Expert report review
Sexual abuse allegations in a custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check?
When a parent alleges that a child was sexually abused, a California custody evaluation must follow Family Code section 3118: the evaluator consults child welfare and law enforcement, reviews their files, avoids repeated interviews of the child and reports on the child's safety. A reviewing psychologist checks each of those steps against the statute, rule 5.220 of the California Rules of Court and the evaluator's own data.

What changes in a custody evaluation when sexual abuse is alleged?
If the court finds a serious allegation of child sexual abuse, Family Code section 3118 applies. The evaluator must then complete a minimum set of steps and write a report on the child's safety and needs.
Section 3118 applies in contested custody or visitation proceedings where the court has appointed a child custody evaluator or made a court-connected referral and finds a serious allegation of child sexual abuse. An allegation is serious when it rests on the child's statements to certain professionals or is supported by substantial independent corroboration.
An emergency partial investigation for immediate temporary orders is exempt. Once the emergency is resolved and the court considers permanent orders, the section applies in full. The court appoints the evaluator with Judicial Council form FL-327, and when the appointment covers an investigation under section 3118, it attaches form FL-327(A), Additional Orders Regarding Child Custody Evaluations Under Family Code Section 3118, effective September 1, 2022.
For the parents the practical change is the scope. The evaluation now has to answer a question about a possible crime against the child, and the statute names the agencies and records the evaluator must reach before forming any view about custody or visits.
What must the evaluator do at a minimum under section 3118?
Consult child welfare services and law enforcement, review and summarize the child welfare file, obtain criminal background information, review or conduct a child interview and request a forensic medical examination or explain in writing why one is not needed.
The statute lists these steps as minimum requirements. In its words they "represent minimum requirements of evaluation," and the court must order further evaluation when the child's safety requires it. The statute asks for a written explanation only where the evaluator does not request a forensic medical examination, so a review starts by checking whether the report and the evaluator's file show each of the other steps.
Each step produces a document the reviewer can compare. The consultation with child welfare and police should appear with a date and a name. The report should contain a summary of the child welfare file. Criminal background information should be listed for the relevant adults. The child interview should be identified: who conducted it, when, how it was recorded and whether the evaluator watched the recording or relied on a summary.
On the forensic medical examination, the statute requires the evaluator to request one or to explain in writing why it is not needed, and a report silent on the point leaves a gap the reviewer will name.
Why does the statute limit repeated interviews of the child?
Section 3118 requires the evaluator to avoid repeated interviews of the child wherever possible. Each additional interview by a parent, a therapist or an investigator can change what the child says and how the child says it.
The words of the statute are that the evaluator shall "wherever possible avoid repeated interviews of the child." That is why the statute lets the evaluator review an interview already conducted, for example by a child advocacy center, instead of conducting a new one.
For the reviewer this creates a sequence question. How many times was the child asked about the events before the evaluator's contact? By whom? Were the questions open or leading? Was the first account recorded? The answers may sit in the child welfare file, the police report and the therapist's notes, which is why section 3118 requires the evaluator to obtain them.
Rule 5.220(j) adds a related ethical rule for every evaluation: the evaluator must not pressure children to state a custodial preference. In an abuse case the same concern applies to questions about the alleged events.
Who may conduct a section 3118 evaluation?
An evaluator who meets Family Code section 3110.5: a licensed psychiatrist, psychologist, marriage and family therapist, clinical social worker or professional clinical counselor, or a court-certified evaluator, with completed domestic violence, child abuse and child sexual abuse training.
Section 3118 refers to the qualifications in section 3110.5. That section requires completion of the domestic violence and child abuse training program in section 1816 and compliance with rules 5.220 and 5.230 of the California Rules of Court. Since 2005 an evaluator also "may not evaluate, investigate, or mediate an issue of child custody" without child sexual abuse training.
The required training content is listed in the statute: how children disclose abuse in families, the effects of abuse, its extent, family dynamics, techniques for identifying and assisting victims, and victims' legal rights. Evaluators must declare under penalty of perjury that they meet the Judicial Council's standards and, where applicable, hold a license in good standing.
Form FL-327(A) names the professionals who may be appointed for a 3118 investigation: a licensed psychologist, marriage and family therapist, clinical social worker or psychiatrist. The reviewer checks the evaluator's declaration and training record, because a gap in qualifications is an objection that does not depend on the content of the report.
What must the evaluator's report contain?
Under section 3118(b)(6), a confidential report filed with the clerk and served at least 10 days before the hearing, addressing the child's safety, the interview documentation, a summary of law enforcement and child welfare findings and recommendations.
The statute lists the contents. The report addresses the safety of the child and includes documentation of the child interview, a summary of law enforcement information, background material such as a therapist's summary with privileged communications excluded, and the status and recommendations of any child welfare investigation. It also covers information on domestic violence or substance abuse, the family's eligibility for the Victims of Crime Program, therapeutic recommendations and any other information that would assist the court.
Rule 5.220 sets the form: a confidential report on an evaluation under section 3118 is submitted with form FL-329. If the family is under an ongoing child welfare investigation, or the evaluator made a referral, section 3118(c) requires the evaluator to inform the family law judicial officer in writing.
The statute also protects reporters: the evaluator may not disclose the identity of any person who reported suspected abuse. A reviewer who sees a reporter's name in the report notes a breach of that rule.
Which general rules for custody evaluations still apply?
All of rule 5.220. The evaluator must assess each party in comparable ways, substantiate conclusions from multiple sources where possible, present information that does not support the conclusions and describe the limitations of the evaluation.
