Examinations
Can you sue an expert witness? Witness immunity and claims against your own expert
Whether an expert witness can be sued depends on who sues and for what. Testimony is protected by witness immunity, which the U.S. Supreme Court applied in Briscoe v. LaHue (1983). A party that hired an expert who botched the work has a claim in Pennsylvania and Louisiana: in LLMD v. Jackson-Cross (1999) and Marrogi v. Howard (2002) the courts allowed negligence suits against the party's own expert. Washington's Supreme Court barred such a suit in Bruce v. Byrne-Stevens (1989).

Can you sue an expert witness?
Rarely for the content of testimony, which witness immunity protects. A party may be able to sue its own expert for negligent work in some states, such as Pennsylvania and Louisiana, but not in others, such as Washington.
The answer turns on two questions. The first is who brings the claim: the opposing party, who lost because of the expert's testimony, or the party that hired the expert and was let down by the work. The second is what the claim targets: the opinion the expert gave, or the way the expert did the work behind it.
For the opposing party the door is mostly closed. Witnesses are immune from civil suits based on their testimony, and an expert is a witness. For the hiring party the courts have split. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court in 1999 and the Louisiana Supreme Court in 2002 allowed negligence claims against a party's own expert. The Washington Supreme Court in 1989 held that immunity barred one.
The sections below follow those decisions in order: the source of immunity, the case that extended it to a paid expert, and the two cases that let clients sue.
What is witness immunity, and why does it exist?
It is a common-law rule that witnesses cannot be sued for damages over their testimony. In Briscoe v. LaHue (1983) the Supreme Court explained it: fear of liability could deter witnesses or make them shade their testimony.
Briscoe v. LaHue, 460 U.S. 325, decided on March 7, 1983, in an opinion by Justice Stevens, held that 42 U.S.C. 1983 does not authorize a damages claim against a police officer for perjured testimony at a criminal trial. The officer testified as a witness, and "a police officer on the witness stand performs the same functions as any other witness." The Court wrote that "immunity analysis rests on functional categories, not on the status of the defendant."
The Court gave the common-law reasons. A witness who fears a lawsuit may be reluctant to testify or may be "inclined to shade his testimony in favor of the potential plaintiff." The Court quoted an 1860 decision: "the paths which lead to the ascertainment of truth should be left as free and unobstructed as possible."
Immunity does not leave false testimony unchecked. The Court named the safeguards: the witness "takes an oath", "responds to questions on direct examination and cross-examination" and "may be prosecuted subsequently for perjury."
Does immunity cover an expert paid by a party?
In Washington it does. In Bruce v. Byrne-Stevens (1989) the state Supreme Court held that being retained and paid by a party does not deprive an expert of witness immunity, which also covers work done to prepare the testimony.
Bruce v. Byrne-Stevens & Associates Engineers, Inc., 113 Wn.2d 123, 776 P.2d 666, was decided on July 20, 1989, by a 5-4 vote. Two neighbors on Clear Lake sued the owner next door, whose excavation caused their soil to subside. They hired an engineering firm to estimate the cost of restoring lateral support. Its principal testified to $10,020 for one lot and $11,020 for the other, and the plaintiffs won judgments in those amounts. They later alleged that the real cost was about double and sued the engineers for negligence.
The court held the suit barred. "As a general rule, witnesses in judicial proceedings are absolutely immune from suit based on their testimony." And: "The fact that Byrne was retained and compensated by a party does not deprive him of witness immunity." The purpose of the rule "is to preserve the integrity of the judicial process by encouraging full and frank testimony", and a witness's reliability rests on "his oath, the hazard of cross examination and the threat of prosecution for perjury."
The court extended immunity beyond the words spoken in court: it covers the preparatory work behind the testimony, here the engineering estimate. It set a limit: "We do not hold that any professional negligence is immunized whenever an expert later relies on it in court." Immunity applies to acts in the course of or preliminary to judicial proceedings. Four justices dissented and would have allowed a client's malpractice claim against its own expert.
When did a court let a party sue its own expert?
