For attorneys

Can a lawyer outsource legal work such as expert letters, and what does ABA Opinion 08-451 require?

A lawyer may outsource legal and nonlegal support work. ABA Formal Opinion 08-451, issued August 5, 2008, permits it if the lawyer remains ultimately responsible for rendering competent legal services to the client under Model Rule 1.1. Under the same opinion the lawyer complies with Rules 5.1 and 5.3 on supervision, obtains client consent before sharing information protected by Rule 1.6, charges reasonable fees under Rule 1.5 and avoids assisting the unauthorized practice of law under Rule 5.5.

A lawyer in a law-firm hallway hands a case folder to an assistant.

Can a lawyer outsource legal work?

Yes. ABA Formal Opinion 08-451 says a lawyer may outsource legal or nonlegal support services provided the lawyer remains ultimately responsible for rendering competent legal services to the client under Model Rule 1.1.

The ABA Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility issued Formal Opinion 08-451 on August 5, 2008. William E. Gericke and Thomas G. Wilkinson Jr. quote its text in an article for the ABA Section of Litigation. After the sentence on Rule 1.1, the quoted passage says that a lawyer who engages lawyers or nonlawyers to provide outsourced legal or nonlegal services "is required to comply with Rules 5.1 and 5.3." The lawyer "should make reasonable efforts to ensure that the conduct of the lawyers or nonlawyers to whom tasks are outsourced is compatible with her own professional obligations as a lawyer with 'direct supervisory authority' over them."

Helen Hierschbiel wrote in the Bar Counsel column of the Oregon State Bar Bulletin for November 2008 that the ABA committee found "nothing per se unethical about a lawyer outsourcing legal work." Eileen Libby, associate ethics counsel for the ABA Center for Professional Responsibility, wrote in the ABA Journal that the opinion concludes Model Rules 5.1 and 5.3 "apply to assignments outsourced overseas." In her account, ethics issues may arise unless the U.S. lawyer "maintains appropriate control over how that work is done overseas."

In an endnote Hierschbiel writes that ABA formal ethics opinions are not binding in Oregon. Where the Oregon Rules of Professional Conduct mirror the Model Rules, the ABA opinions can provide useful guidance in interpreting them. The Florida Bar page with Ethics Opinion 07-2 carries the line "Advisory ethics opinions are not binding."

Which rule applies when the provider is not a lawyer?

Model Rule 5.3. It covers a nonlawyer employed or retained by or associated with a lawyer, and a lawyer with direct supervisory authority must make reasonable efforts to keep that person's conduct compatible with the lawyer's obligations.

Rule 5.3 has three paragraphs. Under (a), a partner and a lawyer with comparable managerial authority in a law firm "shall make reasonable efforts to ensure that the firm has in effect measures giving reasonable assurance that the person's conduct is compatible with the professional obligations of the lawyer." Under (b), "a lawyer having direct supervisory authority over the nonlawyer shall make reasonable efforts" to the same end. Under (c), a lawyer is responsible for the nonlawyer's conduct that would violate the Rules if the lawyer "orders or, with the knowledge of the specific conduct, ratifies the conduct involved." The same responsibility falls on a partner, a manager or a lawyer with direct supervisory authority over the person who knows of the conduct when its consequences can be avoided or mitigated and fails to take reasonable remedial action.

In August 2012 the ABA House of Delegates approved Resolution 105C of the Commission on Ethics 20/20, which added new comments on outsourcing to Rules 1.1, 5.3 and 5.5. Debra Cassens Weiss reported in the ABA Journal on August 6, 2012 that the revisions changed the commentary but not the black letter rules. She quoted the Commission's report: the changes "are neither an endorsement nor a rejection of the practice of outsourcing."

North Carolina's Rule 5.3 has a comment under the heading "Nonlawyers Outside the Firm." Comment [3] opens: "A lawyer may use nonlawyers outside the firm to assist the lawyer in rendering legal services to the client." Among its examples are the retention of an investigative or paraprofessional service and sending client documents to a third party for printing or scanning. The extent of the obligation depends on the circumstances, including the education, experience and reputation of the nonlawyer, the nature of the services, the terms of any arrangements concerning the protection of client information, and the legal and ethical environments of the jurisdictions where the services will be performed.

The last sentence of Comment [3] reads: "When retaining or directing a nonlawyer outside the firm, a lawyer should communicate directions appropriate under the circumstances to give reasonable assurance that the nonlawyer's conduct is compatible with the professional obligations of the lawyer."

Under Comment [4], "where the client directs the selection of a particular nonlawyer service provider outside the firm," the lawyer ordinarily should agree with the client on the allocation of responsibility for monitoring between them.

Who answers for an expert letter filed with USCIS?

The practitioner who files it answers under the disciplinary rules. Under 8 CFR 292.3, a practitioner authorized to practice before DHS may be sanctioned on the grounds in 8 CFR 1003.102, including knowingly or with reckless disregard offering false evidence.

Under 8 CFR 292.3(a)(1), an adjudicating official or the Board of Immigration Appeals may impose disciplinary sanctions against any practitioner "if it finds it to be in the public interest to do so." The same paragraph says that sanctions are in the public interest against a practitioner authorized to practice before DHS who has engaged in criminal, unethical or unprofessional conduct, or in frivolous behavior, as set forth in 8 CFR 1003.102. The sanctions are permanent expulsion or suspension from practice before the Board and the Immigration Courts, or DHS, or all three, public or private censure, and other sanctions the adjudicating official or the Board deems appropriate. Paragraph (b), "Grounds of discipline," states that the categories of 8 CFR 1003.102 are not the exclusive grounds.