Rule 5.220(e)(2) requires a process that lets the evaluator observe and consider each party in "comparable ways" and substantiate conclusions from multiple sources when possible. The permitted methods include reviewing documents such as police records, observing parent-child interaction unless that is contraindicated to protect the child, interviewing parents, interviewing children in an age-appropriate way, collecting corroborating information and consulting other experts on matters outside the evaluator's expertise.
The report requirements in the rule matter most in an abuse case. The evaluator summarizes the data-gathering procedures, the sources and the time spent, presents all relevant information "including information that does not support the conclusions reached," and describes the limitations caused by unobtainable information, non-cooperation or the circumstances of particular interviews.
Rule 5.220(j) lists ethics duties: maintain objectivity, gather balanced information for both parties and control for bias, disclose conflicts of interest and dual relationships, and evaluate a party directly, or through another qualified neutral professional, before making any recommendation about that party. An evaluator who interviewed the accusing parent at length and the accused parent briefly has a comparability problem under (e)(2) whatever the conclusion.
How often are sexual abuse allegations made in custody disputes?
A study published in Child Abuse & Neglect in 1990 found allegations in less than 2% of contested custody and visitation cases in the family court records studied. Of 129 cases with a validity determination, 50% involved abuse.
The study, "The extent, nature, and validity of sexual abuse allegations in custody/visitation disputes," appeared in Child Abuse & Neglect, volume 14, issue 2, pages 151-163. It examined 169 cases. Mothers made 67% of the accusations, fathers 28% and third parties 11%; fathers were the accused party in 51% of all cases.
Of the 129 cases where a validity determination was made, 50% were found to involve abuse, 33% were found not to involve abuse and 17% were indeterminate. The study found four factors significantly linked to perceived validity: the age of the child, the frequency of the alleged abuse, prior reports of abuse or neglect, and the time between the filing for divorce and the emergence of the allegation.
These figures describe one sample from 1990 and do not answer whether abuse occurred in a given family. A reviewer uses them only to check whether an evaluator who cites base rates cited them accurately and did not substitute them for the case data.
What happens if an accusation is knowingly false?
Under Family Code section 3027.1, if the court finds that an abuse or neglect accusation was false and the accuser knew it then, the court may impose money sanctions up to the accused party's defense costs.
The sanctions may not exceed all costs incurred by the accused party as a direct result of defending the accusation, and the court may add reasonable attorney's fees incurred in recovering the sanctions. The section reaches a witness, a party or a party's attorney.
The procedure has its own steps. A party seeking sanctions files a motion, the court issues an order to show cause why sanctions should not be imposed, and the hearing is held at least 15 days after the order is served. The remedy is "in addition to any other remedy provided by law."
The standard is knowledge of falsity at the time the accusation was made. An evaluation that finds the allegation unsubstantiated does not establish that standard by itself, and the reviewer does not give an opinion on it. That question is for the court.
What does a reviewing psychologist check in a section 3118 evaluation?
Whether each minimum step was done or its omission explained, how the child's statements were obtained and recorded, whether both parents were assessed comparably, whether contrary data are reported and whether conclusions follow from the data.
The review works through the statute and the rule in order. The statutory steps come first: consultations, the child welfare file, criminal background, the interview, the medical examination. Then the interview history: every occasion on which the child was asked about the events, by whom and in what form, as far as the records show. Then comparability under rule 5.220(e)(2), the reporting of contrary information and the stated limitations.
The reviewer then reads the conclusions against the data. A recommendation of supervised visits, a finding that the allegation is unsubstantiated or a finding that the child is at risk each has to rest on facts stated in the report. Where the report gives a conclusion and no data, or data that point another way, the review says so with page references.
The reviewer does not interview the child or the parents and does not state whether abuse occurred. The review addresses the method and the support for the conclusions, which is the part of an evaluation a court can test.
What does IAE do when a custody evaluation involves an abuse allegation?
A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a work product review of the evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA custody guidelines. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days.
The IAE review is for parents and family law attorneys who have received a custody evaluation or the other side's psychological report. The psychologist reads the report and the underlying data, checks them against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the APA custody guidelines, and writes where the evaluation follows them and where it does not. The reviewer does not examine the family and does not recommend which parent should have custody.
IAE agrees the review questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days once the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
Registry members passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- California Family Code section 3118 (California.Public.Law)
- California Family Code section 3110.5 (California.Public.Law)
- California Family Code section 3027.1 (California.Public.Law)
- California Rules of Court 2026, rule 5.220, Court-ordered child custody evaluations (Judicial Branch of California)
- Judicial Council form FL-327(A), Additional Orders Regarding Child Custody Evaluations Under Family Code Section 3118 (California Courts Self-Help Guide)
- The extent, nature, and validity of sexual abuse allegations in custody/visitation disputes, Child Abuse & Neglect 1990;14(2):151-63 (PubMed)
Read also
All articles
Capacity to sign a contract or deed: how is the opposing expert's opinion on mental capacity reviewed?
An expert opinion that a person lacked the mental capacity to sign a contract or deed is written after the signing, in some cases years later
Move-away custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check when a parent wants to relocate with the child?
In a California move-away case the court asks whether relocating the child would cause detriment and then weighs factors the state Supreme Court
Who pays for a review of a custody evaluation, and can the cost be recovered from the other parent?
The parent who hires a psychologist to review a custody evaluation pays that psychologist. In California, Evidence Code section 733 says so in termsExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

