Expert report review

Move-away custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check when a parent wants to relocate with the child?

In a California move-away case the court asks whether relocating the child would cause detriment and then weighs factors the state Supreme Court listed in In re Marriage of LaMusga (2004). A custody evaluator's report often carries those factors to the judge, and in LaMusga the evaluator's predictions about the father's relationship with the boys shaped the result. A reviewing psychologist checks whether the report addresses each factor with data and separates observation from forecast.

A psychologist from behind looks at a small suitcase and a child's coat by a doorway

What does California law say about moving away with a child?

A parent with custody may change the child's residence, subject to the court's power to restrain a move that would prejudice the child's rights or welfare. The parent need not prove the move is necessary.

Family Code section 7501(a) provides that a parent entitled to the custody of a child has a right to change the residence of the child, subject to the power of the court to restrain a removal that would prejudice the rights or welfare of the child. Section 7501(b) states the Legislature's intent to affirm the decision in In re Marriage of Burgess (1996) 13 Cal.4th 25 and to declare it the public policy and law of California.

In Burgess, decided April 15, 1996, Justice Mosk wrote for the California Supreme Court that a parent seeking to relocate with the children does not have to establish that the move is necessary. Once a final custody order is in place, the changed-circumstances rule applies: the parent seeking a change bears the burden, the showing must be substantial, and the question is whether it is essential or expedient for the welfare of the child that there be a change. In an initial custody determination, the trial court has the widest discretion to choose a parenting plan that is in the best interest of the child.

An evaluation therefore answers a narrower question than whether the move is a good idea for the relocating parent. It informs the court about the effect of the move on the child, which is the subject the court must decide.

What did LaMusga add to the analysis?

A burden and a list of factors. The noncustodial parent must first prove that the move would cause detriment to the children; the court then weighs stability, distance, age, each parent's relationship and the reasons for the move.

In re Marriage of LaMusga (2004) 32 Cal.4th 1072, No. S107355, was decided on April 29, 2004, with Justice Moreno writing for the majority and Justice Kennard dissenting. Susan LaMusga had primary physical custody of two sons, born in 1992 and 1994, and in 2001 asked to move them to the Cleveland, Ohio area, where her husband had a job offer and she had family.

The court held that the noncustodial parent bears the initial burden of showing that the move would cause detriment to the children requiring a reevaluation of custody. The likely effect of the move on the noncustodial parent's relationship with the children is relevant and, together with other factors, may justify a change in custody, but it does not mandate one. Good-faith reasons for the move do not end the inquiry; the court may consider whether one reason is to lessen the children's contact with the other parent.

The court listed the factors that ordinarily should be considered: the children's interest in stability and continuity in the custodial arrangement; the distance of the move; the age of the children; the children's relationship with both parents; the relationship between the parents, including their ability to communicate and cooperate effectively and their willingness to put the children's interests above their own; the wishes of the children if they are mature enough for such an inquiry; the reasons for the proposed move; and the extent to which the parents currently share custody.

What role did the custody evaluator play in LaMusga?

A central one. Dr. Philip Stahl reported that the father's relationship with the boys was tenuous and that a move could interrupt its progress; the trial court relied on his reports, and the Supreme Court upheld the order that followed.

The court-appointed evaluator, Dr. Philip Stahl, wrote in his 2001 report that the father's relationship with the boys was tenuous at best and that a move could interrupt any progress in it. He identified the critical issue as the mother's real behavior after a move, and in an earlier report he had noted that the children had not reached an age at which they could maintain the attachment over distance.

The trial court denied the move to Ohio, finding that relocating the children 2,000 miles would inevitably under the circumstances be detrimental to their welfare, and ordered that primary physical custody would go to the father if the mother relocated. It found that the mother was not acting in bad faith. The Court of Appeal reversed. The Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeal and remanded with directions to affirm the transfer of custody to the father if the mother moved to Ohio, noting that the trial court had carefully considered the comprehensive reports prepared by Dr. Stahl and the evidence submitted by both parties.

The opinion does not require an evaluation in every move-away case. Justice Kennard's dissent shows what a review would look for on the other side: she wrote that the trial court never addressed the harm to the children of losing their mother as primary caretaker and did not show that it weighed the importance of stability. A report that predicts harm from the move but says nothing about harm from a change of custody leaves one half of the comparison unanalyzed.

What does a reviewer check first in a move-away evaluation?

The court order and the referral question, then whether the report addresses the detriment question and each LaMusga factor, and whether the written explanation required by rule 5.220 was given to the parents.

California Rules of Court rule 5.220 governs court-connected and private child custody evaluators appointed under Family Code section 3111. Under rule 5.220(d)(1)(B) the court gives the evaluator, before the evaluation begins, a copy of the court order that specifies the scope of the evaluation. The reviewer starts with that order: an evaluation ordered to address relocation should say what it found on detriment and on each factor the court will weigh.