Sanctions under section 1003.102(c) apply to a practitioner who "knowingly or with reckless disregard makes a false statement of material fact or law," including "knowingly or with reckless disregard offering false evidence." If a practitioner has offered material evidence and comes to know of its falsity, "the practitioner shall take appropriate remedial measures."

Paragraph (o) makes failure to provide competent representation a ground for sanctions, and competent representation "requires the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation." Paragraph (u) applies to a practitioner who "repeatedly drafts notices, motions, briefs, or claims that are filed with DHS or EOIR that reflect little or no attention to the specific factual or legal issues applicable to a client's case, but rather rely on boilerplate language indicative of a substantial failure to competently and diligently represent the client."

Can the firm bill the client for an outsourced expert letter?

Yes, within Rule 1.5. Where overhead is minimal, the work should be billed at cost plus a reasonable share of supervision costs not already covered by the legal fees, according to Opinion 08-451 as Hierschbiel quotes it.

In the passage quoted by Gericke and Wilkinson, the opinion says: "The fees charged must be reasonable and otherwise in compliance with Rule 1.5." Hierschbiel writes that, in the absence of an agreement with the client to the contrary, a firm that engages a contract lawyer may add a surcharge to the costs it paid. The markup is limited to a reasonable allocation of overhead such as office space, support staff, equipment and supplies. For this point she cites ABA Formal Opinions 00-420 and 93-379. She then quotes Opinion 08-451: overhead may be minimal or nonexistent for work outsourced to an overseas firm, and in that case "the outsourced services should be billed at cost, plus a reasonable allocation of the cost of supervising those services if not otherwise covered by the fees being charged for legal services."

Opinion 07-2 says the firm "may charge a client the actual cost of the overseas provider," unless the charge would normally be covered as overhead. In a contingent fee case, the Florida committee wrote, it would be improper to charge separately for work usually done by the client's own attorney and included in the standard fee, even if that cost is paid to a third party provider. The committee also quoted Florida Consolidated Opinions 76-33 and 76-38: where the client may dispute or misunderstand the basis of the charges, the lawyer's intention to use nonlawyer personnel and bill for them "should be discussed in advance with, and approved by, the client," especially where substantial use is to be made of such services.

A letter provider can also invoice the client directly. The firm then passes no cost through, and the client pays the provider under its own agreement.

What checks does Opinion 08-451 recommend before outsourcing?

Reference checks and background investigations of foreign providers, interviews with the principal lawyers, a review of the foreign regulatory framework, written confidentiality agreements and a conflicts check, as Eileen Libby lists them in the ABA Journal.

In Opinion 07-2 the Florida committee agreed with Los Angeles County Bar Association Opinion 518 on conflicts of interest. Under that opinion the attorney "should satisfy himself that no conflicts exist that would preclude the representation" and could be held responsible for any conflict of interest created by hiring the provider, including conflicts from relationships the provider develops with others.

Libby lists the steps the ABA committee recommends before a U.S. lawyer outsources legal work:

  • The lawyer should conduct reference checks and background investigations of foreign providers and intermediaries.
  • The lawyer should personally interview the principal lawyers involved in the project and assess their credentials and qualifications.
  • The lawyer should evaluate whether the regulatory framework governing those lawyers is compatible with U.S. standards.
  • The lawyer should determine whether legal documents and other materials might be seized even where client confidentiality is claimed.
  • For particularly sensitive work, the security of the foreign provider's premises and computers should be evaluated.
  • Written confidentiality agreements are "strongly advisable in outsourcing relationships," according to the opinion.
  • The outsourcing lawyer should verify that the provider does not also do work for adversaries of the lawyer's clients on the same or substantially related matters, and if it does, the lawyer could choose another provider.

How does IAE work with immigration attorneys?

IAE prepares expert opinion letters signed by members of its registry for EB-1A, EB-1B, EB-2 NIW, O-1, H-1B and L-1B petitions and for RFE and NOID responses. The case assessment takes one business day and is free.

On the page for attorneys, the attorney sends the petition category, the beneficiary's field and the filing or RFE deadline, with the beneficiary's CV and the draft petition or the RFE. Within one business day the secretariat replies which letters make sense for the case, who the expert from the IAE registry is, the cost and the deadline. The assessment carries no obligation.

The attorney receives the expert's CV and a link to the registry record before the invoice and may decline the candidate. The deadline runs from payment and receipt of the full file: 10 business days for a letter, 5 in rush mode, and 5 business days for an RFE or NOID response, 3 in rush mode.

The secretariat prepares the draft from the beneficiary's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. The draft goes to the attorney and the beneficiary with one round of factual edits, and the expert's conclusions remain the expert's own. Before delivery, facts, dates and quotations are checked against the beneficiary's documents, and text from earlier letters is not reused except section headings.

In every letter the expert signs a declaration of no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary, under the IAE Impartiality Policy IAE-GOV-002. If there is a connection, the expert declines the order. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition, and a package of three letters is signed by three different experts. The service agreement and the non-disclosure agreement are published on the site in advance.

Each case has its own number in the email subject, the letter and the invoice, and the invoice goes to the firm or to the client. The offer carries a 10% discount on the fifth and later paid orders of a calendar month, and a $5,000 prepayment credits $5,600 to the firm balance, with no other discounts. IAE provides an independent expert opinion and is not a legal service. Case strategy stays with the attorney, and USCIS weighs the letter together with the other evidence.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Request

Send your first case

The beneficiary's CV, the petition category and the deadline. The expert, the CV, the cost and the deadline within one business day.

Case for assessment

Received

Expert, cost and deadline within one business day

CategoryEB‑2 NIW
Beneficiary's fieldGeotechnics
RFE response duein 30 days