle was at that momentExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