Rule 5.220(e)(1) lists the written explanation the parties receive about the process: the purpose of the evaluation, the procedures used and the time required, the scope and distribution of the report, the limits on confidentiality, and the cost and payment responsibility. Guideline 3 of the 2022 APA Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations asks psychologists to identify the evaluation's stated purpose before accepting a referral.

The reviewer then builds a table: each LaMusga factor in one column, and in the next the pages of the report that address it and the data behind it. Factors with no entry, or with an entry that rests on a single source, are the first points of the review.

How does the reviewer test the evaluator's predictions about the move?

By separating what the evaluator observed from what the evaluator forecast, and by checking whether each forecast rests on data about this family: the history of contact, the quality of each relationship and the children's ages and needs.

A move-away report contains two kinds of statements. Some describe the present: how often the children see each parent, what the evaluator observed during each parent's time with them, what teachers and other collateral sources reported. Others predict the future: that contact will shrink, that the relationship will weaken, that the children will adjust or will not. The reviewer marks each statement as observation or forecast.

Each forecast needs a basis in the record. A prediction that long-distance contact will fail is stronger when the history shows missed visits and weak contact already, and weaker when it rests on a general view of distance. Guideline 10 of the APA guidelines asks for an evidence-based, multimethod and multitrait assessment, and the reviewer checks whether a forecast is supported by more than one method: interviews, observation, records and collateral information.

The reviewer also checks that the report addresses both directions of harm. The LaMusga factors begin with the children's interest in stability and continuity in the custodial arrangement. A report that forecasts loss from the move must also say what the children would lose if custody changed, which is the point Justice Kennard found missing in the trial court's analysis.

Did the evaluator assess both parents and both settings?

The reviewer checks that both parents were evaluated and that information was gathered in a balanced way, as rule 5.220 requires, and notes what the evaluator could not see, such as the proposed new home, school and support network.

Rule 5.220(j)(1) requires the evaluator to maintain objectivity, provide and gather balanced information for both parties, and control for bias. Under rule 5.220(f)(3) and (j)(3) the evaluator may make a custody or visitation recommendation only for a party who has been evaluated and may not offer recommendations about a party unless that party has been evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional.

Relocation cases add a setting the evaluator usually cannot visit: the new city. The reviewer checks what the report says about the proposed home, school, extended family and the relocating parent's work there, and where that information came from. Information supplied only by the relocating parent is noted as such.

The current arrangement matters too. The last LaMusga factor is the extent to which the parents currently share custody. The reviewer compares the report's description of the schedule with the orders and with records of actual contact, because a report that treats a shared arrangement as primary custody, or the reverse, starts the analysis from the wrong place.

How does the reviewer handle the reasons for the move and the children's wishes?

By checking that the report records the stated reasons and their sources without judging good faith on thin evidence, and that the children's views were obtained in a way suited to their age and free of a parent's influence.

LaMusga lists the reasons for the proposed move as a factor and lets the court consider whether one reason is to reduce the children's contact with the other parent. An evaluator may report what each parent said about the reasons and what documents support them, such as a job offer. The reviewer checks that the report separates these facts from the evaluator's inferences about motive and states the basis for any inference.

The wishes of the children count if they are mature enough for such an inquiry. The reviewer checks how the evaluator asked: how many times, in whose presence, after what events, and with what questions. A child interviewed right after a visit with the relocating parent, or asked a leading question about the new home, gives an answer that needs the conditions recorded.

The children's ages bear on more than their wishes. In LaMusga the evaluator had written that the children had not reached an age at which they could maintain the attachment over distance. The reviewer asks what the evaluator relied on for such a statement about these children.

How can the evaluation be tested at the hearing?

Through cross-examination of the evaluator, under procedures each California court must develop under rule 5.220(k), and through a party's own expert, whom the party may call at its own expense under Evidence Code section 733.

Rule 5.220(k) requires each local court to develop procedures for expeditious and cost-effective cross-examination of evaluators, and lists considerations such as videoconferences, telephone conferences, audio or video examination and scheduling of appearances. A review written before the hearing gives counsel the questions: which factor the report did not address, which forecast rests on one source, which information came only from one parent.

Evidence Code section 733 provides that nothing in the article on court-appointed experts prevents a party from producing other expert evidence on the same fact or matter, and that a party calling its own expert pays that expert's fees. A reviewing psychologist can testify or work as a consultant who prepares the cross-examination.

The court weighs the evaluation with the other evidence. In LaMusga the trial court relied on the evaluator's reports and explained its decision on the factors, and the review is aimed at the factors the court has to decide.

What does IAE do when a move-away evaluation is in dispute?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a work product review of the evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA custody guidelines. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days.

The IAE review is for parents and family law attorneys who have received a custody evaluation or the other side's psychological report. The psychologist reads the report and the underlying data, checks them against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the APA custody guidelines, and writes where the evaluation follows them and where it does not. The reviewer does not examine the family and does not recommend which parent should have custody.

IAE agrees the review questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days once the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Registry members passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member