In LLMD of Michigan v. Jackson-Cross (Pa. 1999). The expert's lost profits figure of $6 million fell apart on cross-examination because of a mathematical error, the testimony was struck, and the Pennsylvania Supreme Court allowed the malpractice suit.
The client retained Jackson-Cross through its attorney as its lost profits expert in a federal breach of contract case. An employee prepared the calculation in a spreadsheet. On cross-examination, defense counsel showed that the calculation contained a mathematical error that undermined the whole figure. The firm's chairman, who testified, conceded the error and could not recalculate on the stand. The trial judge struck his testimony, and the next day the client settled for about $750,000. Jackson-Cross later produced a corrected figure of $2.7 million.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court, in an opinion by Justice Zappala decided on October 26, 1999, held that "the witness immunity doctrine does not bar Wintoll's professional malpractice action against Jackson-Cross." It drew the line at the substance of the opinion: an expert should "not be subjected to litigation because the party who retained the expert is dissatisfied with the substance of the opinion", but here "the allegations of negligence are not premised on the substance of the expert's opinion."
The claim was about arithmetic. The opinion that lost profits existed was not under attack. The way the expert computed them was.
Did other courts follow that approach?
The Louisiana Supreme Court did in Marrogi v. Howard (2002), on a question certified by the Fifth Circuit. It held that witness immunity does not bar a claim against a retained expert for deficient litigation support work.
A pathologist sued Tulane to recover fees he said had been under-billed for his services. He hired a medical billing and coding consultant to review the records, prepare affidavits and testify. The consultant's first affidavit estimated $523,485 in billable services, against less than $250,000 actually billed. Tulane found mathematical and coding errors. At a court-ordered deposition the consultant revised the figure to $392,740, admitted further errors and then refused to continue. Tulane won summary judgment on the strength of that deposition.
The Fifth Circuit asked the Louisiana Supreme Court whether witness immunity bars a claim against a retained expert, "asserted by a party who in prior litigation retained that expert", arising from "the expert's allegedly deficient performance of his duties to provide litigation services". On January 15, 2002, the court answered in the negative: "Witness immunity or privilege in Louisiana does not bar a claim against a retained expert witness."
The court reasoned that immunity "itself is an exception to tort liability, and thus should be narrowly construed", that Louisiana's immunity cases involved defamation and retaliation suits against adverse witnesses, and that it would be "illogical, if not unconscionable" to shield a professional from malpractice because the work was used in litigation. On February 14, 2002, the Fifth Circuit reversed the dismissal and sent the case back.
Is disagreement with the expert's opinion enough for a claim?
No. The Pennsylvania court in LLMD wrote that an expert may not be held liable merely because the opinion is challenged, and that differences of opinion will not establish liability for professional negligence.
The words of LLMD: "An expert witness may not be held liable merely because his or her opinion is challenged". And: "Differences of opinion will not suffice to establish liability of an expert witness for professional negligence." The Louisiana court framed its answer around the expert's "agreed upon duties to provide litigation support services" and discussed the Pennsylvania decision, including its caution on differences of opinion.
So the claims that survived had a measurable failure: a spreadsheet error that made a $6 million figure collapse, a billing review with errors the expert admitted. A party that lost because the court preferred the other side's expert, or because its expert's honest opinion turned out to be wrong, has no claim under these decisions.
Can the other side sue your expert?
In general, no. Testimony against an adverse party is the core of witness immunity. Bruce states the general rule of absolute immunity for testimony, and Marrogi describes immunity applied in defamation and retaliation cases against adverse witnesses.
An opposing party who believes the expert testified falsely has the remedies Briscoe described: cross-examination at trial and a referral for prosecution for perjury. A civil suit for damages against the witness is not among them.
The Louisiana Supreme Court in Marrogi drew the same line from the other side. It wrote that witness immunity in Louisiana "has been applied in defamation and defamation-like cases, as well as retaliation cases against adverse witnesses, expert and otherwise", and its answer concerned only a retained expert sued by the party that hired him.
What do these cases mean when you hire an expert?
That the client's protection is mostly before testimony: a clear engagement, a check of the calculations and data, and a review of the report before it is disclosed. Suits after the fact are uncertain and depend on the state.
