Expert report review
Capacity to sign a contract or deed: how is the opposing expert's opinion on mental capacity reviewed?
An expert opinion that a person lacked the mental capacity to sign a contract or deed is written after the signing, in some cases years later. A reviewing psychologist checks which legal test the expert applied, which records describe the person on the day of signing, and whether each named deficit is tied to the act in dispute. California Civil Code section 39 and Probate Code sections 810 to 812 set those tests in writing.

What does the law ask when a party says they lacked capacity to sign?
Whether the person could understand and appreciate the rights and duties the decision created, its probable consequences, and its significant risks, benefits and reasonable alternatives. California states this test in Probate Code section 812.
California Civil Code section 39(a) makes "a conveyance or other contract of a person of unsound mind, but not entirely without understanding," subject to rescission if it was made before the incapacity was judicially determined. Section 39(b) adds a rebuttable presumption "that a person is of unsound mind" where the person is "substantially unable to manage his or her own financial resources or resist fraud or undue influence." The same subdivision limits the proof: "Substantial inability may not be proved solely by isolated incidents of negligence or improvidence."
Probate Code section 812 gives the working definition. A person lacks the capacity to make a decision unless the person can communicate the decision and "understand and appreciate, to the extent relevant," three things: "the rights, duties, and responsibilities created by, or affected by the decision," "the probable consequences for the decisionmaker and, where appropriate, the persons affected by the decision," and "the significant risks, benefits, and reasonable alternatives involved in the decision."
Section 812 opens with an exception for the separate law on capacity to make a will. A reviewer therefore reads the opposing report for the standard first. An opinion that measures a seller against the standard for wills, or against a clinical definition of dementia, has answered a question the court did not ask.
Which deficits count, and what must connect them to the signing?
Probate Code section 811 requires a deficit in a listed mental function and evidence of a correlation between that deficit and the act in question. A diagnosis of a mental or physical disorder is not sufficient in and of itself.
Section 811(a) lists four groups of mental functions: alertness and attention, information processing, thought processes, and the ability to modulate mood and affect. Information processing includes memory, communication, reasoning and planning. A finding of incapacity must be supported by a deficit in one of the listed functions and by "evidence of a correlation between the deficit or deficits and the decision or acts in question."
Under section 811(b) a deficit may be considered only if it "significantly impairs the person's ability to understand and appreciate the consequences" of the act. Section 811(c) lets the court weigh the "frequency, severity, and duration of periods of impairment." Section 811(d) states that a diagnosis "shall not be sufficient in and of itself" to support a finding that a person lacks capacity.
These four subdivisions give the reviewer a checklist. For each deficit the opposing expert names, the reviewer looks for the function it belongs to, the test or observation that established it, the date of that test, and the sentence that links it to the contract or deed. A report that lists a diagnosis and a low screening score and then states the conclusion has skipped subdivision (a).
Who has to prove incapacity, and what does the presumption change?
The starting point is a presumption that every person has capacity. The party who attacks the document rebuts it with evidence of deficits, unless the facts trigger the Civil Code section 39(b) presumption of unsound mind.
In Algo-Heyres v. Oxnard Manor LP, No. B319601 (Cal. Ct. App. Feb. 28, 2023), the Court of Appeal quoted Probate Code section 810(a): there is a "rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that all persons have the capacity to make decisions." Under section 810(c), as the court quoted it, a finding of incapacity "should be based on evidence of a deficit in one or more of the person's mental functions."
The court noted that if the Civil Code section 39(b) presumption applies, the party who claims capacity has to prove it. On the facts of that case the court did not need to decide whether the presumption applied, because the evidence of incapacity was substantial without it.
For a review this fixes what each side's expert has to deliver. The expert for the party attacking the document needs dated evidence of deficits and their link to the signing. The expert for the party defending it can rely on the presumption only until such evidence appears, and after that needs evidence of what the person understood.
Which records persuaded the court in Algo-Heyres v. Oxnard Manor?
Hospital and therapy records made within weeks of the signing. The court relied on an occupational therapy rating, a neurologist's note and a speech-language pathologist's findings, and gave little weight to illegible physician forms that had no explanation.
Cornelio Heyres had a stroke in August 2009, spent about two weeks in a hospital and about a month in inpatient rehabilitation, and entered a skilled nursing facility in October 2009. Four days later he signed an arbitration agreement. He lived there until his death nine years later. When his wife and son sued the facility, it moved to compel arbitration. The trial court denied the motion, and Division Six of the Second Appellate District affirmed in an opinion by Justice Baltodano.
The evidence was specific. An occupational therapy assessment rated Heyres as needing total assistance, 1 on a 7-point scale, and noted that the ability to "solve complex problems such as managing [a] checking account" required a score of 6 or 7. A neurologist wrote that he "is nodding his head and seemingly understands the simple questions, but not . . . the complicated ones." Three weeks after the stroke a speech-language pathologist recorded poor cognitive insight and total assistance with executive function and problem solving. His son declared that Heyres did not appear to recognize his wife or granddaughter.
The facility offered physician forms stating that Heyres had capacity. The trial court gave them "little weight": the notes were nearly illegible and came with no supporting explanation, and no expert declaration was filed to interpret them. Applying section 811(b) to the act itself, the Court of Appeal held that the trial court could reasonably infer that the deficits impaired his ability to understand and appreciate the consequences of waiving his right to trial.