Both successful claims began with errors that a second reader could have found: arithmetic in a lost profits model, coding and pricing in a billing review. Both experts saw their numbers fall apart under the other side's questions, and both clients lost the case or settled for a fraction of the claim.
A claim against the expert comes after that loss, in a separate lawsuit, under the law of a state that may or may not allow it. Washington's Supreme Court barred it in Bruce. The practical remedy is earlier: a review of the expert's report by an independent specialist before the report goes to the other side, so that a calculation error is found by the client's team and not by opposing counsel on cross-examination.
How does Russian law hold an expert accountable?
Through criminal liability for a knowingly false report under Article 307 of the Criminal Code. The court, or the head of the expert institution, warns the expert of that liability, and the warning is stated in the report.
Article 307 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation punishes a knowingly false report or testimony of an expert, given in court or in pretrial proceedings. Under Part 1 the penalties include a fine of up to 80,000 rubles, compulsory work of up to 480 hours, correctional labor of up to two years or arrest of up to three months. Under Part 2, when the act is combined with accusing a person of a grave or especially grave crime, the penalty is forced labor or imprisonment of up to five years. A person who voluntarily declares the falsity of the report before the court's judgment or decision is released from liability.
Under Part 2 of Article 80 of the Civil Procedure Code, the court order appointing an examination states that the expert is warned of liability for a knowingly false report by the court, or by the head of the forensic institution when the institution's specialist does the work. Under Federal Law No. 73-FZ, in the version of July 22, 2024, the head of the institution takes the expert's signed acknowledgment (Article 14), and the report must contain the warning (Article 25).
The same law sets the expert's duties: to carry out a full examination of the objects and case materials and to give "a substantiated and objective conclusion" on the questions asked (Article 16). Under Article 7 the expert is independent and may not be dependent on the body or person that ordered the examination, and persons who exert pressure on an expert are liable.
How does IAE work with the specialist who signs the report?
The specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, is approved by the client before work starts, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. IAE also reviews other experts' reports.
The IAE expertise page lists three kinds of work: an examination on the client's questions, a specialist opinion for court, arbitration, investigation or negotiations, and a review of an expert report. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts.
The specialist prepares the document, and the draft is checked for facts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, depending on the volume of materials, and a 48-hour rush is available for cases with tight deadlines. The expert can be verified in the registry by Member ID or QR code.
For a report prepared by another expert for the client's own side, a review answers six questions: method, completeness, soundness of conclusions, the expert's competence, form and procedure, and whether the report can be relied on. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy or on claims against experts; those questions are for the client's attorney.
Sources
- Briscoe v. LaHue, 460 U.S. 325 (1983) (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Bruce v. Byrne-Stevens & Associates Engineers, Inc., 113 Wn.2d 123, 776 P.2d 666 (Wash. 1989) (Justia)
- LLMD of Michigan, Inc. v. Jackson-Cross Co., No. 59 E.D. Appeal Docket 1997 (Pa. Oct. 26, 1999), majority opinion (Justia)
- Marrogi v. Howard, 805 So. 2d 1118 (La. 2002), No. 2001-CQ-1106 (LSU Law Center)
- Marrogi v. Howard, No. 00-30786 (5th Cir. Feb. 14, 2002)
- Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, Article 307 (rulaws.ru)
- Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, Article 307, version of December 29, 2025 (klerk.ru)
- Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, Article 80 (rulaws.ru)
- Federal Law No. 73-FZ of May 31, 2001 On State Forensic Expert Activity in the Russian Federation, version of July 22, 2024 (rulaws.ru)
Read also
All articles
Can an expert witness testify outside his or her field, and when does a case need a second expert?
Rule 702 admits opinion testimony of a witness qualified by "knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education". Courts apply that test to each
Lay witness or expert witness: when does an opinion need an expert under Rule 701?
A witness who is not testifying as an expert may give an opinion only if it rests on the witness's own perception, is useful to the jury and is "not
Foreign law expert witness: how do U.S. courts determine foreign law under Rule 44.1?
In a federal court the judge decides what foreign law says. Rule 44.1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure lets the court consider "any relevantExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