The case gives a reviewer three questions for any capacity report. How close in time is each record to the signing? Does the record describe a function, such as handling a checking account, or only a label? Did someone qualified explain the record to the court?
Does a diagnosis of dementia undo a deed?
A diagnosis alone does not. In Stratton v. Grant a physician testified that the seller was not competent on the date of the deed to understand the transaction, and the court judged that transaction.
In Stratton v. Grant, 139 Cal. App. 2d 814, a homeowner agreed in January 1953 to sell her home and furnishings to one buyer for $9,300 and signed a deed. In February 1953 she agreed to sell the same house to a second buyer for $7,000, and that deed was recorded on March 4, 1953. On April 21, 1953 she was declared incompetent and a bank was appointed guardian of her estate. Her physician testified that she had senile dementia and, in his opinion, was not competent on the date of the second deed to understand the transaction.
The trial court rescinded both deeds under Civil Code section 39. The first buyer did not appeal, and on the appeal concerning the second sale the Court of Appeal affirmed. It stated the test as "whether or not the party was mentally competent to deal with the subject before him" and to do so "with a full understanding of his rights." The finding was that she "did not actually understand the nature, purpose and effect of said agreement and said deed." The court added that "it is not necessary that one be incompetent to enter into any kind of contract or to transact any business."
Read together with section 811(d), the case marks the two errors a reviewer looks for. One expert treats the diagnosis as the answer. Another treats the person's ability to shop, drive or converse as proof of capacity for a sale of the home. Both skip the transaction: its price, its terms, the alternatives the person had, and what the person said about them at the time.
What does a reviewing psychologist check in a retrospective capacity opinion?
The legal standard the expert used, the date and author of every record, the tests and their norms, the observations of people present at the signing, and the reasoning that links each deficit to the act in dispute.
The reviewer first builds a timeline. The signing date goes in the middle. Every medical note, therapy assessment, test score, bank record and witness statement cited by the opposing expert is placed before or after it with its author. Section 811(c) makes frequency, severity and duration relevant, so the timeline also marks acute episodes such as a hospital stay, an infection or a change of medication, and the periods between them.
The second step is the testing. If the expert examined the person, the reviewer checks which instruments were used, whether the norms fit the person's age, education and language, and how long after the signing the examination took place. A score obtained two years later describes the person on the day of testing. The expert has to state the grounds for applying it to the signing date.
The third step is the link to the act. The reviewer copies the sentence in which the expert connects a deficit to the contract or deed and compares it with section 812: rights and duties, probable consequences, risks, benefits and alternatives. If the report holds no such sentence, the review says so and cites the page.
The last step concerns sources of information. Statements by the party who benefits when the document is set aside are compared with records made by people with no stake in the case, such as the notary, the escrow officer, the treating physician or the bank employee. Where the expert relied on one side's account only, the review lists the records that were available and not used.
Can the opposing capacity opinion be excluded or limited?
In federal court the party offering the expert must show that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and reliable methods reliably applied. A review identifies the opinions that lack that support, and counsel decides how to use them.
Federal Rule of Evidence 702, as amended in 2023, admits expert testimony only if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data," that it "is the product of reliable principles and methods," and that the opinion is a reliable application of those principles and methods to the facts of the case.
A capacity review sorts its findings by those conditions. Missing records and one-sided histories go to sufficient facts or data. Tests without norms for the person's group, or a screening tool used as if it were a full assessment, go to method. A conclusion about the signing date drawn from an examination long after it, with no explanation of the gap, goes to application.
The reviewer has examined no one and gives no opinion on whether the person had capacity. The document addresses method, data and the legal test the opposing expert used. Whether to file a motion, cross-examine or retain a testifying expert is counsel's decision.
What does IAE do when a capacity opinion is in dispute?
A psychologist in the IAE registry reviews the opposing psychological report and its records and writes where the opinion follows the legal test and the data. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days.
IAE prepares forensic psychological reports and reviews of the opposing evaluation in three areas: child custody, decision-making capacity and emotional distress. In a capacity dispute the reviewing psychologist reads the report and the underlying data and checks them against the standard the court applies. The reviewer does not examine the person.
The client sends the opposing report, the records it relies on and the document in dispute, and describes what to check. IAE agrees the review questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist in its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days once the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
Registry members passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- California Civil Code section 39 (California Public Law)
- California Probate Code section 811 (California Public Law)
- California Probate Code section 812 (California Public Law)
- Algo-Heyres v. Oxnard Manor LP, No. B319601 (Cal. Ct. App. Feb. 28, 2023) (Justia)
- Stratton v. Grant, 139 Cal. App. 2d 814 (Justia)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Sexual abuse allegations in a custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check?
When a parent alleges that a child was sexually abused, a California custody evaluation must follow Family Code section 3118: the evaluator consults
Move-away custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check when a parent wants to relocate with the child?
In a California move-away case the court asks whether relocating the child would cause detriment and then weighs factors the state Supreme Court
Who pays for a review of a custody evaluation, and can the cost be recovered from the other parent?
The parent who hires a psychologist to review a custody evaluation pays that psychologist. In California, Evidence Code section 733 says so in termsExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

